Guardianship of Moylan
Opinion
FILED
SUPERIOR COURT
OF GUAM
EU?' .5¥JN 15 PM 3* DE? CLERK OF COURT
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF GUAM BY: --»~..*. ».
IN THE MATTER OF THE Superior Court Case No. SP0106-07 GUARDIANSHIP Related Case Nos. sp0104-07. SPOl05-07.
sp0107-07. SP0110-07. and sp0111-07 OF
YUK LAN MOYLAN, DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES
An Adult,
In re Guardianship of Moylan, 2018 Guam 8 (Moylan III),reversed the SuperiorCourt's
prior decision denying the payment of attorney's fees for Richard Moylan's litigation efforts that
resulted in the return ofTCDs to the Wards, Francis Moylan and Yuk Lam Moylan. On remand,
this Court now considers the appropriate amount of attorney's fees for that claim. Moreover, the
same opinion vacated and remanded all odder claims for attorney's fees tim the trial court's July
26, 2016 decision related to litigation in In re Guardianship of Moylan, 2017 Guam 28 (Moylan
11). The Court now considers whether Richard may recover attorney's fees under the substantial
benefit doctrine for litigation eftbrts that resulted in a holding that there was no enforceable oral
transfer of property from the Wards to the present Limited Guardian, Lina Leialoha Alston
("Princess").
1. Background
Attorney Douglas Moylan is the grandson of the Wards and the son of Richard Moylan
In 2007, a series of guardianship petitions were filed concerning Mr. and Mrs. Moylan, Richard,
through Attorney Moylan, entered appearances and litigated various issues in:
o SPOl04-07 - Petition filed Princess and Francis L. Moylan, Jr, on June 22, 2007, over Mr. Moylan's person
OREGQNAL
SPOl06-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 2
o SP0105-07 - Petition filed by Kurt Moylan on June 22, 2007, over Mr. Moylan's estate o SP0106-07 _ Petition filed by Kurt on June 22, 2007, over Mrs. Moylan's estate
O SP0107-07 - Petition filed by Princess and Jr. on June 22, 2007, over Mrs.
Moylan's person
o SP0110-07 - Petition tiled by Richard on June 26, 2007, over Mr, Moylan
o SP011l-07 ._ Petition filed by Richard on June 26, 2007, over Mrs. Moylan
The issues presented in these petitions were tried and then appealed in CVA08~016. In
2011, the Guam Supreme Court resolved various guardianship issues In re Guardianships of
Moylan, 2011 Guam 16 (Moylan 1). The Court incorporates here the factual and procedural
background discussed therein.
Following the issuance of Moylan I and Moylan II, Richard moved to recover his
reasonable attorney's fees and costs. In denying the motion, the Court found that under 15 GCA
§ 4101, a party must be a guardian in order to apply for attorney's fees. Dec, and Order (Jul. 26,
2016). Since Richard was not a guardian and did not satisfy any exception to the American rule
regarding litigation expenses, the Court found that he could not recover attorney's fees and costs.
Upon Richard's appeal, the Guam Supreme Court vacated the Decision and Order to the
extent that it resolved Richard's claim for attorney's fees based upon litigation subject to the
court's opinion in Moylan II. Moylan III, 20]8 Guam 8, The Guam SupremeCourt partially
vacated and partially reversed the trial court's Decision and Order and remanded the matter to
this Court,
II. Law and Discussion
A. The Scope of Issues on Remand
As an initial matter, the Court must determine the scope of the issues on remand. The
Guam Supreme Court instructs that "[o]n remand, a trial coin must comply with the mandate of
5 t HEEENA L , E sp0106.07 DEc1s1on AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 3
the appellate court. Thus, in determining how to proceed on remand, the trial court must examine
both the mandate and the opinion and proceed in accordance with the views expressed therein."
Town House Depot Stores, Inc. u Ahn, 2003 Guam 61] 16. The Guam SupremeCourt has further
cautioned that "trial courts are not to construe remand orders 'so narrowly as to prohibit the
court from considering matters relevant to the issues upon which further proceedings are
ordered." Moylan II, 2017 Guam 281129 (citing Lamb v. Hoffman, 2011 Guam 131122).
In Moylan Ill, the Guam Supreme Court mandated the following;
For the reasons discussed above, we VACATE that portion of the trial court's July 26, 2016 Decision and Order to the extent that it resolved Richard's claim for attorney's fees based upon litigation that was the subject of the court's opinion in Moylan ll, 2017 Guam 28. We REMAND those issues and direct the Superior Court to dismiss that portion of Richard's motion without prejudice or, upon final resolution of those issues, determine whether Richard is entitled to attorney's fees in accordance with the legal principles enunciated by the court in this Opinion. Additionally, we REVERSE that portion of the trial court's July 26, 2016 Decision and Order regarding the payment of attorney's fees for Richard's litigation efforts that resulted in the return of the TCDs to the Wards and REMAND the matter to the Superior Court so that it may calculate the appropriate arnowit of attorney's fees in the first instance.
2018 Guam 8 1]33, In remand proceedings, Richard indicated that the scope of fees and costs
that he seeks to recover includes:
o work associated with eftbrts to recover over $l.5M in life savings deposits to names of Wards alone
o recovery of real estate (the house occupied by Princess),
O defense of Judge Barrett~Anderson's determination that the Wards are entitled to recovery of monies (a loan) owed by F.L. Moylan Corp.,
o protection of the late FL. Moylan and Yuk Lan Moylan's civil liberties such as the sealing of their cases, and O legal work related to recover compensable fees and costs.
Legal Brief Re: 8/17/18 Supreme Court of Guam Mandate (Dec, 2, 2019).
:0
""*~
F'il*e"*im 5 I.
£"i§L.3l§*~¢~§L,,.
r. s 1 l I
SP0106-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 4
Moylan 111 instructs this Court to calculate the appropriate amount of attorney's fees
associated with Richard's efforts that resulted in the return of the TCDs to the Wards.
Furthermore, Moylan III directs this Court to review Richard's litigation efforts: (i) in
maintaining title in the name of the Wards to the residence where Princess currently resides, and
(ii) in recovering shareholder loans payable to the Wards--in other words, the two issues
addressed in Moylan II. Since no further action has been taken on these issues, the Coup finds
that both are ripe for the Court to determine whether Richard is entitled to attorney's fees in
accordance with the legal principles enunciated by Moylan III.
As to other issues, Richard does not specify which issue he seeks review for his efforts to
protect the Wards' civil liberties. He submits billing entries for work done in association with
his litigation efforts to unseal all guardianship records, see Moylan L 2011 Guam 16 1]55 and
Order (Jan. 24, 2012), and his efforts to contest the appointment of Princess as a special guardian
for which she failed to have adequate notice, see Moylan V, 2018 Guam 21. However, Richard
fails to present the Court with a legal argument regarding the award of attorney fees for these
issues. Accordingly, the Court declines to consider whether to award Richard attorney's fees for
his efforts to unseal all guardianship records and contest the appointment of Princess as a special
guardian.
Richard also seeks attorney fees for his efforts to recover compensable fees and costs.
Again, he fails to present to the Court a legal argument as to why it should award him attorney
fees. Since this issue also falls outside the scope of the Moylan III mandate, the Court declines
to consider it here.
In sum, the Court strictly complies with the scope outlined in Moylan III-~that is, whether
the substantial benefit doctrine entitles Richard to an award of attorney's fees for his litigation
1 e
QRGE
a A z E
e
SPOl06-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 5
efforts: (i) in maintaining title in the name of the Wards to the residence where Princess currently
resides, and (ii) in recovering shareholder loans payable to the Wards. The Court will also
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
FILED
SUPERIOR COURT
OF GUAM
EU?' .5¥JN 15 PM 3* DE? CLERK OF COURT
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF GUAM BY: --»~..*. ».
IN THE MATTER OF THE Superior Court Case No. SP0106-07 GUARDIANSHIP Related Case Nos. sp0104-07. SPOl05-07.
sp0107-07. SP0110-07. and sp0111-07 OF
YUK LAN MOYLAN, DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES
An Adult,
In re Guardianship of Moylan, 2018 Guam 8 (Moylan III),reversed the SuperiorCourt's
prior decision denying the payment of attorney's fees for Richard Moylan's litigation efforts that
resulted in the return ofTCDs to the Wards, Francis Moylan and Yuk Lam Moylan. On remand,
this Court now considers the appropriate amount of attorney's fees for that claim. Moreover, the
same opinion vacated and remanded all odder claims for attorney's fees tim the trial court's July
26, 2016 decision related to litigation in In re Guardianship of Moylan, 2017 Guam 28 (Moylan
11). The Court now considers whether Richard may recover attorney's fees under the substantial
benefit doctrine for litigation eftbrts that resulted in a holding that there was no enforceable oral
transfer of property from the Wards to the present Limited Guardian, Lina Leialoha Alston
("Princess").
1. Background
Attorney Douglas Moylan is the grandson of the Wards and the son of Richard Moylan
In 2007, a series of guardianship petitions were filed concerning Mr. and Mrs. Moylan, Richard,
through Attorney Moylan, entered appearances and litigated various issues in:
o SPOl04-07 - Petition filed Princess and Francis L. Moylan, Jr, on June 22, 2007, over Mr. Moylan's person
OREGQNAL
SPOl06-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 2
o SP0105-07 - Petition filed by Kurt Moylan on June 22, 2007, over Mr. Moylan's estate o SP0106-07 _ Petition filed by Kurt on June 22, 2007, over Mrs. Moylan's estate
O SP0107-07 - Petition filed by Princess and Jr. on June 22, 2007, over Mrs.
Moylan's person
o SP0110-07 - Petition tiled by Richard on June 26, 2007, over Mr, Moylan
o SP011l-07 ._ Petition filed by Richard on June 26, 2007, over Mrs. Moylan
The issues presented in these petitions were tried and then appealed in CVA08~016. In
2011, the Guam Supreme Court resolved various guardianship issues In re Guardianships of
Moylan, 2011 Guam 16 (Moylan 1). The Court incorporates here the factual and procedural
background discussed therein.
Following the issuance of Moylan I and Moylan II, Richard moved to recover his
reasonable attorney's fees and costs. In denying the motion, the Court found that under 15 GCA
§ 4101, a party must be a guardian in order to apply for attorney's fees. Dec, and Order (Jul. 26,
2016). Since Richard was not a guardian and did not satisfy any exception to the American rule
regarding litigation expenses, the Court found that he could not recover attorney's fees and costs.
Upon Richard's appeal, the Guam Supreme Court vacated the Decision and Order to the
extent that it resolved Richard's claim for attorney's fees based upon litigation subject to the
court's opinion in Moylan II. Moylan III, 20]8 Guam 8, The Guam SupremeCourt partially
vacated and partially reversed the trial court's Decision and Order and remanded the matter to
this Court,
II. Law and Discussion
A. The Scope of Issues on Remand
As an initial matter, the Court must determine the scope of the issues on remand. The
Guam Supreme Court instructs that "[o]n remand, a trial coin must comply with the mandate of
5 t HEEENA L , E sp0106.07 DEc1s1on AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 3
the appellate court. Thus, in determining how to proceed on remand, the trial court must examine
both the mandate and the opinion and proceed in accordance with the views expressed therein."
Town House Depot Stores, Inc. u Ahn, 2003 Guam 61] 16. The Guam SupremeCourt has further
cautioned that "trial courts are not to construe remand orders 'so narrowly as to prohibit the
court from considering matters relevant to the issues upon which further proceedings are
ordered." Moylan II, 2017 Guam 281129 (citing Lamb v. Hoffman, 2011 Guam 131122).
In Moylan Ill, the Guam Supreme Court mandated the following;
For the reasons discussed above, we VACATE that portion of the trial court's July 26, 2016 Decision and Order to the extent that it resolved Richard's claim for attorney's fees based upon litigation that was the subject of the court's opinion in Moylan ll, 2017 Guam 28. We REMAND those issues and direct the Superior Court to dismiss that portion of Richard's motion without prejudice or, upon final resolution of those issues, determine whether Richard is entitled to attorney's fees in accordance with the legal principles enunciated by the court in this Opinion. Additionally, we REVERSE that portion of the trial court's July 26, 2016 Decision and Order regarding the payment of attorney's fees for Richard's litigation efforts that resulted in the return of the TCDs to the Wards and REMAND the matter to the Superior Court so that it may calculate the appropriate arnowit of attorney's fees in the first instance.
2018 Guam 8 1]33, In remand proceedings, Richard indicated that the scope of fees and costs
that he seeks to recover includes:
o work associated with eftbrts to recover over $l.5M in life savings deposits to names of Wards alone
o recovery of real estate (the house occupied by Princess),
O defense of Judge Barrett~Anderson's determination that the Wards are entitled to recovery of monies (a loan) owed by F.L. Moylan Corp.,
o protection of the late FL. Moylan and Yuk Lan Moylan's civil liberties such as the sealing of their cases, and O legal work related to recover compensable fees and costs.
Legal Brief Re: 8/17/18 Supreme Court of Guam Mandate (Dec, 2, 2019).
:0
""*~
F'il*e"*im 5 I.
£"i§L.3l§*~¢~§L,,.
r. s 1 l I
SP0106-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 4
Moylan 111 instructs this Court to calculate the appropriate amount of attorney's fees
associated with Richard's efforts that resulted in the return of the TCDs to the Wards.
Furthermore, Moylan III directs this Court to review Richard's litigation efforts: (i) in
maintaining title in the name of the Wards to the residence where Princess currently resides, and
(ii) in recovering shareholder loans payable to the Wards--in other words, the two issues
addressed in Moylan II. Since no further action has been taken on these issues, the Coup finds
that both are ripe for the Court to determine whether Richard is entitled to attorney's fees in
accordance with the legal principles enunciated by Moylan III.
As to other issues, Richard does not specify which issue he seeks review for his efforts to
protect the Wards' civil liberties. He submits billing entries for work done in association with
his litigation efforts to unseal all guardianship records, see Moylan L 2011 Guam 16 1]55 and
Order (Jan. 24, 2012), and his efforts to contest the appointment of Princess as a special guardian
for which she failed to have adequate notice, see Moylan V, 2018 Guam 21. However, Richard
fails to present the Court with a legal argument regarding the award of attorney fees for these
issues. Accordingly, the Court declines to consider whether to award Richard attorney's fees for
his efforts to unseal all guardianship records and contest the appointment of Princess as a special
guardian.
Richard also seeks attorney fees for his efforts to recover compensable fees and costs.
Again, he fails to present to the Court a legal argument as to why it should award him attorney
fees. Since this issue also falls outside the scope of the Moylan III mandate, the Court declines
to consider it here.
In sum, the Court strictly complies with the scope outlined in Moylan III-~that is, whether
the substantial benefit doctrine entitles Richard to an award of attorney's fees for his litigation
1 e
QRGE
a A z E
e
SPOl06-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 5
efforts: (i) in maintaining title in the name of the Wards to the residence where Princess currently
resides, and (ii) in recovering shareholder loans payable to the Wards. The Court will also
calculate the appropriate amount of attorney's fees associated with Richard's efforts that resulted
in the return of the TCDs to the Wards and for the other issues Mat satisfy the substantial benefit
doctrine.
B . The Substantial Benefit Test Applied
I n Moylan III, the Guam Supreme Court held that the "substantial benefit" exception to
the American Rule applies in Guam and may be utilized in the context of guardianship
proceedings. The Guam Supreme Court instructed that when using the substantial benefit
exception, the "relevant question iswhether a substantial benefit has been conferred on an
ascertainable class, which is generally decided on a case-by-case basis." Id., 2018 Guam 81130.
Furthermore, in deciding whether a substantial benefit has been conferred, the Court is to
consider whether "one individual's action has obtained a decision providing substantial
pecuniary benefits to other persons Id. 1126, In such instances, "the trial court determines
whether the interests ofjustice require those who received a benefit to contribute to the legal
expenses of those who secured the benefit." Pipefirzers Local No. 636 Defined Benefit Plan v.
Oakley, Inc., 104 Cal. Rptr. ad 78, 81 (App, 2010). Underlying the rule is the broad equitable is
principle "of encouraging persons acting in good faith in the interests of an incompetent
Moylan III, 2018 Guam 81]28.
Richard has undoubtedly conferred a "substantial benefit" on the Wards through his
litigation eiTorts that resulted in reversing "the trial court's determination that Princess be 711
transferred 'whatever fee interest the Wards' [sic] held in Princess's current residential property.
Moylan 11,2017 Guam 281123 (citing Dec. & Order, Dec, 1, 2015). The Wards are clearly
I
€3REG!E\EAL n
SPOi06-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE A'r1'o RnEy's FEES Page 6
identifiable and plainly benefited from their Estate retaining the title to Lot No. 2053A-3-I
located in Matte, Guam and nullifying an alleged conveyance that violated the Statute of Frauds,
The reasonable attorney's fees expended by Richard in his effort to have the property returned
are therefore properly shifted to the Wards .
As for Richard's efforts in recovering shareholder loans payable to the Wards,Moylan II
upheld the trial court's determination that it would be futile to decide the loan issue. 2017 Guam
28 1138. As a result, the portion of the Findings of Fact that found FL. Moylan Corp. owed the
Wards $I,983,772.75 was effectively vacated. See id, 1i 38 (citing In re Moylan, 2011 Guam 16
111] 56-59 and Finds, Fact & Conch. L., (Nov, 10, 2008)), Accordingly, since the Wards do not
stand to recover any fiends from Richard's litigation efforts, the Court does not find that the
efforts on the loans conferred a "substantial benefit" on the Wards,
C. Award of Attorney's Fees
The U.S, Supreme Court has found that "[t]he most useful starting point for determining
the amount of a reasonable fee is the number of hours reasonably expended on the litigation
multiplied by a reasonable hourly rate." Hensley u Everhart, 461 U.S. 424, 433 (1983). This is
known as the "lodestar figure," which is a "presumptively reasonable fee." Gonzalez v City of
Maywood, 729 F,3d 1196, 1202 (9th Cir. 2013). Under the lodestar method, the court calculates
the fee award by multiplying the number of hours reasonably spent by a reasonable hourly rate.
Paul, Jonson, Alston & Hunt v Graulty, 886 F,2d 268, 272 (9th Cir. 1989). The court may then
adjust the lodestar figureupward or downward based on the factors outlined inKerr that are not
subsumed in the lodestar calculation.' Gonzalez, 729 F.3d at 1202.
1 The Kerr factors are as t`ollowsi (1) the time and labor required, (2) the novelty and diflicuity of the questions, (3) the skill requisite to perform the legal service properly, (4) the preclusion of other employment by the attorney due to acceptance of the case, (5) the customary fee, (6) whether the fee is fixed or contingent, (7) time limitations imposed by the client or the circumstances, (8) the amount involved and the results obtained; (9) the experience, reputation, and ability of the attonieys, (10) the "undesirability" of the case, (l l) the nature and length of the
h " " :.
p .x 5
f *-a i H E - 1. '
p
L ,
SPOl06-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 7
1. The Applicable Rate
Attorney Moylan seeks approval for an hourly rate of $300. In determining a reasonable
hourly rate, courts look to the prevailing rate in the community. 81um v Stemson, 465 U.S. 886,
895 n.11 (1984). A $300 hourly rate is not uncommon in Guam. See, e.g., Gange et al. u Gov 't
of Guam, CV1461-10 (Dec. and Order at 19 (July 22, 2015) (approving a $300 hourly rate)),
Palmer u Mariana Stones Corp, CV0709-13 (Dec. and Order (Dec. 17, 2018) (approving hourly
rates between $200 and $400)).
The Court agrees with Attorney Moylan that the work for these cases has been complex.
The issues have been wide-ranging and of first impression for the Guam courts. It also agrees
that the $300 hourly rate is comparable to the rate utilized by the ward's Guardian Ad Liter and
community rates. The Court therefore approves Attorney Moylan's requested hourly rate of
$300.
2. The Number of Hours
Time is reasonably expended on the litigation when it is "useful and of a type ordinarily
necessary to secure the final result obtained from the litigation." Webb v. Ba, Of Educ. of Dyer
County, 471 U.S. 234, 242 (1985). Counsel has the burden to demonstrate that the number of
hours spent was reasonably necessary to the litigation. Hensley, 461 U.S. at 437, Further,
counsel bears the burden of submitting detailed time records justifying the hours claimed to have
been expended. Id. The court may reduce hours where documentation of the hours is
inadequate, if the case was overstaffed and hours are duplicated, if the hours expended are
deemed excessive or otherwise unnecessary. Id. at 433-34. The court may also reduce hours
professional relationship with the client, and (12) awards in similar cases. Kerr v Screen Extras Guild, Ire., 526 F.2d 67,70 (9th Cir. 1975), cert denied, 425 U.S. 950 (1976).
i ,¢*'=\
/~*; F"~$ E g . 5 5 :L
r
E El \ét"z
I z
l
\. J u
r l
SP0106-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 8
unreasonably spent, or where excessive time is spent on a particular task, or where there is
redundant and/or ambiguity in the billing. Id.
The Court has reviewed Attorney Moylan's time records which span twelve years of legal
work. The time records do not segregate the time he expended on the litigation efforts that
resulted in the return of the TCDs to the Wards or his efforts that resulted in the retention of the
title to the residential property occupied by Princess, Instead, he provides the Court with a linear
breakdown of all fees and costs expended in all matters related to the Guardianship of Yuk Lam
Moylan. The Limited Guardian objects, arguing that Attorney Moylan may recover fees only for
time reasonably incurred for the substantial benefit of the Ward.
The Court agrees with the Limited Guardian and shall only award fees for work that can
be attributed to efforts to return the TCDs or the property In careiiilly reviewing the time
records, the Court finds four categories of hours billed relating to the TCDs and the property: (l)
work done solely on recovering the TCDs, (2) work done solely on the issue of transfer of
property to Princess, (3) general guardianship litigation, and (4) work done on CvA20l5-030
(which resulted in Moylan II). The Court's review of the time records is attached hereto as
Addendum A.
For categories one and two, the Court is satisfied that the description of the services
rendered is sufficient to apportion the hours to work done on either the return of the TCDs or in
transferring the title. The Court finds that Attorney Moylan spent a total of 171.8 hours on work
done solely on recovering the TCDs. For work done solely on the transfer of the title to
Princess's residential property back to the Wards, the Court finds that Attorney Moylan spent a
total of 56.35 hours.
I?
SPOl06-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Page 9
For category three, the Court finds that Attorney Moylan spent time working on the
TCDs and property transfer issues in association with general guardianship litigation work
before the issuance of Moylan I. Specifically, Attorney Moylan billed time related to his
appearances at hearings and the trial, preparing motions, responding to motions, and working on
the appeal leadingup to Moylan I. In total, the Court Ends that Attorney Moylanspent a total of
85715 hours on these issues. Because the recovery of the TCDs and the transfer of property
only madeup a portion of the issues covered in Moylan 1, the Court finds it reasonable to reduce
the hours by 50%, Accordingly, the Court finds that Attorney Moylan spent a total of 428.58
hours working on the TCDs and property transfer that is enveloped in the time billed for general
guardianship litigation prior to the issuance ofMoylan L The Court also finds it reasonable to
apportion the time equally between work done on the TCDs and work done on the property
transfer. Of the 428,58 hours, the Court apportions 21429 hours to each task.
Lastly, for category four, the Court finds that Attorney Moylan spent 91.45 hours on work
related to CVA2015-030, Similar to category three, CVA2015-030 concerned multiple issues--
namely, the transfer of the title to the property and whether F.L. Moylan Company owed the
wards $l,983,772.75. Since the Court is only awarding Attorney Moylan for work done on the
property transfer, the Court finds it reasonable to reduce the hours in this category by 50%.
Accordingly, the Court finds that Attorney Moylan spent a total of 45.73 hours working on the
property transfer that is enveloped in the time billed for work related to CVA2015-030.
In sum, the Court finds that Attorney Moylan spent 386.09 hours on litigation efforts that
resulted in the return of the TCDs to the Wards, At a rate of $300 per hour, the Court awards
$1 I5,827 in attorney's fees. The Court further finds that Attorney Moylan spent 316.37 hours on
litigation efforts that resulted in transferring Princess's residential property back to the Wards. At
MG * I
¥ M ann
SP0106-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE ATTORNEY'S FEES Pa g e 10
a rate of $300 per hour, the Court awards $94,911 in attorney's fees, In total, the Court finds
Richard entitled to an attorney's fee award of $210,738.00.
3 . Interest
Attorney Moylan asks that the payment of attorney's fees not be required until after Mrs.
Moylan passes but before the guardianship case closes. He also asks that statutory interest be
applied, though he does not identify which statute applies.
Section 47106 of Title 18 of the Guam Code Annotated provides a 6% annual interest
rate upon the rendering of judgment, The Limited Guardian opposes the imposition of interest
but does not explain why section 47106 fails to apply to an attorney's fee award. While no
Guam Supreme Court case touches upon the applicability of statutory interest to an attorney's fee
award, other jurisdictions find that attorney's fee awards are indistinct from damages awards
when it comes to post-judgment interest, MidAmerica Fed. Say. & Loan Ass 'n v
Sh earson/American Exp., Inc., 962 F.2d 1470, 1476 (9th Cir, 1992), Associated Gen, Contractors
of Ohio, Inc. \L Drabik, 250 F.3d 482, 494-95 (6th Cir. 2001).
While Attorney Moylan asks that the Court permit the delayed payment of the attorney's
fee award on the condition of the assessment of interest, a delay of payment offers may still be
to the detriment of the ward. The Court does not have enough information as to whether the
ward will incur a greater loss by the immediate withdrawal of the attorney's fees amount or by
the delayed payment with interest paid upon the ward's passing. Now that the parties have the
Court's calculation of awarded fees, the Court asks the Limited Guardian and Attorney Moylan
to brief whether the immediate payment of attorney's fees causes a greater detriment to the estate
rather than a delayed payment with interest.
I B!
l .* n'"`\8 E*\. r.1:
Q
* E '-1F 11
s
T 5* 1 ti G mom
' :
SP0106-07 DECISION AND ORDER RE 1Y[ITORNEY'S FEES Page ll
D. Attorney Moylan's Request for Costs
Attorney Moylan asks for costs, including for filing fees and research, Under CVR 54.1,
an application for costs is first submitted to the Clerk of Court, who then taxes costs in
accordance with that rule. An application may be filed by the prevailing party within thirty days
airer the entry ofjudgment.
The Court will issue a Judgment awarding attorney's fees upon finalizing the interest
issue discussed above. By the discussion herein, Richard Moylan is deemed to be the prevailing
party on the TCD issue and the property transfer issue. When the Judgment is issued, Attorney
Moylan may apply for costs related to these issues as set forth in CVR 54.1,
111. Conclusion
The Court finds that Richard is entitled to an attorney's fee award of $210,738.00
Within thirty days of this Decision and Order, the parties may submit a brief on the issue of
whether the ward's estate will suffer a greater detriment if immediate payment of the award is
ordered versus payment of the award plus interest paid upon the ward's passing.
SO ORDERED this 15th day ofjune 202I .
HON E. YZE M. IRIART E Judge, Superior Court of Guam
Attachment: Addendum A
Appearing Attorneys: Jacqueline Taitano Terlaje, Esq., Law Office of Jacqueline Taitano Terlaje, for Petitioner Lina Leialoha M. Alston Douglas B. Moylan, Esq., Law Offices of Douglas B, Moylan, and Gary Wayne Francis Gumataotao, Esq., Law Offices of Gumataotao & Pole, P.C., for Richard E. Moylan
t"H`T»E~='=gtH
»< »a» 9*"&=L35§"..?f
.
, \ r
~<=. 'J z IZ ~.» < o o o o
E :| 2 3 Q Q 3 S 33 3 S 3 q 3 go Q S 33 S 'o 'g 3 ID o
8 ma s IO
3
o
S IO
8 o
8 'a1§ a
§s : no o so., l~ fn. 8 <1 co n_ 8 ¢o <1 co go o .. v~
3 s s Ana as 0 so so ease so w ee he as some so
o
ea Ana as
m o
Se
o
IO m o ca o o m "*: P 'Q Q q w: q '1 3 3 3 3 3 Q g "1 'Q q;
N
'u W co q» Q 1- N N 1- 1- P (D N N we (\1 2 'a
H i
ah :l
W ug
*§,;2i§§§
o :|:
§ s 2 EE 1:
N
r§§ g
's
L?
=@
S' ._ G
c
"Q av E __ §"§ c 3 8
,as
'g
Gs
Q .g
if! l g *fill s
a §->§ »"'§ .
2 3 Q; '°`
2
.. 8$
r~
Be 2
liiiéggll;i# ..§
w 1 - o 1-
D.
§
§
GO
igifiesN 5
iii
l ; }3*§%§H'*€$Ii =;
_lg on
`§
g §is
E
sat I n
2= §
'*~».
ifiligili §
it a i
egg Gs? =§ §@e H .._,-_,,
8
§ é E -~..-»
w
=~i avg
E
*i§§!§!§§E H so
o
EQ* *HY FQ
222 l' Q
8
kg;§;;s;;,;:;, J § Q o 3
.i gr; 1
9
41 8 °°l5
.§
2
§§ 7. c ED .3
5
Jet 5£%, 4.1i ,I _.- 23.2 :E
"*i§i§§i'l * Eleni;
Q 5%
§§
2
40¢0 §°,Q
:E
15 8 a w
o
=s'§§
5 §§§;§§§%§§E§§§§§§ ;§i§§§§i§§§§§ii§ § .g a. go
'C
§ E 0
i§iéiéliiiéi§§i§§§§;§§§§ii§§§§§§§§§§§§ r~ l~ v~ r~ r~ 'é
r~ v~ r~ r~ r~ 1\ l~ r~
o o
8 Q 8 Q Q# Q N N
§ §§ § go Q v~
g
N g 8 a g N 8 5 a :: 2 5 Q Q Q o Q
<r B §§ B g 0 §
m
Q
B S Mn E B B co E so Q r~ S ea B co g g
N
§ Mr < o o E 'g 3
o
Q 88
Rici 3 o Q S 33 3338 8° no
o
Q 33 3 Qo Qoo 33 Qoo v so 88% §s5#
'u 10 IO c o 'E N S S8
o
o 1-
Ma n n go] .8 mg 8 go I-O-Er § s 1 -
J
l~ o>
E g ea IO
as me he
o o
he
o
so so me so £19
o o 10
he he as as 8 IO I-O o
he
m
so so 10 I-D
he
o
so
Q
an so so
I-D o
he
"1 3 Q Q Q Q 'Fe ": "2 N. Ag N "2 *z o o 'Q
o q
1- 3
v o Q
"2 on 3
v
co N P co (1) o o N 1- 1- 1- O 1° P Q E 3 2 3 >.
ii 3, " 55; g 3 "5
cm
S 2*
§
0 0
§ 5` .=¢ §2 E 2
E
2-
§'
§§»§§i li a §§§ 2 to
§ §"§ 55 'E
W
§
"5 2 w ;
3: vo
8 Ag
°e
o 'vo
E
2
s
u= ¢ 9
S
§ .so S2 #sea ow-
it' ,£§§!!si ' I
c
5 `5 S w E
i
in 2 2cu
II' IJ.; b'§sf". S El!Q ui .itsi liIlI E' >
2 %
a ET 2 cIa
c
.Q 2 39
3
.§ 5% (0 .: 'et ¢= &
luigi-§i§s;: 1 :2 o
2 g .» Q o2§ 3 § ¢._ .
U)
'pa .s
we8 8 'E n .!=
~5 '§ fr
I i ' § § ! i § ~ ¥ ¥ !§§i§§§§§
E
"iii '
e a i f fiy ~ i1i!i%¥
if iiiiii
n! lx _"lim lpf I n s LE 0 § ~=;Q
Gil §§§==~1 "-Ir 1!"- "
9 5
u
nr
a
5 1:
&§§
i id!! I, I I 5s.55155 'I l;;
§§!§§, 5.§§-¥i J! Gsiiiiif lii§'§§1i E I§i!§s~i§'§§§§a
' c
& g S! o
Qin;
§ §§§§l§§§;l§§§§§ ;§§§?%§§§!§§§i%§i§!;§§ s
§§§§§§§§§§l§lll§§§l§§§§l§ll§l§§i§§§§il§ 8 g 1=
r~ l~ v~ r~ r~ I*- r~ r~ o v~
§ <8 o l~
Q
§ a8 1-
o O o g o a a g o 1- r~
a o
Q
o
Q Q o
Q 9. Q
B 'Q R R o N g 1- I*- R B au
Eg S of g Q of
Q
OF
'a Q :- ,- 0) --.
m
g 07 Q
m
2 2 OJ 05
,_
m
m
9 ff < E o 3 3 ood 3 o o o gi g o
Q 3 q,Q 8888 8 ,oQ o cg S
g Q q I-D'O IO
E0 o o S S <5 =;> S S #2 2 cl 1.6 url up essis 3 ID
a
o
S
1- so N
N NO 8 2 <1 2 .q» N co co :acc 11 s < < s E he Se
O
so
o
m e
o
ah ID S Q I-D se
ID
w
O
me
o
'S 'sv-
'Q 1 -
LQ 3 'Q N
o 1-
s as D 1-
3
'p
a
1-
gg
F
Q
1-°
2.
Q
gg N *
2. P3 N N Q
5 lc 3 of
lg* Iii; ii
g
' s "6
;.tE
E
E
Q
2
w§§;§.hié'i§§
E
o E
g
g
S
3
E'
E
'Er an .Q on 's
c
2 '§§ 33 Q o .6 g : 5_c
l*l ••
Qs :as
g
%§§§.9
an s 8 § 2.9 § 's-won
E5§i§!/§%i1i§2§ii§
vo •1 "6
o
E
22
v =E
2
6
Q w §
Se? go ;=§
ft
Agf a O d
4%l
*as go ill 8
sg E. é? ii; s,5§§ a*E 2 EE ea §2$ g 2' o 2&
. ,Q gt E §
c
o =2 'E
~5 33 g§§
illy* s 's _--_ m"=*= vb , -
E
? go vo § . :oE 0> ¢ _ .
u§§*l¢»l@§!§@%¥§§2°*f§§*
-1
*5 o as Q on S
Hz w e c cc c 4*
2
|2la;
l iii !?i§§iig§5 .Q .9 '°E'
ii ,§§§
Q-
QF?
-'U
if,
E b
Qu E <D>~§ 8 QL"
§~=
§a gtélléié s 25
3 Eiégii 5 § E
#ET £3 <5
§ =!3¥ qaéigéa . -=§§§¥§§§ if ~§
35
Os
a25 I ii§1§i€§l
iii il§§§ii§§§§§§=§
-*§*§i§5 aiééfs
§§ g §
c _o 'c §§§§§§-:§;§§§§§§§§§§2§;i§iéiiééi2 §1§§§l;§§§§l§§§§§lélfééiIE;illiéliégili
o
° ~x
-
o
r~ r~ N r~ r~ r~ l~ r~ 0888
gQ gg 8g
r~
'é gQ § 0 o
§Q 8 §§
v~ o l~
g 3 N 3 QQQQ g
g g g ov ggQ rs a §
O)
B
o
o
o E
O
o 1-
N
o g
no
v 6
o
a
v
B
<- v v
SSQQ
N
Tr
N
v 5 E' §
o 1- 1- 1- v-
Hz < E 8333333333333 33 E'it .8.8§§§§.§"si§§8.8
o
Q
o
Q 33
-g o
o
Q
a
3
ID
o
Q
o
m
20 'n
S
'Q
a
Q q
vv ° l*- N
1 Q
3 5 so .- .- 1-
< g 5 Se 1-0
me Ana Ana
o
as as h e I-O o
so ,no
so 1-0
he so
o
as 1.0
Ana as
I-O
so ao ee
ID
ea ae as
I-D
as
o
<~! 1-
3
o 3
o Q
N *t Q3
o 1- P
Q- 1-
"1
o
3
<1
'Q
N
"1 we
S
N
*": 1-
S
10
'1 fr
'*: -Er
'Q co
3 § g §
e §.. § _g 's 23 iE §¥H§~§§;¥§£=§;;
.s
°3 go 1:
'J
e.- 8 o D
8. _g
m
EE E .9 sB
§i§ E i e §§
§§§§§*§§;i2§;§
E
go
5 § §
2% c
.Q w
o§a
2
J §;§l"l;§§§ €lli§Ei§ Tv- £ °
Eh `E 2 g §§
._
§ §
TU
15
no
5
8
c
_g
P
§ a s .§§ 'en 'E
o E' 3:5,§
Q m
é
ea? § 2 Eal ...
2
-,
ii§§ §§%§2§=§§;*if='§ *i -r
2
=§£ e:g go E
§§i§ IE E »= 3 SQ# w '
..-.
`*~<~
>
2
§ ig§éi
Q
.z
4ga .z
§§ §§¥;§§§§ Lil;
FE
8
s 2
o o
ire
3
s is QU ¢...,. _. »~"
.. Q so
§@*2
-;
s
§
3
Egiflii §i§£& gt 2El.;
in
9
. § :E 2§ "5
2
"5
_n- ~°
gm Gs l d
i§i!§§§§§§§
'a
alma 2
B 3
.E > TO i .o _ s
§§Eé§k
§.8
£'E 'g
0% 2
§°3=§=§,§
5 .. . 8 i § *
'E c
s
§§§§l§§ E §§*§§§§§§ €§ ;§i51l==»§ll Egan
§l»¥§§§2:%%€¥%¥
E
2°
s Qi i is f g f s a§§§ I ii age §§£§§§~§8 §§§ é ll£1IIslsl!li§€§€§§l%l§%il§§§¥§l§l§§l Q o §9. 8 8 §Q S
o
§ r~ of to o 1-
Q ea Q ea o o
E
1- o
1-
1-
5 1-
S sag ala g ea
8 N g <rQ N Q o 3eo 3 a
B Q
<r g
I-O
1-
o
.§g go :§§ *g ll Q 1 -
Q Q Q Q Q. 1 - - 1- 91 Q 1 - v
v c 1-v o g o 1-
1"
\ . v ' N
1- N
v
3. T*
<1 <r 1- 1-
< E S o
s
E§ 8N. r~8 E q Q
o
.33 333333333 3 3q 8s 3o 8 s go; §§§§§§.§§§
:\ no m
20 QQ
Q
¢O 51
3 s w
14
< g § as
Q
so
o
me
o
vs ea Reena
o o f
996669 o o o o :m o 6 0 Q m
as
m
go. he as o .Q o
as
an
'Q
N
q
q*
'Q
N
s. Fl 'Q =t<=a
1-0 00€")
=t Q Q 8. Rx *. Q Q re N on v on co 1 N we co
*z we
~Q co
.Q ,v
Q
N
m_ lb
3 l~ Fl
an
§ Le 2
E
;Q2 : o
o §in§ e§ is,,"€ §
-2
i?
§;§
o
i §i lm;
§i %§géieig
U (D
c
a t 1: .Q
gt 8
3 §§§
:|
lg 2 5
o
m
c
ll; go;
; a
.a
,Sim - § l
*E*
i
¥iii"!'§§!
§€§§§
2
Hel ii 2
E
'Ne 2
255 "65
5
1 ,.._ S
§ll§§§_,
3 E rm
§=***ii'§*'*¢
.2 .3 § g
u.
3
. g Eu cu S
E
/ .
§l§ § §5
In
/p f"..
§ al* kg; E §§ ;§§§§l§§ 3 é §£§ E ,,-.= .
§§§§§§§§ A*El g iii; §§E§l§
§§!§§"= §,E5323
5
.J
§5§5
1152 g 2 .. 2 @2 E
8 u- E .E5 5 "5
iiggiig-u? ii.§i§ 5 2 .6 *
3
sgsg g
c a &"6&"~5 21
§§§l§§§ ~aQ€=§2 E t
§§§
M c
8
g o
`g§§§§ i , lg;
38e89°8
§2=§
00 qaé
w
§§§§
e o g
g
fiéié 2; Q Up{i§iiii§§§¥§§§§§i§ Elli E
e
82
§
3
555i 3 2 § § E§§E§g<sE
g
93 li§§§§§l§§¥§;l§§§§§§l§§ ~° s § S o
2
'é
1- F 1-
1- 1- 1- N N N N IoD ( D /~ I* r~ 'a
1 -
v' v I"- 1-
a
1 -
a 3 8
g of E `5 a Q R 'R r~ v 6 g Q "6 g ll Q a a N 1-
E 1-
"--..
1 " v a Q -we 3 E g O QS < E 3 :8 3 3 3 333333 3 3 33333 3 S § 1-1- arenas
'D o N ID o mmmwg N o S 3 58 s s i v F N
< E g so
o
as
Q
Se I-O
e»ae»eea ea as as
in ID o I-O
u se as he he he ea he
m
~= x Q "1 3 ' 1 "2 3 Q '~2 mq cq if N 1- o o P o o 1- we co co o o o o ID of _0 .as so
n iHi§ ".';ii
Eg 2 c
i=x E; Et I $1 £5| QQ
E
IE Ti5 § g2 lg;
lg, ;
2' 's :x é' "5 an
c
v:
E
;§:§l,§ §i*§'tEli
§§ Q
0
E
,M I _[E E §§§;§§i§i§ X
05
§§§li§§ mlsgsglai cf
§§ is iiiiiii
§ *E cm a» ll o-a
go iiiéiii §§§§If§i§§€
. p g
.Q 1: 0 r°rw\ A lr11-v-»
s
3 _|
>- 2 g u: .Q
r....n.
e/*
3 \. >
2 E s xi"
e
I s "If q I §is§¥§i§§§§§i I I
2
';§§§§§,=8§
as§§En§§§il=§ >
o
g
2
r no
bi
.Q
cm 2 8 8
25
a c
15
an .E
3
121 g§§§§§§§§§§§Iiiii;§§§§§if§ agog 8.8.88 E
5!£!€2i€€
"a
s § g 01 g rsssgfili iihl §5§ '5
s 95. §l§§l§§ll§§§§§i§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§ r~
o
'S n888°88 r~
O
g n cvgqg
0
r~ o r~
a
o
a §§§§§ 'S
a
§ ll a Q S E a g S (D
QSSSIQ Qo QO
3 Q
§@§s§ N N N
B
g
/~
2 < E 2 3333333 3 33 o 3 o o Q _Qo °. 3 o QQQQQSS 8 3 QQQQQ . . 3 995 r22as§5~
Q
Rx c `E 2222222 IO v~ If!
r~ of ea 8
co
r~ co oNo
v g
v
o
1-0
IF S as
N
0 'u 1: < sE 2 s w w a w se w se so so h e so ass Ana go. 69 69 some eeeaeeeeeesese so OOOOOOI-O o ID Q o I-D o o I-O m m o o o ca o mn ln I-O \Ql.Q'qu'.!¢Q\Qt~: 'Q N. 'Q Q **! Ag q; . . =Q=Q=QQQ~.'~= "2 o o o o o o o o 1- 1- N o o 1- 1-
E ac 3
§¥ 2% w E o 0
Q 2E;
'at
3 2 'é' o c ~<
-E
O
3Q S as
EE; =§
,Gs la
3
E§
O
as
-Qs
it é §§§_§§ E
2
S s>v~ s:
e me
QE o 2 15§ b
1§ §
i §§5§*
.QE So' g 2 a g 2°
ii §§§§§
TO c
so
E
I §§§i§
o
I
Gs a E
c
W
Ea E 2§§. §<v~ E .Q
3
1630. §g.%§ 2 E
;§ illll
m
E T... §§§§§§§ 2 '5:E' =§§§ 3
So :§ 3°'2838 §'6<» § ..
N U
§§¢aaa 8`
at I
§
E 65 Q.~"> 223 .S ...
nay; §§éié!§ g l gm-9
go!
.H s
w §l§§§§§§ c ode'
'al
8
*as
o
E
'E
o
is 5 an i, , _
i§§§§§¥§,§§§ 315 IFifi
E
£0 Ag .
is We; légiggs'
I IE'fl
2 g .8 so i f
c
o
°i
§%'iii§2§§£*§i*§§ QE' 2 'E £§§§s= >._a>
19:
.Q 2
.=
l
_s " lEE 'E Z'
§§i§§€§i=
8 : »2 .gwggs isggggg .§§i§ 22 3 i:'i*§*¥ *Si §§§§§§§§§§§2§§ g 4-»
.s $925 .go !"*§§§§l !§§i §!
lg?
§ggiggggglggggggggg gggl=§§§§l§§i§l§l 8
p
Y`llYll\l\l\l\ O CQQQSO r~ r~ |\ o r~
o o 'oS r~ r~ o r~ 8 o oNo 8 • aaaaa~a a a a a e a a o o r~ so oN o Q o
N
5
Q N 1- N a
N
g (r)
B
o
o
Q
§ggggggg Q R Q 0g8 co 1~ l~ r~ g R Q Q so
c
m
,j< E 'g Q
o
3. $ 3 3 88S88g 8 3 Q sq 333 S833
1: 0 `E o s S
N
v
Q
NI O :Q gggl r- so 2 8 .8 Q 5
o
mo 16 l~l Mn 6
§ N
$8 pop S282
<1 1 -s o
3 'é'
g < he 89 eeefa as new so so so so so as Ana Ana he h e so so Ce o IO ID o o o q "2 *. '.Q 'Q Cal N N 1- V
333333 11
co
3
we
I-O to of
3 3 3 o o N
3 .3 3 3 m o 1- N
E a ac 8
IQ*lg i ili§l,§l2 ~§ Ef
Ag w8
*ii g ` r~
Q
2
\v--
v
D. cm
é
o
§ s go; age
.g
'if :i~ .Q >
§
3
89
s
_ ti §§ 552
2: 5
§§§;;s
é \uA.w -§»;e§» cm.
3?
go 833
Si fiig gg .g
£?3§
»':2
5'§
E I
E
2
a
8
2
>
8
gt
r~ a§8 .35
.¥i'!i§-ia 2lg;
3 Q%= as q> 3 I 5 as 2 we
\`:z~"*"
I i § §i§i£££§i§!i. I "
.Q
> 'Q E 2"'a> *G
8 m o=SE
2§a
.2
8. o '@l;§
%;§§2;§; ;;;t;§§§2§¥l§gs gel _kg
2_5 ..|" .*
Iii §§si».§¢§';§=§; §.l§§ j .Q > t ll as; go
§i*¥.§i§i@l§§ii§*§i* lid*i ei."§ 635. ~§s- i....li== I; §.~§ll= ==» llffl §
m
.959 °*8 ?
li; l?
§ »
limi:-'iaeiiitgigla éQizéi..Ii
o
§
.->.c
¢ 2 o s§§§ s Ea
ziiiiii liI!!!§§§iMllil§=1!illl§l i i 'C x ea 8 .Q .m .u .as Q 0 E > F
r~ r~ :o- r~ v~ r~ v~ 1~ r~ r~ r~ r~ §
r~ r~ o o o o o o o o N
o N
o N
o o o o l~ 8 8 g a Q
Q N N o
N o
N a
s uB" m Q B B 304° o Q oo
Q
ea ea: of
vw-1-v-rv a a a a a a
2
of
I! E z.<, : m° N 'S
o
B Q g o
E 0 b bo
B § 6
g
s` m
'53 < o E :83. 3333S S 5533 3 3 o 'Q
o
Mn . 3338 32 3 Q 3 s-
E0 gt o 8 gag Sus
N
1 -
Cal
F
gggm we .s S v- 1
3 E m N 1- cm v 10 h- 1 - r~
< *g Ehe as www so I-O Q 1-0 o 1-0 o o as 9 so ea
1r0.o In
he ea 69
IO
Ana I-O
as so so ea I-D I-D o o
as
m
ah 1-0
sa w
N
. kg *: '=c |": kg
1- o N o co
Q
N "1 -q *°1
o o o
$3 vs
<1
"2
o
'*: *": 'Q 'Q o o N o
'1 co
N. 3 3
; ID
E
6
.Q s r~ 5- § §§ c
8
5
as
`;§ § ii* ii}%;§§
UI .E ,g
lg £3 f* § 1% -:.E" 3 a 3 =B-8 D.
B ='
c g o o Et S 0
kg*§§,»!
a a §§ ¥§§£§ 'E 'E o o .Q a
a
3%
'ii £2
ET c so % go 2 8 é §
§ § §§§¥§§ §1.§£§i u
3 2
3
O
s.
3
5 w s '8 VI 2 E 22° 5g
zi§i1,!i*!€§i§§ viii, i- 5 i E oc as c 4 c
go
ii! z I E >~$ 'o 3 cu == .Q
m 4-v
s' `s_§
c
§§§§g§
o .n = m oo ' o5 E m ea
pp. Us i14.%§ ~= 0 _
o * t 1:
g? ... ii g lg
E » .
g §¥§i§i§§¢ iité ft gt :ii'l'=.=i isgoET
0
iii'
I= x..>
g .»
i§i:!€..l»
.\
wt! §§i§§§§§ s ;§i'l»i§¢§§ is FH §
as
g 'u o 2~ § Ia E
21§ii2§ iiiii*§ H*9 % % st?
o
lgsll D. gpa ;
ll g sig a
o
2: 1:
'cf c
g E
o
9Q
.o
Q*
8 .5c
i ¥*§§li§pll §§§§§s§¥§l i:i§§§l§§§* ._
co r t o
c m cu
r J §u§ 1 5 -¢52 ii
9 -2 2 »-
8
o
a1%
._
c
Ililéliifffurlgfiiigliill§§§:§§§§;
E : `D
§§§ii
av c .0; .
E s-
r~ r~ o r~
o v~
o v~
o r~ r~ r~ r~ r~ N r~ l~ r~ r~ l~ v~ r- to~ v o~ |\
o a o 0 o o Q N N N N
o
o g g g 8
Q Q Q §, Q
r~ o 8 8 S8oQ N 8 8 3 a a 8 B l~ R 5 E 8 Q <r v r~ w \ 1-
Q
1- g Q N N a av.
co a a g
al: Oleo * Q B 2 of
t Q Q
of ea Q
co
QQQQQ of ea ea GO om
2
om g G O) om ea r . GJ U2P o g
Q
9 1-
go < E 23 3 § 8888888888 seas 88 §§ Q§ as
o
Q Q 3 3
o o
S n' ,of d of ii 6 ii vo of o.onn 2 .1-- 2 5§ go S 2 l-0 O N 2CO eg g s 2~s 8= "E 1' m 'U 'u < E a s wwwwwawae8 ee so he ease 6196n9 we cease me he 8 sown 4:>'u'ao<:oc>mo o o 10 1-0 o o m o 8 2 I-O
*z
m
.r~ r~ v r~ 10 Q 10 10 1- Q q ; "': to 'Q -ng 1- c:ic:S.c:i,c:5c:$c\i<\idc*5 1- N co o o no 55 2. o to
833 N *t
o 'o
Q
E
i a 6i§ I
; 3 § *i
v* §
co
3
ht, ft MQ; §.! Si E* Ar
_
2
8
§2> USE §§§
.g §§. 2?85$ g o E 12, 1.2,
N
q
1-
2§- lg ! la! n 3% :§
ET
5 no '5 .so
_ _ ;
l iiQin!
i §§§%i:. D.
w
liggi ; g;1_1
!i§§1*'
lg.
a
2
al'Eiiiii
"'la/~;;§§
1. 'iii2Wt
O
0.
§§#'1. :gt
iiii2i'!!12
2
Ag; I ,v ,-
I Ji : .
, -
¥ill§i§ll'zi'i F t;
!!iiiiI§ lim.
alia I
i{=l§§§ii
i
?
'23 so'
°EU:
o
122%
=§2
o :§
i i.;
%§§§iiii~i,I!:lil i"'§i¥='="ii' '
2 g 8
9 .9
El; ;§§ E
i ~s §55i list;=;§5§E§§i;i§§;'§
as4c 3 'u-
s Lil l.~-'ll i#éé
i~ Q t
aélfl liillll;ll§l§§l§lll!Slxl;Lai `§ 8 g l=
r~ r~ r~ r~ 8
|\
'S g 1Ng~ r~l~r~l~r~r~ v~ E "
§ S § s 88 3 g o o @ o
v~
§ 83
r~
o
.3§
Q
BQ a S % go Q Q
8
ES
ET g, a g
§§
<1
o S m m o o o o 1- 1- 5 5 B
v 1- F 2 ,. o
~.¢ < E 218 38§8~=8§8§§§§3§§3 as Se IQ Q ST S o cg
o
Q
o
'D §§~§'§s§~~~~§~s § as 3 § : S 3 IO ws N m N o c 1- o 3 N \- o m 10 S
3 < < s s al" he Ana as o o o I-O o o :Q
N
aassaasissasssss 1 Cal
3 8 1-*GI
'Q ID
Q
W
2
o
3
N
to
o
Q
N
3
of
11
N
E s xo s Q
§
% i E a*
if II isi ; E
g
'o
o
3 i
9
'" I* *lg
3o ,Q
¥§§§§ *ii 2§=:¥§
06 o s 5 O
Q 5
's c 'u Q m N O
ii
15
2. ' Ii
2 ii£=£§£E.v§*!; 5
's
9
I
"l§vlE=E.f§i§ii§
o . }
§c
o
ig
o
'E I a o o =
;
higii g If;
H l.*-sz.. - ££,93i 3% sQ .E 1 .:
2
I *If I Q
lg, §!i*qH.@!§i-£ II
2 c a of m §§
BilMil
s Ia
.S
5
go? °¥ 2$E§»Es£§S 2 'S Egg; E I 151 ii Ill"*l'i**i¥ 'E 'é
'E I QSs imies*
s
lliéii Qs»°* § Q = £2 8
Isl"1135i § a sin HI .*.i§hli ,lzii §?§%€
g
e»
Iii 31.ii glim;
ii51i "!'IiiI 1il!lisl!tg1 rn- Iii
.viii ill}§§§§ ii§E§ hhnl
§ ;1i§I§ as z Ifiiiililfaiiliiigé rin! iii? I
ghiiiiililliiliifiliilifililliiillxlé HUH!!!
"""5555 » SO r~ r~I*- v~ r~ 8 oo 8 '5 r~
|*- r-
"8 S S S O O O C o Q O O S 5 r~
o
o
l*-
o 8 o
Q Q Q Q Q Q Q ° ° ° g Q a 3 S QQ 8
o
ll N \» oao>s
Q
q Q \ l s\ 3g-QQQQQQQ QQQo B gQ; v
: "
a
Q
Q -we
a
B 'a 8 Q Q
v .- B G
°
§O v O v vOvQrQvQvQvOv vv1v- VPF v v vFvp 1'
1-
. Q
1 - 1"-
Q
1- v 3";~ 1-
a N § 1-
.. a
N
1-
'S` go < o o o E :| u 333338 Q I-O q 3. 3 'Q m. Q 3. 33333 3 3 3 3 3 Q %8 fl'3°2
2 0 3 < g < s 8 r- co m
o
g; 1-
10 a 8 § Ns 8=s=.':
N N
S S
2 v vN to o
ID -we
E it? he ea 9 et Q < as he 69 he so w e he .eaeenew wanna; 69 1-0 IO o o o o 1-0 zoo ID o I-D I-O m ID S 1- 0 I- O o o o U 1-
*s 3 *. Q q \n
a n cm o n N N
Q
N
3
N
N.
o
i v, 'w Q
co
"2 co
Q; "': "2 *t 'w N Q on o we
1- l~: q Q o c o N on 00
Q
ca
_o 'E ah 3 o
g i
:|:
*a
i i é 8 _,_,.9
.55 .Q
§ S
3
gigi El Q; § *5 c
a? $ 0
'E
i E §
g 8
2 2 §§§§§l§ Q I§ go 2 > i
§ 26% ~§ §€§
§
2 E
§ 5 5la* ><8 §§ 2
m 3
El I
al* =a U
o
E
=§§ Q; §
8
El
I
- gt iii l§fi§i
Et 5 8 E.o_ _ J Si? §2 .Q
115 *i
's .»..
22 §»§§ & § ii»
5 3 u g o 2 o xi - u
iii*§§ § §§§~§Q i @§ g Hali a= _
gt ii* 55
'ESQ .z
§§s§ E
.`§
9; go
. . Q
6 \
i %§§=§=§¢-li.§§ gtliu 'Q 2 QQ § é§'="
3 iii i §§5; Q
r..-.;~
225ii,i§§iii§§222
2 a if c 'u
of
o Quo. - 2 g 8 2 §
EE*
550)
bxs oa°'t 2°§"= 3:
§§§9 g §22 > s
`§*a as
S§s
a §~'§§§ .
§§§'?§il§tl§§; %`*§E iiii in D. G.
. o
pa
Ll. u. ~e
;§§§¥€§iii-
CE or
Q '§*a.§s on ea pa §
2
go 3°M"»e&§_§si §§i,,§s9}
38
6 :38363 o
QQu e 8%'§§§§§§§§ §§~=
2 - ,§5%
=__= § ; '
Nm
eg-.9
o
s >>-U g='z§§£§§§§ gom ;§_.E EE;
Hgiiii
Q.
g ><
go §§§§§.f§.§s§ ii
§ c 8o Eg ; I-
"S 'E
c
o
§§§§ §;;§§§§g
"Q" ggi
*;i o if 'E -r
I
r~ l~ 8 Gs 3
r~ r~ r~ |\ r~ o o o
g go 1-ofN §§§§§
Q o 8 8 8 o o o o 8
§§§§§§§
g
ea r~ u-
N
1-
8
1-
N
1-
Q Q |\ 1- L:
N
1- 5'
222§~
5 g o v- ggggg
ggggs
N N N
Q
PP av
ea
E 1- =! < 3 333 S S 33 33 gVin 3 3 'oQ oQ o
la 'so § 8 as is nm s E o g S 33 355 8 3 Q :| IO 10 u'> |*- o o 2 of 3% St'""' 1-0 u 1:
¢*> vas Nov r~ so '5 1- 3. 1-
1-0
F
1 - W neo ~=r
2 *a
8. 333 3 o we
N
33 83833 333 1.0 o *`*! Q 1- O
32322 2 of
E co W P G 1-
3 ac 3
§§2 § E i ss 1
§ ;¥ .Q s:
E; g!§.§§§§, i§;§'2§§ s: .1 3 go g
i E §i§'. as 2 Q'
5231555
5
3 L. 2§
E Ag; so ag lgrligi
S
i i g hill; i tg Qs
To 8 i i ti
3
Ag a §{§*
I; §§ §§
€ I H * L .2
o
E \
a
iii
Q 2
=!.5'§fi
8
W Hal
o
En- vo
§
-g»
3Q ...
:iiiiiiMii
8
§ §§ Sis? ff
E
...I 8
c
3 c Q
/ f
§§§§*§
'Et o
i Na !**Ii=i= 3
8
; .Z
igiiiiiiiiiin Q Qg* §§ I 8 .Q a:
'5 >
*tip*i!i
S Q
§z§i
g
°§ Q PS
aiiii Z' I g i-12, § 23 "E
S 8 : Q?
Q I, ,='
_ro
§ 8 8 _
§§¢ii%§§i§§¢I§
c
3 1:
~-
52
o 'o 8 2
a :i
Q
' x 'E _g Y a
Q §€§s §<8
£2
:i
ili 315i§§'
mfiii f='.¥i§§
at* i¥§¥ i i
._ o 8 3 § 2:
2 S' .J éE
l~§i;§ ; liM ii£:E§i *.1§§2§§ §
2 'c e
8
o
al ll; ll .Q 9:
Eéfizi
gt.
5ll§l§iii§li1£illi§i:ii llltil i ba
g .N
txllfxillilm
l~
of as of of no 8 Q of of of of of of coco Q go g to to o
t o o f
o of
g o §§ § Q 9. 8 8
Q Q Q o o a 3 o O
g N
g
3a 0 8 o
a B R go g
*
8
Q gN 8
N o
o
N
8 8 8 3 B N a ..-
1-p EE
Q *-. --. --.
531- :1-Q1-E- Q 1 "
so "--. v- Q 8 'QQ
v* 1- -_ 1-Q Q Q. : 1- v- -_ g r.. x '-.
1 - 1 -
"1F -
|I
we
f; Q < o o o 8 'g 3
o
333 S 3 333 S 338 3333 S 3 sss§
E an. 3 Q Q Q .
NOS o S QS- 1- <1 gun '°8-'93
`E 8 lco
- r~ 20 ID St 2 m S 2 S p
<0 v an 1-
o
co
B < s ro w
'g
E
< ea 69 GB he as so
o
Q
11'
I-D '*!
W
we o
Q 3 2. 2 3 3388
N of Q
o
Q
N
Q
P
o
3 Q 1- N
o
3 3 3 gcm0AgmoQv 'QoQ
E
a
xo
3
I 2 § r;f5 §§
8
I: Fl
Gsg s L 'U
Q is'
'c m ¢:L
§ vi
iii ft? #iii i
g
8
o
3
Iii iii!# =;¥%i5 ég
o
§D o Vi E >x2 5 2 c
o
a: E E mov:
o n. G §~.g§ .Q
U
.3
9
§§591 §,Q iiiii§=§ "in g
£32 :L mg 2 " Ia 0 4; c an al
11
:|
ET v: so 0 A g_ m U 2 \-
§
8` 'a v .c m . < Gag*
Qt- 8 3 1v.:°5
ii
§: Iii? =iié'iii§iiH
i* 3-is ilg
3 c Q ..
3 8
So 2 E if Vo u2 E .»» tlég 3 E; l: E__ =2 E £21
E m .
.go g gm! - m
o
~§°'e °2"' _vo -_
Ag. I" . Et m 5 E §
'§¥'tiif§§§¥§§i' Pg!
:8EI2 2 °
§'2 -5 : ii s Q S; is 2
3% §§§§§i.esSit ;
's 3 .232 . 33 =293 .§=*`
"'§§2§§
'lidi iVlilifiii
Elia! I Iii s ligig iiléfv ll; o pa
pie 81: o
P* ii; {*la:»*l§l'
.,§ 2 30 §9Iii
><
"ii£ii.i!£5!%§!ii
r i*' 05-»» 21-:E.-
2
8
as§§;i%;§§§ii§
QQ O
it! Wt!! .Ii i ilg; m 3¢ n §<QES § o
éiééllléllliialglQillllllllig lieig o v- <
* 2
52% .; by;
8 § o8of o8Q Sa § oa ggm¢ of of
8
8 of 3 § § 8 §§°§§ no 8 Q
a
of to §
o
3
o o
QQ§§
o
B Q g g gggg
I Q
N
B
E 1- B B Q a g g N
g "E= Q B Q §=a§ N N N
B
Q v-
Q 1-
Q Q QQ- Q S S S gggg of v 1-
1- 1- 1-
ID 1-
5 °§ < E 3233333333333 33 *s 333833 3333 3333 3 E5??~§22a8 .8§ "3"38§§ #25535 w e a\-* I* ~n r~ o o 2o E < s of 1 -
g esaoaeefaeuaeaeoawee s e a OO!-010|-DSI-l'3DOOC)
3 3 *'*! <\! 3 Q q Q -Ag SNQQ
0
1-0 m
eeefaeeaeaea
o o ob
assesses 69 ea vo he O l-O l-O ID I-D O O
Ana IO
'Q'-Q<l*!"°:N o N o o o o.":=z~=2~Q=c 1- N 1- o o of <r F F ~Q~.~!<\! '1
fl¢l 2% : .
s § : a iE Q
Qa g al*5 H E 'I =l §
8
§ 5' i ,g ft § lg gr
is 8§ 5, }
§ at §%§!l§'§
Na! § § l==l *E iiis ;s
8
Liz" 3 *I i%:§*
o Q !§'!§I *f§!§*'i
~§
.§2
.
¢§!/iiiiiii g_.
I.;
§'a *I gt
-* 3 ._
8
g
o
2
8
.
5 5
-»
2
g
8 g §
2
i'I§'
8 0 0 8 %§:,°-- 0 o a iii"
I ..
g g§"5 E ° 5 § 'u 'g 5% 'Q . g *§»§ an 83
ii,i;,iii;i log*=*Hf . 31 M.: Q.I .I I go
5 o > 2 .. 5 g n
§
8
S
.8
2
fail lai I i i i3 E' 2 agziéiiilli §§§2§§§§§§ iii* go H lg 5 2 _Q
2 2 Sm
8
a »§§§§i gtéiz i3i§* ,g 52 * i
8
é g o_ m g .Q .2
s °15 2 ;5~,5 8
Q
n ii§ g.i!§ n*§¢=I
><
.8
i!!Mi!i§i }§;gii%!£ §@ 'E°.,
3§§§,1i go z
i§§§**il§.' . § §i§§ §s§§§**ils&ii§§§§§mi§ Eire l
9 §l§ 9 8 e E
.Q a:
a ad
§s6
2
sEl gggisl ii 'zsa 'llT u I no w
§§§§§§ ea
§8§§ §§s§ § w m to
of of o 8
;éégg§§g§§g§ 8 a Q a g : 23 :B :B1- SR =Sa$ ea$$ Q2 so co g m Ia<*>waco gggg gggg au
'$` so 1°-
o °E < o o o
E :
E§38§ 3 3 33 N 3S 3 3 553 3 3 3 3 333 3553 o 100 Asa\-
Q Q Q
3 5 gm 1-
'D v 1- N l~ o o IO c o 3 S 15 S 1- 1- - v co 1- ro ~='.> Q to 8510 1- ID ID I* 3 < ss 1 - 1 -
2 s eeee aeeuaeeee ease ease was was so s o as as h e a s a s Q w w w ID o ID 10
O
Q Q
O o
l~»
o
1"1-
u'> o
' QS~ ! < = .
m
H Q
o
as 33
my
2 3 *t
o
IO n.
o IO Q "2 Q
o
Q N. "1 1- O O
Q Q 3
3i i i w N O *l' o o F Q N 1- o
ac :I o :|:
i s I I I I-» E g lg I 3. iiVI I Higiii2g
#ii
,g sh §§§ lg?
s
.2 c w <
1:
ll E Q §§§ c5
iimis
ii HI 5Gs;' 1g; vs!Siiiii é 3 5 go
;;;§{':=§;;;;8 g I Ig
g
§
go , .
I
!i-I .s E u
'6 `5
f..
iii! H E Ag; Q ! 5
ii ,Say
I 4!!fiéigiis' 'i §§!§§§
2
I H55 =§
8
F*Q£5
3 z ...\
.2 'B i'f§§
Ii 'ti' *I g
iijglii ** i I §§l.iiI8*1.i§ ""s!"H5!1§I al,
51;i1.1
Eialéli !iI!!!"1i! in liisl% sliililisi
ll it" lit
iEI il
2E I F
sf, i
i"i§.ii§ iii c o
1:
E Iii? Ag! gll1lssz,l:!l!1i;lllilélilll;llls;l;l El! ii!
0
I
§§§§ 8 8
ea of of of Q to Q of g 8 o o a B §§88 g o Q Q 8 8 g g a o Q g
§ Q 0h"- ¢*> RESS g o 3m m3 gF vg Qg It we
a
Q :up
'S` I* 1"
2 < ti o o E Q Q Q Q Q 33 333 oQo 3 3 3ID S SO 3 3 S 33 SS E0 3 g <
o
o
of
o
N § 'a s go SR" S oz 5 so S SO S 2 m o
IO
o o
2 =§
< s E < Ana Ana Ana 9 he Ana Ana Ana he he Ana Ana
§ §§§ 5E§§T§§.§ Q o Q o o 10 o I-O o lg
o
we; 1-
Q
m
'Q 1-
Q
N
go o
Q
1-
'Q
o
sq
o
Ag q o F n. q
o cm
_g a ac o
*§*sessq
iis Ii Q .Q s
53535
$ 9 *§ o E ~3
I;5¢ ' e
z 8
gt i €
s 0 0
§!1!
2
o
3o
g* *§ §§ §§
S' Q 9
g D
'a 01
§§§§; 5
\; m 8.
i EQ iin%§§§§ ii
< < > . o
lI o u E z sQ a c as
"EEE§i§
o
's Q E
,My -,sgssslm
N
.5 §
s 3 I
§
0
§0 cm 3 \}
go;
co " 6 'o
Gina 5235 o
o
E 5
§'a'
O
a
~3 1. J
~s=;§;=§£§ §€2 2 s
E
giiiiig;
oz
goa 2§"'*
s sos°.:~ Ill iH"s§»§l2§§§ 5; E 3 522 2 E Ea
s .5
it 2 § 1t§§§§§§§§
>
2
i; ll'llI!s1i§m§§§§§
v>
'viii §!§I='=' l§§§§§§
o
3
.Q §; 1:
illiiuigi...it >
§"a's'§.8i@ §
M
9
'Q
c
E
liifillliil a .g»g»g.3 gs
Qt 3
D
Hrrrrégé
8% g
gigi °§_'£= 2§ 2
g .'s :O';
~._ 3
£3 § .c
i i ;§@§=?-'i§§'§'§'§5§=l ' iii?
.9 'o o Our Qm 5
E gfiggg Sr .!5 s58'%%§§§!3§»!§ gl§l§§551§§§§§:ll§;§§;llilililiilé§l .u
0 'Ru
of
o
of
o
8
8°°8 @§§ § s §%§ § 3§§ 3 g
8
ea to
o
8
m
o
o
no to w
o
8 N N g § 38 3g §§ §§
o
Q a
g
g S S Gs Ag
%g a o 3 cm <r R g R P a m m
D Q -Er :weEq*s.
fr g Q Q Q g Q1 Q
< IO Q
ID
of
9 1- .j < Q o o S O o o E 5 2 S 33 3 oQ 'Q Q Q I 3 3 3333 3 S 3 v lo Q Q S 3 g§2§ <1 2
U (\1 I-O o N r- N o IO o c o 'E 8532 % to
2
co : 8 S
o
m
ID N 1-
v~ o
o co P IO r~ 0 q) 8
5'é an m v cn 1- v-
et 'L 1- 1-
3 < g E so ea so so as so he < ID o 3 o o o 9 2 .s lg S g o 11 N co o an N
8
N
8 3 Q Q
t~2 Q 4 Q o N o N
2
N
I-O N. CO
Q
<r
10 m N. "°1 O D 1- O
o
'Q q;
(D
Q
Q
1-
é S 25 o
I
:if iii' 5
§§§§
% § §; S ,iii
Q
15
I
i§it;
in § 3g ,_
1
!1 1 0
2
ii* gIa o
s§'l
5
at § le ;
s' EE? s §§g'§§ I ! iii QE i t } I § §Q ii §3 §-.§ i §§ §¥i§§% gt
I
3
_§§ E§1 in iii2i ;3
s"
~§§§§
, _, . ,
siégega
all,ll§§i§§ §£%u§§§ 111§§§§§...
:%!i»=° '
i 2% i
§.0
¢;§§l;» Q .5 fa §
o
f ._ _\
£p21 f S ***§i§iii"
I;-
.Q l§§§§ h§¥' =
fgiéglg
lg Q g 8 §~'!.c
girl iiiiI§'!Ii: in£i§§§ o in as c
§§?'*.;"'!i'§ {§§§l§§§§g€ *§§§ Qt;
.Q
ala; ;¥s§§'§ go Fig 's ><2€~E
: 'c
;' 3 % §§ go
§i1mi §§§IiIIi!3 ' vag§!§§§ Ea Q I-i1 w 8 o
FH121i o N Oa .5
liléliillgllll s§ili££i§!lli§ >
go ! Q .9 1 8 Ea! 2 £
Q
.9°
's
2 5
9
of m of 8 of to m as so L , of of of of o o o of of to
o Q o ea
8
o S o Ng N
3 Ng Qo oQ no
g
• a a a
o
o o
Q
8 a 88o is 8 q- q- g
N
B
8 8 8 8 a
Fr 8 N
B g N
s E E Q Q co 0 o
g
<o
Q
so co co: w co co
s. co Q
o
<1 g Q Q E S 'Q
ea B B o o Q
o
E
Q
ea
'$` m 1-
o ng <
o
E3 'g Q 833833 So SS 3. 33 3 33333333333 'D c 2 udooaomo 'g m $33833 1- p gQ a .5 ""8 S1'S88S$1'8§% m et 3 < s*a L 1- v 1 -
s s as ea as w w ea es w so me as he he he Q; he as as as as ea so w 1 0 o 1 0 o o o o ID IO 'U 0 3 3333 3 1 o
m
SO
I-O
QD
o Q -Ag Q O 1-
o
q
1- v o o 1 - 1 ' d c l 6 <6 Q-5 l~:
2 'E Hz s *c -'E
12
: up
s gt E Ii 1,g32 2
ii §§;§§!hl2i!1/§ _n Q i
O
3
i Q! go
N
'U
m
§'§§§ €§§' §. so' .Q 'D
§; i§§l` " 2's 2¢°> 0 ;.= E1E§%i{%§!1i!i=;%! .1;§a.»;: t EE 3 ;5 c
e
2 co .s 22
av:
.E
4/1 00
'cl
2 i
*E Ag; g O F
U) r Q Q == ..
' _'REP'
g 'o E Q 8 =
mu; qt gr;I If g g'*il§¥*§=§§
m
no ._ 'ea §
c
g 40 g I
§§§%%Ell§§E
§ £1 *s ii I §§§§,¥ii!lIi
6 E :|
&1*§§ n i
o
='*ii}1
.5 .L s
:l 'E 9
9
:J
iiiiigiif E! ii!! »off
=€
.Hat
ililh 'Q I1 s E572 QB
E
B
I. is,
is! liiifiiilr ..
§23§§§§;;§§¥§§ §% 3 2 go..
llsii' -2 i§i§§'i""".§§§§§» eiggéiiiié a. c - o o §
EE
5 on
lti %ii=%%1
*a al§§§§,§§§§
'c E v
g §§§§§!l!!!§!;l2§E£l§£l£l£§l§£§;§ ..~
83888» of
o
N N o
a
of
N oN oo 8 g o o
§§ of
S
of of 8 8
of
o
a
§ gggggg r-
BB 'a a 8 8 N Q E Q 9. 9.
Q
ea 'go <0 'R E Q
l*- 1~
'fa " ii-"
o
g II
N
< E :8
O
Q 3. 3 3 333 3 o
Q
o
sq 83 3 oQ Qo S 553 33333333 ea an 358° §mg§§=§§
:| 2o 3 2 SO o ggwQ 1- 2co IO
N
co
Mimi so 8 2
10 ea
3 < 2E Q Q 1 - 1 *
s sw as as ah he he he Ana he so was as w e n e w w w w w w w ea ea O ID o IO
Q
03
11
0)
1-0 o N Q P (NI
338 3 Q *Q we
i n "': co
:Q vs o o
If)
N
. 33 <*) ¢') 1 "
Ag 'Q *": 'Q Q A g 1 - Q D CO ¢ O N 1-
3 HL -5
O
c
c
g 0
`5
E; ~§ i o o
;;§§ §§§;§§ s~§§ § 2 2 c 2 .,= Vu 3
m
g .Q _Q
06
gt 5 0
aw 1: N fn
I' vi 2- I .Q
'E a>
E
2o 3
c *5
c ea o G2: g ea 8 a5 : an 35.3
8
E
8 s
_ g g . s ,t g léé E l lage E Q- Ii I a
.5> §°~¥ Q . c
S i 2 2 go
§§@i§§§§="§i§§* i HH 2 E
a 5
"6
Iiiiixi
W a. - c g
lai § §§%i§
vo
H; ,§§ al g . .
go: t z BE
go ~2 §§
E.»2"6
Inkg § s
§§¥§§§§§§'§',§§§l**i§;,
o o 9
8
8
D
' . I
§*'ll§2§;§:-*§* ggiig- ii g if Q;
E l§§ it Iii §i§i£;£ "6
I-"E as
.9§g ID m"" 'a .Q
s§9 'S B Ia § s '6
i§§§,§§
E 52
E%§§ 2 I .E
a s
Gs i; Q E
llliill
3
§,§§#"P8 _° .Q 0235* O
*s .-'_ ~5-8§% g .§
;§§§ii§§§§§§§§;§ Eiggggigigigg .o
s 9:
g§§§§§§§§§§§§§§l§8 §l§@§;=§§§§i§§§§§ m'2§§'SEE
8 S 88 8 8 o §
co
of
8
of
§ S 'pa o o o on on w
g <rt8 38
Q
a a a o
o
to 8 Q Q go
5 go a S 8 5S g SS 3§§ Q B <o r~ 1- 1' 1-
B B
r~ r~ R
Q
of
1- a g v
Q Q ea ea
m
S So OF 0; om 1 F ' 1-
1-1P' 1
- F1'' _
F 11-
v'' 1' P
N
a DC < o o o o
33 o 383 ,re Q Q o E 33 Q Q Q S 3 S 3N 3 3 3 3 :|
20 2go by; 2 N R 23 v §m§
o
cg m 'S
1-
mo
N
to
. Q
I-O r- ZN 1 -
3
N
m
Q
v
h-
of
N
P
N
P
Q
o
1-0
3 < s coco 1 -
s s -he ea
I
so he Ana he
o o
ea se h e as as
o o o
me he
Mn
he 1-0
he
o
he 1-0
so
m
so
m
ea he O ID
ass so 10 m
he
o
32 'u GI o I-O ' 1 'Q fr N
O
q; '-Q P o
*I
n
Q
ew
Q 'Q Q N Q 1-
3
o
°! 1-
Ag
F
Ia.
o
°*!
o
"1
o
N
co
"=c<~! 1 - 1"
*t *t o O q
1-
Q B 2 o
l`=§§ §§ ;§3§
2
uW
2
l~§ - '
iffiiétl 5;§
iigllgiégii
§ § ..c
o
1:
2
:
'Q
2
a o
5
E =%¥§§ 1:
m Vt:
"'
;'§`*l§§§l§- €..§;§
P
-I .i
o
a . o
I
§,§%,§§§§
(D z
§§§ w .Q >
O
242 §
: c g o `5
i3§§
o 8 (0 I 8. 2 s =§§§ § 8 ..F ¢.
*
o l c 2 5
s=§i
E << Ea 5 § § 23b 38
Ur »...__ ,
to é'
-... §
2
§
-.....
> S
;» 'iégéé
E\- o _ w- o Hz •1 <9 8 9
iglij s
5 *a
8
§§§§ 2"-2 vi sag 322 egg §§.8
§§§; ;§¥§§'§§§
2 .: c 0 -»
=§ 5§5s a
3? *5 Ur:
5 §§*s§§z§ §<§ f; i
D. 3 » \
Ag $29022 <
. I
lg E
':§s§§§§§
Ein l '
no ,ago *l;§§§*
sugf'ii 'iil glli sQ *i§§§§§ G s 8 (D(D_g
Q : : ¢-»9Q. QS. EE is 'E g .
510 w s
Q U
of
§l§§ 8i 5 §§ii- Ii wee § ll
\.
§§ 2 go €og§l$._ °§ 'Q
l§§l5';*h *§§§rig;.2§§.§ §
£8
°;sl= § I §=:§*§=*»*l§2§i~l*r E §=§*°2:§§l §£ i1!1§§§sl£El1§%§§§l§§l§i§=§§i§l§§s§ ,g
g
g3hiLi§s§§§§§§isilééigigiii :Sian isééiiilii O) m 8¢> of 88§ o3 m §Q ea
OF g o §8
a § 8§ § 8 8
g g 1'§§
B Q Q c
Q
2% 1- § §
vN 3a Q Q § a a 8 8.3.
E N Q \- 8§ g
0
Q
-§
g_ _ § § § § 1- 5 v 1- g g v- g §§ Sg <r <*> co
N
5 N
¥ < E 2 o Q 33 $3
o
q
o
Q
o
Q 33 "q"q
o
Q q
o o
3 3 'QQ S S NQF'Q mo. as § 8
10 r- I*-
U c 0 m `E 1- '55 r- 3 I-O
I-O on (\l
an m r~ N IO 1- (0 1- 1- |*-® no
r~ co
o
1-
g < ss 1- gr) N
g s so he so Ana Ana so as he QB he he as so he Ana
o
he I-O
so he 1-0 o
he ea
o
so so ah
o o o o o I-O I-O l-D 1.0 ID 'Q o 10 10 ~.=~! g o -Q
Q
'Q O) 1"
ng 1-
Q
F
*. "°': Q O
=Q~Q Q 1-
Q
N
Ag
N
"': '-Q Q N
3
N
-Ag 1-
v ¢*! *"! Q o 1-
E Q 1- (\l 1 -
g l .§23§§
=I E .25Q of,
3
:I
rss ' E c
c
a
3
..=
.c o 8
(0
°'
§ 25 25 g 8 0 q) 3 <5
i§ g
o
: on w
2 ..=
(D m
8 L
Q .
3 2 0 Q. 8 2 c "6 E 8
m :» .Q
ii**iiiii §§W§i§§§§ E go o
ET ; o 11 o Q *s 5 .3 2'
iiI*§8§i§i iii s
'6
If o ° = as a~E §
Ia m E 2
8
§ 3"-
of
.i%i.§ ;
"5
5282
ii!0 5§t '2E§
Ag;Q
> E o 0 2350 g an E .Q m 1:
E
:E
2
1555; o E 2'
g
( 1' `
i»i** § g 3 Ii in E iii; §§§§§ E E o 5_51
S
o
E
o
§§§ §§§ %§§ §§% §"§§` E9¢ on 2
»55O°a
§
EEO,
'u ..
zlgi zia8 E sea
§ =§§§ *%i*-§ 8§§*5§§ é'
§
co
~¥;?%=8 E2§ i t
§ It§'=§ . =*% ii go . .
Qgueg 'E
llfgigg "ilg'is !3, .-§i';§§§§§§; ,R at
8
ITS; I s§§§§g "5
5% E; 32 go .§§s§§* §§»~ au § .I§§2§ ¥s§§ s%§»-
.gg
¥*l€§;*l;§.l.=@ i=¥~§=~2§§§§=§,§ £3533 U O
Iiii%¥ia5¥ii;¥g§'§¥3§i§¥§';52§-si§§s§§l Q; 5§§§§§5ggg5§§§§§§§§5§§5§§§§§§5§§§§§§% o .Q - m > no Lr
o
o go v ' 1 -
c> N m o o Q ca F 1*
o
o
1* S 1: 1- v- v :I ; 1 -
O P O 1-
8 a a 5 a a a o
S
o
Q ?a NE S F o o 8 Q Q Q 8
B Qq-N
a
8
~8 <r 8 `65 9. B `§ 3 Q
F
Q
"6 v' o
N
a 'a Q "
g_W --..
-=r
o g $5 go 5 ._ Q .- Q
1- Q
"
o a v'
8 P 1- N Nm a * 1- 1- l-
9 co
N
E < o o o o o
E 2 ioi o o
5533 3S S3 isS Qoo 'Q Q Q Q Q
o
S 55 S O S
=§ So
3 sq Q U 'B gt w e v v- ¢*> 8 Eu l*°~ co m
I-D o
N 10 cO r~ N 8 Of o N co p \-
v'
N
E < s'é' 'Q
g s Se an Se as he ah he so 89 he he GB GB go. he as so so as so ID o o m Q o o ID ID o o -Q g|1'
Q m
"E 1~
m
Ag 'Q 'Q 1- o *rt
o
Q
F
Q
1-
o
'Q
o
(\l
o
Q
W
o
'Q
v
o! LQ Q O O p
33 '.Q
o
"z
o
n. Q Q 1-
Q
N
§» of I §» I.
'E
a..
§§ § G~§sQ ,e 5 "6 E :of 'o 3 I *a S I~5 (D
v:
o
<0 o
g
"f:§§{
13 S 305 w - o "6 0
§ @§§§§°l§§i§§il§ i
°' *.:
or .Q 'g
3 Et.,
, 2 a. soQ 1: 8 .03 so' Gs §
1:
0
o
s 'n it (O E o o 8 5 E 2 I I. E go c 5 ac
**!§s§l§§§§3ii§*¥i
E.:11:1
.l.l.l* aisil§"
2 E
.g
§§% ~» §ow-"g E
5 2 'D .Q
gnI L; . s up !£i!Iif
¥£§§;£l§3§li§il§i
oz : . ~5a;§ 'E
5 ,é
E go o m 8 1:111L
'3 1:3 § 2 0 2 "
3
E
SOu
i § i § § £ & i §*iQ
i i ii1§ §a liiélI
as. 1 Q52e o as 8
c
S °"5
E
:| o 2 en - ';
et sixl*§l;¢§;g .2 SM. § !`U
c
E N 0 .5'3 g 3 n»1:1:1¢ lilgighi g '§'°a 2 Q of
£_§ E 5 l§§§§3
l§§§§;r is '§§ii
.Z -
5§ a 1-
U)
'0 e
5.
Q *5 .c .8 5
3 z B
32
El? lg;§sl
E i I l* E Ii?iggggg
2 lg
(D
I 0 m? o
Qu .3 fl) €2 %sggg
5
323% .E o 3
's g =s:
£5
2
§§§§'ft Q., 2 a 03 r
Qiiiii§¢§§i@§¢§§§§=§,§§»§ mE 8
so §§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§2 °: °.a
gffélg 33 55.
co ID ID IO IO IO ID IO 1- 1- (D co 1-
v o
v o o o o © -"3 0
3a
(D 0
3 o o 1-
1- 5 5 o S £93 <0
v
§
Q Q Q Q
QgQ
o
8
E g
ea (D Q NB to 1- N a 8 8 5 Q 1- P Q
Q
F
gg N N N 1- 1- 1- _Q *Q 5 N Q-
1- v* F 1- F
Q
1- S N S g m
5 N ¥ < E 7 3 3 33 Mn. o-fa oQ I* o Q Q
'~"-! Lo.
o
Q
o
'Q
o
Q
o
Q
o o o
Q
o ocg Q
o 3 S 33 3
EQ $2 Cal s o 8 of (D
1 -
(\l o
S
N
S
I-O 1-
01 IO ea
N
v
v'
N N
fs 1-
1-
g s 1 - N 1- 1-
< E s as
I-O
so
I-O
use I-O O
as
m
he he On o
ea 1-0
he I-D
he
o
so 1-0
he
Q
he
o
he
o
Ana he o o
he
m
Ana
m
he en Q o
he IO
'1 "2 ' w '
o
Eu; q "':
1-
Q
N
"2
o
Q
1 -
'Q
o
kg 1-
Q kg 1- O
*1
Q
"°1 0)
Q -ng 1- CO
*t
O
is 5. I
i§ §*J 5 § E
E
- gig :s
E
w
O s= -
2
5§
2 0
g Ag
l==§=3=§*'*§
%§ § 88 E E g~5 \\J "5 ~6
§§l;§ 3: 3
ii
\. °°1:
%5
so i
3, I
N
3
c Q 'U
c 2 sno
c o
ii §§ § 2 s= o E 2 E
in*§ Q Q -= i
§ all
.§
2
g Q
'U
Eu g § g§
Vii' 'a '**'§%§*; IE
0
§ §'§ %
3
*a o c s c .
c _V)
GO : 2
3. I E O = 'a Hz ,Q
o 8
l§§;§§%
.g0 g 2E '<5 8
go Q'2 f §§§ 5 's $8 5 ~5
Es
ii-*ifw
§
.
I i §§§§
go;
I
'¥%¥§§§§'
§§§ %@§
G e Q.
I
.3 5 >
2
FT
, V
o
§
15 " ' 0%
go E; §§ ._Q..
gt 'Q §"§§
ii; gtiE i 'i £§s §§*§
é
!§§§ €§§§§%i§§§§!,, i Es
'a
§Qi l§§§§l§§i§§ié§1§*§¥§s i 83°§
%¥»§il§;§§*»¥
5 j i §€§§§l§l !i§§*E§!§il§l§ §§3%§ §§§§§§§5 § §§§§§3 ééiééééé E 3
a
2§ §§§5§ if '§§§§§;%§2l§§§2s§§§ .:§§§8§§é§E§§§§§
Ei i i é l=
i
lss§§§;§§;§s§§§§§§2§§§§§§§é§é§ssg2?
£ co <o 0 so <o v0
(D co I-O co
co (D m 2 vv <0 o
o
1- 1 - 1 - co
1-
1- o 1-
o v
(D
o
'5 o o
Q Q
o
N 8 8 1-
o
co co
v'
co t-
a Q
o
Q 3 oa o
Q o
5 Q N o 3
g o v B a a o o o 1-
18 Q 1- Q <r 1-
5UPg co SQ g 1 - 1- 1 - co Q B a 1- 'a a "5 . ..
8
8
1- v 1- N
co co r~ r~ r~ of a as a 1 - 1- 1 - 1- 1- <- 1-
ID
5 N ng < E :| 7 3 3 3 3 .3 Gs 3 g o 3N 3
o
mo 3 o
Q
o
Q
o
q
2 2 § 3 N 2 '5 S § go 2 2 a 2 S 8 3 N 11 --
N
1- <- S
Q
1- 8
co
s 0 5 1- I-D
< E Eeo ae ee o m an 0 0 0 so 0 0 0 0 no no 6§ €9 0 as 0 Q
3 3 3 'N 3 o N
3
F
3
o
s
o S
o 3
n•
3
o
S
Q-
'S
*
3
F
3
o
3
o
3
F
3
of
3
1'
8 o o
§ 2 Z
; Gs' 8 % §,*g-
as. ..= Ce m E Nb E "a Q 8 "'
"6 5 1: 1: o 3 5 :> 0 o 0 2 0 ..
g p t 5 3 'B E \.
Q; *§§§§§5§§§3
om m "5 c E o ig § o #QE I "F °6 $35 3
(0
O .§ 1:
:Q `6 s
co
g
E
as
g
5
c V) 3 °.:
Gs a -s
5=l§§§i§§=§;§§§ o E 9 o *5 Se c § o E
2; *is S8§ : _ n. r
" ~§%§§§%§§I i'ilia;=ll aw o w 'S n. `5 >~ .g 2 3 >&v cm o O 2 0)
2
m
'cl QQ
05 z E s
e
E
23 2 O 'Q 2 5S 3
5
2 of 08 `7 2 353° 2
§€§l"§'§§s= i? 3? o 1: = Ag .
IE ! E 2 4-1 m
l§I§.§§§
.5 E 23 of § 'gEo
i; 'la 2%
m
9
*a
2
§§_ 5
o
E
o 2 5* 8
o o \J 0 </v50
%§5§ iiié§§§§§ ;¥ *Vi > 2 m v: u= Q o
"Ag 'wt :|
5
> ~";§§ ';8.§50 §,;= go l §'§¢
RJ
C
2
Si 3
E we g 5 3
§ §§§*§l§£ l al5 §§§ §§12 2 E ;la I § §ii
> o 303 8
§ Q 8
Q
s §§§§§§%§l¥ § § =§g El?
;'* 5
o
o
Hz g pa
3 "§2§§§
~"5E¢°g m>° 5 j§§§:§l§ i§f§§i%r§ §§~§§ Q 'IE ii 8§§-.s0
iii é
r.50 S- o %2-= U c
§§.§=§§l l3€§€e§¢§l§§§i§ii§¥ § Et §£§g$§§§§§§§§§§¥§§§£§§5§i§§§§§g§§§2§§ \ an S ': r~ l~ r~ \- I*-
l~ v r~
v l~
v r~ v~ l~ r~ r~ v~ h-
r~
E v-
3 a 6 v- 1-
|\ N r~
N E a a
N
g 8 Q o 3 o a 6 5 5 <8 o r~ Q B a B g e 3 m a §z§ § 3 s 9.
Q
1- a a co 2 m 2
Ia 2 <r E
as Fr Q 2 0 E
(D a go 3 cco §
ea
5 N
<
3
E3<N1 3 3vv 3 E 'D o N N r~ c r~ ID 1- we r~
B m s 1-
Ev? Fl
< g Eesse n ce I-D O I-D I-0 v»
10
¢? ": ": Q
3 oo m o o .a as
2 5 3
s§§§ o 0
1: -o
2
i? m
U
c
2
§§§§ vi
':
o
`6
c
2 Hz E8 ilwé W t
g§.§*l§ I -§ 5 s 15
I I 9 :
s iii; iii E; §§§.z ~§ § §§§ §§§§
§=@§ .go §€§a go Hz
g
ii 2253 ;= Ag §3"§§
a'°;-8
§§§§§2% EE,
I
r~ 1- v~ c0py011he01iui1lalwae~nlIed0c in: 3 5 2 Judweruflqz
Q
o a
a a m a p I (am /'*I 1:76 N v N
- g 3/;?""
}ale' .z< nm°_L.zi@w
-v "lark Sup-=rl0r Court ml Glim
Guardianship of Moylan (Guardianship of Moylan) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.