Gordon Hollow Blast Grate Co. v. Zearing

198 S.W. 97, 130 Ark. 535, 1917 Ark. LEXIS 447

• Court: Supreme Court of Arkansas
• Decided: October 22, 1917
• Status: Published

Opinion

HUMPHREYS, J.

Appellant, in tbe year 1907, sold tbe Stoneman-Zearing Lumber Company a trimmer and edger for $656.25, and retained the 'title in said machinery “until tbe purchase price, including all paper that may be given to apply on same, has been fully paid in cash.” Not having paid the purchase price, the Stone-man-Zearing Lumber Company delivered to appellant, in evidence thereof, two notes, one being due November 10, and the other November 20, 1909. On January 7, 1910,-tbe Stoneman-Zearing Lumber Company was placed in tbe bands of a receiver by order of tbe Prairie Chancery Court. Appellant filed the notes with tbe receiver for allowance, which were allowed by tbe receiver and also allowed by tbe court on November 17,1910. Tbe machinery in question was sold by tbe receiver under an order of tbe court in settlement of tbe general claims of tbe company. After tbe court bad allowed appellant’s claim and the machinery had been sold, appellant appeared in court and filed the original contract with a petition in which they asked that their claim be made a preferred claim. The court disallowed the claim as a preferred claim but allowed it as a general claim. From this order, an appeal has been prosecuted to this court.

(1-2) The contention of appellant is that it did not waive its right to follow the property by presenting its claim to the receiver and court for allowance. This court has held that a vendor of personal property, who reserved title in himself until payment of the purchase money, waives any right to follow and reclaim the property by bringing a separate suit for the price and recovering a judgment thereon. An election to recover the purchase price by a vendor is a waiver of its reservation of title. Cox v. Harris, 64 Ark. 213; Davis v. Jones, 67 Ark. 122; Neal v. Cone, 76 Ark. 273; Hendrickson Lumber Co. v. Pretorious, 82 Ark. 347; Nashville Lbr. Co. v. Robinson, 91 Ark. 319; Hollenberg Music Co. v. Bankston, 107 Ark. 337.

In Hendrickson Lumber Co. v. Pretorious, supra, a vendor, who had reserved title in himself until the purchase money was paid, was permitted to intervene and claim the property after it had passed into the hands of a receiver. In that case, the vendor had not obtained an allowance or judgment on his claim before intervening.

(3) It is insisted, however, that appellant should have a lien for the purchase money on the proceeds of the sale of machinery in the hands of the receiver. It is well settled that our statute does not create a lien in favor of a vendor of personal property for the unpaid purchase money; and that it is too late for a vendor to obtain a lien by seizure after the property of an insolvent corporation has passed into the hands of a receiver. Halpern v. Clarendon Hardwood Lumber Co., 64 Ark. 132.

The decree is affirmed.