Estate of Jones v. Howell

687 So. 2d 1171, 1996 WL 444936
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedAugust 8, 1996
Docket93-IA-00569-SCT
StatusPublished
Cited by21 cases

This text of 687 So. 2d 1171 (Estate of Jones v. Howell) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Estate of Jones v. Howell, 687 So. 2d 1171, 1996 WL 444936 (Mich. 1996).

Opinion

687 So.2d 1171 (1996)

In the Matter of the ESTATE OF Samuel Otto JONES, Jr. Sandra Jones Penalver, Individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Samuel Otto Jones, Jr., Deceased, Carol Ann Jones Mangum and Judy Mae Jones Kackley
v.
Sharon Browder HOWELL, Natural Mother and Natural Guardian of Samuel Clinton Howell.

No. 93-IA-00569-SCT.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

August 8, 1996.
Rehearing Denied January 23, 1997.

*1172 Travis T. Vance, Jr., Vicksburg, James W. Nobles, Jr., Jackson, for Appellants.

Raymond O. Boutwell, Jr., Brookhaven, Birdia Greer Pitts, Dunwoody, GA, for Appellee.

Before DAN LEE, C.J., and BANKS and MILLS, JJ.

*1173 DAN LEE, Chief Justice, for the Court:

The Appellants, the sisters of the deceased, Samuel Otto Jones, Jr. (hereinafter Jones), brought an action in the Warren County Chancery Court to determine Jones' wrongful death beneficiaries for purposes of bringing a wrongful death action against the tortfeasor responsible for Jones' death. The lower court held that Jones' natural son, Samuel Clinton Howell, who had been adopted by another man in 1986, was Jones' wrongful death beneficiary under Section 11-7-13 of the Mississippi Code of 1972 (hereinafter Miss. Code Ann. § 11-7-13 (1972)). Jones' sisters (hereinafter the Estate) aggrieved by the chancellor's ruling, filed this interlocutory appeal and assigned the following as error:

I. THE WRONGFUL DEATH STATUTE OF THE STATE OF MISSISSIPPI DOES NOT ALLOW AN ADOPTED CHILD WHOSE PARENT IS KILLED TO TAKE AS A WRONGFUL DEATH BENEFICIARY UNDER SECTION 11-7-13 OF THE MISSISSIPPI CODE ANNOTATED.
II. CONSTRUCTION OF THE MISSISSIPPI WRONGFUL DEATH STATUTE BY THE CHANCERY COURT OF WARREN COUNTY, MISSISSIPPI, DEPRIVES THE ESTATE OF SAMUEL OTTO JONES, JR. OF RECOVERING ALL DAMAGES OF EVERY KIND.

This Court has previously addressed the issues now before this Court in Alack v. Phelps, 230 So.2d 789, 793 (Miss. 1970), and Warren v. Foster, 450 So.2d 786 (Miss. 1984). In Alack and in Warren, this Court held that an adopted child could inherit from his natural parent or parents. Moreover, in Alack, this Court held that an adopted child could bring a wrongful death action for his natural father's death. Because we are bound by our previous decisions, we affirm the lower court's holding.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

Samuel Otto Jones, Jr., was killed in an accident on September 14, 1991. Jones' sister, Sandra Jones Penalver, applied for and was granted letters of administration for Jones' estate. Then, the Warren County Chancery Court authorized Penalver to proceed with any wrongful death claim that might lie for Jones' death. Subsequently, the Estate filed suit against the alleged tortfeasor in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi.

During the course of discovery conducted in the wrongful death action, the tortfeasor learned that Jones had a son by an earlier marriage and that the son had been adopted by Jones' ex-wife's new husband. As a result of this development, the Estate filed an action in the Warren County Chancery Court to determine whether Jones' natural son was a wrongful death beneficiary.

Samuel Clinton Howell, Jones' natural son,[1] was served with process through his mother and guardian, Sharon Browder Howell (Jones' ex-wife), and a hearing to determine Jones' wrongful death beneficiaries was held in the Warren County Chancery Court on April 14, 1993. After hearing arguments, the chancellor entered his Order holding Samuel Clinton Howell to be Jones' sole heir under the descent and distribution laws of the State of Mississippi as well as Jones' sole wrongful death beneficiary.

Jones' estate filed a motion to reconsider and this motion was subsequently denied. Thereafter, the Estate requested, and was granted, leave from the chancery court to file an interlocutory appeal with this Court. The Estate's request for interlocutory appeal was granted and this case is properly before this Court.

STATEMENT OF THE FACTS

Samuel Otto Jones, Jr., was killed in an automobile accident in Hattiesburg, Mississippi, on September 14, 1991. Thereafter, Jones' estate filed a wrongful death action in the United States District Court of the *1174 Southern Judicial District of Mississippi. During the course of discovery, the alleged tortfeasor learned that Jones was survived by a natural son, Samuel Clinton Howell, who had been adopted by his mother's new husband. As a result of this revelation, the Estate filed an heirship hearing in the Warren County Chancery Court to determine Jones' wrongful death beneficiaries.

It was determined at the heirship hearing that Jones was survived by his father, Samuel Otto Jones, Sr., and his sisters, Sandra Penalver, Carol Ann Jones Mangum, and Judy Mae Jones Kackley. Moreover, it was determined that Jones was also survived by a son, Samuel Clinton Howell (formerly Samuel Clinton Jones), born during his marriage to Sharon Browder Howell.

Jones and Sharon divorced in 1983, and Sharon and Samuel Clinton Jones moved to Louisiana where Sharon subsequently remarried. In 1986, Sharon's new husband, Bernard Howell, II, adopted Samuel Clinton Jones.

The lower court, after taking testimony and reviewing Mississippi case law, held that Samuel Clinton Howell was Jones' sole wrongful death beneficiary and sole heir under Mississippi's intestate succession law.

STANDARD OF REVIEW

Whether Samuel Clinton Howell is Jones' wrongful death beneficiary is a question of law, and we review questions of law de novo. This Court will reverse for erroneous interpretations or applications of the law. Bank of Mississippi v. Hollingsworth, 609 So.2d 422, 424 (Miss. 1992); Harrison County v. City of Gulfport, 557 So.2d 780, 784 (Miss. 1990).

I. THE WRONGFUL DEATH STATUTE OF THE STATE OF MISSISSIPPI DOES NOT ALLOW AN ADOPTED CHILD WHOSE PARENT IS KILLED TO TAKE AS A WRONGFUL DEATH BENEFICIARY UNDER SECTION 11-7-13 OF THE MISSISSIPPI CODE ANNOTATED.

Simply put, the issue in this appeal is whether Samuel Clinton Howell, Jones' natural son, can bring a wrongful death action for the death of his natural father. The Estate argues that when we read Miss. Code Ann. § 11-7-13 (Mississippi's wrongful death statute) in pari materia with Miss. Code Ann. § 93-17-13 (Mississippi's adoption decree statute), we must conclude that the legislature intended that Samuel Howell Clinton's rights to bring a wrongful death action for his natural father's death be terminated at the time of adoption. Further, the Estate argues that this Court is obligated under the Full Faith and Credit Clause, Article I, Section 4, of the United States Constitution to apply Louisiana's adoption law to the case sub judice. Specifically, the Estate argues that because Samuel Clinton Howell was adopted in Louisiana, we must look to Louisiana law to determine whether or not an adopted child can inherit from his natural parent. Under Louisiana decisional law, the Estate contends, a child who has been given up for adoption cannot inherit from his natural parent or parents. See Simmons v. Brooks, 342 So.2d 236 (La. App. 4th Cir.1977).

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Joe Alexander v. Matthew Bryan DeForest
262 So. 3d 1111 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2019)
Cossey v. Cossey
22 So. 3d 353 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2009)
Burley Ex Rel. Hill v. Douglas
26 So. 3d 1013 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2009)
Tyrone v. Tyrone
32 So. 3d 1206 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2009)
In Re Estate of Burns
31 So. 3d 1227 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2009)
Kabbes v. Burns
31 So. 3d 1227 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2009)
Jenkins v. Jenkins
990 So. 2d 807 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2008)
James A. Burley v. Eddie E. Douglas
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2007
In Re Estate of Kirkpatrick
2003 WY 125 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2003)
Shippey v. Marafioti
2003 WY 125 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2003)
In Re Estate of Yount
845 So. 2d 724 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2003)
Illinois Cent. R. Co. v. Hawkins
830 So. 2d 1162 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2002)
In Re Estate of Blanton
824 So. 2d 558 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2002)
Choctaw Maid Farms, Inc. v. Hailey
822 So. 2d 911 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2002)
Tonita Gonzales v. Nellie Gray
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2001
Briney v. US Fidelity & Guar. Co.
714 So. 2d 962 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1998)
Greyhound Lines, Inc. v. Gerald Sutton
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1997

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
687 So. 2d 1171, 1996 WL 444936, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/estate-of-jones-v-howell-miss-1996.