Griffin v. Abshire

878 So. 2d 750, 2004 WL 1196668
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJune 2, 2004
Docket04-0037
StatusPublished
Cited by5 cases

This text of 878 So. 2d 750 (Griffin v. Abshire) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Griffin v. Abshire, 878 So. 2d 750, 2004 WL 1196668 (La. Ct. App. 2004).

Opinion

878 So.2d 750 (2004)

Kevin Dale GRIFFIN, et ux.
v.
Doris John ABSHIRE, et ux.

No. 04-0037.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

June 2, 2004.

*751 R. Chadwick Edwards, Jr., Edwards & Edwards, Abbeville, LA, for Plaintiffs/Appellants/Appellees: *752 Kevin Dale Griffin, Camila Broussard Griffin.

J. Isaac Funderburk, Funderburk & Herpin, Abbeville, LA, for Defendants/Appellants/Appellees: Doris John Abshire, Theresa Pommier Abshire.

Court composed of JIMMIE C. PETERS, MICHAEL G. SULLIVAN, and JOHN B. SCOFIELD,[*] Judges.

PETERS, J.

This appeal arises out of a dispute between neighbors over the size, ownership and use of a private road established in a 1951 act of partition. Kevin Dale Griffin and Camila Broussard Griffin (the "Griffins"), husband and wife, are the plaintiffs and defendants in reconvention in the litigation. Doris John Abshire and Theresa Pommier Abshire (the "Abshires"), husband and wife, are the defendants and plaintiffs in reconvention. Dissatisfied with the judgment of the trial court, both sets of litigants have appealed. For the following reasons, we reverse in part, amend in part, affirm in part, and render in part.

DISCUSSION OF THE RECORD

The litigation stems from an act of partition dated September 21, 1951, dividing the community of acquets and gains previously existing between Martial Trahan and his deceased wife, Alene Hebert Trahan.[1] In that partition agreement, Martial Trahan and his children[2] divided both movable and immovable property. One of the properties received by Martial Trahan in full ownership was a twenty-five acre tract of land in Section 4, Township 12 South, Range 2 East, Vermilion Parish. The partition agreement described the tract by the property surrounding it rather than by metes and bounds. Of significance to this litigation is the established western boundary of the tract, the Hunter Canal. Because some of the immovable property transferred to his children lay north and west of the twenty-five acres, Martial Trahan granted his children a thirty-foot servitude of passage along its western boundary.

Martial Trahan died on January 21, 1971. On February 12, 1971, his children entered into an act of partition wherein they divided the twenty-five acres as well as other property.[3] Enite Abshire[4] acquired the west one-fourth of the twenty-five acres with the remaining three-fourths being divided among the other three children. This act of partition continued to describe the divided tracts by the property surrounding each, and not by metes and bounds. It described the west boundary of Enite Abshire's tract as the Hunter Canal.

*753 On November 4, 1982, Enite Abshire transferred 1.431 acres of the property she obtained in 1971 to her son, Doris John Abshire, and his wife, Theresa Pommier Abshire. The cash deed transferring the 1.431 acres described the property as:

That certain tract or parcel of ground, containing 1.431 acres, more or less, and being located in Southeast Quarter (SE¼) of Section 4, Township 12 South, Range 1 [sic] East, Vermilion Parish, Louisiana and being the same property marked "DORIS ABSHIRE & THERESA POMMIER" on a plat of survey prepared by Stephen J. Langlinai [sic], P.E., dated August 27, 1982, and attached hereto and made a part hereof.

The attached plat established the location of the 1.431 acres as a generally rectangular tract extending 370 feet north and south on the east and west boundaries and as situated north of a line approximately 760 feet north of the southern boundary of Enite Abshire's property. The east line of the 1.431 acres corresponded to Enite Abshire's east property line, but the west line fell thirty-eight feet east of her west property line along the Hunter Canal. The plat described the thirty-eight-foot parcel not transferred as a private right-of-way. Additionally, the plat extended the thirty-eight-foot-wide private right-of-way the complete length of Enite Abshire's western boundary. In other words, the right-of-way described on the plat was eight feet wider than the servitude of passage granted in the 1951 act of partition. The deed did not transfer the Abshires any interest in the right-of-way, but simply described the right-of-way.

On June 12, 1991, or almost nine years after she sold the 1.431-acre tract to Doris John and Theresa Abshire, Enite Abshire divided the remainder of the tract, as well as other immovable property, among her children. In the act of donation transferring the property, four of her children (Hazel Abshire, Roland Abshire, Doris John Abshire, and Linus Abshire) shared the remainder of the west one-fourth of the twenty-five acres, while her remaining children received other properties. The four named children each received a lot measuring 170 feet east and west and 380 feet north and south, with Hazel Abshire acquiring the lot immediately north of Louisiana Highway 696 (the southern boundary of the original twenty-five acres); Roland Abshire acquiring the next lot; Doris John Abshire, who already owned the next lot based on the November 4, 1982 transfer, acquiring the lot immediately north of that acquisition; and Linus Abshire acquiring the northernmost lot. The act of donation described the west boundary of each lot as "the 30 foot right-of-way." Thus, whether intentionally or by inadvertence, Enite Abshire retained ownership of the thirty-foot strip as well as her entire interest in the servitude of passage.

Kevin and Camila Griffin purchased Hazel Abshire's tract on July 8, 1992. In the cash deed, Hazel Abshire also transferred to the Griffins "[a]ll of [her] rights, titles and interest in and to the 30 foot private road right of way which runs northerly along the west side of [the property transferred]." Doris John and Theresa Abshire acquired Roland Abshire's tract on July 19, 1995.

On September 5, 2001, the Griffins instituted suit against the Abshires.[5] In their petition, the Griffins asserted an undivided ownership interest in the thirty-foot servitude of passage and asserted that the Abshires had constructed a fence on the thirty-foot *754 tract in an effort to impede their use of the property, had filed criminal complaints against them for their attempted use of the property, and had trespassed on the tract that they purchased from Hazel Abshire. The Griffins sought closure of a ditch the Abshires had dug along the west boundary of their property, removal of the fence, damages, and attorney fees.

The Abshires answered the petition and reconvened for damages of their own, asserting that the Griffins had obstructed the natural drainage from their property, had prevented them from utilizing the right-of-way, and had interfered with the peaceful possession of their property.

Following a trial on the merits, the trial court entered judgment declaring the servitude of passage to be thirty-eight-feet wide, declaring that the Griffins had acquired an undivided interest in the servitude of passage and rejecting the damage demands of both parties. On appeal, the Griffins assert that the trial court erred in setting the right-of-way width at thirty-eight feet and in failing to award damages for trespass, and the Abshires assert that the trial court erred in concluding that the Griffins acquired an undivided interest in the servitude of passage.

Griffin Appeal

The 1951 act of partition described the servitude of passage as follows:

[Martial Trahan] ...

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Bayou Fleet Partnership v. Clulee
150 So. 3d 329 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2014)
CARABINE v. DeGRAVELLE
11 So. 3d 85 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009)
Donald F. Carabine v. Oliver Degravelle, Jr.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009
Lacombe v. Carter
975 So. 2d 687 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2008)
Randy Lacombe v. Marvin F. Carter, Jr.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2008
Sellers v. St. Charles Parish
900 So. 2d 1121 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2005)
Schexnayder v. Entergy Louisiana, Inc.
899 So. 2d 107 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2005)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
878 So. 2d 750, 2004 WL 1196668, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/griffin-v-abshire-lactapp-2004.