Finkel v. Texas-Edwards, Inc.

295 So. 2d 903
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedSeptember 18, 1974
Docket12309
StatusPublished
Cited by7 cases

This text of 295 So. 2d 903 (Finkel v. Texas-Edwards, Inc.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Finkel v. Texas-Edwards, Inc., 295 So. 2d 903 (La. Ct. App. 1974).

Opinion

295 So.2d 903 (1974)

Bernard A. FINKEL, Trustee, Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
TEXAS-EDWARDS, INC., Defendant-Appellant.

No. 12309.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

May 28, 1974.
Rehearing Denied July 1, 1974.
Writ Refused September 18, 1974.

*904 Lunn, Irion, Switzer, Johnson & Salley by Harry A. Johnson, Jr., Shreveport, for defendant-appellant.

Stagg, Cady & Beard by William M. Cady, III, Shreveport, for plaintiff-appellee.

Before AYRES, BOLIN and PRICE, JJ.

PRICE, Judge.

This is an action brought by the testamentary executor and trustee named in the will of Julia Levy, a New York domiciliary, seeking to recover damages under a contract of indemnity undertaken by defendant, Texas-Edwards, Inc., in favor of the decedent.

Defendant by exceptions of no right and cause of action contests the right or capacity of plaintiff to prosecute the action, and, in answer, denies an enforceable obligation has accrued under the contract.

The trial court sustained the exception of no cause or right of action and on appeal this court reversed the decision and remanded the cause for trial on the merits. See opinion reported at 267 So.2d 766 (La.App.2nd Cir. 1972).

After trial on the merits the district court rendered judgment for plaintiff in the sum of $204,142.60. Defendant perfected this devolutive appeal and plaintiff has answered the appeal, requesting an increase in the sum awarded as damages.

The sequence of events giving rise to this matter are substantially as follows:

On July 6, 1956, Julia Levy, the owner of a two-thirds undivided interest in the *905 fee title to property on the northeast corner of Texas and Edwards Streets in Shreveport, joined with the owners of the remaining one-third interest in a lease to Henry C. Beck Company for a term ending on September 1, 2021, for an annual rent of $30,000. This lease was assigned by Beck to 522 Market Street, Inc., whose corporate name was subsequently changed to Texas-Edwards, Inc. On May 2, 1957, an agreement was executed wherein Julia Levy agreed to join in a mortgage with the lessee, hypothecating her undivided fee interest in this property to enable the lessee to procure the necessary financing to construct a multi-story office building. This agreement was modified on June 19, 1957, to increase the sum of the proposed mortgage to Travelers Insurance Company to the sum of $2,300,000. In connection with this transaction an indemnity agreement was executed on August 25, 1959, wherein defendant, Texas-Edwards, Inc., agreed to perform all of the terms and conditions of the mortgage to Travelers and to indemnify and save Julia Levy harmless for all loss, cost, damage or expense incurred by her by reason of any default by defendant under the mortgage. The proposed mortgage was duly consummated with Travelers Insurance Company for the increased amount and the building was constructed as intended.

Julia Levy died on October 19, 1964, and her will was probated in the State of New York, the place of her domicile. Plaintiff, Bernard A. Finkel, was named in the testament as executor and was made trustee of two trusts which by the terms of decedent's will were the recipient of the residue of her estate after payment of several cash legacies. In an ancillary proceeding in the district court for Caddo Parish, Finkel's capacity as executor and trustee under the New York proceeding was recognized and he was sent into possession as trustee of all of the decedent's property in this State after payment of appropriate inheritance taxes owed the State of Louisiana.

The rental payments under the lease with Texas-Edwards, Inc. falling due on August 1st of each year were duly paid unto plaintiff until 1970, at which time the lessee defaulted on his lease payments and also defaulted on the mortgage to Travelers. The property subject to the mortgage, including decedent's two-thirds fee interest and rights to lease rentals, was seized by the Sheriff of Caddo Parish under foreclosure proceedings instituted by the mortgagee on or about September 25, 1970, and subsequently sold at public sale.

Plaintiff seeks damages under the indemnification agreement from defendant for loss of the value of ownership rights in the property of $210,000, loss of past due rentals, $46,666.64, and attorney's fees and incidental expenses of $4,500.

The trial court found plaintiff entitled to the sum of $200,000 for general damages (value of loss of property right); and $4,142.60 for special damages, including attorney's fees.

The two issues presented for resolution on this appeal are the capacity or right of plaintiff to bring the action, and the correctness of the amount awarded as damages for breach of the indemnity agreement.

EXCEPTION OF NO RIGHT OF ACTION

Defendant's position that plaintiff has a lack of procedural capacity to maintain this action stems from the language of the August 25, 1959, indemnity agreement, which states in part:

"In consideration of the execution and delivery of Levy of a certain mortgage to The Travelers Insurance Company.... and in pursuance of the provisions of that certain agreement dated May 2, 1957, as amended by amendment dated June 19, 1959 .... Texas covenants and agrees, for the benefit of Levy, her heirs, executors, administrators, and assigns, as follows...." (Emphasis ours)

*906 Defendant contends the agreement does not specifically include a trustee as a beneficiary of the covenants imposed on it by the agreement and that plaintiff's power and authority as an executor terminated upon his being recognized and sent into whatever property decedent owned in this State by the judgment of possession rendered in the ancillary probate proceeding. Thus, under these circumstances, defendant contends plaintiff has no capacity to sue.

Defendant further contends should it be determined plaintiff continues to have authority to proceed as an executor, then in that event he should not be allowed to recover as no actual loss has been shown to have accrued to him in this capacity which is a condition precedent in an action under a contract of indemnity obligating the indemnitor to hold the indemnitee harmless from an actual loss as opposed to an agreement merely indemnifying against liability.

Further discussion of this argument of defendant is unnecessary because of our conclusion plaintiff has the capacity to proceed as trustee.

Defendant's opposition to plaintiff's capacity or authority to sue to enforce this contractual obligation hinges on the technical contention that the failure of the August 25, 1959 written contract to specifically enumerate a "trustee" as one of the contingent beneficiaries of the contract in the absence of the indemnitee, Levy, precludes an intention that the benefits of the contract inure to such a status.

We do not find the parties intended any such limitation when the August 25, 1959 instrument is construed together with the May 2, 1957 agreement from which it emanates. The former contract in which defendant obligated itself to execute a contract of indemnity to protect Levy provided she fulfilled her agreement to execute the proposed mortgage on her fee interest, contained the following provision:

"6. This agreement shall be binding upon and shall inure to the benefit of the parties hereto and their respective heirs, administrators, executors, successors and assigns." (emphasis supplied)

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
295 So. 2d 903, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/finkel-v-texas-edwards-inc-lactapp-1974.