First National Bank of Lafayette v. Gaddis

250 So. 2d 504
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJuly 13, 1971
Docket3510
StatusPublished
Cited by16 cases

This text of 250 So. 2d 504 (First National Bank of Lafayette v. Gaddis) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
First National Bank of Lafayette v. Gaddis, 250 So. 2d 504 (La. Ct. App. 1971).

Opinion

250 So.2d 504 (1971)

The FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF LAFAYETTE, Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
Irene Hines GADDIS, Defendant-Appellee,
Wilmer C. Goss, Jr., and WCG Investment Corporation, Intervenors-Appellants.

No. 3510.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

July 13, 1971.

*506 Robert Dragon, Jr., of Dragon & Kellner, Lafayette, for defendant-appellants.

Bean & Rush, by Warren D. Rush, Lafayette, for plaintiff-appellee.

Before FRUGÉ, SAVOY and HOOD, JJ.

HOOD, Judge.

The First National Bank of Lafayette instituted this action against Irene Hines Gaddis to foreclose by executory process on a real estate mortgage executed by defendant. Wilmer C. Goss, Jr., filed an intervention seeking to enjoin the sale of the property on several grounds, and upon his demand a temporary restraining order was issued by the trial court prohibiting the sale. WCG Investment Corporation was later substituted for Wilmer C. Goss, Jr., as intervenor.

Plaintiff, First National Bank, then filed an exception of no right or cause of action to the petition of intervention and a motion to set aside the temporary restraining order. In its motion to set aside the restraining order, plaintiff also demanded judgment for damages, costs and attorney's fees for the wrongful issuance of that order.

After trial, judgment was rendered by the trial court: (1) Dissolving the temporary restraining order; (2) condemning Goss to pay plaintiff $200.00 as attorney's fees for the wrongful issuance of that order; (3) sustaining the exception of no right or cause of action filed by the bank against intervenor Goss; (4) rejecting the demands of WCG Investment Corporation for a preliminary injunction; and (5) condemning intervenor Goss to reimburse plaintiff the costs incurred by it in preparing documents which intervenor had requested by means of a subpoena duces tecum. Wilmer C. Goss, Jr., and WCG Investment Corporation have appealed.

Appellants contend that the trial court erred in the following particulars: (1) In failing to hold that intervenors could rely on the public records which indicated that the promissory note secured by the mortgage on which this foreclosure proceeding is based had prescribed; (2) in giving effect to a waiver of prescription which was signed by the maker of the mortgage note; (3) in failing to hold that plaintiff is barred from proceeding by executory process *507 because of the lack of authentic proof showing the relationship of the mortgage note to certain other notes made by defendant payable to the bank; (4) in holding that the mortgage note sued upon is the note described in the act of mortgage; and (5) in condemning intervenor Goss to pay court costs and attorney's fees.

On October 9, 1961, defendant Gaddis executed a promissory note for the principal sum of $2,000.00, made payable on demand to the order of "Myself," and endorsed in blank by the maker. This note was paraphed for identification with an act of mortgage executed by the maker on the same date, affecting the tract of land in Lafayette Parish which plaintiff seeks to have seized and sold by executory process. The note was used by the maker, Mrs. Gaddis, as collateral security for a loan which was made to her by the First National Bank at about the time the mortgage was executed.

When the above mentioned mortgage note was executed, Mrs. Gaddis owed the bank the principal sum of $3,250.00. Her actual indebtedness was evidenced by a "hand note" for that amount, made payable to the order of the bank. On the back of that hand note there appeared a statement to the effect that the maker, Mrs. Gaddis, had pledged certain assets to secure the payment of the note, and one of the assets so pledged was the above described $2,000.00 collateral mortgage note.

Payments were made periodically on Mrs. Gaddis' indebtedness to the bank, and from time to time renewal hand notes were executed by her for the amount of her remaining indebtedness to plaintiff. On the back of each such renewal hand note there appeared a statement, signed by Mrs. Gaddis, that the maker pledged the above mentioned $2,000.00 mortgage note, and other assets, to secure the payment of the indebtedness which was evidenced by the hand note. The bank has retained the $2,000.00 mortgage note in its possession continuously since it was first pledged as security for defendant's indebtedness, because Mrs. Gaddis has never fully paid or extinguished her debt to the bank, and the mortgage note has been pledged to secure her indebtedness continuously since it was executed in 1961. Mrs. Gaddis now owes the bank $1,749.31. Her debt to the bank has never been reduced to a figure less than that amount since the 1961 mortgage note was first pledged to plaintiff.

On March 3, 1965, Mrs. Gaddis sold all of the property described in the above mentioned mortgage to Wilmer C. Goss, Jr. The purchaser in that sale paid a part of the purchase price in cash, and to evidence his indebtedness for the balance due, Goss executed a promissory note made payable to the order of Mrs. Gaddis for $1500.00. That note was secured by a vendor's lien affecting the property which Goss had just acquired from defendant, that being the same property which Mrs. Gaddis previously had mortgaged in 1961 to secure the $2,000.00 collateral note.

On March 11, 1965, Mrs. Gaddis signed a statement on the back of the above mentioned $2,000.00 collateral mortgage note, by which statement she acknowledged and agreed to pay the indebtedness evidenced by that note, and she specifically waived prescription, without novation.

Wilmer C. Goss, Jr., sold the same property to WCG Investment Corporation by deed dated February 17, 1966. The evidence shows, however, that the vendee corporation was wholly owned by Wilmer C. Goss, Jr., and his wife, and that Goss is President of it. Goss testified that "I act as the corporation."

The last hand note which was executed by Mrs. Gaddis, made payable to the order of the bank, is for $2,378.82, and is dated November 3, 1968. By a statement appearing on the back of that note, Mrs. Gaddis specifically pledged as security for it three collateral notes, one of which is the $2,000.00 mortgage note which was executed by Mrs. Gaddis in 1961. Another note pledged to secure that hand note is the $1500.00 note *508 which was signed by W. C. Goss, Jr., on March 3, 1965, and secured by a vendor's lien of the same property.

Intervenor Goss eventually paid this $1500.00 note, and from that payment $629.51 went to the First National Bank and was applied as a credit on Mrs. Gaddis' indebtedness to that bank. That is the only payment of principal which has been applied on defendant's indebtedness to the bank since November 3, 1968, and after crediting it to the $2,378.82 hand note executed by Mrs. Gaddis on that date, it leaves a balance of $1,749.31 due by defendant, that being the amount claimed by plaintiff in this proceeding.

Intervenors concede that when Goss purchased the property from Mrs. Gaddis on March 3, 1965, and when he sold it to WCG Investment Corporation on February 17, 1966, the public records showed that the property was encumbered by the mortgage which defendant had executed in 1961. They point out, however, that the recorded mortgage showed that the note which it secured was a demand note which ordinarily would prescribe in five years after the date of the note, or on October 9, 1966.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Whitney National Bank v. Blueridge, Inc.
606 So. 2d 902 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1992)
FIRST FEDERAL SAV. & LOAN ASS'N v. Burrows
539 So. 2d 685 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Assoc. Financial Ser. of America v. Rogell
449 So. 2d 526 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1984)
Plumbing Supply House v. Century Nat. Bank
440 So. 2d 173 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1983)
Boudreaux v. Trapp
420 So. 2d 1012 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1982)
Terrebonne Bank & Trust Co. v. Smith
415 So. 2d 414 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1982)
Chrysler Credit Corp. v. Stout
404 So. 2d 304 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1981)
Gulf National Bank at Lake Charles v. Dupuis
402 So. 2d 789 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1981)
Liberty National Life Insurance v. Prine
385 So. 2d 416 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1980)
American SEC. Bank of Ville Platte v. Deville
368 So. 2d 167 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1979)
Houston v. McCoy
351 So. 2d 829 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1977)
May Co., Inc. v. Heirs of Sumage
347 So. 2d 916 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1977)
McLendon v. Brewster
286 So. 2d 513 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1974)
Louisiana National Bank of Baton Rouge v. Heroman
280 So. 2d 362 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1973)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
250 So. 2d 504, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/first-national-bank-of-lafayette-v-gaddis-lactapp-1971.