Fonseca v. Consolidated Rail

Opinion

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21  )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 1R 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU

PXFKDJJUDYDWHGKHDULQJLPSDLUPHQW7KLVFRXUWDIILUPHG )LOH 1DPH DS

WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVJUDQWRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWEDVHGRQWKH VWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQVFRQFOXGLQJWKDW0RXQWVKDGIDLOHGWR 81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 UDLVHDJHQXLQHLVVXHDVWRZKHWKHUWKHKHDULQJORVVKHILUVW EHFDPH DZDUH RI LQ  ZDV D VHSDUDWH LQMXU\ IURP WKH )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 DJJUDYDWHGKHDULQJORVVKHH[SHULHQFHGLPPHGLDWHO\SULRUWR BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB KLVODZVXLWLQ &$5/26 )216(&$ ; ,Q FRQWUDVW WKLV FRXUW UHYHUVHG WKH JUDQW RI VXPPDU\  MXGJPHQWLQ&DSXWRY&6;7UDQVS,QF1R 3ODLQWLII$SSHOODQW  :/  WK &LU 1RY   XQSXEOLVKHG WDEOH  1R GHFLVLRQ ZKHQ DQRWKHU OLIHORQJ UDLOURDG ZRUNHU ZKR KDG Y  EHHQH[SRVHGWRORXGQRLVHIRUWKLUW\\HDUVVXHGXQGHU WKH ! )(/$IRUGDPDJHVIORZLQJIURPKLVHYHQWXDOKHDULQJORVV  &2162/,'$7(' 5$,/  $OWKRXJK &DSXWR KDG EHHQ H[SRVHG WR mH[FHVVLYHO\ KLJK &25325$7,21 QRLVH OHYHOVl IRU GHFDGHV KH XQOLNH 0RXQWV ZDV WROG DW  SHULRGLFKHDOWKH[DPVWKDWKLVKHDULQJZDVQRUPDO&DSXWR 'HIHQGDQW$SSHOOHH  ZDVQRWDZDUHRIDQ\FXPXODWLYHHIIHFWVRIWKHH[SRVXUHWR  VXFKQRLVHXQWLOZLWKLQ WKUHH \HDUVRIKLVILOLQJVXLW 1 7KLVFRXUWLQUHYHUVLQJWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVJUDQWRIVXPPDU\ $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW MXGJPHQWKHOGWKDWDPDWHULDOIDFWXDOGLVSXWHH[LVWHGDVWRWKH IRUWKH1RUWKHUQ'LVWULFWRI2KLRDW7ROHGR GDWH ZKHQ WKH FXPXODWLYH KHDULQJ LPSDLUPHQW PDQLIHVWHG 1RnsDPHV*&DUU'LVWULFWsXGJH LWVHOIEDVHGRQERWK&DSXWRjVWHVWLPRQ\DQGWKHWHVWLPRQ\RI DPHGLFDOH[SHUW$OWKRXJKWKHSODLQWLIILQ&DSXWRXQOLNH $UJXHG)HEUXDU\ )RQVHFD SURGXFHG PHGLFDO WHVWLPRQ\ WR KHOS UHEXW WKH GHIHQGDQWjVPRWLRQWKLVGRHVQRWDOWHUWKHIDFWWKDW&RQUDLO 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG$SULO IDLOHGWRFDUU\LWVEXUGHQLQHVWDEOLVKLQJDVDPDWWHURIODZWKDW WKHVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQVKDVUXQ %HIRUH'$8*+75(<DQG*,/0$1&LUFXLWsXGJHV &2//,(5'LVWULFWsXGJH ,,,&21&/86,21 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB )RUDOORIWKHUHDVRQVVHWIRUWKDERYHZH5(9(56(WKH GLVWULFWFRXUWjVJUDQWRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWDQG5(0$1' &2816(/ WKH FDVH EDFN WR WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW IRU IXUWKHU SURFHHGLQJV FRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKLVRSLQLRQ $5*8('  ( s /HL]HUPDQ (s /(,=(50$1 $662&,$7(6 7ROHGR 2KLR IRU $SSHOODQW  .HYLQ & $OH[DQGHUVHQ *$//$*+(5 6+$53 )8/721

7KH +RQRUDEOH &XUWLV / &ROOLHU 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW sXGJH IRU WKH (DVWHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 7HQQHVVHH VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ

  )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 1R 1R )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 

1250$1&OHYHODQG2KLRIRU$SSHOOHH21%5,()( 7KH FRXUW LQ )OHPLQJ EDVHG RQ WKH DERYH WHVWLPRQ\ s/HL]HUPDQ(s/(,=(50$1 $662&,$7(67ROHGR FRQFOXGHGDVDPDWWHURIODZWKDWKLVFODLPZDVEDUUHGE\WKH 2KLR IRU $SSHOODQW  .HYLQ & $OH[DQGHUVHQ *DU\ ) )(/$ VWDWXWH RI OLPLWDWLRQV  6HH DOVR &DPSEHOO Y *UDQG :HUQHU*$//$*+(56+$53)8/721 1250$1 7UXQN:55&R)GWK&LUWK &OHYHODQG2KLRIRU$SSHOOHH &LUsDQm>,@I&DPSEHOOjVFRQGLWLRQ>ZLWKLQ WKUHH\HDUVRIKLVFRPSODLQW@ZDVDQDJJUDYDWLRQRIKLVLOOQHVV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB SULRU WR WKDW WLPH KLV FODLP ZRXOG EH WLPHEDUUHG LI KH UHDVRQDEO\VKRXOGKDYHNQRZQWKDWKHZDVVXIIHULQJIURPWKDW 23,1,21 FRQGLWLRQGXHWRKLV*UDQG7UXQNZRUNEHIRUHWKHVWDWXWHRI BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB OLPLWDWLRQVH[SLUHGl,QFRQWUDVWWR)OHPLQJDQG&DPSEHOO WKHUH LV QRWKLQJ LQ )RQVHFDjV WHVWLPRQ\ WKDW DOORZV XV WR 521$/'/((*,/0$1&LUFXLWsXGJH&DUORV)RQVHFD FRQFOXGHDVDPDWWHURIODZWKDWDVLPLODUDFFXPXODWLRQRIWKH ZKRGHYHORSHGFDUSDOWXQQHOV\QGURPH&76DVDUHVXOWRI GDLO\VWUHVVHVRIPDQXDOODERUPDQLIHVWHGWKHPVHOYHVPRUH KLVHPSOR\PHQWDVDUDLOURDGODERUHUZLWK&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO WKDQWKUHH\HDUVEHIRUHKHILOHGKLVFRPSODLQW &RUSRUDWLRQ&RQUDLOVXHGKLVIRUPHUHPSOR\HUIRUGDPDJHV XQGHUWKH)HGHUDO(PSOR\HUVj/LDELOLW\$FW)(/$&RQUDLO $FFRUGLQJ WR &RQUDLOjV DUJXPHQW LI WKH LQMXULHV WKDW ILOHGDPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWDUJXLQJWKDWWKHVWDWXWH GHYHORSHG LQ  RU  DUH VLPSO\ DJJUDYDWLRQV RI RIOLPLWDWLRQVKDGUXQRQ)RQVHFDjVFODLP7KHGLVWULFWFRXUW )RQVHFDjVHDUOLHUGLVFRPIRUWWKHQKHZRXOGKDYHVDWLVILHG JUDQWHGWKHPRWLRQDUXOLQJWKDW)RQVHFDQRZFKDOOHQJHVRQ WKHVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQVRQO\LI KH KDGILOHGVXLWE\ DSSHDO)RUWKHUHDVRQVVHWIRUWKEHORZZH5(9(56(WKH ZLWKLQ WKUHH \HDUV RI KLV ILUVW DFKH RU SDLQ  6XFK D UHVXOW MXGJPHQW RI WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW DQG 5(0$1' WKH FDVH IRU ZRXOGXQGHUPLQHWKHSXUSRVHRIWKHGLVFRYHU\UXOH6HH8ULH IXUWKHUSURFHHGLQJVFRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKLVRSLQLRQ Y7KRPSVRQ86GHFODULQJWKDWWKH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI D VLPLODU UXOH WR YLFWLPV RI VLOLFRVLV ZRXOG ,%$&.*5281' PDNHLWmFOHDUWKDWWKHIHGHUDOOHJLVODWLRQDIIRUGHG8ULHRQO\ DGHOXVLYHUHPHG\l0RUHRYHULI)RQVHFDKDGILOHGD)(/$ $ )DFWXDOEDFNJURXQG VXLW LQ  ZLWKRXW DQ\ PHGLFDO HYLGHQFH EH\RQG KLV &DUORV)RQVHFDDUHVLGHQWRI7ROHGR2KLREHJDQZRUNLQJ WUDQVLHQWDFKHVDQGSDLQVDIWHUDORQJGD\jVZRUNWKHUDLOURDG IRUWKHUDLOURDGLQWKHHDUO\VDVDODERUHU)RQVHFDjVMRE ZRXOG OLNHO\ KDYH FODLPHG WKDW WKH DFWLRQ ODFNHG DQ\ ZDVUDLOURDGPDLQWHQDQFHZKLFKLQYROYHGFKDQJLQJUDLOURDG HYLGHQWLDU\VXSSRUW WLHV PRYLQJ UDLOV DQG SHUIRUPLQJ RWKHU UHSDLUV  %HFDXVH 7KLVFRXUWjVSULRUGHFLVLRQVDSSO\LQJWKH)(/$VWDWXWHRI )RQVHFDZDVDVHDVRQDOHPSOR\HHKHRQO\ZRUNHGIRUDERXW OLPLWDWLRQVWRFDVHVRIKHDULQJORVVVXSSRUWVWKHGLVWLQFWLRQ HLJKWHHQPRQWKVRYHUDSHULRGRIIRXU\HDUV)RQVHFDOHIWWKH EHWZHHQ )OHPLQJ DQG &DPSEHOO RQ WKH RQH KDQG DQG UDLOURDGLQWKHPLGVPRYHGWR7H[DVDQGZRUNHGIRUDQ )RQVHFDjVFDXVHRIDFWLRQRQWKHRWKHU,Q0RXQWVY*UDQG RLOPLOO+HUHWXUQHGWRKLVHPSOR\PHQWZLWKWKHUDLOURDGLQ 7UXQN:55)GWK&LUWKHSODLQWLIID DVDIXOOWLPH\HDUURXQGODERUHUDMREKHNHSWXQWLO OLIHORQJUDLOURDGHPSOR\HHZKRKDGEHHQH[SRVHGWRFRQVWDQW +LVGXWLHVZHUHWKHVDPHDVEHIRUHFRQVLVWLQJRIWUDFN ORXGQRLVHWKURXJKRXWKLVFDUHHUZDVJLYHQDKHDULQJWHVWLQ PDLQWHQDQFH UDLO UHSDLU VZLWFK UHSDLU DQG RWKHU PDQXDO +HZDVQRWLILHGWKDWKHKDGH[SHULHQFHGDGHJUHHRI WDVNV SHUPDQHQWKHDULQJORVV0RXQWVKRZHYHUGLGQRWVXHXQWLO DIWHUKHZDVSODFHGRQGLVDELOLW\OHDYHEHFDXVHRIKLV  )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 1R 1R )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 

mDFFXPXODWHGHIIHFWVlKHFODLPVWRKDYHGLVFRYHUHGZLWKLQ 7KURXJKRXW )RQVHFDjV HPSOR\PHQW ZLWK WKH UDLOURDG KH WKUHH \HDUV RI ILOLQJ KLV FRPSODLQW  1RWKLQJ LQ &RQUDLOjV XVHGKDQGWRROVVXFKDVWRQJVVOHGJHKDPPHUVVSLNHPDXOV HYLGHQFHFRQWUDGLFWVWKLV WHVWLPRQ\&RQUDLOWKXVIDLOHGWR SLFNV DQG VKRYHOV  +H DOVR XVHG SRZHU WRROV VXFK DV DLU VDWLVI\LWVEXUGHQRIVKRZLQJWKHDEVHQFHRIDPDWHULDOIDFWXDO KDPPHUVDLUJXQVDQGUDLOVDZV$FFRUGLQJWR)RQVHFDjV GLVSXWHZLWKUHJDUGWRWKHVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQV$OWKRXJK GHSRVLWLRQWHVWLPRQ\KLVKDQGVZRXOGKXUWDIWHUXVLQJPDQ\ &RQUDLO FKDUDFWHUL]HV WKH ODWHU FRQWLQXRXV SDLQ DV D PHUH RIWKHVHWRROVEXWWKHSDLQZRXOGDOZD\VVXEVLGHE\WKHQH[W DJJUDYDWLRQRI)RQVHFDjVSULRUGLVFRPIRUW8ULHDQG$SDULFLR GD\7KLVUHSHWLWLYHEXWWHPSRUDU\GLVFRPIRUWZDVDIUHTXHQW LQVWUXFW XV WR YLHZ WKH mDFFXPXODWHG HIIHFWVl DV D GLVWLQFW FRQVHTXHQFHRIKLVHPSOR\PHQWXQWLORU)RQVHFD LQMXU\XQOHVVWKHHYLGHQFHVXJJHVWVRWKHUZLVH FODLPV WKDW WKH SDLQ LQ KLV KDQGV GLG QRW LQFUHDVH EHWZHHQ DQGWKHPLGV 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW LQFRUUHFWO\ UHOLHG RQ WKLV FRXUWjV XQSXEOLVKHGRSLQLRQLQ)OHPLQJY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS $OWKRXJK WKH H[DFW GDWH LV QRW FOHDU IURP )RQVHFDjV 1R   :/  WK &LU 1RY   GHSRVLWLRQ WHVWLPRQ\ KH GHYHORSHG SHUVLVWHQW SDLQ LQ KLV XQSXEOLVKHGWDEOHGHFLVLRQLQJUDQWLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW KDQGVVRPHWLPHEHWZHHQDQG8QOLNHEHIRUHWKH $VDQLQLWLDOPDWWHUWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWPLVWDNHQO\UXOHGWKDW SDLQZRXOGQRWJRDZD\WKHQH[WGD\7KHHDUOLHVWLQGLFDWLRQ m>W@KRXJKXQUHSRUWHG,FRQFOXGHWKDWWKHFRXUWjVRSLQLRQLQ LQWKHUHFRUGRIDQ\DZDUHQHVVE\)RQVHFDRIWKLVLQWHQVLILHG )OHPLQJLVFRQWUROOLQJDQGUHTXLUHVWKDWVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW SDLQ ZDV D PHGLFDO UHFRUG IURP 0DUFK RI  ZKHQ KLV EH JUDQWHG LQ WKH GHIHQGDQWjV IDYRUl  )RQVHFD Y GRFWRUZURWHmULJKWKDQGGLVFRPIRUWVHFRQGDQGWKLUGGLJLWV &RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS1R:/DW GLG QRW UHFDOO KLVWRU\ RI KDQG WUDXPDl  )RQVHFD FDQQRW

 1' 2KLR sDQ    &RQWUDU\ WR WKLV DVVHUWLRQ UHPHPEHUVD\LQJDQ\WKLQJWRKLVGRFWRUDERXWWKHVHSDLQVEXW XQSXEOLVKHGRSLQLRQVDUHQHYHUFRQWUROOLQJDXWKRULW\6HHWK GRHVQRWGLVSXWHWKDWKHSUREDEO\SURYLGHGWKHLQIRUPDWLRQ &LU5J6DODPDOHNLVY&RPPLVVLRQHURI6RF6HF XSRQ ZKLFK WKH QRWDWLRQ LV EDVHG  'U 6SLQHOOL )RQVHFDjV )GWK&LU GRFWRUGLGQRWRIIHUDGLDJQRVLVRUWUHDWWKHSDLQ 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWDOVRHUUHGLQFRQFOXGLQJWKDWm>W@KHIDFWV ,Q 0DUFK RI  )RQVHFD XQGHUZHQW TXLQWXSOH E\SDVV LQ)OHPLQJDUHLQGLVWLQJXLVKDEOHIURPWKHIDFWVLQWKLVFDVHl VXUJHU\ IRUFLQJ KLP WR UHWLUH IURP WKH UDLOURDG  'XULQJ D ,QVWHDG)OHPLQJLVPRUHOLNH&DPSEHOOWKDQLWLVOLNHWKHFDVH FRQYHUVDWLRQZLWKDQDFTXDLQWDQFHODWHUWKDW\HDUWKHVXEMHFW DW EDU  7KH SODLQWLII LQ )OHPLQJ OLNH )RQVHFD VRXJKW RI)RQVHFDj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m46RWKHZRUN\RXZHUHSHUIRUPLQJEDFNLQWKH 2Q0DUFK)RQVHFDILOHGVXLWDJDLQVW&RQUDLOLQ µV ZDV FDXVLQJ \RX WR KDYH WKH V\PSWRPV WKDW \RX DUH WKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUWIRUWKH1RUWKHUQ'LVWULFWRI WHOOLQJPHDERXWLQ\RXUKDQGVWKHQXPEQHVVDQGSLQV"$ 2KLR+LVFDXVHRIDFWLRQVRXJKWGDPDJHVXQGHUWKH)(/$DV

VXSSRUWRIWKHPRWLRQZDVWKHGHSRVLWLRQRI)RQVHFDWDNHQE\ m>7@KHLQTXLU\LVZKHWKHUWKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWVD &RQUDLO)RQVHFDSURGXFHGQRHYLGHQFHLQRSSRVLWLRQWRWKH VXIILFLHQW GLVDJUHHPHQW WR UHTXLUH VXEPLVVLRQ WR D MXU\ RU PRWLRQEXWLQVWHDGUHOLHGRQWKHVDPHGHSRVLWLRQWHVWLPRQ\ ZKHWKHULWLVVRRQHVLGHGWKDWRQHSDUW\PXVW SUHYDLODVD 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWJUDQWHGWKHPRWLRQRQsDQXDU\,Q PDWWHURIODZl WKLV DSSHDO )RQVHFD DUJXHV WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW HUUHG LQ JUDQWLQJVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWDJDLQVWKLPRQKLV)(/$FODLP %RWKSDUWLHVDUJXHLQWKHLUEULHIVDERXWZKRVHEXUGHQLWZDV WRSURIIHUUHOHYDQWPHGLFDOHYLGHQFHVXSSRUWLQJRUGLVSXWLQJ ,,$1$/<6,6 WKH VHSDUDWHQHVV RI )RQVHFDjV GDLO\ GLVFRPIRUWV DQG ODWHU FRQWLQXRXVSDLQ$OWKRXJKVXFKHYLGHQFHZRXOGKDYHEHHQ $ 6WDQGDUGRIUHYLHZ KHOSIXOLWZDVQRWUHTXLUHGDVDPDWWHURIODZ$SDUW\ZKR PRYHV IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW mEHDUV WKH LQLWLDO EXUGHQ RI :HUHYLHZGHQRYRWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVJUDQWRIVXPPDU\ VKRZLQJ WKH DEVHQFH RI D JHQXLQH LVVXH RI PDWHULDO IDFWl MXGJPHQW6HHHJ+ROORZD\Y%UXVK)G sRKQVRQY8QLWHG6WDWHV3RVWDO6HUY)GWK WK&LU6XPPDU\MXGJPHQWLVSURSHUZKHQWKHUHDUH &LU)XUWKHUPRUH&RQUDLOKDVWKHEXUGHQRISURRIRQ QRJHQXLQHLVVXHVRIPDWHULDOIDFWLQGLVSXWHDQGWKHPRYLQJ DOODIILUPDWLYHGHIHQVHVVXFKDVWKHVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQV6HH SDUW\LVHQWLWOHGWRMXGJPHQWDVDPDWWHURIODZ)HG5&LY &DPSEHOOY*UDQG7UXQN:55&R)G 3 F,QGHFLGLQJDPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWWKH WK&LUVHHDOVR$QGHUVRQY/LEHUW\/REE\,QF FRXUW PXVW YLHZ WKH HYLGHQFH DQG GUDZ DOO UHDVRQDEOH 86m>7@KHLQTXLU\LQYROYHGLQDUXOLQJRQ LQIHUHQFHVLQIDYRURIWKHQRQPRYLQJSDUW\6HH0DWVXVKLWD D PRWLRQ IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW RU IRU D GLUHFWHG YHUGLFW (OHF,QGXV&RY=HQLWK5DGLR&RUS86 QHFHVVDULO\LPSOLFDWHVWKHVXEVWDQWLYHHYLGHQWLDU\VWDQGDUGRI   7KH MXGJH LV QRW WR mZHLJK WKH HYLGHQFH DQG SURRIWKDWZRXOGDSSO\DWWKHWULDORQWKHPHULWVl7KXVLI GHWHUPLQHWKHWUXWKRIWKHPDWWHUEXWWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHU &RQUDLOIDLOHGWRPHHWLWVEXUGHQRISURRI)RQVHFDKDGQR WKHUHLVDJHQXLQHLVVXHIRUWULDOl$QGHUVRQY/LEHUW\/REE\ REOLJDWLRQWRSURIIHUDQ\DGGLWLRQDOHYLGHQFHLQRUGHUWRUHEXW ,QF  86     $ JHQXLQH LVVXH IRU WULDO WKHVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQVGHIHQVH H[LVWVRQO\ZKHQWKHUHLVVXIILFLHQWmHYLGHQFHRQZKLFKWKH MXU\FRXOGUHDVRQDEO\ILQGIRUWKHSODLQWLIIl,GDW &RQUDLOjVHYLGHQFHFRQVLVWHGVROHO\RI)RQVHFDjVGHSRVLWLRQ WHVWLPRQ\)RQVHFDjVWHVWLPRQ\KRZHYHUVXJJHVWVWKDWWKH % 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWHUUHGLQJUDQWLQJ&RQUDLOjVPRWLRQ WZRLQMXULHVDUHGLVWLQFW+HZDVXQHTXLYRFDOLQKLVWHVWLPRQ\ IRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWEDVHGRQWKH)(/$VWDWXWHRI WKDW WKH IUHTXHQW GLVFRPIRUW WKDW KH H[SHULHQFHG IRU WKUHH OLPLWDWLRQV GHFDGHVZDVQRWFRQWLQXRXVDQGZRXOGDOZD\VVXEVLGHE\WKH IROORZLQJ PRUQLQJ  )RQVHFD ZDV DVNHG LI WKH SDLQ DQG 7KH )(/$ SURYLGHV D IHGHUDO FDXVH RI DFWLRQ DJDLQVW D GLVFRPIRUWHYHULQFUHDVHGDWDQ\SRLQWSULRUWRRU UDLOURDGE\DQ\HPSOR\HHLQMXUHGRUNLOOHGDVDUHVXOWRIWKH +LV UHVSRQVH ZDV m>Q@R LW ZDV WKH VDPHl  )RQVHFD DOVR UDLOURDGjV QHJOLJHQFH  6HH  86& †   $OWKRXJK WKH WHVWLILHGWRWKHIROORZLQJm>:@KHQ,ZRUNHGDORW,IHHOP\ )(/$ SURYLGHV D UHPHG\ WKDW SDUDOOHOV FRPPRQ ODZ KDQGVKXUWEXWWKHQH[WGD\LWZDV JRQH %XWDURXQGWKDW QHJOLJHQFHFDVHVWKHVWDWXWHKDVEHHQmOLEHUDOO\FRQVWUXHG WLPHDERXWZKHQZDVWKDW,VWDUWHG":KHQ,JRWWRIHHOP\ WR IXUWKHU &RQJUHVVj UHPHGLDO JRDOl RI KROGLQJ UDLOURDGV KDQGVKXUWLQJLWZDVDERXWWKUHH\HDUVDJRRUWZR\HDUVDJRl UHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKHSK\VLFDOGDQJHUVWRZKLFKWKHLUHPSOR\HHV DUHH[SRVHG6HH&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUSY*RWWVKDOO 7KHVHVWDWHPHQWVVXJJHVWWKDWWKHIUHTXHQWGLVFRPIRUWWKDW 86    FLWLQJ SUHYLRXV )(/$ FDVHV WKDW )RQVHFDH[SHULHQFHGDVDODERUHUDUHDGLVWLQFWLQMXU\IURPWKH UHOD[HG WKH VWDQGDUG RI FDXVDWLRQ UHTXLUHG H[SDQGHG WKH  )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 1R 1R )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 

7XUQLQJWRWKHIDFWVLQWKHSUHVHQWFDVHZHFRQFOXGHWKDW GRFWULQH RI QHJOLJHQFH SHU VH EH\RQG WKDW FRYHUHG E\ WKH )RQVHFDjVFDXVHRIDFWLRQDFFUXHGXSRQWKHODWHURIWZRNH\ FRPPRQ ODZ UXOH DQG SHUPLWWHG UHFRYHU\ IRU ODWHQW WLPHSRLQWV2QHWLPHSRLQWZDVZKHQWKHDFFXPXODWHGLQMXU\ RFFXSDWLRQDOGLVHDVHV IURPKLVGDLO\ODERUVEHFDPHRUVKRXOGKDYHEHFRPHDSSDUHQW WR)RQVHFD)RU)RQVHFDjVFODLPWRVXUYLYHWKH)(/$VWDWXWH 'HVSLWH LWV mKXPDQLWDULDQ SXUSRVHVl &RQJUHVV SODFHG RI OLPLWDWLRQV KH PXVW HVWDEOLVK WKDW WKH IUHTXHQW EXW FHUWDLQ OLPLWDWLRQV RQ UHFRYHU\ XQGHU WKH )(/$  6HH WHPSRUDU\SDLQKHH[SHULHQFHGIRU\HDUVZDVGLVWLQFWIURP *RWWVKDOO  86 DW  m7KDW )(/$ LV WR EH OLEHUDOO\ WKHFXPXODWLYHLQMXU\WKDWUHVXOWHGLQFRQWLQXRXVGLVFRPIRUW FRQVWUXHG KRZHYHU GRHV QRW PHDQ WKDW LW LV D ZRUNHUVj WKHUHDIWHU  6HH $SDULFLR  )G DW  DIILUPLQJ WKH FRPSHQVDWLRQVWDWXWHl2QHVXFKUHVWULFWLRQRQOLDELOLW\LVLWV FRQFOXVLRQRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWWKDWDPDWHULDOIDFWXDOLVVXH WKUHH\HDU VWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQV6HH86&†m1R H[LVWHGDVWRZKHWKHUWKHKDQGGLVFRPIRUWWKDWILUVWPDQLIHVWHG DFWLRQ VKDOO EH PDLQWDLQHG XQGHU WKLV FKDSWHU XQOHVV LWVHOILQZDVmVHSDUDWHIURPKLVLQMXU\l7KHRWKHU FRPPHQFHG ZLWKLQ WKUHH \HDUV IURP WKH GD\ WKH FDXVH RI WLPHSRLQWZDVWKHPRPHQWZKHQ)RQVHFDm>NQHZ@RULQWKH DFWLRQDFFUXHGl H[HUFLVHRIUHDVRQDEOHGLOLJHQFHVKRXOGKDYHNQRZQ>RI WKHLQMXU\jV@JRYHUQLQJFDXVHl)ULHV)GDW,Q $OWKRXJKmDFFUXDOlRIDFDXVHRIDFWLRQIRUWKHSXUSRVHVRI VXP)RQVHFDjVFDXVHRIDFWLRQDFFUXHGXQGHUWKHGLVFRYHU\ DVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQVJHQHUDOO\WDNHVSODFHmZKHQWKHUHKDV UXOH ZKHQ KH ILUVW NQHZ RU LQ WKH H[HUFLVH RI UHDVRQDEOH EHHQDYLRODWLRQRIOHJDOO\SURWHFWHGLQWHUHVWVlRUmZKHQWKH GLOLJHQFHVKRXOGKDYHNQRZQRIERWKWKHLQMXU\DQGLWVFDXVH WRUWLRXVHYHQWLVFRPPLWWHGlVRPHLQMXULHVDQGFDXVHVDUHVR 6HH+LFNV)GDWVWDWLQJWKDWWKHGLVFRYHU\UXOH ODWHQWDVWRHOXGHGLVFRYHU\DWWKHWLPHRIWKHLQMXU\FDXVLQJ FRPPHQFHVWKHOLPLWDWLRQVSHULRGRQmWKHGDWHE\ZKLFKWKH HYHQW6HH+LFNVY+LQHV,QF)GWK&LU SODLQWLIIUHDVRQDEO\VKRXOGKDYHGLVFRYHUHGERWKFDXVHDQG FLWLQJWKH5HVWDWHPHQW6HFRQGRI7RUWV†FPWV LQMXU\l F H 7KXVLQRUGHUWRGHWHUPLQHZKHQDQLQMXU\ DFFUXHVXQGHUWKH)(/$jVVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQVRQHRIWZR $SSO\LQJWKHVHUXOHVWR)RQVHFDjVFDXVHRIDFWLRQZHPXVW UXOHVDSSOLHVWKHWLPHRIHYHQWUXOHRUWKHGLVFRYHU\UXOH,G GHFLGHLIDJHQXLQHLVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFWH[LVWVDVWRZKHWKHU WKHV\PSWRPVWKDW)RQVHFDFRPSODLQHGRIZLWKLQ\HDUVRI 8QGHU WKH WLPHRIHYHQW UXOH D FDXVH RI DFWLRQ LV KLV ODZVXLW LV D VHSDUDWH LQMXU\ IURP WKH V\PSWRPV WKDW KH FRQVLGHUHGWRKDYHDFFUXHGWKHPRPHQWDWRUWLRXVDFWRFFXUV H[SHULHQFHGIRUWKHSUHFHGLQJ\HDUV,IDV&RQUDLODUJXHV m>L@IJUHDWHUWKDQGHPLQLPXVKDUPLVGLVFHUQDEOHDWWKHWLPH WKHFRQWLQXRXVSDLQ)RQVHFDH[SHULHQFHGEHJLQQLQJLQ RIWKHWRUWLRXVHYHQWl,G7KHWLPHRIHYHQWUXOHDSSOLHVWR RUZDVVLPSO\DQDJJUDYDWLRQRIWKHSULRUGHFDGHVRI VLWXDWLRQVLQZKLFKDWUDXPDWLFHYHQWRFFXUVUHVXOWLQJLQD WHPSRUDU\ GLVFRPIRUW WKHQ )RQVHFDjV FODLP LV WLPHEDUUHG QRWLFHDEOHLQMXU\HYHQLIWKHIXOOPDQLIHVWDWLRQRIWKHKDUP XQGHU $SDULFLR DQG &DPSEHOO  2Q WKH RWKHU KDQG LI WKH UHPDLQVODWHQW6HHHJ$OEHUWVRQY7s6WHYHQVRQ &R FRQWLQXRXV SDLQ DQG QXPEQHVV WKDW GHYHORSHG LQ WKH PLG )GWK&LUDSSO\LQJWKHWLPHRIHYHQW VLVDGLVWLQFWLQMXU\IURPWKHQRUPDOGLVFRPIRUWVRID DFFUXDO UXOH WR D SODLQWLII ZKR ZDV H[SRVHG WR FDXVWLF GD\jVZRUNDVDUJXHGE\)RQVHFDWKHQKLVFDXVHRIDFWLRQ FKHPLFDOVWKDWLQLWLDOO\FDXVHGKLPWRORVHFRQVFLRXVQHVVDQG PD\VXUYLYHWKHVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQVGHIHQVH:HQHHGQRW XQGHUJR PHGLFDO WUHDWPHQW EXW GLG QRW UHVXOW LQ VHYHUH GHFLGHZKLFKFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIWKHLQMXU\LVDFFXUDWHUDWKHU SV\FKRORJLFDODQGSK\VLFDOGLVRUGHUVXQWLODGHFDGHODWHU ZHPXVWVLPSO\GHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKHHYLGHQFHLVVXIILFLHQW IRU D UHDVRQDEOH MXURU WR ILQG LQ IDYRU RI )RQVHFD  6HH ,QFRQWUDVWWRWKHWLPHRIHYHQWUXOHWKHGLVFRYHU\UXOHLV $QGHUVRQY/LEHUW\/REE\,QF86 DSSOLHGZKHQQRVLJQLILFDQWLQMXU\LVGLVFHUQDEOHDWWKHWLPH RI WKH WRUWLRXV HYHQW RU LI WKH FDXVH RI DQ LQMXU\ LV QRW  )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 1R 1R )RQVHFDY&RQVROLGDWHG5DLO&RUS 

DSSDUHQW6HH+LFNV)GDW8QGHUWKHGLVFRYHU\ FDXVHGKLV&767KHGLVWULFWFRXUWJUDQWHGWKHUDLOURDGSDUWLDO UXOHDFDXVHRIDFWLRQLVGHHPHGWRKDYHDFFUXHGZKHQmWKH VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRQ$SDULFLRjVFODLPIRUWKHLQMXU\WRKLV SODLQWLIIUHDVRQDEO\VKRXOGKDYHGLVFRYHUHGERWKFDXVHDQG ULJKWKDQGWKDWZDVLQLWLDOO\GLVFRYHUHGDQGWUHDWHGLQ LQMXU\l  ,G  $ SURWRW\SLFDO GLVFRYHU\UXOH FDVH LV RQH LQ ,GDW6XPPDU\MXGJPHQWZDVGHQLHGKRZHYHURQWKH ZKLFKDQRFFXSDWLRQDOGLVHDVHUHPDLQVGRUPDQWORQJDIWHUD UHPDLQLQJ FODLP DQG m>W@KH FDVH SURFHHGHG WR WULDO RQ WKH SODLQWLIILVH[SRVHGWRWKHFDXVHVRIWKHLQMXU\6HH$OEHUWVRQ WKHRU\WKDW$SDULFLRFRXOGUHFRYHULIWKHMXU\IRXQGWKDWKLV )GDW LQMXULHVZHUHVHSDUDWHIURPKLVLQMXU\WRKLVULJKW KDQGl,G 7KH 6XSUHPH &RXUW ILUVW DSSOLHG WKH GLVFRYHU\ UXOH WR D )(/$FDVHLQ8ULHY7KRPSVRQ86ZKHUH 7KLV FRXUW DIILUPHG WKH GLVPLVVDO RI $SDULFLRjV FDXVH RI DUDLOURDGHPSOR\HHFRQWUDFWHGVLOLFRVLV\HDUVDIWHUH[SRVXUH DFWLRQUHJDUGLQJWKHLQMXU\RQWKHEDVLVWKDWLWZDVWLPH WRWKHVLOLFDGXVWWKDWFDXVHGWKHSXOPRQDU\GLVHDVH%HFDXVH EDUUHG,GDW7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGHQLDORIVXPPDU\ WKHSODLQWLIIZDVQRWDZDUHRIWKHGDPDJHEHLQJFDXVHGDVD MXGJPHQWDVWRWKHLQMXULHVZDVDOVRDIILUPHGKRZHYHU UHVXOWRIWKHSURORQJHGH[SRVXUHWRWKHGXVWWKH&RXUWDSSOLHG mEHFDXVH $SDULFLR FUHDWHG D GLVSXWHG LVVXH RI IDFW DV WR WKHGLVFRYHU\UXOHLQRUGHUWRGHWHUPLQHZKHQWKHFDXVHRI ZKHWKHU KLV  LQMXULHV ZHUH D VHSDUDWH LQMXU\ RU D DFWLRQDFFUXHGIRUWKHSXUSRVHVRIWKHWKUHH\HDUVWDWXWHRI FRQWLQXDWLRQRIKLVLQMXU\l,GDW$FFRUGLQJWR OLPLWDWLRQV6HH8ULH86DW7KH&RXUWUXOHG $SDULFLRLIWKHLQMXU\KDGVLPSO\EHHQDQDJJUDYDWLRQ WKDW IRU VXFK ODWHQW RFFXSDWLRQDO GLVHDVHV mWKH DIIOLFWHG RIWKHKDQGGLVFRPIRUWWKHFODLPZRXOGKDYHEHHQWLPH HPSOR\HH FDQ EH KHOG WR EH LQMXUHG RQO\ ZKHQ WKH EDUUHGXQGHU86&†,GFLWLQJ)ULHVY&KLFDJR DFFXPXODWHG HIIHFWV RI WKH GHOHWHULRXV VXEVWDQFH PDQLIHVW 1RUWKZHVWHUQ7UDQVS&R)GWK&LU  WKHPVHOYHVl,GDW)XUWKHUPRUHWKH&RXUWUHIXVHGWR ,Q FRQWUDVW m>L@I $SDULFLRjV >@ LQMXULHV DUH D VHSDUDWH FKDUDFWHUL]HHDFKLQKDODWLRQRIWKHVLOLFDGXVWDVDVHSDUDWH LQMXU\WKHQ$SDULFLRjVFODLPLVQRWWLPHEDUUHGl,G LQMXU\,G5DWKHUWKHLQMXU\DWLVVXHZDVQRWHDFKEUHDWKRI VLOLFD GXVW EXW WKH mDFFXPXODWHG HIIHFWl RI DOO WKRVH GXVW 7KLV FRXUWjV UHFHQW RSLQLRQ LQ DQRWKHU )(/$&76 FDVH ILOOHGLQKDODWLRQV,G &DPSEHOOY*UDQG7UXQN:55&R)GWK&LU IXUWKHULOOXVWUDWHV$SDULFLRjVGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQWKH 7KLV FRXUW KDV SUHYLRXVO\ DSSOLHG WKH GLVFRYHU\ UXOH DV DJJUDYDWLRQRIDWLPHEDUUHGLQMXU\DQGDFODLPWKDWLVGLVWLQFW GHVFULEHGLQ8ULHWRDFDXVHRIDFWLRQVLPLODUWR)RQVHFDjV IURPSUHYLRXVLQMXULHV7KHSODLQWLIILQ&DPSEHOODUDLOFDU 6HH$SDULFLRY1RUIRON :5\&R)GWK&LU UHSDLU ZRUNHU EHJDQ WR H[SHULHQFH SDLQ WLQJOLQJ DQG  DEURJDWHG RQ RWKHU JURXQGV 5HHYHV Y 6DQGHUVRQ QXPEQHVVLQKLVKDQGVGXULQJWKHWLPHIUDPHWKDW 3OXPELQJ3URGV,QF86,Q$SDULFLRD ZDVVRVHYHUHDVWRDZDNHQKLPIURPKLVVOHHS3ULRUWRWKHVH UDLOURDGWUDFN PDLQWHQDQFH ODERUHU GHYHORSHG SHUVLVWHQW HSLVRGHV&DPSEHOOKDGQRWH[SHULHQFHGDQ\SDLQLQKLV GLVFRPIRUWLQKLVULJKWKDQGLQHOHYHQ\HDUVDIWHUWKH \HDUV DV D UDLOURDG HPSOR\HH  ,G DW   &DPSEHOO EHJLQQLQJRIKLVZRUNIRUWKHUDLOURDG$IWHUmFRQVHUYDWLYH QHYHUWKHOHVVZDLWHGXQWLOWRVHHDSK\VLFLDQZKHQWKH WUHDWPHQW    WKH V\PSWRPV UHVROYHG WKHPVHOYHVl DQG SDLQ LQ KLV KDQGV KDG ZRUVHQHG  $SSO\LQJ WKH UXOH LQ $SDULFLR ZHQW EDFN WR ZRUN DIWHU D PRQWK DQG D KDOI $SDULFLRWKLVFRXUWKHOGWKDW&DPSEHOOjV)(/$FODLPZDV $SDULFLR)GDW1HYHUWKHOHVVILYH\HDUVODWHULQ WLPHEDUUHG EHFDXVH QR UHDVRQDEOH MXU\ FRXOG ILQG WKDW WKH  $SDULFLR GHYHORSHG SDLQ LQ KLV KDQGV DQG ZDV LQMXU\LQTXHVWLRQZDVRWKHUWKDQDQDJJUDYDWLRQRIWKHVDPH GLDJQRVHGZLWK&76$SDULFLRVXHGWKHUDLOURDGXQGHUWKH LQMXU\WKDWKDGGHYHORSHGSULRUWRWKHIDOORIRXWVLGHRI )(/$WKHQH[W\HDUDOOHJLQJWKDWWKHUDLOURDGjVQHJOLJHQFH WKHOLPLWDWLRQVSHULRG