Eligah Darnell, Jr. v. Steven McCraw, Director of Texas Department of Public Safety

Opinion

15-24-00119-CV

0 _l ·- GrJ •• 2)-f ·- 0 0383LP

ELIGAH DARNELL JR.

A~P€LLAl\l1"

V

5iEVEtJ McCIZ.AW1 OaRECToR, 1£ XA 5 0£ f>tdtTM ErJ'f of Pu&L,c RECEIVED IN

5Afe,y l5th COURT OF APPEALS AU&TIN, TEXAS

AfftLlE[ APR 3 0 2025 CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE

CLERK

1 I

PLA1r1T1ffs -APPE LLANTs 5E lo,J O Su PPLE Mftn"E 0 8Rt£-f

10 TH£ HONOR.AB Lt Cou~,:

COME'i Now, £LIGAH PAP.NELL -;f(I.J APPELLANT,,,.. TIJf ABove ~tLE'P

0 R fa11/ o Lou 5 WITH PR fJu 01 Cf 1 IM E Dt cL4R.ATo RY 'J'"uoG~,1 fn/T AIJD IM J"uN CTn/E RELIEf App Lt CATt or,1 ~ r A8 Lt of Co rhl:.1Yrrs • PA,z-n es !-lND cou,,zseL

IN OE X Of A,U1l/ oernr;5

IV! rrre e, I} L -m. crs

o fZA L A12GU.~£i\l-r SrrrTtl'YI£~ Afl.GU m Ef'J'T PIZAf Efl_.

Ljf R.V lCt

COUI\J5£l

'l "'f fv €1\l f\ll ( lu1; W1 DI tz.fc1 ore Vl 5 HA L V, Ti f P..

1

·,EX Ii 5 o EPn P.__f,v'lf,vr of f'uBLu: off,,£ of ·TH€ Ai1oruJ,£i GEll/ffvil , ft ftf1 LA w ErJ fo RJ 6 fl\l)t,JY- Offrfllsf Ot u P1 01 f?)ox l 2-.. 51.f £ Au 511 NI cf )(ft 5 7871 I~ 25'-/ g \ No£ x. o-f A1xr1+011-.rr, E" s C.f\5£S

AN DNjMous /\0rJL7" 3 82 5,W,3d 53! L1Ei,APPt/J..L1':fftrl 7.01).)

C~AB1/lEf V s·nrrr 3S~ 6,W,3d g,20 Cr£X, (t,fYlrAPP, 2°11)

UJ RE f<.;1,J, 954 D1!JJ,'2d 186 (1EX,lq?3)

6

/VlcCeAW V CI '52.5 S,J,3J Joi fox,APP, q11i01%2ot7)

l1-i1ll AMEND ·,ex, ct \J \ PflA (, RE r'Yl, eooe i {p 5: oti ·-re>CCrv,PfZ/\l, P-Erfl1ioDE ; 3?, oD1rf(C{.) 3tt, o·l? ·,EX, Gov-r cooE 1

l Or.11110~ 5o<-H,Wf oavv...Aro<l·--f 1"u{)Gmctl\lf Ul\10(:i<..

• I\ pp-~ LlA rJ1" \ oru Gt !'1 A" r i;,

1""HE' U,J1fo1UY\ ()ec,tJ'tfUl--ro(l'f JLl,DGM€N1 Ac( 'f£~, (,!Ve PVJ\l, i:'-ct"1 CoQE AN~

t:,;37, ooi.t c~) ·ro 06Cl"-R-i tUf6JlL A:,rs, Ul1R.A V1e.f51 UtvcorJ,;"f(T"t-t'ftoNrtl UNDER. oue P1-Dt(5t (lACA':>t 111-fH AMi:N0f\t\&l'll, llND ,o Dcft{U'l'lt~c f1toffR (.)<Aftl1'ao,.J

Of r...€Gl'i'ffU}"ftON Llrv.DfR. lH,lP,, C,l,p, (lfl,\lol·l\1'5·1)

1

• APP~llll~·f 1 o(ur,tr.lA.L Pff11torJ. /\Uo ')011<>141 ffl..o5f~crtvE 1,-l'J'ufll!cr10N1 Rruef

UtJOf(( 1ft, tf1J1 P/UlG, Rcri'l, ccot ~ (q':5, oll AGI\IN'il 'ii-IE ors D1tEl'TO(l IUtGAL /lc:f\~ U L'f!V\ \fl V,f,<j j It\} Mt 1t 1'3 ..ft llPV.£-11 rJ G ttL l, 7... C., C., f, J ~1-.Ct€OttJG 5fA7<J1oL'{

AU."f\-loKt"ti) ANO O\ll,£l"f ·11-tf OP5 OtP~H:,oct -io Co1tiu1 At-Jo Rcto!U"\

-r,·rrri t R-t e,o rtO s /hlD ol\t u1\1,€ 11'.\fv {CM /\"fH) tJ rlA fl- oE Pu lblr c. J ·fo ~fu: c1 /\ l 0·1\\ AtJ r,H v(P._ ':>1\ ti REG 1'311t1,-n fJ ~ flE ~ u 1,tf vn Et,tf u r-J 06K , H, &i z, c, c, f,

ANO 1'Uf V1cT,M of ~He Uf\/DEllL1 1115 t:>.ffE"156 ,~1 (A(A5£ ro3~<-/l./c,I -ro

--~• C

t?Jr A -P~l;rru/f e:- a) AND E{fr')pf1otJ, Sm- A~45o ( o~\loll vo Lt ·- .;-,,

l17~, ,r

J-~ . . (j) 71-H ·T((t/1~ (0WL1 010,1'")1S'>EO AS M/.\Uuou~ Oil ftttVolvu5 i,,J!'fl{ p;.e:_fu(Jr(.£ (c r,_, \foL t • Z.&5·· 2<t 1 )

' Maf10._i fort tJELN 11uAL Wns fi L£D (cR, voLi ... 272.#ZBB) oveR.a.ul£D Bf Offrllt1"tCN. of LAtN

Al.:fl-louGH 11-1 E A pPtllv\1\lT 010 NOT P-i£G_UE5f OP-fi l, ARGUN1 E.l'JT OJ HI 5

ll\\l'1lflL 0ittcf ANO ~upplEmtru1"EO; f\£Pl1 Bt11:fJ OR.n.l AR.GU('l)[,t1JT Ma'(

6£ 'Sorne1Htrl6 lb (orlvlDl~ fo~ 'THE foltuuJ,tJG RE!tSV,.,6:

cl

,, TH~ AffoR~l'lt'i lGEt'1£RAt H,~5 AfZ(;,U£O ·,HA""f 1Hf. 'Ju8~;-f/Hl·r,,t l

11

1

'51M liwr1 --r1:vr I rJ . . . , AwoNiMous AoutT 381 5,c.,.),3d '5 31 (It,( /\Pp, AU ~17 l'l 2o I ~) I 5 11\/'.,e Lt iiA l'l'T 13 €C!J U~E App tl/A•rf Hos I\ 'ff)(fl s col\hfI cfl oN , 5£E (APPt LL El's B RI ef- A-r 13 -p 't- 1o)

96

·;, A ":>uo~JfAN1tAL ~LlE•}flON of WHfTHtR A DPS R£(RGtl~.Ernc,\?1'

11\l i\tHlK1tJG A 5ut:><:JTANf1AL 61M1 LAruTj Dr::TftcN\1Ntl1io11J l\5 ,1 I

o, 'l CU S'ifO IN Ario N'IMOl,/5 Aoui:i All 1 D 1ffr11.ctJT fR.oM THE l :JS}U,£ of Ho1;J ·-ro ·-re.EA, O,Jf ~tfr,:TUltv fZEfERE N l€ ·,o

A~ o-rH rn. 'J1irn.n1: 1 1, e, J Pf:I.JA L P1<.o v, ~, oN As o, scu?'>E o 0 f '1'1 ◄ r 'o ur 12.1; M r co wrr 1111 1NJ R£ µ,,-:r, J 951 s, vJ, 2d IB s (11}(, ft'!~ 3) HAS AIt~ 'jf N, ..,. ~;--r(\ 1" € ,_,,,.. 111E 1u~15pguo£NC£ Of 'd-\/S .._/ ·,H,s Q_vESfq ol\l IS l fl/\Poe-f/lN l To •- - -

0 t-U\Ll'78' SLll'tl.1;J\.(}1; Gour-~ PR.6C£Dci't-r 1N IN P-£ R.1',1". £XPLR-1rJcO Hoi~

·ro ·ra.urr <0"1€ frf«ri,rrts RtfEtZErJcE --ro /ltvo1HeK IN 311toZ7 1 E:l, Govrcoof > 1HE: 'fH1r1-o Cout, of APPEf-lL5 CIL[A1""EO A SuP.Jvrt1NTJtiL 51«HLtitl1Tt TEST l\ ff fo K PPS ·,o -fOUo(;J f J1 . ArvorJy- MOJS ADtJ,LT I AND tH£ ·Tr.xff~ lowt1 of 0 ,,

C1c1 N\ 1l'i/1 L APPGf1Ls to LLovJEO Wni-1 A LEG11 L 5uffiuuJcy to•1i1"1pAR.D ·n-lll1 \l

RfQu•P--ES A OfS AG6ttf ·1\J 1E~rnfy A ·T1tu-1 L REGAW1rdG !'t 5u6~ ;I [;, )

- 'Jr11~rrrn • L :Jl•YJ1 l A e • T ' / ·rfBT 1"1 -

C~Ji6n£t

~-

3 8 ~ t , 1 ; J 1 3 d 52.0 c-Y-£'/, ct1fYl,AM

I

fer; 1!·1£ A-r1D/cAIEf GEI\.IERAl'5 WouLo L£Ao ,o 11"1 A8Sur.JJ /{fsutf ·11-1t11 " t< Wo1AtO ALlotiJ I\ OPS' 'JuPJ0TruJ1tA L 'J1M1L11zrrf OrTEflM11J11110"1 ,l

·,o IJf L£ G/l L DrsPrfE 1lt£ fA c, rT Wou.LD Nar P11ss ·n~E Af\.to1~yrvlou'> 1 •

Arxu:r' 01in10Arn ~111) PLY Bww:,c A ·-r£X:A5 Off£NSE , s AT /'.':hLttJ A~10 ')r1LL 6r lLLEGnL W1-fEg£ Af\1 OUT. . of--:J,A;,E Co,,ivicnoN 1s /tr ISSLl €,

1i1,s ·-r-tre of A05uRJ>rTY WAs NOT rv11:,1tJT WHEN 11-1£ orlo (I

-i.' .

Cov\ ftf of A PP£ALS CREA,£0 ·,HE 6u~s11qtrrtAL tJ1m1LflRJ1i tf':)t,

(7~ to)

liu 12.£ ts N o Le:v r._AL tl"IIZ t,;;> v fn t,uA 1,, l);,~f'l ·toP.. DtSMl~/j/t ~ AS NM Lie, oU5 oP.

ftuv'oLou'5 vJ,,11 pRcJuo1cf APP£llArrrs l(rttM7 for<. DEllA/211,oP-Y

A"1o ,~1;rutJcftlfE Ricli&f ~JIIE,te: AfPfllttNT5 Clt111'() t6 lt10tf5Trl'1Gut5H118l£

fro,"" n,r ':)1!1.u11iol\l 1111 McClnW v c.r. 525 6,W,3d 701 frcx.,AFF, • ({

"t·rn 01 'ff 2ol7 ) IM il1 Coo irr Huo 1 C.1 :5 prrn; or1 AUff,W, Ar10 Mil({aiAI

I

HA s Nv, 015pt11Eo; ·r,.111, DPS otJL/f\lf Pu0uc fA.tco«:os ({£-fucr 1,1co£1LEcT

lhlfot111)4'ft o~f I ANO i:;,I I-Ins 5oUG/.fr 11\IJlll\l(flVE f<El.t£f ·10 l01V)f)[l

Mc C{U\W ll) Rtfo(UY\ ·,Hf f<.£(O(l05 ·-ro R£fLrcT 'Ti1E P{U)PER J)

f N. for fV\ t'ltl Oi! t

HH.t, APPtll11Nf Htb SouGt-iT Pto5P6C1il!E f?.£Lnf lo OccL•1/Z£ ftlE

utrrn \J1us Acr U!lcotlv1rfunoriAl lfrJOER 01.lE Pfloer'.±) Pe,li/ctfl'f:'7

1

O£1 f /U\i'\ 1f'I t 1U c PeoPE/L Ou RI-ill oN of /<£ G, ~I/Zfl1i ol! fat AP(1EC!11111j /f

'' No ,JV 10(£ MT PR.WR. C.ONV1 rnatJ IN CA US£ 03WL/L/&t-W Ci u'/£AR.. Rapu,ec• - ,vi rr.rr) I /\lJu tJ crw N Dt Rff-r1 tJ G OP.S ---ro Rc-foe rY) rr15 (<Eco fc05

lo R..E .fL€ Cf lOIZ. tZ e,a I 1J fo trri I-J1i ON RWAW Iti G RtG I 5fiCIITt ON Pl111A1l0 fl,\ AND Vrcnm IN(Ol&l41lON, Ca, Vol I -A-r'S)

\JJUEllEtoeE, PR.EfYlt'JfS CDrfSt0E:f!.fOiAPP£Llt1ri1 Pru~15 TN£ cour1r GRA,i/T ,I

''-

RE LA ef APf>ellf\r.JT 15 -:rw:rrt"/ £wrn,LEO ·-ro lt1l TUE' INTEP-£51 of ·-yt1'::J1liie,.

---"" .

Ort -rr-t t6 loff-1 O!rl R£5P1:.crfuUt1

o-F APt1L 2ol3, fi;L(iJ~!A

/If ft Lf11tl1

I\ 7/ A ·,t2.u€ lo N of AP PE LLA,rr~ 5u,otJf) Su ffLf ,,ofnf(flL Aff£llA1t 8e.Atf /J115

PJftl'I Pl~CED l t,l tH € Ll,01 N)/-\tL /100f£SSfO --ro :

V151-IAL V r'lrR

offtcf of ·-ruE A·rroetJEf G(N[fcr➔ L lnw E~fotCE mENT 0£f£tA15£i Of/\/, P. o, Bo;( 12548 Au,-nrJ ,·-rx ·7B 71/- 25YB

olJ ,ft ,s Zo·-rH Ofl l of APe~L Lol1 ftf1e£"11l{ cowrr of Af PtALs P, Oi0oK l 1852. Au:fn"1,·-r1, 7B 7ti

fZ E'i ~.n o,rn f'l toP-- Le AV£

Re, APPEllnrtTs t,J;) 5uepLfmtNffD n.no-r,ofJ

Ju', (5Jl~- OOllq"'c.,\J'

. ,, (I Cltflll I f"l cLo<; £0 , t; APPf Ll 11 t1t11s f\11 rJfv otJ fo ,t Lcv1 ·v r (I ( H AND _APPELL4l\tr:) -ZrJo '5uPPL£rY1€f\it£D l\no11101J

pl£A'Jt f1 lf WffH lfH E (o llil,

E Ll GA l~ 0 MN Hl J K.#/ IP 15 218 l(pl2~ ·fv11 Zos~ "1rn~l67)tt co lo Ny /1)c 1S38& RECEIVED IN

15th COURT OF APPEALS

AUSTIN, TEXAS

APR 3 0 2025 CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE

CLERK

HIGAH DAKNEU JR ~&f6278 20&1 rr~ 2osr ff~ltJ£S5fr Colo,!j;ftJA_s 75880

• fif(ffNTi/ Courr or Affr~is Po, Box 12862

• Ausn#i1t;(As 787!/

APR 3 O2025 CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE

CLERK