Fowler v. Gulf Insurance Company

306 So. 2d 406, 1975 La. App. LEXIS 4115
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJanuary 15, 1975
Docket4818
StatusPublished
Cited by5 cases

This text of 306 So. 2d 406 (Fowler v. Gulf Insurance Company) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Fowler v. Gulf Insurance Company, 306 So. 2d 406, 1975 La. App. LEXIS 4115 (La. Ct. App. 1975).

Opinion

306 So.2d 406 (1975)

Thomas H. FOWLER, Jr., Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
GULF INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant-Appellant.

No. 4818.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

January 15, 1975.
Rehearing Denied February 5, 1975.

*408 Bolen & Halcomb by Roy S. Halcomb, Jr., Alexandria, for defendant-appellant.

John M. Sherrill, III, Alexandria, Thomas H. Fowler, Jr., Monroe, for plaintiff-appellee.

Before FRUGÉ, DOMENGEAUX and WATSON, JJ.

WATSON, Judge.

Plaintiff, Thomas H. Fowler, Jr., an attorney, was injured on May 4, 1972, while a passenger in an automobile owned by Louis Mac Ray and driven by Van McNair. Plaintiff filed suit to recover for the injuries received in the accident and obtained a verdict in the trial court against defendant, Gulf Insurance Company, the insurer of the Ray vehicle, as follows:

     Pain and suffering:      $40,000.00
     Permanent disability:    $50,000.00
     Medical expenses:        $ 3,274.09
                              __________
     Total:                   $93,274.09

The defendant insurance company has appealed, alleging that the trial court erred as follows:

1. Denying defendant the right to introduce certain evidence;
2. Finding policy coverage for the accident;
3. Failing to find plaintiff guilty of independent or contributory negligence;
4. Making an award of $50,000 for permanent disability, defendant contending that the amount is manifestly excessive and unsupported by the evidence.

As the trial court stated in its reasons for judgment, the $40,000 awarded for pain and suffering and the $50,000 awarded for permanent disability were the maximums that could be awarded under the pleadings, plaintiff having alleged damages in those amounts in his petition.

In ruling on defendant's motion for a new trial on the question of plaintiff's permanent disability, the trial court pointed out that plaintiff's right hand is small and atrophied; the skin is shiny and slick; the fingers are frozen in a fixed position; and the hand amounts to nothing more than a claw. The trial court stated that plaintiff's ability to try cases and check titles is impaired, his social life is affected and he is unable to participate in many hobbies and sports.

The testimony was as follows:

Plaintiff, Thomas H. Fowler, Jr., testified that he is an attorney and was involved in an automobile accident on Highway 165 North about seven miles south of Monroe on the night of May 4, 1972. Plaintiff was using a 1970 Plymouth Duster owned by one of his clients, Louis Mac Ray, and the automobile was being driven at the time of the accident by Van McNair. The driver went off the road onto the gravel shoulder and lost control of the automobile, which turned end over end into the left ditch. Plaintiff's hand went through the window, and the glass caused his primary injury to the right hand. After the accident, plaintiff was in St. Francis Hospital for 30 days where he had surgery twice and then in the V. A. Hospital in Shreveport for another 30 days for intensive therapy. Plaintiff testified that he experienced considerable pain in his hand and wrist and was still having discomfort as of the time of trial. He is righthanded and unable to write except to sign his name. Although he could formerly type 60 words a minute and used this ability in his practice, he can no longer type. Plaintiff *409 testified that he is able to drive but no longer likes to do so because of his lack of use of the right hand. Plaintiff testified that his principal hobby is fishing; he now requires help with his fishing rig. He had known Van McNair by sight for a long time and picked him up on the highway around Ball or Tioga when he recognized his face. McNair offered to drive after they had driven about 10 miles and plaintiff let him do so. They stopped at a bar where plaintiff had one drink and took another with him and McNair had half a can of beer. Plaintiff testified that he did not ask McNair about his driving because McNair's father was in the used car business in West Monroe and he had often seen McNair driving used cars. Prior to the accident, plaintiff observed McNair's driving for some ten miles and McNair had been driving well. Plaintiff was treated after the accident by Dr. Frank X. Kline, Jr. and Dr. Jack Tom Jackson of Monroe.

Louis Mac Ray testified that he is in the investment business and was represented by plaintiff. Plaintiff used one of Ray's cars whenever he wanted or needed one. Ray testified that he normally had four automobiles and insurance coverage for four. In 1972, he purchased an Oldsmobile Toronado to replace a Cadillac and a Plymouth Duster to replace a Mustang.

Ray testified that he relied entirely on Mr. Daniel Page Ferguson of Humphries Insurance Agency to maintain insurance coverage on his automobiles. Plaintiff's exhibit 3 and defendant's exhibit 8 is a letter written by Ray to Humphries Insurance Company dated April 20, 1972, which states in part:

"Please substitute a 1971 Oldsmobile Toronado, Serial Number ..., and a 1970 Plymouth Duster, Serial Number..., for the 1971 Ford Mustang and the 1971 Cadillac .... transfer the full coverages to the Oldsmobile and the Plymouth...."

Ray testified that he was forced to hire other counsel because of plaintiff's accident and paid Mr. Joseph Lesage of Shreveport something over $18,000 for attorney's fees in a case which plaintiff had been handling, and Mr. Charles Rine around $7,000 for another matter that plaintiff had been handling prior to his accident. Ray testified that these fees, amounting to $25,000, would have been earned by plaintiff. He mentioned another case where he received a judgment of $75,000 which plaintiff had had on a 40% retainer prior to his accident and for which Ray employed a Mr. Bolin, an attorney in Columbus, Ohio.

Daniel Page Ferguson testified that he had been in the general insurance business for 23 years and was employed as manager of Humphries Insurance Company in West Monroe from October of 1968 or 1969 until September 5, 1973. He represented eight or ten insurance companies, among them Gulf Insurance Company, defendant, and handled insurance coverage for Ray and his corporations. Ray generally asked for coverage by letter. Ferguson received the letter identified as P-3 and D-8 but procrastinated, and the accident happened before the substitution was made. Ray was billed for his insurance coverage on a monthly basis. At the time of the accident, Ray had a personal insurance policy covering four automobiles, the inception date being July 26, 1971 and the expiration date July 26, 1972. The policy had not been cancelled as of the accident on May 4, 1972. It had not been countersigned by Ferguson. Ray had double coverage with Gulf Insurance Company on two of his automobiles, since they were also listed in a policy insuring Ace Investment, Ltd. and/or Allstate Diesel Co., Inc. Ferguson said the accident created an embarrassing situation since he had received the letter requesting a substitution from Ray but had not made the change, and he also discovered at that time that there was double coverage on these two automobiles. Humphries *410 Agency was not a sole agent for Gulf Insurance Company and not a direct employee of that company. Ferguson had binding authority with Gulf Insurance Company. Ray did not specify from what company he wanted insurance.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Loveday v. Travelers Ins. Co.
585 So. 2d 597 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1991)
Lindstrom v. Arnold
421 So. 2d 1178 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1982)
McKowen v. Gulf States Utilities Co.
351 So. 2d 1248 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1977)
Sayre & Toso, Inc. v. Manser Agency, Inc.
351 So. 2d 198 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1977)
Coco v. Winston Industries, Inc.
330 So. 2d 649 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1976)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
306 So. 2d 406, 1975 La. App. LEXIS 4115, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/fowler-v-gulf-insurance-company-lactapp-1975.