Glen McClary, Marisol McClary, John Ingram, Pam Ingram, Michael Kovacs, Chelsea Hamilton, Samuel Livingston, Gwynn Livingston, Avondale Sogro, LLC, Saleeba's, Inc., Robert Freeman Lee Living Trust, and Morven Lake, LLP v. City of Jacksonville, Florida, Katherine Hyde, Kevin Eugene Hyde, Ingleside Properties, LLC, DCWJ, LLC, Larry A. Sale, Registered Agent, Larch, Inc., Janice Niemeyer, John Grayson Milne, Jane M. Taylor, Gayle Register Bolton, Jennifer Bolton Stapleton, Lydia Veal
This text of Glen McClary, Marisol McClary, John Ingram, Pam Ingram, Michael Kovacs, Chelsea Hamilton, Samuel Livingston, Gwynn Livingston, Avondale Sogro, LLC, Saleeba's, Inc., Robert Freeman Lee Living Trust, and Morven Lake, LLP v. City of Jacksonville, Florida, Katherine Hyde, Kevin Eugene Hyde, Ingleside Properties, LLC, DCWJ, LLC, Larry A. Sale, Registered Agent, Larch, Inc., Janice Niemeyer, John Grayson Milne, Jane M. Taylor, Gayle Register Bolton, Jennifer Bolton Stapleton, Lydia Veal (Glen McClary, Marisol McClary, John Ingram, Pam Ingram, Michael Kovacs, Chelsea Hamilton, Samuel Livingston, Gwynn Livingston, Avondale Sogro, LLC, Saleeba's, Inc., Robert Freeman Lee Living Trust, and Morven Lake, LLP v. City of Jacksonville, Florida, Katherine Hyde, Kevin Eugene Hyde, Ingleside Properties, LLC, DCWJ, LLC, Larry A. Sale, Registered Agent, Larch, Inc., Janice Niemeyer, John Grayson Milne, Jane M. Taylor, Gayle Register Bolton, Jennifer Bolton Stapleton, Lydia Veal) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court of Appeal of Florida primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.
Opinion
FIFTH DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL STATE OF FLORIDA _____________________________
Case No. 5D2024-2154 LT Case No. 2021-CA-000632 _____________________________
GLEN MCCLARY, MARISOL MCCLARY, JOHN INGRAM, PAM INGRAM, MICHAEL KOVACS, CHELSEA HAMILTON, SAMUEL LIVINGSTON, GWYNN LIVINGSTON, AVONDALE SOGRO, LLC, SALEEBA'S, INC., ROBERT FREEMAN LEE LIVING TRUST, and MORVEN LAKE, LLP,
Appellants,
v.
CITY OF JACKSONVILLE, FLORIDA, KATHERINE HYDE, KEVIN EUGENE HYDE, INGLESIDE PROPERTIES, LLC, DCWJ, LLC, LARRY A. SALE, REGISTERED AGENT, LARCH, INC., JANICE NIEMEYER, JOHN GRAYSON MILNE, JANE M. TAYLOR, GAYLE REGISTER BOLTON, JENNIFER BOLTON STAPLETON, LYDIA VEAL, ET AL,
Appellees. _____________________________
On appeal from the Circuit Court for Duval County. Virginia Baker Norton, Judge. Maria Soledad Bodero and Glen A. McClary, Jacksonville, for Appellants.
Jason R. Teal, Deputy General Counsel, City of Jacksonville Office of General Counsel, Jacksonville, for Appellee, City of Jacksonville.
No Appearance for Remaining Appellees.
June 23, 2026
PER CURIAM.
AFFIRMED.
WALLIS, EDWARDS, and HARRIS, JJ., concur.
_____________________________
Not final until disposition of any timely and authorized motion under Fla. R. App. P. 9.330 or 9.331. _____________________________
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
Cite This Page — Counsel Stack
Glen McClary, Marisol McClary, John Ingram, Pam Ingram, Michael Kovacs, Chelsea Hamilton, Samuel Livingston, Gwynn Livingston, Avondale Sogro, LLC, Saleeba's, Inc., Robert Freeman Lee Living Trust, and Morven Lake, LLP v. City of Jacksonville, Florida, Katherine Hyde, Kevin Eugene Hyde, Ingleside Properties, LLC, DCWJ, LLC, Larry A. Sale, Registered Agent, Larch, Inc., Janice Niemeyer, John Grayson Milne, Jane M. Taylor, Gayle Register Bolton, Jennifer Bolton Stapleton, Lydia Veal, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/glen-mcclary-marisol-mcclary-john-ingram-pam-ingram-michael-kovacs-fladistctapp-2026.