Eli v. Carter Oil Co.

Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Eli v. Carter Oil Co.

1932 OK 754, 23 P.2d 1011, 164 Okla. 302, 1932 Okla. LEXIS 535

Supreme Court of Oklahoma·Decided November 22, 1932·No. 19818·Published·Cited by 1 cases

Opinion

KORNEGAY, J.

In this case the matters involved are several cross-appeals from an order in accounting. A separate appeal was prosecuted in case No. 20110, by the Carter Oil Company, the Tidal Oil Company, J. Wood Glass, and F. A. Calvert. An opinion in that case has been rendered, which is decisive of this ease.

The decision appealed from of the No> *303 wata county district court on the accounting in this case, rendered on September 14, 1928, is in all things reversed, and the decision of this court rendered on April 19, 1927, is set aside, and the opinion filed at that time and reported in 126 Okla. 12, 257 P. 761, is withdrawn and overruled, and 'it is ordered that the original case reversed therein from the Nowata county district court be now affirmed, the same being case No. 5204 in said court.

HEFNER, SWINDALL, and McNEILL, JX, and HENSHAW, Special J., concur. LESTER, C. X, CLARK, V. C. J., and YOUNG, Special J., dissent. RILEY, X, not participating. CULLISON and ANDREWS, JT., disqualified.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

KORNEGAY, J.

In this case the matters involved are several cross-appeals from an order in accounting. A separate appeal was prosecuted in case No. 20110, by the Carter Oil Company, the Tidal Oil Company, J. Wood Glass, and F. A. Calvert. An opinion in that case has been rendered, which is decisive of this ease.

The decision appealed from of the No> *303 wata county district court on the accounting in this case, rendered on September 14, 1928, is in all things reversed, and the decision of this court rendered on April 19, 1927, is set aside, and the opinion filed at that time and reported in 126 Okla. 12, 257 P. 761, is withdrawn and overruled, and 'it is ordered that the original case reversed therein from the Nowata county district court be now affirmed, the same being case No. 5204 in said court.

HEFNER, SWINDALL, and McNEILL, JX, and HENSHAW, Special J., concur. LESTER, C. X, CLARK, V. C. J., and YOUNG, Special J., dissent. RILEY, X, not participating. CULLISON and ANDREWS, JT., disqualified.

Eli v. Carter Oil Co., 1932 OK 754, 23 P.2d 1011, 164 Okla. 302, 1932 Okla. LEXIS 535 (Okla. 1932).

Pincite

1932 OK 754 (Eli v. Carter Oil Co.) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Opinion

Related