Erie Insurance Exchange v. McGee

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Erie Insurance Exchange v. McGee

474 A.2d 1171, 327 Pa. Super. 56, 1984 Pa. Super. LEXIS 4592

CourtSupreme Court of Pennsylvania

DecidedApril 27, 1984

Docket230

StatusPublished

Cited by9 cases

This text of 474 A.2d 1171 (Erie Insurance Exchange v. McGee) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Pennsylvania primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Erie Insurance Exchange v. McGee, 474 A.2d 1171, 327 Pa. Super. 56, 1984 Pa. Super. LEXIS 4592 (Pa. 1984).

Pincite

Opinion

PER CURIAM:

Appellants, Stanley S. and Lorraine L. McGee appeal from the trial court’s denial of their request for delay damages under Pa.R.C.P. 238 in their uninsured motorist arbitration award against appellee Erie Insurance Exchange hereinafter Erie. The trial court held only that the Supreme Court did not intend to award prejudgment delay damages to be awarded to successful plaintiffs under arbitration clauses such as that found in Erie’s uninsured motorist policy. Pursuant to Erie’s request that the trial court modify the arbitrator’s award, the court held that the arbitration clause was governed by common law principles. Appellants do not contest that characterization on appeal. However, appellants contend that to interpret Rule 238 as not applying to uninsured motorist arbitration awards impermissibly segregates plaintiffs injured by uninsured motorists from all other plaintiffs in personal injury cases. Thus, they urge Rule 238’s applicability to them.

Greenspan v. United Services Automobile Association, 324 Pa.Super. 315, 471 A.2d 856 (1984) is dispositive of this case. By that decision, common law arbitration decisions *58 which are not attacked as resulting from an irregularity James D. Morrisey, Inc. v. Gross Construction Co., 297 Pa.Super. 151, 443 A.2d 344 (1982) or as unconstitutional or against public policy, United Services Automobile Association Appeal, 227 Pa.Super. 508, 323 A.2d 737 (1974), may not be modified or corrected by another tribunal.

This Court in Greenspan refused, acknowledging the Supreme Court’s constitutionally created rule-making power, to include common law arbitration within the ambit of Rule 238.

“If the Supreme Court had . desired a court of common pleas to have the authority to modify a common law arbitration award so as to affix ‘damages for delay,’ it could have made provisions for such a practice in the Rules of Civil Procedure.” Greenspan, supra, 324 Pa. Super. 315, 471 A.2d 856.

Thus, the order of the lower court, denying appellant McGee’s motion to modify the arbitrators’ award to include delay damages is affirmed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

PER CURIAM:

Appellants, Stanley S. and Lorraine L. McGee appeal from the trial court’s denial of their request for delay damages under Pa.R.C.P. 238 in their uninsured motorist arbitration award against appellee Erie Insurance Exchange hereinafter Erie. The trial court held only that the Supreme Court did not intend to award prejudgment delay damages to be awarded to successful plaintiffs under arbitration clauses such as that found in Erie’s uninsured motorist policy. Pursuant to Erie’s request that the trial court modify the arbitrator’s award, the court held that the arbitration clause was governed by common law principles. Appellants do not contest that characterization on appeal. However, appellants contend that to interpret Rule 238 as not applying to uninsured motorist arbitration awards impermissibly segregates plaintiffs injured by uninsured motorists from all other plaintiffs in personal injury cases. Thus, they urge Rule 238’s applicability to them.

Greenspan v. United Services Automobile Association, 324 Pa.Super. 315, 471 A.2d 856 (1984) is dispositive of this case. By that decision, common law arbitration decisions *58 which are not attacked as resulting from an irregularity James D. Morrisey, Inc. v. Gross Construction Co., 297 Pa.Super. 151, 443 A.2d 344 (1982) or as unconstitutional or against public policy, United Services Automobile Association Appeal, 227 Pa.Super. 508, 323 A.2d 737 (1974), may not be modified or corrected by another tribunal.

This Court in Greenspan refused, acknowledging the Supreme Court’s constitutionally created rule-making power, to include common law arbitration within the ambit of Rule 238.

“If the Supreme Court had . desired a court of common pleas to have the authority to modify a common law arbitration award so as to affix ‘damages for delay,’ it could have made provisions for such a practice in the Rules of Civil Procedure.” Greenspan, supra, 324 Pa. Super. 315, 471 A.2d 856.

Thus, the order of the lower court, denying appellant McGee’s motion to modify the arbitrators’ award to include delay damages is affirmed.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

474 A.2d 1171, 327 Pa. Super. 56, 1984 Pa. Super. LEXIS 4592, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/erie-insurance-exchange-v-mcgee-pa-1984.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack