Gilmore and Helm v. Brown

Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)

Gilmore and Helm v. Brown

284 S.W. 1017, 215 Ky. 100, 1926 Ky. LEXIS 675

CourtCourt of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)

DecidedJune 11, 1926

StatusPublished

Cited by10 cases

This text of 284 S.W. 1017 (Gilmore and Helm v. Brown) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Gilmore and Helm v. Brown, 284 S.W. 1017, 215 Ky. 100, 1926 Ky. LEXIS 675 (Ky. 1926).

Pincite

Opinion

Opinion of the Court by

Drury, Commissioner

Dismissing.

The appellee recovered a judgment against the appellants for $225.00. An appeal to this court was granted’ by the court below. The appellants superseded the judgment there, and have prosecuted that appeal. Where the amount in controversy is less than $500.00 *101 the trial court is without jurisdiction to grant an appeal, and a supersedeas bond executed in such cases is void. See Childers v. Ratliff, 164 Ky. 123, 175 S. W. 25; Davis, et al. v. Davis, et al., 178 Ky. 779, 199 S. W. 1075; Frazier v. Ison, 194 Ky. 550, 240 S. W. 39.

It has been held, however, that when a record is duly filed in the office of the Court of Appeals, and no appeal was prayed in the -court below, the filing of the record will be treated as including a motion that the court grant an appeal, although no motion asking for such an appeal is filed with the record. See City of Covington v. Sullivan, 172 Ky. 534, 189 S. W. 709; Carter Co. Com. Bank v. Eifort, 179 Ky. 232, 200 S. W. 342. Where an unauthorized appeal'has been granted by the circuit court, a party may abandon his appeal thus improperly granted and apply to the Court of Appeals for an appeal, by motion, as required by the statute; and the filing of the record without a motion for an appeal, or the grant of an appeal by the clerk of the Court of Appeals, will be treated as a motion for an appeal as required by the statute. See Matney v. Edwards, 179 Ky. 243, 200 S. W. 366; Searcy v. Golden, 180 Ky. 324, 202 S. W. 486.

If the appellant here had filed this record with the-clerk of the Court of Appeals and had taken process from this court against the appellee, this would have been treated as an abandonment of the appeal .attempted to be granted below, but no such step was taken in this case. The steps taken in this case are identical with the steps taken in the case of Julian v. United Clothing Store, 180 Ky. 653, 203 S. W. 549. Much that is said above is taken from section 16 of Miller’s Appellate Practice, where a more elaborate discussion will be found. Parties desiring to appeal from judgments less than $500.00 should file the record with the clerk of the Court of Appeals, should take process from this court, and if they desire to supersede the judgment the bond should be made here and the supersedeas issued by the clerk of this court. Motion for an appeal should also be made here, though, as we have seen, this is not absolutely necessary if the other steps be taken as indicated..

See also rule X of this court.

Thus we see that this court has no jurisdiction of this appeal, and it is dismissed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Opinion of the Court by

Drury, Commissioner

Dismissing.

The appellee recovered a judgment against the appellants for $225.00. An appeal to this court was granted’ by the court below. The appellants superseded the judgment there, and have prosecuted that appeal. Where the amount in controversy is less than $500.00 *101 the trial court is without jurisdiction to grant an appeal, and a supersedeas bond executed in such cases is void. See Childers v. Ratliff, 164 Ky. 123, 175 S. W. 25; Davis, et al. v. Davis, et al., 178 Ky. 779, 199 S. W. 1075; Frazier v. Ison, 194 Ky. 550, 240 S. W. 39.

It has been held, however, that when a record is duly filed in the office of the Court of Appeals, and no appeal was prayed in the -court below, the filing of the record will be treated as including a motion that the court grant an appeal, although no motion asking for such an appeal is filed with the record. See City of Covington v. Sullivan, 172 Ky. 534, 189 S. W. 709; Carter Co. Com. Bank v. Eifort, 179 Ky. 232, 200 S. W. 342. Where an unauthorized appeal'has been granted by the circuit court, a party may abandon his appeal thus improperly granted and apply to the Court of Appeals for an appeal, by motion, as required by the statute; and the filing of the record without a motion for an appeal, or the grant of an appeal by the clerk of the Court of Appeals, will be treated as a motion for an appeal as required by the statute. See Matney v. Edwards, 179 Ky. 243, 200 S. W. 366; Searcy v. Golden, 180 Ky. 324, 202 S. W. 486.

If the appellant here had filed this record with the-clerk of the Court of Appeals and had taken process from this court against the appellee, this would have been treated as an abandonment of the appeal .attempted to be granted below, but no such step was taken in this case. The steps taken in this case are identical with the steps taken in the case of Julian v. United Clothing Store, 180 Ky. 653, 203 S. W. 549. Much that is said above is taken from section 16 of Miller’s Appellate Practice, where a more elaborate discussion will be found. Parties desiring to appeal from judgments less than $500.00 should file the record with the clerk of the Court of Appeals, should take process from this court, and if they desire to supersede the judgment the bond should be made here and the supersedeas issued by the clerk of this court. Motion for an appeal should also be made here, though, as we have seen, this is not absolutely necessary if the other steps be taken as indicated..

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

284 S.W. 1017, 215 Ky. 100, 1926 Ky. LEXIS 675, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/gilmore-and-helm-v-brown-kyctapphigh-1926.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack