Graham v. State

403 So. 2d 275, 1980 Ala. Crim. App. LEXIS 1207
Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama·Decided April 1, 1980·Published·Cited by 24 cases

Opinion

403 So.2d 275 (1980)

Richard GRAHAM
v.
STATE.

4 Div. 787.

Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama.

April 1, 1980.
Rehearing Denied April 22, 1980.

*276 Myron H. Thompson, of Thompson & Faulk, Dothan, for appellant.

Charles A. Graddick, Atty. Gen., J. T. Simonetti, Jr., Asst. Atty. Gen., for appellee.

BOOKOUT, Judge.

During the late evening hours of June 29, 1977, Mary Ann James was raped and stabbed to death in her apartment in Daleville, Alabama. She had been stabbed at least fifty-seven times. At the time of the crime, the victim was a lieutenant in the Missouri National Guard on active duty at Ft. Rucker, Alabama. The appellant was a warrant officer and likewise stationed there.

The appellant was indicted for the capital offense of "rape when the victim is intentionally killed by the defendant," § 13-11-2(a)(3), Code of Ala.1975. He first entered a plea of not guilty, but later changed his plea to guilty after his trial counsel engaged in plea bargaining on his behalf. After an extensive colloquy, in camera, pursuant to Boykin v. Alabama, 395 U.S. 238, 89 S.Ct. 1709, 23 L.Ed.2d 274 (1969), and execution of an Ireland form (Ireland v. State, 47 Ala.App. 65, 250 So.2d 602 (1971)), the appellant's change of plea was accepted by *277 the trial judge. A jury was empaneled for the purpose of allowing the State to present a prima facie case pursuant to § 15-15-24(a), Code of Ala.1975, and the procedure approved in Prothro v. State, Ala.Cr.App., 370 So.2d 740 (1979). The State then introduced evidence which we will summarize below.

Major Anthony Keil was the "Field Officer of the day" at Ft. Rucker on the date of the crime. He saw the appellant talking to the victim at the Officers Club around 10:15 or 10:30 that night. Keil talked to both the victim and the appellant, and when he left the club after about twenty minutes, Graham and Lieutenant James were still talking and drinking together.

Iris Croshaw was the night clerk at the Daleville Inn where the victim resided. On the night of the crime, the appellant came to her office sometime between 10:15 p. m. and midnight and asked for the apartment number of a Mr. Bailey. However, when the appellant received that information, he said that since it was so late he would leave and return the next morning to see Bailey. A map of the apartment complex showing the location of each apartment was displayed on the desk of the office in the presence of the appellant. Lieutenant James' body was found in her apartment the next day.

Robert Nipper was the appellant's cellmate in the Dale County jail where the appellant was awaiting trial on the instant charge. The appellant admitted the murder to Nipper and made elaborate plans for Nipper to escape and kill another woman in the same manner. Appellant believed that another identical crime committed while he was in jail would convince the police he was innocent and he would be released from jail. From the record:

"Q. Would you tell the jury what all he [appellant] told you about the James girl?
"A. Well, he told me that he had met her in a bar that night and talked to her, and he went back to drinking and didn't talk to her no more until later on. He said he was going up to these Daleville Apartments to check on a friend of his coming in from another country, and he had seen her in the parking lot, so he went up there and tried to talk to her again and was trying to pick her up. He said they got to arguing and that's all he said about it at that time. He cut me off.
"Q. Now, did you on occasion more than once talk to him in regards to that particular case?
"A. Yes, sir.
"Q. Did he tell you other things about what he wanted you to do?
"A. Yes, sir, we had talked about it for a long time. We made an agreement that I was to escape and go out there and kill another woman just like he did so he could get out. He had wrote down on this paper what he wanted me to do to make it look like the same killer. I don't have the paper with me now.
"Q. Will you describe what it says?
"A. Well, he told me to stab her at least 50 times, and he was going to give me some of his hair to take and put on the sheet, and he told me to put her in the bathtub and fill it up with water and turn the mattress over and mess up the room to look like it had been robbed or something."

The appellant gave Nipper the names and addresses of two women he might kill. One worked across the street from appellant at Ft. Rucker, and appellant had obtained the name and address of the other one day when he was at the telephone office and overheard the woman give that information to someone there.

The plans were further detailed by Nipper:
"A. Well, when I got out, I was going to go to North Carolina and stay there and he would give me the name of a trailer park that I could get a job there, and I was to get my social security card and he would give me some school dates and stuff to go get my new social security card with, and I was to—
"Q. Speak up. I don't believe they can hear you.
*278 "A. I was to send him that new social security card I got and he was going to make me up a false ID, and I was to come back and kill a woman and then go on back to North Carolina and he was to meet me later up there and in—and give me this ID and some money for doing this.
"Q. How much money?
"A. One or two thousand dollars.
"Q. Did you at one time have a microphone hidden about your body?
"A. Yes, sir.
"Q. And this conversation that you're talking about, in addition to what you said—the other stuff, was that taken down by officers?
"A. Yes, sir.
. . . .
"A. ... That's all that—when this murder happened, he was supposed to get out. He was going to meet me at the Holiday Inn Saturday evening at 6:00 on December the 23rd and he was going to give me one or two thousand dollars and driver's license and ID, Honorable Discharge, and certificate for a high school G.E.D., and if he didn't show up there at the time, there is a statue there at Ft. Bragg, and right where this `X' is marked there would be a key down there buried about two inches under the ground and there would be a briefcase in the airport and that key would unlock it there.
"This right here is the name that I was supposed to use; S. A. Grant. I was supposed to say I lived at 71 Marlborough Street, Boston, Mass., and to say I was born on July 28th 1954.
"This says `Fairlane Acres, Mobile Home City' and is where I was supposed to live, and get my social security number —"

The note which the appellant gave Nipper with coded instructions was deciphered and read to the jury by Nipper and was admitted into evidence. However, a transcript of one of their conversations tape recorded from a microphone hidden on Nipper was not admitted at trial. Nipper voluntarily told the police about the appellant's incriminating statements to him and volunteered to use a microphone concealed on his body to transcribe other conversations with the appellant.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Graham v. State, 403 So. 2d 275, 1980 Ala. Crim. App. LEXIS 1207 (Ala. Ct. App. 1980).

403 So. 2d 275 (Graham v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

DeBruce v. State
890 So. 2d 1068 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 2003)
Norris v. State
563 So. 2d 47 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1990)
Russo v. State
548 So. 2d 1083 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1989)
German v. State
492 So. 2d 622 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1986)
Gilmore v. State
497 So. 2d 577 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1986)
Harvell v. State
465 So. 2d 462 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1984)
Jackson v. State
452 So. 2d 895 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1984)
Taylor v. State
445 So. 2d 1004 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1984)
Zeigler v. State
443 So. 2d 1303 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1983)
Minnifield v. State
439 So. 2d 190 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1983)
Billingsley v. State
437 So. 2d 601 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1983)
Phelps v. State
439 So. 2d 727 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1983)
Burkett v. State
439 So. 2d 737 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1983)
Mallory v. State
437 So. 2d 595 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1983)
Miliner v. State
431 So. 2d 581 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1983)
Coon v. State
431 So. 2d 569 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1982)
Moulds v. State
426 So. 2d 942 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1982)
Sims v. State
428 So. 2d 162 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1982)
Spears v. State
428 So. 2d 174 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1982)
Morrow v. State
426 So. 2d 481 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1982)