Gary Lee Mount v. State
Opinion
NOV 03 2015
In the FouaTHEWTHCouRY-d£HI
GRRN LEE n&QUTWPEUJMT • 1.VS. -ZZ THE STATE OFTEXftS RfPEUTE
Court o9 Wc\S Cou^T^Tex^S Cause- Nos. RTOS; Presiding —
R PRO SH BRIEF FOW RVPEV.V.F1K) \
Gt\ftv! YJtE houwT ?R0 SE
HcCoiONEU- UKJXT 3oo\ S.EKAXU tWXVJfc ^E\)XU~ETE*RS (1-20 JV* <£. VOT X
JTOENTXTY OF pfifrTXES TWOft COUUSEl
PursuooaVToTex.Opp.E384UHVie^o\\ow\ng are pcxr-EVes or counsel "Eo"YW^uA^e.meri'Vat>pe.a\ed
TV>e. Hor>ooaV}\e. KocVEenae CaWruSS *m^ CtA cn\ rv a\ fc\&V* cT Co urV \Xs\ FraaEVvA Hqus^cv;t^xcxs inooa BppeUauT?t\0 SE: Gar^ FlouPvT IVCcxwU UrnT 3ogIS.E
fVttorn^sEoc- $>E fV\ RW Curry (OfvH|>p^U \kr^s Ocu*xVf ^^°^ M-oC^e-y's O^fvte Vo-3je'aoV^ IftEXTTW OF vftRTxES ftvoo Cloomseu FuVarne-ys For T\ppe.Y\coc\T* PV«TY\e.oAor& Wo^r^s (ftVT^wO Eo.E>c>x 30OE33 WsTor^TexaS ^230 lAs.'D^oraE Summers (Oa%^\) WX\Q> SEaepWcresTj SuiW ^° Hcusiorlj Texas T|0L>S PEO SE; G-ar^ E^ouxYT "TleConncW IVvV 3ooV S.EmH^ for\>e. 1X3 0^ TTBLE QE CO^TE\0TS_ IftE^TTT^ OF pftfCVXSS: ED (v-*) TRBEE OF CoKJTEKiTS : HTl (\-M Xwt>E.x of FiuTttofcTTx^s: ED \-\£> STRTEnEWTOETH^ CESE; \T3 I STFXEnEWT REG-ftEE)!^ RFFESX^CES TOTWE E£C0ftft: \j) \ ISSUE ERESFKHTEV. \ x\ \ THIS ?EQ> SE ftrEFPtX^ETFE ER^SErJTS THFse Xss\jf:s For RhvWvJ VlTW hEEXT issuE tCXi SE£; Eo-3^ \ -VE<^ H •Va\tvVe^-Xc\5vVu.«Lacfe.<*^-VE«i yvm,a.<£s <*E "VKe JuCofS. ar>^ dL"< &CorsEEW"Eoc\-fc Vo -VE-e c!eVe-i\clk<\TS JeEcv>JU-yxV Wj«A-! a^ Q, ^Xx o- awd \tv\o a.t°V>aj DD) TflftlE QE COE)TrtOTS> STP\TEnEMTOE Fibers; ttS. STE\TEnEE5T OE^CXS XM SUREST OX CfVS-ES CTTEO: EL^J SUmftr\V OFTEE P&GX5 vXF.\OT,' \PS Sumn^N oetue eftSEs: GH3 Evx&Etucx; ilxm PMVfER : 0") Cevxt excite of seexjxc.es; (Q IH3) fflftEX Or E)UT¥eofixTT^S S4<3:& - Cos>q.s: • AlcorT^ V.S-U^e Piv*tr^ v. S-VcvV <> o-^ G-e orsU, 34S U. S. SS*?; 541 J]& PlsEdrcx-EE V. SEoEe o^Te.r»uessee;3S&.U.S.m,\H\LH, SXT-^U^SSu.EJuUlSi; fere^vj V, rw^Wd^nS U.s.32;83.5.CT. II?4^^) WtW^ \). SX<>.Ve o^S-^VV CwoUK^a^ OS.HV&j H^o.^3 S.CT, 66.1,^0. 11 L.EJU Wl B<^d 0(\E»ro-ci^ \J. \VrT 0*^,311 U.S. l£~0 ?a S.CLT. 1(^,31 UeJu^ao4 CmV) CV^o,EgT;3C)OS.Na;, S iiD ( ^Us^Ev^ c^^^a)j CoSSeW V. S-WVa errT^X^S/ E m x o? TVuTttofrTTX^S , C^e$w\\\ U&r EVv\S \LW&cW\er.&L3 t>.S.£& u4.V^ S.CT.13.W > Feller V. ?e.*rV<> aESXxE* o^fWeO YorE^o ti.S. 3^ 33^353^X4-11 S^CT. 3"^ 3*nf IS L.^.&Un. FJerro, ?3H S.W. OlJl 31o;313 .ClX*- d^cv,- fcft. mO Gig\;0.v, 1x3. 40^ as, \&>t 3\ x.E-a a G-WElHVv^rWtWX 533a SAaJ. 3d 110 (Tex-C^isN. ktf. apUbE.Ex3:s 33o Ke^U^ver^XWC.V. Schlock, 244 U.S^W, 1H S.CT,^3}4l0;1B L.Erd-^k. WW V.SWVe.MSS.W. 3i r)S-4.6Te^dr>v.^- * 1 * a^oS) @ jj\)C>SX OF fiuT\\O^TEXES_ SXd-& Cfi£«* Le^ra V.fce.ro\o, 344 U.S.5^556,1H S.CT/1&,W?^8 L-Ed14S; Ilooney V. HoloV\o,n,ai4 U.S. 103,SS S.CT. 3H0; 11 U Ed an rWsoxos\\ vr. UrvH^SWs^sa as, \^1 s.ct. \, VU f_ TVrV»e\ m. HuCkHrs Lms^ \ VJEeuT. 3oV, yL- E<1,^ {VVmsEv U People, o^ 5U-E& oElUeW VorV, ^4 U.S. Holy 404,35" S.CT 131.IS?, 81 L;^<) . /CX?t 10 ier\o-VE.o \). S^cXe oE VWv| WrU, 340 U.S. aU3^Hly 1) - s. cx. sas, 30.1, ^ u £d -2UI: m d.cx u43> su.^xad m. fye US-Va-Ve oE Kwsas) 3\t U.S. CU3, US S.CT. VTA, 84 \_xA.a\4. ? &ln|Ci«. V.S-WEt, o£ ftr\car,s ax&£6 "Ross \j.s^cXe a.33 s.v). ad \au,is^Exe^c^^- %>. \1S0l CerWcr\ ^rXed 1\ S.CT iTAI, 340 lh£. %HLy ^SL.Ed.U^ reversed 1L S.CT/m,S4l U.S.1l8tlX EoVV UUofted SV StyXVV v. S-Va-Ve oETexcS, 3\\ U.S.\ SVroEW V, SW 0^ CedAWr^ 343 U.S. \8\/\1011^S. CT. 511^03, Ik U.ed. ?4X( d«*sg.fvV'»^_opl£ialJ. SHr\»n5 U ConsWiVi*,^ U.S. 31^.31?,S3 S.CXVW 115,41 XX d-315; SovcVWfx V<*aV^ cC.U SaW/Wc, Sftl as, 4oi;UL c. 33 s.ct. Qin .aso,5i \_.xd Lua; TKo^ u swa^smv s.vu. ad 3i%^4 (ma) S^CT-3315 21 L.Bd.Sui H${ (mS) WeN> VI.SW-Ve.jaiSS.VJ. ad \S^L\ETe*,Cr,^,Hj>p. Iis-n , , ' < * 9 \ v IflfcEX oE-^uT^o^XTx^S ^6<*5 WEVY^n V. VMsof^SU.S.m,^ SXT.2^^ L.Fj 1083 and: VjE^Ee v. 1W3^3&4 u.s.iiao^s s.ct; ?98,S1 L.ed. 1343- Ward USVofrejOET^x^piu a£,s
\SD \CQWiSTTTuTrovJsy U.S. Cok)ST ou^ STATUTES / TouPe^oA Coda \W.§§ ac>.OH (Verrvorv Sukp ~&oVX) TeX* Period Code ftntt. § 3.03. (\)cr RULES t * XlUt>EX OF foUTttoWXX^grS Pede.ro. iCMtS De. vlarco \j, US.,1St8 P. £uAo14(\\^ C\r.m\) GortXoAez-SoWod UUnWed SVis/ Cl44 E3d £13 v\s-V C\r.Siool\ Q-uzrrio.r\ V. Sec^E^^e^EoECo^ecEvorSjkUS F.30- \33WC\WE C\r.2io\l\ Gr\tV\f\ UrVrc.e.jUCt E.3Fj.33l(lAE CW. aoio) cTcnes U Co^r\'(Y\ori-weo.\VVv oE EerEuckx/, U^VE.Cir^Tl E. £d 3SS,333, w\-VW mreScvoyer's Pe\\Vlon,(l=\XO., 2&1 Had SOS", Sol, vlorcV^ome^ V. ^030.^ U-C.^SU E.S^pp.3^ See g&neraHy ar^oXxV\or». AV-.F-d-^d IS^S. XiMkCX OF fiuTHQ^XTSSi © F^d^r^X Ceases S^.\riVCuft.\\\eF U P^cWr, V\U F.3d.441;44X L%¥k C\r. mill Tw^o<\M.ftf)3t;^^ F.ad ius; iv.U-sw* ex r&V. (1VECW. Y1S3) U^W S3c,xes vjAJcV>sW,31fc F.3d 1Sl;80l.^K C\r.aoc4^ \J ma STfiTgnguT QY^TWE: C^F£ © STftTEHEluT OFTttE CftSE TEe. ftc^oAWrvY wo-s oXo^e.d Ey mdveEoaertXS wWk XV\e or?eose oE iX^<>Aed Se.xu.oA IssauVVand l^rcwccVed Vx\ddr»a.^\c>^ \r\ Cause r\u. Pe^oX Code E)^w, ^-IXVY^fnon Sv^p^^V P&Wr Y»eo»X\nQ OuCNXsViC^eriV £v\d^nc.eXV\&.Jucv ^e.a-E«L^ctd VEe. ftopeAWovY Xo 1£Tye The CXe>Els record \r\ \4M.4l1S wVANoecEXed asccCWOV?TEe CWrVs r-ecor'd\rv \44111C wTU W cXVed. oj=>cc CWCSX) TEe. TeporV©rvs record -Eor VEe -EAcA CorSlsVs o? e.\^E"E VoVu.c\X f\W\d
X XSSO£
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
NOV 03 2015
In the FouaTHEWTHCouRY-d£HI
GRRN LEE n&QUTWPEUJMT • 1.VS. -ZZ THE STATE OFTEXftS RfPEUTE
Court o9 Wc\S Cou^T^Tex^S Cause- Nos. RTOS; Presiding —
R PRO SH BRIEF FOW RVPEV.V.F1K) \
Gt\ftv! YJtE houwT ?R0 SE
HcCoiONEU- UKJXT 3oo\ S.EKAXU tWXVJfc ^E\)XU~ETE*RS (1-20 JV* <£. VOT X
JTOENTXTY OF pfifrTXES TWOft COUUSEl
PursuooaVToTex.Opp.E384UHVie^o\\ow\ng are pcxr-EVes or counsel "Eo"YW^uA^e.meri'Vat>pe.a\ed
TV>e. Hor>ooaV}\e. KocVEenae CaWruSS *m^ CtA cn\ rv a\ fc\&V* cT Co urV \Xs\ FraaEVvA Hqus^cv;t^xcxs inooa BppeUauT?t\0 SE: Gar^ FlouPvT IVCcxwU UrnT 3ogIS.E
fVttorn^sEoc- $>E fV\ RW Curry (OfvH|>p^U \kr^s Ocu*xVf ^^°^ M-oC^e-y's O^fvte Vo-3je'aoV^ IftEXTTW OF vftRTxES ftvoo Cloomseu FuVarne-ys For T\ppe.Y\coc\T* PV«TY\e.oAor& Wo^r^s (ftVT^wO Eo.E>c>x 30OE33 WsTor^TexaS ^230 lAs.'D^oraE Summers (Oa%^\) WX\Q> SEaepWcresTj SuiW ^° Hcusiorlj Texas T|0L>S PEO SE; G-ar^ E^ouxYT "TleConncW IVvV 3ooV S.EmH^ for\>e. 1X3 0^ TTBLE QE CO^TE\0TS_ IftE^TTT^ OF pftfCVXSS: ED (v-*) TRBEE OF CoKJTEKiTS : HTl (\-M Xwt>E.x of FiuTttofcTTx^s: ED \-\£> STRTEnEWTOETH^ CESE; \T3 I STFXEnEWT REG-ftEE)!^ RFFESX^CES TOTWE E£C0ftft: \j) \ ISSUE ERESFKHTEV. \ x\ \ THIS ?EQ> SE ftrEFPtX^ETFE ER^SErJTS THFse Xss\jf:s For RhvWvJ VlTW hEEXT issuE tCXi SE£; Eo-3^ \ -VE<^ H •Va\tvVe^-Xc\5vVu.«Lacfe.<*^-VE«i yvm,a.<£s <*E "VKe JuCofS. ar>^ dL"< &CorsEEW"Eoc\-fc Vo -VE-e c!eVe-i\clk<\TS JeEcv>JU-yxV Wj«A-! a^ Q, ^Xx o- awd \tv\o a.t°V>aj DD) TflftlE QE COE)TrtOTS> STP\TEnEMTOE Fibers; ttS. STE\TEnEE5T OE^CXS XM SUREST OX CfVS-ES CTTEO: EL^J SUmftr\V OFTEE P&GX5 vXF.\OT,' \PS Sumn^N oetue eftSEs: GH3 Evx&Etucx; ilxm PMVfER : 0") Cevxt excite of seexjxc.es; (Q IH3) fflftEX Or E)UT¥eofixTT^S S4<3:& - Cos>q.s: • AlcorT^ V.S-U^e Piv*tr^ v. S-VcvV <> o-^ G-e orsU, 34S U. S. SS*?; 541 J]& PlsEdrcx-EE V. SEoEe o^Te.r»uessee;3S&.U.S.m,\H\LH, SXT-^U^SSu.EJuUlSi; fere^vj V, rw^Wd^nS U.s.32;83.5.CT. II?4^^) WtW^ \). SX<>.Ve o^S-^VV CwoUK^a^ OS.HV&j H^o.^3 S.CT, 66.1,^0. 11 L.EJU Wl B<^d 0(\E»ro-ci^ \J. \VrT 0*^,311 U.S. l£~0 ?a S.CLT. 1(^,31 UeJu^ao4 CmV) CV^o,EgT;3C)OS.Na;, S iiD ( ^Us^Ev^ c^^^a)j CoSSeW V. S-WVa errT^X^S/ E m x o? TVuTttofrTTX^S , C^e$w\\\ U&r EVv\S \LW&cW\er.&L3 t>.S.£& u4.V^ S.CT.13.W > Feller V. ?e.*rV<> aESXxE* o^fWeO YorE^o ti.S. 3^ 33^353^X4-11 S^CT. 3"^ 3*nf IS L.^.&Un. FJerro, ?3H S.W. OlJl 31o;313 .ClX*- d^cv,- fcft. mO Gig\;0.v, 1x3. 40^ as, \&>t 3\ x.E-a a G-WElHVv^rWtWX 533a SAaJ. 3d 110 (Tex-C^isN. ktf. apUbE.Ex3:s 33o Ke^U^ver^XWC.V. Schlock, 244 U.S^W, 1H S.CT,^3}4l0;1B L.Erd-^k. WW V.SWVe.MSS.W. 3i r)S-4.6Te^dr>v.^- * 1 * a^oS) @ jj\)C>SX OF fiuT\\O^TEXES_ SXd-& Cfi£«* Le^ra V.fce.ro\o, 344 U.S.5^556,1H S.CT/1&,W?^8 L-Ed14S; Ilooney V. HoloV\o,n,ai4 U.S. 103,SS S.CT. 3H0; 11 U Ed an rWsoxos\\ vr. UrvH^SWs^sa as, \^1 s.ct. \, VU f_ TVrV»e\ m. HuCkHrs Lms^ \ VJEeuT. 3oV, yL- E<1,^ {VVmsEv U People, o^ 5U-E& oElUeW VorV, ^4 U.S. Holy 404,35" S.CT 131.IS?, 81 L;^<) . /CX?t 10 ier\o-VE.o \). S^cXe oE VWv| WrU, 340 U.S. aU3^Hly 1) - s. cx. sas, 30.1, ^ u £d -2UI: m d.cx u43> su.^xad m. fye US-Va-Ve oE Kwsas) 3\t U.S. CU3, US S.CT. VTA, 84 \_xA.a\4. ? &ln|Ci«. V.S-WEt, o£ ftr\car,s ax&£6 "Ross \j.s^cXe a.33 s.v). ad \au,is^Exe^c^^- %>. \1S0l CerWcr\ ^rXed 1\ S.CT iTAI, 340 lh£. %HLy ^SL.Ed.U^ reversed 1L S.CT/m,S4l U.S.1l8tlX EoVV UUofted SV StyXVV v. S-Va-Ve oETexcS, 3\\ U.S.\ SVroEW V, SW 0^ CedAWr^ 343 U.S. \8\/\1011^S. CT. 511^03, Ik U.ed. ?4X( d«*sg.fvV'»^_opl£ialJ. SHr\»n5 U ConsWiVi*,^ U.S. 31^.31?,S3 S.CXVW 115,41 XX d-315; SovcVWfx V<*aV^ cC.U SaW/Wc, Sftl as, 4oi;UL c. 33 s.ct. Qin .aso,5i \_.xd Lua; TKo^ u swa^smv s.vu. ad 3i%^4 (ma) S^CT-3315 21 L.Bd.Sui H${ (mS) WeN> VI.SW-Ve.jaiSS.VJ. ad \S^L\ETe*,Cr,^,Hj>p. Iis-n , , ' < * 9 \ v IflfcEX oE-^uT^o^XTx^S ^6<*5 WEVY^n V. VMsof^SU.S.m,^ SXT.2^^ L.Fj 1083 and: VjE^Ee v. 1W3^3&4 u.s.iiao^s s.ct; ?98,S1 L.ed. 1343- Ward USVofrejOET^x^piu a£,s
\SD \CQWiSTTTuTrovJsy U.S. Cok)ST ou^ STATUTES / TouPe^oA Coda \W.§§ ac>.OH (Verrvorv Sukp ~&oVX) TeX* Period Code ftntt. § 3.03. (\)cr RULES t * XlUt>EX OF foUTttoWXX^grS Pede.ro. iCMtS De. vlarco \j, US.,1St8 P. £uAo14(\\^ C\r.m\) GortXoAez-SoWod UUnWed SVis/ Cl44 E3d £13 v\s-V C\r.Siool\ Q-uzrrio.r\ V. Sec^E^^e^EoECo^ecEvorSjkUS F.30- \33WC\WE C\r.2io\l\ Gr\tV\f\ UrVrc.e.jUCt E.3Fj.33l(lAE CW. aoio) cTcnes U Co^r\'(Y\ori-weo.\VVv oE EerEuckx/, U^VE.Cir^Tl E. £d 3SS,333, w\-VW mreScvoyer's Pe\\Vlon,(l=\XO., 2&1 Had SOS", Sol, vlorcV^ome^ V. ^030.^ U-C.^SU E.S^pp.3^ See g&neraHy ar^oXxV\or». AV-.F-d-^d IS^S. XiMkCX OF fiuTHQ^XTSSi © F^d^r^X Ceases S^.\riVCuft.\\\eF U P^cWr, V\U F.3d.441;44X L%¥k C\r. mill Tw^o<\M.ftf)3t;^^ F.ad ius; iv.U-sw* ex r&V. (1VECW. Y1S3) U^W S3c,xes vjAJcV>sW,31fc F.3d 1Sl;80l.^K C\r.aoc4^ \J ma STfiTgnguT QY^TWE: C^F£ © STftTEHEluT OFTttE CftSE TEe. ftc^oAWrvY wo-s oXo^e.d Ey mdveEoaertXS wWk XV\e or?eose oE iX^<>Aed Se.xu.oA IssauVVand l^rcwccVed Vx\ddr»a.^\c>^ \r\ Cause r\u. Pe^oX Code E)^w, ^-IXVY^fnon Sv^p^^V P&Wr Y»eo»X\nQ OuCNXsViC^eriV £v\d^nc.eXV\&.Jucv ^e.a-E«L^ctd VEe. ftopeAWovY Xo 1£Tye The CXe>Els record \r\ \4M.4l1S wVANoecEXed asccCWOV?TEe CWrVs r-ecor'd\rv \44111C wTU W cXVed. oj=>cc CWCSX) TEe. TeporV©rvs record -Eor VEe -EAcA CorSlsVs o? e.\^E"E VoVu.c\ SXoXe.EXAeA Xo Corr^V9erj^t£Te>s'k>vG- x STftTEriWT QE TE)CTS STfiTE~n^luToX f^cTS VE W<>-^ ^!»**sO. O* We^s^y beccu^d tEe f ye^o otJji^l vr&c, ir\»E \ik <^m-0 *f-o ftAWaey Kn*u/$ Hlte u^s In£touNv qk<\1Ey 5-WXo expeT'T i^IX (vessel, X ot.sk 4^-6 YXsW OujtX^ 4-c f>& dXrew 4X-fc ^Uf1^^®tH^ 3T K^e 4r^o k k a ErieX X pt^y W-bE Ud>i ir\ce Ca^e / CDACfcfAfA^ A*-& Wktrx V\& 6*1 A^ju.vnp^ ^u.4-^Xe drt^zrS Xkfc 0^65&<\^qe^ J £a5]JU o-r^MLe ^c^j-hsod? s\y 15c^Yc undeC swor-n a /<&>Hx fccVftn&y <3-on^Wz s wH-^ -VKo. XXX e nr\ oauA Su/g^E uso-i? <\eg oX: u.e> XEc_A£££±Cv So 4-WlS is ju.sX^o<^e ^X XVe> ^e^H 4e£>X ^.c^y dWX/C\Vf>7 u/Vveyv /X A^^ 5 jjXcXA.y k/M^K Ui'oUXei- vwy Fcd^r^t £ot^sXlT]:&t-4X*if\ »E XKfc- 2^5- b^puX^ ft ,l eWrA vT«\fc; <\ s ±*[JL ycc((, }fe Sol} I f^QQt«4/a.4eit ^eXt^oi heS<^u{{- h*pp£-^ F» 3 r^<>iK wWefx X3 c^^H^^vC^* Skfc li^J Xc yoJ\ Ol-^BC <7oJ^L ^acM-^lJ^ V\6^ upXW*v Orvy 5e-tv\o.n <^.wi^ ct-r^XkfcO p^a.1^ S^SXwcufs k/ctS 77?ia- (T\ M tX 7^\© VK OanoL^dS * VA> "-> 'I'fiKfc V\o-v>e.nv'FV\al 5ex /^/Xk/vu6 before Ko^ tva6 Co\lee-fed! by Ibe^cVy 6X*T)? C*l£ k-6 yi Aa^ ftflteitfijf* 3/ia JTh b*ff\ $e& <& 4,11 5k& hfiA^y^u/ke^Ske /ef^ Xke t^l'S? &/d>* #0'-^ ^X Jdv6 W^ T^A^^/H^r /l /" f rfV^r "A* ?u.X^ \fia\^cc{- cx-\j[ -/-kiX ©v'l'Me eel p«~j&3" CLA.^ Xk£ l^e's cv,<\.Q be^Wy /5 /oXaAS©- ($> ^TBT^/ner/v/T o-FF&cFfS T® Jotf-W\o Xke.s e> cr^es. waw$rt^ kX fkese. ^KaNe^HoP (9>y6«T5 iV TX-6C^^^X^ JQ-'V xil^^X -XesX v-Py dt<,?\r\c rj±.tjuff*h*4^ MftoAcenc-e ^X^.jev|3ed^6© CXr\^>Xy So^e^Ex.) 5 eu\d> c?^ y\oc ^$fe> S ki<2> S*toewkar<> b^y^e -fi^i *^xi ^^v «k ouX ; x- ~-*-s *Tt ^ m. <=>- cK^oWxr- fKoy\e> ON ft pc-es&ni* TXecc -<*£> o^XMc<£^Au^ Otf&-You^dSt\ ker ^rvi FAVJ-^ /4/^hX- )-\$~)3 9 d'keC© m/»5 Xkfc KoM_'^e> tX t^^i2__AfcXXjQ_Xk€ i/e. k»o/e> J) |U 1/lXKo Pl^WldfCG; ic^X Kj6 £><£cT""Xr^/^ fav<=\ b^j irn Xke Xt-uaF^ /cc/^eCx Jl^^Xkfc- Ik/v^S^i jcX^sA<3Xfvve«j tv^say ^«-y^ k^ D^-k^ u-P o- <3-^y <3Xcc-keX X u/ot4^ oi$str\y arg^MeiftT Xbo^X^kfc pe^jVay Xei>Xfvvo^Y ctvx&XkeWXs Xk*.X^5 ao± A/yJi4 XkE^ 1«7 ^k^X kt W*J ^ I u>ou\d. r&«ju.e.s-V VXoX AV,er<£. \sr\c-V su^ElcVt^X ^£ &*y AWkX u^b u,e^U«j -^ k& ScUd 4WX Eeccmse 0^ JpkeWX XEoXXEere u/ RJUr Sxle because V^c^^uer's 5ivae S \ Ae Ji^sP O/OvA ^uta \wVo W\ -rW4- \oVU ex ou^e 0€>t / ^ ^cVyV.lW /vfKedrJn4^^ fKojf C)o\fv¥ ^VcWV. »<, ^Kere 5oMe ' ervN^'VK* aoolT" reYVx€L Sxvnx^VVv Came. oucV a'5? VVvocV rac C^se£f tu©-^ qls s.w. ad slsl.ai3 tTtK.c^.ftvr*md k\ OdT-W V. SVXe oETe*<^ (3S£ US, AS . Q8 5-CT/ PbkercxXkU SkUd?Tt^esseey3SA US. myM, Bra^ \xrfWtWtJJ3fTi U.S.SS;SS SuCTJW tatf) EaAey US-UXe. o^f S^u-Ek (Xwi; n<*. 0$ &c^ed OnfcroJkj V, PWXcandjSnS LAS, |S~0 ?2t s.cT.n^^/ ked.Aox^/ 0f?&) Bc^Vey V, UnVWfc SkAes, W (AS- 44H, 48 /-S^ \oS s.ct,22ns %n u»Ed.ad vs/ (msd CWWt 3^ s.W. 3i %2 LT^xCAm. ^p-Aco'O C*vvfrvonG^\8S'SW, 2d 41kET*x.Cr^.fyp,aoo6»3 CooPer vX^e3^U5. V.HS 5.C-TJ^i^C £d* aJ £~ tWvs v.Wecks\er,9iUSaS-aa.Qq.V^ S.CT. 15,/V. 4S LX£d./^S, fe\Aer V* ?eop\e oX SXxXe. oE JOfcvoVork .3f0 US.3/5) 3aai33L,J-r»oX.4;rllS.CT,3o3;3on/?5' JL.Rck&k1] Rerro-j , si l. Ei iUd /^ ?& s.cn G-ka.kreman\;3S2iS.V,2d VQoTTex.CMrn. jfyf 9u>i0ktx.xs33O VU\ey U SXoXeo*? OW o 3<2A US,$7<*,S?1~£$ZCT. 3a3L.3o3.n x.Ed.aaq; K«n-kWc\c.k;j>)C.. USeur\oek>3Hn U.S.1\0,\&\, H4 S.eT.Ho^mo^S L^d.^4. KeeX&r V. SEaXe, H&S.\J. 3d HSkXTexXAm.ftpk^iO STFTEn^T OF- FBCTSXM Sufr?oftT oF CfiStS CTTH D S-KX C****} Leyra V. ftenno^H'l V.^SS^^SSZ^H S&T.^W-L/IW-W L.xdTO: iVserosk v.UEXed S-KXeSj 3Sa U.S. 1,14 S.CT-\, lEXd- PlarXn V-HunkeAS Lessee, 1VJEeak3oH,Hl~.Ed-Tk ?\aEnsk\ U?eo^\e okSXaAe oElUevJ York}3aH US.S?0l^V3 gss.cxisiTia^s^ u.Ea. loan. MlemoXko USEoXe oE rWvj\o^d,340 U.S. Ql^ani/U s.dT.sas^a^^s u.td.xua. )V)eOue U Eeopk oXAW SX<*Xe oEXlUnols^o U.S.CM m s.ct \w% 3L.td.ad mm. P^le USXXe oX W>s teople V, SavvkdeS, 1N.V. id XS^o^Sn, VSY IXY. S.ild So^saTisi* N.E.ad 8S3;8S<-asss. Fayne V. S+oXe o^r fAckcxnsas, 3S4. U.S. 5-&o,S^ 18 S-CT ® STftTtriEKJI QE FRCTS XM ,SuWET QE CfiSES „. . CXTj^X SEoXe • Ccses; RoSS y. SA-Xe^£33 S.U Ad 1%,IS^LTex. Cr>v JApp-tfXo] ~~ aerX\orar\ qrcnred *\\ S>.tT S^^HO US. W> <&"LFd- L% reversedXl SXTHHCl^l U.S. ?IS.
SekXk V. SVcXe o^Tex^S, 311 US. \Ql8. ISO WS-CT /6>V, 1US. L.U.8H- SkroEle \). SXaXe oX CoX.WnW343 USASl^oXl^CT .-STt,kC>3 ^3 L.Hd.2rl0i.(d^stnX\CN5O^n\on). SXerEo^U Co^sXank\n,a8n U.S.348.3^8,SB S.CT.im ns^nu.td.sis, SouXkern?ac\-?;e Co, U SokuyWr^an U.S.LOl^ll. 33 SXT.^TXaSo^q L.Ed US. TEomas V SXaXe, 2H1 S>V). 3d 31^7^ (ma) IKW SWXeS U Ba^leyjHll U.S. kk\Ul-8V0X S.CT.33n5 24 L.^d .ad 4£( (ins) Wdk USEoXe^TS S.W, ad lSS;lUlLTex.C^fn.Rpp.H5t) VJEWcnan V. \aJ\\soa, 31$ U.S. ^88^ L2 S.CT. 870, SI L.Ed 16S3 and; wE'Xe Ui R^fer^^ U.S. nLO} USS.CT^ /p _STfiT_Er\EMXOEEECTSX\Q Su^oftT Of CASES _CTTET^_ 5-V-«Xe gn A.^d, \3HS. CjuS^I Ward U SX Rh^ RWldoXU R>aAdk, 3^C\r.,nSF.ad2i5, 33ft.k.fUd Ccses; Won; Un\W SWV*s ex ret, Curran V. SXaEe o^r t>e\eware; 3^,Clrj SSI F.Qa *M. Ee IXerco V. US.^&S F.^Ej. \OHM Cll+k Clc. \ Guzmw v. SeereTary,\iepEoT Correeklans^USF.SD. muuxkcw.aoiO Gkv-rrin V- ?;erce} uaF.^o.ssiXnAhcir.aoiG) frTixrenrMTcr-FTicTs xto suEEq^TQT cases CXTgXj_ Cases: Tones V. Covnn\onvJea\Xk o^ kenTixeky^+E G1Y4 ?? F.ad 355,338, wl+W to re Sawyer's PeXVXon.^Ak.C^ osa r\ad t&S, 20*t. PlonX^ovAery UEeoe^ t).C,SU F, Supp-38^ See generally arroA"cX\oa.XC«Ed.aol) SXe\rkueE\er V. rwEneA,11U YMMH I, W(8-+k- c\a rm) Tko^son\J. bye, 3rd.C;r.}aQt\ F.^d %3;UXXed SVoXes fiXCel. UrdXedS-VcXes UTuekeC,1IU ?.2b.SnU} S2S, SSI. UniEedSX^eS UVJeksTeA^a F.3d Hal^Ok^XK C\c.X°oH) VanUeW V. U.S 33U F.ad UAH (TeX*) \%3>) SUMrlPtM OFXHF ^ECUvA^\OT ?^:ix SunnfM of TEE CftSES E\JXVoEk)C^ PRfXYER T CXRTXXXCPTTDE $Efc\)Id£S SuiWVftfrN OrTHF ftftftUMfc*" fegtf 1cf M 0 "v -jVroux>\\ "H\oc\ CkSrarVe fno^v V\o~V HyaoU/^^ U5t Hl^ d£^ir\<£curyV Ux^e o^^V^^c^ ^v\ay depend/ feTiToAtP u^«x? cie;(\ie.^ a^ ^oc^sS cVY W.vJ \ (\ ^oEh SOnnPikN OFTWE fiRQrU^g2£I (5) \j\ o loXi 6 Cocvs4Xc(^ ConX\eE\o^ oEAo.\^e^-VWoX^k otse oX ^LeEesXtAotw, Knov>or\'Vo »«. •Su.c.Vy Eyrafc\--e_se.AE>XAes o¥ AW SkXe, Is adenWl oE dae. ^roce/ss) ard Ake.^e \s also a ctamaA O^ dae. ^raee's.s, wke^ FEe SAcXe,-VEe&ugk noT S Co^sXUo.^ Vftoe\fcle AEoX a. SA«Xe roay -^oE krvA/jto<}\y useTcdse eAncle^ee AftalaAl^AXlse A-esA\ roooy-Eo 0EE00 <\ a Xo\nVec* Co-twAcXYan, lr^kE G£pv\se.d o^ro*VVve.r ^out\ds*for W\\e\>itscj Co^i^ fWisWX SFcAeA ftVforrey d.d noAk\^ Xo eorrecX X^seX^Xmotvy oE w\Xne^s,.^eE;A-Une^ u/^deMW doe t>roces5 oX Io.uj . Fe TEeio\aX\oA o£ Eke FoUeXe&nAk E»mendme(\TXo Xke ConsX\XuX\o AoXXke UkxA-ed SX&A-es.. Fi v^sA",WEs eS-WEl\ sEel XkaX AGowuledlon oEEX;(Ned AErouqE use oE A&.Ue ev^dence^ te?- krowu Eo kesueV Ey re.5reSenA"«Xwes CrtAke SXsXe., musAAdl u.f\der Ar\€i. Eoa^XeenAk \W TVvc SQstfAe, v^suH otaVoTv^ w\\«.*v "VVve Sx~oAr<^ c^HYiou.^ OAXtJT X ^ 1 0b /p De^^oiH S-foCtfe. Fa\ledTo CorrecL+?e^juue^J Tes^^on^ mMW&LW^y**. V.X\rmo\Sjn<\ s.e+ |H3 MAmmo-cke^A';!^ eAFsXUsFed -VkcXo. Cor,v'icX\oo oWFxWd Akfouqh use G-FkJse p>\ PeAXloner.w^s de.nled di^e process oE kw in uVokk'onoF+Ke fOUL^-Vc6^V F(v^clfnetXvX'Ak€. £e u^^^iCA 5^V\yr\<; \f\"VV\.e. f)a5Sencer>S^ar *tK -VKocV V6 puMei UP ^eWirvi S-^Y Cutty's Vioa5eoA tt^s^c^Tkart- Console. ct,v\J ouc^ V\ Dwtte^ \\&^GV4LX** SU ct\*-*- dl> pajfci^ Lljtlt,^ \H Xklkv^KeU^S^i! button ;|1 *vA \4 U^ W^Vx Uf.xve l§ yes $irv 1'WolJ fr^ We, „TWt\ ^ Ak \ w Ekfc iAue*s Jk*r M^'1* 5<«^Say5 '. . ?*' 5 Mo ke ck>AlX f\Xvr A9- 6AoX fi*feVc«Y s-r^ 'W U U*W MUcvc 53 ^cw O? SU u^ IJvJ ^ ^f n^F^3W^ ^5X,X^ ^ ^ Ske ^ A-r f^Y\cor\&£> aJb^d-^y 5kc ^* **£^ A)^kX-, tfW^r tf*A W*/ "*vi e^txirnV^k^X, vA.WUr*, yek- ^ ^r;fft A+S^i ke ^aX K-ic^^X fkere Rr\&uvnHMT -r^Vc^s 4V>*cV X(^e o^se^uecA \r\ ^VViVs co.se- V^Ys^ o^r ^ecie.Wecr) ^o^^*VV\ocV ^oe\\ \$ ^ucs4or\ Vier e\WuJ oxvsl- *Oo cVW-O Oojt*Vs a^r Vvec V>oAv| . P\cd -VV\e e\bow U/^ dV0$WccC^A; wVaxC-Vn ujolA^ (v\e^ -VVnclV 4WV VJO.S -r-^W af\d sVv<^ ^ssVaccxrkeJ) V*e^ clVww.. SV\e W<* To^cr 4o *VW cWW a<^ Wvc ^WY S^U cvY ^loVoA V\e/C SCv>ac 0s? 'VVi^crv ^e^-\ecVeA *YW ^edt\eSS €>% Y\er<2\W; eA)tr\ a^e.C ex)tT^ cx^VeO $o^e.V^e w\\cO\ \^ us<^>^ \\\<& V\^oA\ fNO ^deSS, VoukCccxVl 3ee.-VW redness VVve.^ \\ $£\\cA" ov useA Vns- ssA \^"V s^r^^ kmi or l^c-y ^ 6 a\> tY\o^v\\£veS DM ft Vo Bu4 s\\e 304 \o 4VnojV \v*sp\W relarV^ely $uvek. ^otv\^e Vv^^e. peWod VWV VVms cxWegedsv'Vuck^fv OC^ciurreci^ w^VxnViOiA^S- Mou- \ •\V\ct\c olWuV WxarV.X W<^f\Ye<\ V* Da\rv*V 4o V*u^ cx\Verv"V\or\ cx\bo-uoV kcxA kere^s Xke Xk\ nq ,ke. c3l^ in Xsee OrtwjAkk^ - He- sk^iXkere on Xke 5Ht\r Occurred OtxV VW wYvoW VWe* X4 'CvnX^VvV Woe Werx VW QcCkA.<>Vv GvW SyriVYxeY* c yyvc^X^u^aoA 4W>4 s Yv**> wo^> s^o^oYcxcn^ *X4 ^<> wVveWer o-r f\oV VY\e^e Ys a. c4ou.W4 VVacxV Ockey ^\ou-^V oil Ji VVtvS S\r\cie C\oWAy SavO \J^4 Vvo.£>£>eC\ £.<^* TV\oVl^> w/WV X w- Pk\A XAk\nk <^XXke CAetcXusIVn^ wrkerAyo-tA 2EX ot O^&D e A Sum^QFTwe cases fw^^e v-xuwiSjTi sxx \m a4; iiin) m^ cw lcXV >s es4o\WWA VWV a CocwxeVVo^ o^Y^Vcvedl YVrou^Vx u^e oY YoAse, e\)\de^eo.jVoou;r) Vo W>sacW \i\| re^eserrYoVWes cV VWS4 VW SfckYe f eVuses Vo disclose revuesYea £V\cU.r>c& YY\oV \s Va\>oroVAe Vo VW JeYec\ r e^cxrd\ess oV vdVeVWr W e Ae*?©cvse rrvad^ .Ov re^tie^V^oJVeJ Vo cWciAose rele\MrvY CaaYa qojV^ (Lvi A«. Qio\\ *) W\\5 3soO(TW c°^4 o^i^^Ji Wese C^bU C<^V\otf\ Vie ?\VeA OkC\i S^T^ Scdorr\\<»5>oV\ 4o ^e4eorvvk(\e wWY\x 5VccVe^vveAV3/4>o\\ce re pov-^s. /oe^V^cl vv;/\ VW .S4a4e>s vuorV-^rodoLcV Vo\Jter (j^JWasj^ lOHMlUYk C\rXmOU* Q. Co^vltVUn rous4 be overturned wVWY\ resV \rpatV H^on 4Y\e WowW^ use oV -W\se -VesVooony V4? SunnfW orrtt^ c&siS- VWc-e \S ar^xj reaSoriaYAe. \\W\n WoAVWV VW T CGuz,xviar\ v* SeareVarv^^^^oYCcE-^eY^^s (cUS K3b ClWVv O, Oo\V)C P^osecucVor ^scohA^V^V^owl^ usee) OerN\u.cecATesV\ (hdavi J (feaseA or, ftroly MHartcc^ 3^ U^S^VSO 9Z SXX H>A ~3\ \,ecY StQ \0M C\l^( Y\e C^VVi G\r« floAQ^ . , - SV«Ve Wou) \ -• VW sYrcYe W v>WWWfi (yVigraAy V* ^^1*^303 <§) jSOEMHk^H of Tttg CfySES U^SAgl^S S.CT. \m, )OF.eE>.Q^.a\S VnAkkcAa ^rnpeo^cXw^enX e\kienee AXvoT w-o-ukk kkeki kaue eXXeredl Xke oaXcoraa ok Xke C<^2>eA kere -VWj \o\sEr\oX ^^Vorney Su.bkAessed \mp k \)\o\ ,3;CT. DA3 CTFc von A^closure ^EAX"is evloler>ee oX¥e<^X\n u»X\oXvA<^ Corvl eX\oA .. Viken Xke rek ^\nA oXVovjeA Xo 50 uACorre>eXe;i wken aX QoCiecx^e,d; CouAA \f\o,ny reojSonVAes \ik«>EjVv*o-dl Wvrc oXXecXei Xke iukjenvenX >«~.&3 S-CT.IW Olto3kXWlA XkoX 5u^Cesskn ok moXeAvoA evvAeACe.^u-skk'ies a. AevU XrVo.1 'kCAesfexaekh/e o^ G-<5« J X&.\Ak or Wi-XeuXk akXke e>r0sec jTSX])Trve S-V^Ae Ws cxn nEr \rvv\cc\~We duXy Xo (\JMlk\j^L^^ WorAs askeA ckW o^swe^ed caalA i\^Yo\vaA-ge © Sunm^kH of twr ovsi-rs aneA f\oA-k\fv^ c&klA ke done Xo eAAreA<>rXm|>r Fipb^25is) TEe appF (^jtk CEX^aE^oq s.YJ, 3i %2 (T^CW-Ve Q,oo^X Tke Cov^^V cds« e.g^£.eJ 4k 33km me* \)\ dlcncL f«-(t Q) ueouXy flMTwovfl GkkKJM (gy>\icncc> A$™oA*i ?*?\*r\ \-UA ' TesX\mo^v Ut\der OoXn . OnThe W.XnesS S^cvr»d Usel^OlH \j\reAT"k)Cerr\\AcxX\oA cy tWkkrfjeli tyxf\ In^3,oX3c)UnelH) foepuXj &W SF*Xe:* v^/l Xn Rft3,^A- HO Uae1UXW11) ba^kf Q\«** SFckA \e>^ x believe sW k*Aa. s^oAl kutnA on ker keotct- In k^A-AHl^ Une\3A-Ww.l8) CksFr^cXBlWey ti&fc be^ptXy fe^l Xrs RR3j<*Y S3)Uts«. Ik \WtUU) be^ukf £U*\<\ SKFei £>u_e, ' S- ^ sF<-ee-E cv,+ «X^° «-^ @ $P Xn RRH jOX ns}U«v«. *H AW^&5U tAs A^VcX &MpaAfcv r^ 9^>k Xa^^s Tkc^^bc^s^-^T ^^aX- F'\oesT;< In RkSjOXS^kl ne IX-WOiS) fo\l rk^kkkJ wWX Xo Rk3)nk5H)k\ne1lFE^U^sFrTo.E Morney WkoX o-c-e t^a koki'Ay eoE? TkoX's Elm. SEt^eeX- Wh nk;V\X \So^ \n D<«Xrc.uAo r- p^cXur^, £*/vw noX See\ ns ^ Xnn^oXsOU^eHFE^n^SgX^eH-^rn SkcEei ^ GtcV FkereS kou.ses k«.kTt\i an AXe AexX^-WeX Oi>er }so TVe^e's oo«.n\n^ . v^\Xa nkS^XS-H) k\ ne.1 \Wt) fcVsVseX- Morney S^ UeYWW? ^e/S •W\VW Y^w-r Vx^xge-C dr ^ Xnv& 4-v mu) u^ myw^os) w\ wW, Ke v# Wek VowcloA^ ^\^r CWse."XV 5o^rx) —- $oVer n^ T«.v^ V£ anyXkvn^ ko k\f*v? Kto- 1\^A wWayou. gc-X Xo W^A. ftk) erTe rrtvee ck Ayoa. cj u.ys XuC^n Ack^oa 9X\e ^A SFreeA"? yeS.XA\<(eM)AEkA^XHNeHE^uaS)Wos \# WE\re SA^eeX or w** AFXke SFreek r\ f} ftx^ Xn RR33o;X\\)JUAe..|k.bVft.SX<.Xe^ fcm*«Jk SrwHk was E u\ aq ouX ok keV' Cnr,^ ' RekXe XnKEMJArl4^k\ueaXWo,|c! iWc^S^Ak S^Xe XkcX ske i^^-e noX \X\ny\o Ver AcA- M^l Tk R^3joX-11 ),U ae &BXW 3M. DA SkcWA AkoX ter\cM\&£\S(vAFk aoSEt.C ck\\Are.n u/otXd* Ee \ f\ Xke rkonk ^&£&&£*te©- To©m. Sle<^\n^" keWXe Xn 9kHpX IMAkkW HXEtuT Rroc^S^Xk - XkAk\U\»fto Aoe>(w iXeWVTn Ek3j aX 111*), L^cAXWia.OS'JTW Ek eyxFnn) k\ ne 1FNn^m. (e, G ^cWt XnkkV^OjUae WkWaS. fc.fXS;kW X wa.A Vw>»v\ft H Xke UsAis j-toom. \xssi&Adf or 9w\ax (SIol S^kXk« U)v> *5v> a Xke k< u« K«*ic (H - ^uryXrr ftfc3/xV >H\U^q4H4W£\ *ftdV SWVeS VWV 5V^i M c*^\c* VWeO Wr 9e V>^ I^n^aX\0)ekr\3TYSfne^WjXA lXE«Xe kEX&X ^ni ^Xe \VWaS") Er\%fte^ fte-Axcxhz. SX&XeA khceFXke peTforcU Sw4 Uj^s Eek^V xys^oXrveAkr spa-r-^. E-oX tv\s. S/wejkX ^ny p_eF CiosXj^ SXaXetnenX ky hn WokeXl *\J OifcWi c_X fttt* *ee y H^Y Xn RkS^nXHl); PV. Vcx.kek;Xi5X p^X In^^aA SXoX>X*kXVX 8^ W-2oXxXXX sA^Xes Tke w^F> reSuAXs okFXvnecJ AXPt Xrors aX \easTXwo \iA iuicXak IWunoX StvOVkkkX caaaoX Ee excluded as ce OosSiEW CgaVXaVo r Xo XX1 S Av\ yTure, Tkete. Is XsuXEXXnA" XEormoXtoAXo AXW^Xe uAerfker ^X, E;; Xo k Xo 4k s rnv! )(Xu-re \ s A\a4e, £*>Xe Xn^E^evX oXoXks E^kX.X^) i^k? ATX ,X- SeysTKe biofi CeSctlXs okXXvAec^.AXin Akg.(kX (3TO^aA SWoXs^klXeekewaXKj^X JkXi^kkvV SwcJo V(anri) 1^-k LAk\nje.rAft|i lSa^X ore consvNsXenk w iXk Xke ftkJte Ae<,u.lXs okkOned) XroiA. v\XeA Kl.TkereX»ce fW oV Vk^ feSu-(4s. «U»*V Xn)HkA-cckM^X\nelUAkc^n) Eke^XcX V"6 ' mUy 54*W> Ws ^A ko-S *W? 'el keA X-o AXe f*knX uUhsU Ws -^^gXT ^W- mulXp^ X^a XS^Xes ^kk.XgX-RE^ 1 W ao?S aolfMiilikJ 3s\ *-** kbk k^ve /Ky t»fkhon Fee neek c^w^ uskf-^* ^ p M->1 Xn EAnS Xrxk^S 9^u^ Xn ^SotVnO^^c^ YW^Uk^virereir fl^Mvey t5*y5 ft^d Vtaxek YkvS ^texvx #»is Man 4W^ap^c^e^4iy Knoius m^tV^t acYs /vvuc^ 5Vrcr^X f\W\d
X XSSO£
«"-« A ?k u_,<*£ c^X -K-fc <2-vt\v