George Wilhelm Vogel v. State

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided June 2, 2015·No. 14-14-00104-CR·Published

Opinion

1fc_

FILED IN 14th COURT OF APPFAifi

j^eoi^a^ lOAVvtW ^ oev«\ -§ ""^*» V*c CaorNf cfi JUN 12015 Vory^Sfl^V- ^ i^O«j*v^S>- ChRISTOPUER A.HHIME CLERK -£• ^tssJ^Xg^ ^"\«X«-S A V^^N^y^r Cx..%A «£ V*M^ PO

\^ V*V QoVotocR k^A?ro^' 35cv^l>)<^r (^w-\

-^sfrafiow^i, \s> WrAfe^» Vac^T \o •\v*u \^«soroSf^^ ^oS^vOiS «e£ ^Sp^Vov CjasafT >

Kjiqu"^ r_fm^a_v C-r ^•AcA v\ ^sx^S^^^i Cju.O!a^ O-^^s Wo>>».S V\s,g, ^o<\ Vo^^IsM^ CWA fcgSJgg-T ANncl W^scs Nscu^- ^;VWV)\ Q^^saVJ^ gja^yvsA. ^a^S^Af^ \>?\\c.^«< ^Si^ft O-Te tSOCNS-CC)^^» S^V^N^VCi^V CyCQvtyvOS Spf- QA G-S^PajQuS' y\-Cow\cv€^

^^^

•S^ovN^ro^^ ""3>s*^vigS ^V"A- Njo.^^^v*o. V

^v^^>^ya^C.v_^.v<,c>>Vi-vi-3 *yr €fe<=s> <~^ '5g-'X>\«c>v~5 \o\vpOy.\' i^v sg.

V'OPg^fi^ V=» '<>*.^Wr g^vgiChiX V "gvor <*- o^J»X^

^ySfe.oX^c^— v&Jg_ \»>v>^Nr \ag^ ^t-eno^iis, \>^q> «^ ci^v* CW»X ^&j

\\\»o^v ^e-'5>Bv\^_ ^yv^ \qoVo*«L \

w ^& V Ad^aA^^'^gV C.Q^» •^^S»

£•& At^/sfc oOot^A Vo SM.QobrV^'f^ cL^oeoX \<> C^&v^y'- v-jpyjofv^A ^^oyT Cg-SoW^-T^Ut— ^vo s»V>\ 5> &, C5dP<\\s>VC\V cv \\^fi_ qc^ ovOoh\^ ^insj^e- oifg, KitO "oJr:«yjk.ysfei\s ^wco; ^j&&aU\fr ^vsCcvJ^^H '^^f<^v.QA,gw ^&oe-S> Afr«>jabc-^- i-M/A*—cvre. **S4 &g AV>)gay5>oS> VU^

1Z-*- \b v>-^V|ig-*N>\ \y*^" ^ CLrx,c>N.xv><\ ^^(^sg^a.^ vov\\^. c^aNv Va txA^qvjo^.- N^Vfe^-^yft^- ^^vx^XrSs^ \vj&V>S Vno •5^s^> v"&.^ S^s<^v>»<.<^ N^r QikwWrS gvoe-.'a* vs^r V*1***" ^° **-*> C^Cv^ot \s>'>A ~^\«a>JRS SxJ^-«S$3...^ ^3

^jfraiV*^ fvsfts; Vc*„>1«wjv» ^s> Tq.*<* -et^o^-Sse^ t ^ ^fc ick \ci

v>.aj *T

:frJvo^C Q«ri>JevVV\\l)^.>V \y\^i SS»Q.r\ CVv>^4 CftQ^

fcAT^sft^ Nya CssSs., gfcy\«.»»chance \vvS \y\n\ \pv*a\\ii.r ^.r* Va--^ \a-.> CgJ^O^V^ CgJ=K] ** **•- rs t ^VOs;*^>cscivv^ \o yvfixv*-^ v^g^_c-Vs\^ os&\^gv^cg_ c»- Co°^eA—»3r \vfrk<—

- ^^ ^i»s**-—*S\K^n> Cxj^MOiv'^tJsAyN ^g.c»3\y^»»ss..v'v ^>»e^ ^yV\«» S

o*r t.aOyvSeS—OA Nfs!\S $. CVTiDgjaV * Pc.cL\cUc,\ ^^j^'^fes?ky^c«j[ \W--'-^^bc'ibio^ ^yaS^N^Xs jv>*i NNsc JlprftQ£> rvfiNyt\>\y>S»c.^> '^rN»\>\ <>w &yAcs&V.v\^sp>»As •<^\c«xY*gvvc.vc>\ ^j ::S^_^j^o^-CviN^y~ ^ry^^^^A^^ ^Srst. C^orayjS. ^.X\c\ \ v^a^v gjorroQQroyv^&- gj>j v&,c.v\C g_ \o SsjCVOa: cy Gavy>jvcS\ov>\ • \>^ Vcs ya^V^eA V*r\<- QjNa.. vs

\ i«^

Re^naP c& Ct>x*>rA • t—^- —•

<»jvV ^gN^cfr^^pkcyvt&w , ^^ W-.** ^»tfV c^ ^ftftcg^ \-vwK ^^*gs: V»gpg_

"S QOov'viVfc& \ 5M>OLSNt ex^ft^V^- »vs CvAOeg\ *

"W.

*W C^^Nyvffi VvoA^a cwV V^<-<^ ( CoA^vMjl v~^Wvw \>^\,W^ CO* N

Xt^'V^H^ c^A> ^wS- *W r^f\ V>a^ \sa&j> o^s& »v^O

^f^xww "^Nt. Cr^^VS ^\ ^^< \*>*A .

C-^g-^c-^ ^\ VsnO^-xN^ q<^\ ^t-o ^a*.

~Vs>c.-\ :£- VfNo^. 5 4

V

'}* <{ 1 \V^«^SKvN -i—

_L_ (^\^c,»7.o>- (p8G» 5u>9icM5"7 ^S^o^ez. "lq Su^AUl^ ^^osn^ ^w^vy 4>o "koiA 4yy

tbCO^^O^- (/H^AcN ^ *^\\s iSk^voSrA^k- \JT> SV«V - yQf^tr 85^o^\^(o Q^oyorvcA'O q^

-*a- Cw-mNb r sj %o\vvtk* iiMkiiSJitB^l 03- -"^ vC-Z. ^0^^^3L«l JiOA-

4M- !lw <*Q- -A KUft^AdgTj -l£ E.vi^s^ Loc^t-f •^itlAi^ftl -ik- £». ^a-r U- i*«J- i

n £"* ^cvrW ^y>.rAS ^ot^to^dl J>-?Q

M&- E A. ^a-rVg. ^JfrSan koTSvoadSot

43- jfc a YflfVti fcuayxQ •SlO^vO^cSl^Mt

JLa. g-* \tt.r\s, /^VflvwyVyarA cni ^ o ^ i f t

-^H- 1T* ^o.rV yj^- \nQi^y^^c\8S -^L ?pV«jy^aV v^Cac

^ ^\.TcrT> ^Si^voaJlSfi^ -gg- Cr\ej^cLrs>4 OS> ^WSeA-IVbo

•&*- i^-V4cil>Ou. IkMMl^ 3t»S5^3iaTH>~ jn- S^M- V ks^p^s ^ ryvfcf"

-33- %^^*&% n 90 5(0^^ 8a H 3o ^ JUrMyrvvv ^*3- ^Big^tO-J^S^ 4n- ^ ^rtftavsc^t ^ iu^ 50^)^3

-&- V& «.\ c\ S^^^oQbA^^\ 4&- y^ss^f^. vj \vokA6— i lo\^C^ t~?3 -m- ^SUjtfPt^ ^T^cyaa-g- 5^

-^ —^*»rf^— H'lStO^W^

-^p- ^c^vjf-^cyv %s> s ^ 4 3-a JLL ^ evNsg& sj vWv^>- gfeFS^kfeO-

4*- —^t«^C4*S^^*N- •&g£"SA3rf(rMl

-53- i.O^*V*vA) SXvWt- ±m. ES+w- ad 8^1

L&.ON.^o'* S 818 v ^ a s s -4L 1 ,0^C3- 3*-i3^S4l2T7 a. ¥^ r y v s B^i tfrOJrta'tol. jBJ. ^K.o>rsV» ^g^^^^^^S MX ^ycvr\V>^ n^^aeus^ _y£ Vvoc^SsKS^ 1 ft-Hctbu3 3c*3>

_*ile_ ^Vo.trVv>Na.-L, I^Sio^aa MX ^Kfr cV^^Vy CLofo. .£ Qjfc •UoSOUfeM-

J^SL g,y*?>A v^.Vjy dovxvOsH- J*SL Ki,e.!5Ta.\vN< ^ _$£_ ^ &^>^>v^ \m ^>Sc$ Afro

SL ^•Qb-oS 4^ -5^ ^afrStoarf ^g£ -Si- ^v^p,/ €_K 5"Uqvm3 j£i \Kx^mvM ^XoxVv* l(o^r^HM3 .51 Vv yVvNt^N ^^yaSo» Im3n* iT> V* jg>—\ JoL J5k. VvvYWS '

jSX ^sai^3£rgs^- ^iAS^Mbo*!

JSSl Q^^NM**- .'8ft^Vo«ld^fe»

S3 L\e.^V>VN ij^tfvvn IVo^Sgir^qS

^ 1'^VvA^ 1 SioSd^i fcf !^Md. S3 S C.V 55 Jfe£_ X C-oWy-Agyf- ^SSJ^MV^ft fe>3> •^C^Vq^VK^ J^a^^^lM. JbM_ ^Nt\*>\ 5afi5^a^^57

i*£. VsPs?NvSS^- ftt-n ^voa«A silo

i^i S^V^o^ •gmr,a«McA3 M_ \-U\<^ Uac^ 4^*^0**0*1 (pS> 9vob\A:• So^v J4 ^to^gog H \vo\avAScvN ^5103^^3

•")o v>cy>\a^fi»ij T3ejvr^ |SH5oS5nH ni leHe^K^ZAtoaS

-Oi. '^>j\&^LO<<~ ga^a^^n J33- .—SCjS^c-^.cctejoai feiX- T1-1*^0.341*3 -OX -5g-o^ ^s> 'O^v.w^ i VSo SCA-SAf^ 75" '?W\A' ^Sa^iojLdt (p^o

-7(o 3^ccff^>rj\ %t?> ^0.3^03

J7_7_ !:^cN* >J CfccJ^ l3Hfr^>WU JlSl ^^A <4S3S^.3d48(o

13 ^5v v^Wft y\^,^ l^foosi^a -^- IZX^naV-c 3j ^>cc\Vs. ^ ^)S jwe^cv^pev J&L •"x^**- 3so^>^aq-7

££. •"N^ND •^v^'^ "7(cS3vo3ia^>qr

«£ ^-fiJSs- 4s»^3a ca^r m VJ^>v> ftr&A&J*C^.a/V'feAt%/ ^6gT3d772. f .&£. USj Cro^viC^ loysctraai*)

A. US,, \WV fet^cHb^ ^rL USJ^\ys\\>?1i tesoF&V-is tt ht»FaaaA. ^5_ Mt r o . ^3t*^a<$^HM So_ LQduiA- ftHoS^o^'V^ J3L U-^VxtVy) G*)ok ACZ. ^aL^OflU.

jSa. VjO\\?>A. gq^sio^c^

-93- V^-WkjA ^ KV iaVz e^S- Hu\P^a-T*T

^M- Yey.o •* Co^XiiS>^ "i.—S-tO_ ^C- OvnAtA,^xc^CS VqvV^V-KvX\o^ VqfcK*.TsCy>—S^U «,V»\ J^k- —NXN4- QLs y«A.v»r><^v. \_&>D X^^^g^Sieg^—N Vv>t\o**a vyavsr <~v<^vS ^vx.f'^S'JlL 4^n«- S*-H>V**v frJOt-O ^cryv^vv^c^A V,\V^E^\ v3fi>*\) 3A- :X.xv^j^kxrv>^c; ^^^vy^atfvyj^ ^V Co«j>.»&a\

Cttiw J>*^f.\ ^y.

Cj fl^hf>«.—CJC-C-Wjl JiiiO rSj.

-K1-1—Ci^ X-CT C

fi>f^vj^oN

^W >.-Wfe_ O^XAv^vfv.^V ^My \s«>>Mg ,>>£Xcv,0

\V».\a.v»a>J^.C "^^ws^JSX, Xgt^g-

\^tsiL- a^soc-^vb CjcxvV^o^ WVac \\qft\g^ \o ^W. g\\ftj>A ^!W>-\oJSV^b

^JSSoc\ \T^_^v<^r-XjijC>«LV.^4 gjo^iyVZo^tX^ afgVv*,j»NA.»/v\,S \e>r* cAva^V . o «nA j fejrvv>».fv,^cvwvA.<^ o->aft>\c^^—cigV^o^s* oKAft-r oj^cftAftH U.a^£^0^ O^vO^ , ^VcQK, \aft<- ^.jXg^^ q^ Xt^^>*e»^^^ V^savV&,s.a.,i3 ^.o\ f^N V

jaX V^J ft^^'Ov'O^y^- ovv ^c^^*- •C^ftJ- %V^ ,. ys^J^

^ft.cV"

•.: A ^ .e^osA \x

^ <^- 4-|£<*fcv1^ Af ^> to»Avj,0!—05=