Gavin v. Rogers Technical Services, Inc.

755 N.W.2d 47, 276 Neb. 437, 2008 Neb. LEXIS 134, 104 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 911
CourtNebraska Supreme Court
DecidedAugust 22, 2008
DocketS-07-465
StatusPublished
Cited by9 cases

This text of 755 N.W.2d 47 (Gavin v. Rogers Technical Services, Inc.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Nebraska Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Gavin v. Rogers Technical Services, Inc., 755 N.W.2d 47, 276 Neb. 437, 2008 Neb. LEXIS 134, 104 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 911 (Neb. 2008).

Opinion

755 N.W.2d 47 (2008)
276 Neb. 437

Jamie GAVIN, Appellant,
v.
ROGERS TECHNICAL SERVICES, INC., Appellee.

No. S-07-465.

Supreme Court of Nebraska.

August 22, 2008.

*50 Kathleen M. Neary, of Vincent M. Powers & Associates, for appellant.

Sean J. Brennan, of Brennan & Nielsen Law Offices, P.C., Lincoln, for appellee.

HEAVICAN, C.J., WRIGHT, CONNOLLY, GERRARD, STEPHAN, McCORMACK, and MILLER-LERMAN, JJ.

*51 McCORMACK, J.

NATURE OF CASE

This case presents an appeal from a summary judgment entered against appellant, Jamie Gavin, in a suit involving alleged sexual harassment by Gavin's supervisor. Gavin alleged that the harassment resulted in a hostile work environment and her constructive discharge. In granting the employer's motion for summary judgment, the district court determined that Gavin failed to make a prima facie case that her working conditions were so intolerable that a reasonable person would have felt compelled to resign. We reverse the judgment of the district court, because we find genuine issues of material fact as to both the hostile work environment and constructive discharge claims.

BACKGROUND

In April 2005, Gavin was hired by Rogers Technical Services, Inc. (RTSI), as a business manager and assistant to William Keith Rogers, president of RTSI. Gavin was scheduled to begin work at 7 a.m. on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday and at 8 a.m. on Saturday. Typically, Gavin would report to work at Rogers' apartment. Gavin was expected to let herself into the apartment with a key Rogers gave to her and go to an office located in a second bedroom. She typically worked in the apartment office for a short time before she and Rogers went out to breakfast. They would then travel to RTSI's manufacturing facilities in Friend, Nebraska, where they would work most of the rest of the day.

Rogers and Gavin always traveled to the Friend facilities together, and Rogers always paid for the breakfasts, which Gavin called a "welcomed benefit." Rogers told Gavin that he wanted her to travel with him between Lincoln, Nebraska, and Friend because "he gets tired." Additionally, Rogers has diabetes and he trained Gavin how to provide him with an insulin injection if he became incapacitated. At the end of the day, after returning from Friend, Gavin and Rogers would sometimes continue to work at Rogers' apartment. Gavin would usually go home "[b]etween six and eight."

Two or three days after Gavin began working for RTSI, she began feeling uncomfortable around Rogers. Gavin testified in her deposition that Rogers began "making inappropriate sexual comments" and "telling inappropriate sexual stories on a daily basis." Gavin further explained that their conversations "[a]lways had a sexual overtone, if they weren't outright about sex." On "several occasions [Rogers] would make the comment that nobody is hornier than he is." Rogers would also "always bring up ... this hot blond ... [f]rom his past."

On one occasion, Rogers told Gavin about a pool party where the wife of Rogers' former employer "had gotten this one hot blond to take him into the bathroom" to have oral sex. When Rogers started to describe the details of this encounter, Gavin "stopped the conversation" and told Rogers she was not comfortable hearing the story about the pool party. She told Rogers, "`Maybe I'm the only person left in this world with morals, but I think [it's] not right'" to talk that way.

Gavin testified further, "[Rogers] kept asking me questions about myself. At first I would just blow them off and then he kept asking me and prying into my personal life.... [H]e always had to be near me." According to Gavin, Rogers once told her about swelling in his testicles after deep sea diving. Rogers then explained to Gavin that the two of them "needed to be able to talk about personal things like this." When Rogers repeated *52 that they needed to "be more open with each other," Gavin "kind of felt the need to share." So she told Rogers, "I don't really have anything wrong with me except I have a fibroid tumor." Gavin thinks she may have specified that the tumor was on her uterus.

On another occasion, Rogers asked Gavin about her boyfriend and how he treated her. After Gavin explained to Rogers that her boyfriend had been unfaithful, Rogers commented, "Well, you're a hot girl, and if you were my girl, I'd treat you much better than him." At one point, Gavin told Rogers that she did not "like to hear about sexual things" and that she "didn't like being hit on and ... didn't like being called a hot girl." In response to this comment, "[Rogers] got really upset and he said there was something wrong with me because ... I didn't like being hit on and I didn't like being called a hot girl." Gavin also testified that on two occasions, she "told [Rogers] to stop the conversation, that it was disgusting," and that she did not "like talking about sex."

Gavin testified that she felt especially uncomfortable because RTSI's office was in Rogers' apartment. Gavin had suggested to Rogers that it would be more efficient to move the apartment office to empty space at the facility in Friend, but Rogers did not seem amenable to the idea. On the last Saturday Gavin worked for RTSI, she went to Rogers' apartment as usual at 8 a.m., knocked at the door, and unlocked the door with the key Rogers had given to her. When Gavin walked down the hallway toward the office, she saw Rogers sitting at his computer viewing "a scantily clad blond woman in neon." Rogers could only see that Rogers was wearing a T-shirt and socks. She could not tell for certain if Rogers was wearing any underwear or shorts, but he did not appear to be. Gavin stood there for a moment and then turned around and went home. Rogers never acknowledged Gavin's presence, and Rogers and Gavin did not discuss the incident.

On Monday, Gavin returned to work. Gavin explained that she was nervous and upset about the incident on Saturday and that she thought Rogers would want to have a conversation about the incident. Gavin arrived at Rogers' apartment at 7:15 a.m. Gavin "knocked loudly" twice at the door, used the key to open the door, and called out "Hey" after opening the door. As she walked toward the office, Gavin saw Rogers sleeping in a chair in the living room wearing what looked like only a pair of boxer shorts. The television was blaring loudly, and Rogers did not respond to Gavin's greeting. Gavin felt uncomfortable and left. Gavin never returned to work or communicated with Rogers again.

On cross-examination, Gavin admitted that Rogers never asked her to have sex with him, never asked to view any intimate part of her body, never asked her to let him touch her inappropriately, never specifically discussed her breasts or any other body parts, and never touched her inappropriately. Gavin admitted she told Rogers on only two occasions, during the 3 weeks she worked for him, that she did not want to talk about sexual subjects. During the second week that Gavin worked at RTSI, Gavin also told a RTSI manager that Rogers "tells a lot of stories and [that] it kind of made [her] uncomfortable." However, she "didn't specify and [the RTSI manager] didn't ask" her to elaborate about the topic of those "stories." Gavin did not make any other complaints to anyone else in the company.

On the basis of these facts, Gavin brought suit against RTSI, alleging sexual harassment and constructive discharge in violation of title VII of the Civil Rights Act *53 of 1964 (Title VII).[1] RTSI moved for summary judgment.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Tina Haskenhoff v. Homeland Energy Solutions, LLC
897 N.W.2d 553 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 2017)
Knapp v. Ruser
145 F. Supp. 3d 846 (D. Nebraska, 2015)
Allen v. IMMANUEL MEDICAL CENTER
767 N.W.2d 502 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2009)
Weber v. GASN SHOP, INC.
767 N.W.2d 746 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2009)
In Interest of Shayla H.
764 N.W.2d 119 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2009)
Loves v. World Ins. Co.
758 N.W.2d 640 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2008)
Ehlers v. State
756 N.W.2d 152 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2008)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
755 N.W.2d 47, 276 Neb. 437, 2008 Neb. LEXIS 134, 104 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 911, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/gavin-v-rogers-technical-services-inc-neb-2008.