Esther Hernandez and Prine Eco Group, Inc. v. Apache Corporation; Atmos Energy Corporation; BP Canada Energy Marketing Corporation; BP Energy Company; Centerpoint Energy Resources Corp.; Chesapeake Energy Marketing, LLC; Chevron USA, Inc.; CIMA Energy, L.P.; ConocoPhillips Company; DCP Midstream GP, L.L.C. DCP Midstream Marketing, L.L.C.; DCP Operating Company, L.P.; Devon Gas Services, L.P.; Enbridge (U.S.) Inc.; Energy Transfer. L.P.; Enlink Gas Marketing, L.P.; Enterprise Texas Pipeline, L.L.C.; EOG Resources, Inc.; ETC Texas Pipeline, Ltd.

Court of Appeals of Texas

Esther Hernandez and Prine Eco Group, Inc. v. Apache Corporation; Atmos Energy Corporation; BP Canada Energy Marketing Corporation; BP Energy Company; Centerpoint Energy Resources Corp.; Chesapeake Energy Marketing, LLC; Chevron USA, Inc.; CIMA Energy, L.P.; ConocoPhillips Company; DCP Midstream GP, L.L.C. DCP Midstream Marketing, L.L.C.; DCP Operating Company, L.P.; Devon Gas Services, L.P.; Enbridge (U.S.) Inc.; Energy Transfer. L.P.; Enlink Gas Marketing, L.P.; Enterprise Texas Pipeline, L.L.C.; EOG Resources, Inc.; ETC Texas Pipeline, Ltd.

DecidedFebruary 4, 2025

Docket01-24-00973-CV

StatusPublished

This text of Esther Hernandez and Prine Eco Group, Inc. v. Apache Corporation; Atmos Energy Corporation; BP Canada Energy Marketing Corporation; BP Energy Company; Centerpoint Energy Resources Corp.; Chesapeake Energy Marketing, LLC; Chevron USA, Inc.; CIMA Energy, L.P.; ConocoPhillips Company; DCP Midstream GP, L.L.C. DCP Midstream Marketing, L.L.C.; DCP Operating Company, L.P.; Devon Gas Services, L.P.; Enbridge (U.S.) Inc.; Energy Transfer. L.P.; Enlink Gas Marketing, L.P.; Enterprise Texas Pipeline, L.L.C.; EOG Resources, Inc.; ETC Texas Pipeline, Ltd. (Esther Hernandez and Prine Eco Group, Inc. v. Apache Corporation; Atmos Energy Corporation; BP Canada Energy Marketing Corporation; BP Energy Company; Centerpoint Energy Resources Corp.; Chesapeake Energy Marketing, LLC; Chevron USA, Inc.; CIMA Energy, L.P.; ConocoPhillips Company; DCP Midstream GP, L.L.C. DCP Midstream Marketing, L.L.C.; DCP Operating Company, L.P.; Devon Gas Services, L.P.; Enbridge (U.S.) Inc.; Energy Transfer. L.P.; Enlink Gas Marketing, L.P.; Enterprise Texas Pipeline, L.L.C.; EOG Resources, Inc.; ETC Texas Pipeline, Ltd.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Esther Hernandez and Prine Eco Group, Inc. v. Apache Corporation; Atmos Energy Corporation; BP Canada Energy Marketing Corporation; BP Energy Company; Centerpoint Energy Resources Corp.; Chesapeake Energy Marketing, LLC; Chevron USA, Inc.; CIMA Energy, L.P.; ConocoPhillips Company; DCP Midstream GP, L.L.C. DCP Midstream Marketing, L.L.C.; DCP Operating Company, L.P.; Devon Gas Services, L.P.; Enbridge (U.S.) Inc.; Energy Transfer. L.P.; Enlink Gas Marketing, L.P.; Enterprise Texas Pipeline, L.L.C.; EOG Resources, Inc.; ETC Texas Pipeline, Ltd., (Tex. Ct. App. 2025).

Pincite

Opinion

Opinion issued February 4, 2025

In The

Court of Appeals For The

First District of Texas ———————————— NO. 01-24-00973-CV ——————————— ESTHER HERNANDEZ AND PRIME ECO GROUP, INC., Appellants V. APACHE CORPORATION; ATMOS ENERGY CORPORATION; BP CANADA ENERGY MARKETING CORPORATION; BP ENERGY COMPANY; CENTERPOINT ENERGY RESOURCES CORP.; CHESAPEAKE ENERGY MARKETING, LLC; CHEVRON USA, INC.; CIMA ENERGY, L.P.; CONOCOPHILLIPS COMPANY; DCP MIDSTREAM GP, L.L.C.; DCP MIDSTREAM MARKETING, L.L.C.; DCP OPERATING COMPANY, L.P.; DEVON GAS SERVICES, L.P.; ENBRIDGE (U.S.) INC.; ENERGY TRANSFER, L.P.; ENLINK GAS MARKETING, L.P.; ENTERPRISE TEXAS PIPELINE, L.L.C.; EOG RESOURCES, INC.; ETC MARKETING, LTD; ETC TEXAS PIPELINE, LTD.; FREEPOINT COMMODITIES, L.L.C; HOUSTON PIPE LINE COMPANY, L.P.; J. ARON & COMPANY, L.L.C.; KINDER MORGAN TEXAS PIPELINE, L.L.C.; KOCH ENERGY SERVICES, L.L.C.; MACQUARIE ENERGY, L.L.C.; MERCURIA ENERGY AMERICA, L.L.C.; MORGAN STANLEY CAPITAL GROUP, INC.; OASIS PIPELINE, L.P.; ONEOK WESTEX TRANSMISSION, L.L.C.; PALO DURO PIPELINE (TEXAS GATHERING) L.P.; PERMIAN HIGHWAY PIPELINE, L.L.C.; PETROCHINA INTERNATIONAL (AMERICA) INC.; SEMPRA GAS & POWER MARKETING, L.L.C.; SEQUENT ENERGY MANAGEMENT, L.P.; SHELL ENERGY NORTH AMERICA, L.P.; SYMMETRY ENERGY SOLUTIONS, L.L.C.; TARGA GAS MARKETING, L.L.C.; TENASKA GAS STORAGE, L.LC.; TENASKA MARKETING VENTURES; TRAFIGURA TRADING, L.L.C.; XTO ENERGY INC.; VEGA ENERGY PARTNERS, LTD., Appellees

On Appeal from the 129th District Court Harris County, Texas Trial Court Cause No. 2023-09167

MEMORANDUM OPINION

Appellants have filed an unopposed motion to dismiss the appeal. See TEX.

R. APP. P. 10.3(a)(2), 42.1(a)(1). No opinion has issued. See TEX. R. APP. P.

42.1(c).

Accordingly, we grant the motion and dismiss the appeal. See TEX. R. APP.

P. 42.1(a)(1). We dismiss all other pending motions as moot.

PER CURIAM Panel consists of Chief Justice Adams and Justices Gunn and Guiney.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Opinion issued February 4, 2025

In The

Court of Appeals For The

First District of Texas ———————————— NO. 01-24-00973-CV ——————————— ESTHER HERNANDEZ AND PRIME ECO GROUP, INC., Appellants V. APACHE CORPORATION; ATMOS ENERGY CORPORATION; BP CANADA ENERGY MARKETING CORPORATION; BP ENERGY COMPANY; CENTERPOINT ENERGY RESOURCES CORP.; CHESAPEAKE ENERGY MARKETING, LLC; CHEVRON USA, INC.; CIMA ENERGY, L.P.; CONOCOPHILLIPS COMPANY; DCP MIDSTREAM GP, L.L.C.; DCP MIDSTREAM MARKETING, L.L.C.; DCP OPERATING COMPANY, L.P.; DEVON GAS SERVICES, L.P.; ENBRIDGE (U.S.) INC.; ENERGY TRANSFER, L.P.; ENLINK GAS MARKETING, L.P.; ENTERPRISE TEXAS PIPELINE, L.L.C.; EOG RESOURCES, INC.; ETC MARKETING, LTD; ETC TEXAS PIPELINE, LTD.; FREEPOINT COMMODITIES, L.L.C; HOUSTON PIPE LINE COMPANY, L.P.; J. ARON & COMPANY, L.L.C.; KINDER MORGAN TEXAS PIPELINE, L.L.C.; KOCH ENERGY SERVICES, L.L.C.; MACQUARIE ENERGY, L.L.C.; MERCURIA ENERGY AMERICA, L.L.C.; MORGAN STANLEY CAPITAL GROUP, INC.; OASIS PIPELINE, L.P.; ONEOK WESTEX TRANSMISSION, L.L.C.; PALO DURO PIPELINE (TEXAS GATHERING) L.P.; PERMIAN HIGHWAY PIPELINE, L.L.C.; PETROCHINA INTERNATIONAL (AMERICA) INC.; SEMPRA GAS & POWER MARKETING, L.L.C.; SEQUENT ENERGY MANAGEMENT, L.P.; SHELL ENERGY NORTH AMERICA, L.P.; SYMMETRY ENERGY SOLUTIONS, L.L.C.; TARGA GAS MARKETING, L.L.C.; TENASKA GAS STORAGE, L.LC.; TENASKA MARKETING VENTURES; TRAFIGURA TRADING, L.L.C.; XTO ENERGY INC.; VEGA ENERGY PARTNERS, LTD., Appellees

On Appeal from the 129th District Court Harris County, Texas Trial Court Cause No. 2023-09167

MEMORANDUM OPINION

Appellants have filed an unopposed motion to dismiss the appeal. See TEX.

R. APP. P. 10.3(a)(2), 42.1(a)(1). No opinion has issued. See TEX. R. APP. P.

42.1(c).

Accordingly, we grant the motion and dismiss the appeal. See TEX. R. APP.

P. 42.1(a)(1). We dismiss all other pending motions as moot.

PER CURIAM Panel consists of Chief Justice Adams and Justices Gunn and Guiney.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

Esther Hernandez and Prine Eco Group, Inc. v. Apache Corporation; Atmos Energy Corporation; BP Canada Energy Marketing Corporation; BP Energy Company; Centerpoint Energy Resources Corp.; Chesapeake Energy Marketing, LLC; Chevron USA, Inc.; CIMA Energy, L.P.; ConocoPhillips Company; DCP Midstream GP, L.L.C. DCP Midstream Marketing, L.L.C.; DCP Operating Company, L.P.; Devon Gas Services, L.P.; Enbridge (U.S.) Inc.; Energy Transfer. L.P.; Enlink Gas Marketing, L.P.; Enterprise Texas Pipeline, L.L.C.; EOG Resources, Inc.; ETC Texas Pipeline, Ltd., Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/esther-hernandez-and-prine-eco-group-inc-v-apache-corporation-atmos-texapp-2025.