GGNSC Clarion v. Kane Appeal of PHCA

Opinion

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA MIDDLE DISTRICT

GGNSC CLARION LP D/B/A "GOLDEN : No. 6 MAP 2016 LIVING CENTER - CLARION", GGNSC : WARREN KINZUA VALLEY LP D/B/A : Appeal from the Commonwealth Court "GOLDEN LIVING CENTER - KINZUA", : order entered 1/11/2016 at No. 165 MD GGNSC WILKES-BARRE II LP D/B/A : 2015, which sustained the preliminary "GOLDEN LIVING CENTER - SUMMIT", : objections of Kathleen Kane and Cohen HARMARVILLAGE CARE CENTER LLC : Milstein Sellers & Toll PLLC and D/B/A HARMARVILLAGE CARE : dismissed the petition for review CENTER, PROVIDENCE CARE CENTER : seeking declaratory relief. LLC D/B/A PROVIDENCE CARE : CENTER, MULBERRY SQUARE ELDER : CARE & REHABILITATION, LLC, : GUARDIAN ELDER CARE AT CARLISLE, : LLC, GUARDIAN ELDER CARE AT : MOUNTAIN TOP I, LLC & : REHABILITATION CENTER, GUARDIAN : ELDER CARE AT NANTICOKE LLC, : JEFFERSON HILLS MANOR LLC, : BROOKLINE AT MIFFLINTOWN, INC., : RELIANT AUDUBON HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT EVERGREEN HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT PALMYRA HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT SILVER OAKS HOLDINGS : LLC, RELIANT KADE HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT COVENTRY HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT OVERLOOK HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT BRIARCLIFF HOLDINGS LLC, : PENNSYLVANIA HEALTH CARE : ASSOCIATION :

: :

v. :

: :

KATHLEEN G. KANE, IN HER OFFICIAL : CAPACITY AS ATTORNEY GENERAL : OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF : PENNSYLVANIA, AND COHEN : MILSTEIN SELLERS & TOLL PLLC :

: :

APPEAL OF: GGNSC CLARION LP : D/B/A "GOLDEN LIVING CENTER - : CLARION", GGNSC WARREN KINZUA : VALLEY LP D/B/A "GOLDEN LIVING : CENTER - KINZUA", GGNSC WILKES- : BARRE II LP D/B/A "GOLDEN LIVING : CENTER - SUMMIT", HARMARVILLAGE : CARE CENTER LLC D/B/A : HARMARVILLAGE CARE CENTER, : PROVIDENCE CARE CENTER LLC : D/B/A PROVIDENCE CARE CENTER, : MULBERRY SQUARE ELDER CARE & : REHABILITATION, LLC, GUARDIAN : ELDER CARE AT CARLISLE, LLC, : GUARDIAN ELDER CARE AT : MOUNTAIN TOP I, LLC & : REHABILITATION CENTER, GUARDIAN : ELDER CARE AT NANTICOKE LLC, : JEFFERSON HILLS MANOR LLC, : BROOKLINE AT MIFFLINTOWN, INC. :

GGNSC CLARION LP D/B/A "GOLDEN : No. 7 MAP 2016 LIVING CENTER - CLARION", GGNSC : WARREN KINZUA VALLEY LP D/B/A : Appeal from the Commonwealth Court "GOLDEN LIVING CENTER - KINZUA", : order entered 1/11/2016 at No. 165 MD GGNSC WILKES-BARRE II LP D/B/A : 2015, which sustained the preliminary "GOLDEN LIVING CENTER - SUMMIT", : objections of Kathleen Kane and Cohen HARMARVILLAGE CARE CENTER LLC : Milstein Sellers & Toll PLLC and D/B/A HARMARVILLAGE CARE : dismissed the petition for review CENTER, PROVIDENCE CARE CENTER : seeking declaratory relief. LLC D/B/A PROVIDENCE CARE : CENTER, MULBERRY SQUARE ELDER : CARE & REHABILITATION, LLC, : GUARDIAN ELDER CARE AT CARLISLE, : LLC, GUARDIAN ELDER CARE AT : MOUNTAIN TOP I, LLC & : REHABILITATION CENTER, GUARDIAN : ELDER CARE AT NANTICOKE LLC, : JEFFERSON HILLS MANOR LLC, : BROOKLINE AT MIFFLINTOWN, INC., : RELIANT AUDUBON HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT EVERGREEN HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT PALMYRA HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT SILVER OAKS HOLDINGS : LLC, RELIANT KADE HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT COVENTRY HOLDINGS LLC, :

RELIANT OVERLOOK HOLDINGS LLC, : RELIANT BRIARCLIFF HOLDINGS LLC, : PENNSYLVANIA HEALTH CARE : ASSOCIATION :

: :

v. :

: :

KATHLEEN G. KANE, IN HER OFFICIAL : CAPACITY AS ATTORNEY GENERAL : OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF : PENNSYLVANIA, AND COHEN : MILSTEIN SELLERS & TOLL PLLC :

: :

APPEAL OF: PENNSYLVANIA HEALTH : CARE ASSOCIATION :

ORDER

PER CURIAM DECIDED: December 28, 2016

AND NOW, this 28th day of December, 2016, the Order of the Commonwealth

Court is AFFIRMED.