Emigrant Mission Committee of German Evangelical Lutheran Synod v. Brooklyn Elevated Railroad

57 N.Y.S. 624, 40 A.D. 611

• Court: Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York
• Decided: April 18, 1899
• Status: Published

Opinion

WILLARD BARTLETT, J.

It is to be assumed that the stay was? granted in this case because the learned judge who made the order thought that the appeal raised questions which ought to be passe® upon by the court of last resort before the respondent should be compelled either to stop the operation of its railroad in front of the plaintiff’s premises or pay $3,500 for the depreciation in the fee value of those premises. We cannot say that he was wrong in this view; and' the correctness of his conclusion that the questions of law involve® were grave enough to warrant a stay is in no wise affected by the subsequent action of the elevated railroad company in instituting ccmrdemnation proceedings to acquire the plaintiff’s property. If it clearly-appeared that there was no merit in the appeal, and, furthermore*, that it was taken purely for delay, in order to enable the railroad company to procure, through the condemnation proceedings, a lower valuation of the plaintiff’s premises than had been fixed in the equity action, a different question would be presented. Upon the paper© before him, we think that the learned judge at special term properly exercised his discretion in refusing to vacate the stay.

Order affirmed, without costs. All concur.