Gobeille v. Meunier

41 A. 1001, 21 R.I. 103, 1898 R.I. LEXIS 19
CourtSupreme Court of Rhode Island
DecidedDecember 21, 1898
StatusPublished

This text of 41 A. 1001 (Gobeille v. Meunier) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Rhode Island primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Gobeille v. Meunier, 41 A. 1001, 21 R.I. 103, 1898 R.I. LEXIS 19 (R.I. 1898).

Opinion

Per Curiam.

(1) We think the complainant makes a case for relief. The testimony shows that the respondent is excavating the complainant’s land and has,; erected in part a wall for the purpose of supporting the complainant’s land, placing the wall partly on the complainant’s land, and that he is continuing the erection of the wall along the, whole length of the line between him and the complainant. The law is well settled that the owner of land is entitled to have it supported and protected in its natural condition by the land of his adjoining proprietor, and that if such adjoining owner removes such natural support, whereby the soil of .the former is disturbed or falls away, he is legally liable for all damage so occasioned. Beard v. Murphy, 37 Vt. 99 ; Graves v. Mattison, 67 Vt. 630 ; McMaugh v. Burke, 12 R. I. 499 ; 2 Wash. R. P., 5 ed. 330 et seq. Though equity will not enjoin a *104 land, owner from making excavations on-his own land unless serious injury to the adjoining land is imminent (McMaugh v. Burke, 12 R. I. 499), in the present instance the respondent has already excavated and is proceeding still further to excavate the complainant’s land and to erect the supporting wall upon it. In these circumstances an injunction is the proper remedy to restrain the trespasses. Matteson v. Whaley, 19 R. I. 648.

Walter I. Ballou, for complainant. Adelarcl Arehambault and Alphonse Oaulin, Jr., for respondent.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Beard v. Murphy
37 Vt. 99 (Supreme Court of Vermont, 1864)
Graves v. Mattison
32 A. 498 (Supreme Court of Vermont, 1895)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
41 A. 1001, 21 R.I. 103, 1898 R.I. LEXIS 19, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/gobeille-v-meunier-ri-1898.