Fischer's Pool Swimming Club v. Towamencin Township

87 Pa. D. & C. 157, 1953 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 205
CourtPennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Montgomery County
DecidedAugust 7, 1953
Docketno. 18
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 87 Pa. D. & C. 157 (Fischer's Pool Swimming Club v. Towamencin Township) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Montgomery County primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Fischer's Pool Swimming Club v. Towamencin Township, 87 Pa. D. & C. 157, 1953 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 205 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1953).

Opinion

Knight, P. J.,

This is a bill, answer, and final hearing.

Questions Involved

1. Does the tax resolution apply to Fischer’s Pool if the major portion of the land area comprising the pool and other recreational facilities is not located in Towamencin Township?

2. Does the tax imposed by the taxing resolution exceed the limit óf 10 percent -fixed by the enabling act?

[158]*1583. Does the term, “amusement”, as set forth in the tax resolution apply to the dues of members of the Fischer’s Pool Swimming Association?

4. Does the term, “amusement”, include a swimming pool or swimming club within the meaning of the enabling Act of June 25,1947, P. L. 1145, as amended, 53 PS §2015.1 et seq.

Findings of Fact

1. Plaintiff is Fischer’s Pool Swimming Club, an unincorporated association located at Fischer’s Pool in Towamencin Township near Lansdale, Pa., and brings this action through its officers as trustees ad litem. Frank Lopp, plaintiff herein, brings this action as an individual taxpayer affected by the tax resolution adopted by the Township of Towamencin.

2. Defendants are W. F. Whitman, Wilson F. Allebach, Warren Alderfer, Leidy S. Kriebel, and John L. Kulp, school directors of Towamencin Township and the School District of Towamencin Township.

3. On June 4, 1952, defendants, acting as the directors of Towamencin Township and the School District of Towamencin Township, adopted Tax Resolution No. 2, effective July 5, 1952, under the authority of the Act of June 25,1947, P. L. 1145, as amended, 53 PS §2015.1 et seq., whereby defendants levied a tax on admissions to places of amusement at the rate of 1 cent on each 10 cents, or fraction thereof, of the admission price by such place of amusement.

4. Plaintiffs were notified by the solicitor of the School District of Towamencin Township that it intended to assess a tax of 1 cent on each 10 cents or fraction thereof under the provisions of resolution no. 2, and a tax on annual membership dues paid by members of Fischer’s Pool Swimming Club.

5. Fischer’s Pool was operated for 17 years as a public swimming pool for the use of which an admission was charged. In 1950 the owner of Fischer’s Pool, Eric Arneth, leased the pool and all facilities, except [159]*159the refreshment stand, to an unincorporated association named the Fischer’s Pool Swimming Club for a rental of $20,000 per annum. The club was formed for the purpose of encouraging and fostering swimming and also as a device better to control admissions to the pool.

6. The lessor, E. A. Arneth, is the manager for the club in the operation of the pool and is the one who conducts the business of the pool. He hires and discharges all employes and pays all salaries and other expenses of operating the pool from the rental he receives, except one half the salary of the cashier.

7. Under the bylaws of the Fischer’s Pool Swimming Club, hereafter called the club, there are four classes of members as follows: (1) Resident members composed of those who rent cottages owned by the lessor on land contiguous to the pool. In 1952 the number of resident members was 20 and they each paid $10 per annum and have unlimited use of the pool; (2) senior members made up of persons who have passed their twelfth birthday. In 1952 the number of senior members was 572 and each paid $10 per annum. The senior members have unlimited use of the pool. (3) Junior members are persons under 12 years of age. In 1952 there were 357 junior members who each paid $7.50 per annum. (4) Active members are persons who paid an initiation fee of 50 cents and 50 cents each time they used the pool. In 1952 there were 10,659 active members who paid $2,664.75 in initiation fees or dues. ■

8. In 1952 the total receipts of the club were about $27,000, of which amount the daily admission fees of active members amounted to between $10,000 and $12,000.

9. The facilities of the club are used occasionally by organizations who hold outings there. These organizations pay for the privilege and the money goes into the treasury of the club.

10. The youth program of the Lansdale Recreation [160]*160Center uses the club facilities on various days during the week from 10:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. for the purpose of teaching the children of the area to swim. However, these children do not become active members of the pool but pay a special rate of 35 cents for the privilege of swimming at the pool.

11. In connection with the pool, the club maintains facilities for other sports such as basketball, volley ball, ping pong, shuffleboard, etc. No extra charge is made for the use of these facilities.

12. About two thirds of the land area comprising the Fischer’s Pool project is in Worcester Township; the balance is in Towamencin Township. The swimming pool, the pavilion, the lockers, and some of the other facilities are in Towamencin, the wading pool for little children and most of the other facilities are inWorcester.

13. The active members who pay 50 cents dues per year, plus an individual rate of 32 cents, would be compelled to pay four cents tax under resolution no. 2 of the School District of Towamencin Township, which would be the equivalent of 11.9 percent. The Towamencin tax of 1 cent on every 10 cents or fraction thereof was also to be taxed upon the five-cent Federal tax. All persons over the age of 12 who are active members pay the sum of 42 cents admission, or the sum of five cents to the School District of Towamencin Township which exceds the 10 percent provided by the enabling act. A spectator who comes to the pool purely to watch the swimming pays an admission fee of 85 cents, six cents of which is paid to the Federal Government, and four cents payable to the School District of Township of Towamencin. The annual members being the resident members, the senior members and the junior members would pay the sum of 1 cent on every 10 cents of their annual dues.

14. The Fischer’s Pool Swimming Club is a bona fide organization. It has duly elected officers and in 1952 [161]*161had 11,609 members, all of which were given notice of the annual meeting in 1952 but only 15 attended the meeting. To become a member of the club a written application must be signed by the applicant which must be approved by a member of the membership committee or someone delegated for that purpose. The club has no employes but pays its secretary $100 per annum and it also pays one half the salary of a cashier who is a member of the membership committee and passes on many applications for active membership.

15. The Towamencin Township Amusement Tax Resolution No. 2 contains, inter alia, the following-relevant provisions:

“Providing for the levy and collection of a tax for general school district purposes on admissions to or for engaging in amusements at places of amusement, the major portion of which is located within the school district of the township of Towamencin; requiring all persons conducting places of amusement to secure permits ; prescribing the method and manner of collecting the tax imposed by this resolution; and providing certain exemptions and imposing certain penalties.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
87 Pa. D. & C. 157, 1953 Pa. Dist. & Cnty. Dec. LEXIS 205, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/fischers-pool-swimming-club-v-towamencin-township-pactcomplmontgo-1953.