Ehmann v. Norfolk Southern

Opinion

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU )LOH 1DPH DS

81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

*5(*25< * (+0$11 ; 3ODLQWLII$SSHOODQW    1R Y  !  125)2/. 6287+(51  &25325$7,21  'HIHQGDQW$SSHOOHH   1 $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW IRUWKH1RUWKHUQ'LVWULFWRI2KLRDW7ROHGR 1RnsRKQ:3RWWHU'LVWULFWsXGJH $UJXHGsDQXDU\ 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG)HEUXDU\ %HIRUH'$8*+75(<DQG*,/0$1&LUFXLWsXGJHV +(<%851'LVWULFWsXGJH

7KH +RQRUDEOH sRKQ * +H\EXUQ ,, 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW sXGJH IRU WKH :HVWHUQ 'LVWULFW RI .HQWXFN\ VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ

  (KPDQQY1RUIRON6RXWKHUQ&RUS 1R

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &2816(/ $5*8('  /DZUHQFH $ .DW] &2))(<  .$<( %DOD &\QZ\G3HQQV\OYDQLDIRU$SSHOODQW7KRPDVs$QWRQLQL 52%,621&853+(< 2j&211(//7ROHGR2KLRIRU $SSHOOHH  21 %5,()  /DZUHQFH $ .DW] &2))(< .$<(%DOD&\QZ\G3HQQV\OYDQLDIRU$SSHOODQW7KRPDV s $QWRQLQL 52%,621 &853+(<  2j&211(// 7ROHGR2KLRIRU$SSHOOHH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 23,1,21 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 521$/' /(( *,/0$1 &LUFXLW sXGJH  *UHJRU\ * (KPDQQ DQ HPSOR\HH RI 1RUIRON 6RXWKHUQ &RUSRUDWLRQ VXVWDLQHG ORZHUEDFN LQMXULHV ZKLOH SHUIRUPLQJ KLV GXWLHV FRXSOLQJ UDLOURDG FDUV  +H EURXJKW VXLW DJDLQVW 1RUIRON 6RXWKHUQXQGHUWKH)HGHUDO6DIHW\$SSOLDQFH$FW6$$WKH )HGHUDO (PSOR\HUjV /LDELOLW\ $FW )(/$ DQG WKH )HGHUDO %RLOHU ,QVSHFWLRQ $FW %,$  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW JUDQWHG 1RUIRON 6RXWKHUQjV PRWLRQ IRU SDUWLDO VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW GLVPLVVLQJ(KPDQQjVDFWLRQVXQGHU WKH6$$DQGWKH%,$ +LV FDVH SURFHHGHG WR WULDO RQ WKH )(/$ FODLP  7KH MXU\ UHWXUQHGDYHUGLFWDJDLQVW(KPDQQ5DWKHUWKDQDSSHDOWKH MXU\jVYHUGLFW(KPDQQILOHGDWLPHO\DSSHDOFKDOOHQJLQJWKH GLVWULFWFRXUWjVJUDQWRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRQKLV6$$FODLP )RUWKHUHDVRQVVHWIRUWKEHORZZH$)),50WKHMXGJPHQWRI WKHGLVWULFWFRXUW ,%$&.*5281' $ )DFWXDO%DFNJURXQG (KPDQQEHJDQZRUNLQJIRU1RUIRON6RXWKHUQLQ%\ KHZDVDKHOSHUUHVSRQVLEOHIRUPRYLQJWUDLQFDUVLQ ORFDOSODQWVRIYDULRXVLQGXVWULHVDQGIDFLOLWLHV7KLVMREDOVR  (KPDQQY1RUIRON6RXWKHUQ&RUS 1R 1R (KPDQQY1RUIRON6RXWKHUQ&RUS 

GUDZEDUmPDOIXQFWLRQHGlZLWKLQWKHPHDQLQJRIWKH6$$$V UHTXLUHGKLPWRDGMXVWmPLVDOLJQHGGUDZEDUVl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jV OLDELOLW\ RQ WKH RQWKHFDU$NQXFNOHLVDFODPSWKDWLQWHUORFNVZLWKLWV WKHRU\RIQHJOLJHQFH%XWWKDWZDVWKHTXHVWLRQSUHVHQWHGWR PDWHMXVWDVWZRFXSSHGKDQGVoSODFHGSDOPVWRJHWKHU WKHMXU\XQGHU(KPDQQjV)(/$FODLP7KHMXU\KHDUGWKH ZLWK WKH ILQJHUWLSV SRLQWLQJ LQ RSSRVLWH GLUHFWLRQV o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 LQWHUQDO (KPDQQjVGHSRVLWLRQWHVWLPRQ\ZDVDOOWKDWZDVEHIRUHWKH FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG  7KH FODLP LQ 0\HUV ZDV EURXJKW E\ D GLVWULFWFRXUWZKHQLWUXOHGRQKLV6$$FODLP EUDNHPDQ ZKR VXVWDLQHG DQ LQMXU\ ZKLOH WLJKWHQLQJ D PDOIXQFWLRQLQJKDQGEUDNH(YHQLQWKHDEVHQFHRImSUHFLVH (KPDQQVSRNHZLWKWKH7ROHGR7HUPLQDO6XSHULQWHQGHQW PHFKDQLFDOGHIHFWVlWKHFRXUWIRXQGWKDWWKHEUDNHjVIDLOXUH DQGWKH7ROHGR7HUPLQDO7UDLQPDVWHURQWKHGD\RIWKHLQMXU\ WRVHWZDVSURRIRIWKHEUDNHjVLQFDSDFLW\WRGRVR7KH&RXUW +HWROGWKHPWKDWKHKDGKXUWKLVEDFNZKLOHDWWHPSWLQJWR H[SODLQHGWKDWm>W@KHLQHIILFLHQF\RIWKHEUDNHLQWKLVFDVHPD\ FRXSOH WKH FDUV  (KPDQQ EHOLHYHV WKDW WKH GUDZEDU LQ KDYH FRQVLVWHG RI LWV GHIHFWLYH FRQGLWLRQ RU LWV GHIHFWLYH TXHVWLRQ PXVW KDYH EHHQ GHIHFWLYH EHFDXVH KH KDV QHYHU IXQFWLRQDORSHUDWLRQUHVXOWLQJLQHLWKHUFDVHLQLWVNQRFNLQJ HQFRXQWHUHG RQH LQ DOO RI KLV H[SHULHQFH WKDW KDV DEUXSWO\ IURP WKH EUDNH SODWIRUP DQ H[SHULHQFHG UDLOURDG PDQ VWRSSHGPRYLQJ DWWHPSWLQJ WR WLJKWHQ RU VHW WKH EUDNH LQ WKH FXVWRPDU\ PDQQHUl,GDW,Q(KPDQQjVFDVHWKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFH % 3URFHGXUDOKLVWRU\ WKDWWKHGUDZEDUZRXOGQRWKDYHIXQFWLRQHGSURSHUO\EXWIRU WKHXQHYHQO\GLVWULEXWHGOXEULFDWLRQ$VVXFKLWFDQQRWEH (KPDQQ ILOHG DQ DFWLRQ DJDLQVW 1RUIRON 6RXWKHUQ LQ WKH VDLG WKDW WKH GUDZEDU ZDV LQFDSDEOH RI SHUIRUPLQJ RU (DVWHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 3HQQV\OYDQLD RQ $SULO    +LV SURGXFLQJWKHGHVLUHGHIIHFW FRPSODLQWDOOHJHGWKDWKLVHPSOR\HUZDVOLDEOHIRUKLVLQMXULHV XQGHU WKH QHJOLJHQFH SURYLVLRQV RI WKH )(/$  86& :HEHOLHYHWKDW(KPDQQjVFDVHLVPRVWVLPLODUWRWKDWRIWKH ††DQGXQGHUWKHVWULFWOLDELOLW\SURYLVLRQVRIWKH6$$ SODLQWLIILQ*RHGHOY1RUIRON :5\&R)GWK  86& ††  DQG WKH %,$  86& †  &LU,Q*RHGHOWKHUDLOURDGZRUNHUFUXVKHGKLVIRRW $IWHU WKH FDVH ZDV WUDQVIHUUHG WR WKH 1RUWKHUQ 'LVWULFW RI ZKLOHNLFNLQJDGUDZEDUWKDWKDGIDLOHGWRSURSHUO\DOLJQ6HH 2KLR1RUIRON6RXWKHUQPRYHGIRUSDUWLDOVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW LG DW   +H FRPSODLQHG WKDW WKH GUDZEDU ZDV GHIHFWLYH VHHNLQJGLVPLVVDORI(KPDQQjV6$$DQG%,$FODLPV EHFDXVH LW  VXGGHQO\ VWRSSHG DQG WKDW 1RUIRON  :HVWHUQ WKHUHIRUHYLRODWHGWKHVWULFWOLDELOLW\SURYLVLRQVRIWKH6$$ 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWJUDQWHG1RUIRON6RXWKHUQjVPRWLRQRQ 6HH LG  7KH )RXUWK &LUFXLW KRZHYHU KHOG WKDW 1RUIRON sXQH   KROGLQJ WKDW (KPDQQ RIIHUHG LQVXIILFLHQW :HVWHUQZDVQRWOLDEOH,WUHOLHGRQWKHIDFWWKDWWKHDOOHJHGO\ HYLGHQFHWRSUHVHQWDJHQXLQHLVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFWIRUWKH IUR]HQ GUDZEDU KDG ODWHU VXFFHVVIXOO\ FRXSOHG ZLWKRXW DQ\ MXU\XQGHUHLWKHUWKH6$$RUWKH%,$(KPDQQj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

FDXVHGE\VRPHWKLQJRWKHUWKDQDVLPSOHPLVDOLJQPHQWRIWKH %DVHGRQWKLVHYLGHQFH(KPDQQFODLPVWKDWKHSUHVHQWHG GUDZEDU  7KLV FRXUW DIILUPHG WKH MXGJPHQW DJDLQVW WKH VXIILFLHQWSURRIWRVKRZWKDWWKHGUDZEDUmZDVGHIHFWLYHDQG UDLOURDG ILQGLQJ WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV LQVWUXFWLRQ ZDV LI IDLOHGWRIXQFWLRQSURSHUO\l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jVFDVHSURFHHGHGWRWULDOLQ2FWREHURIRQKLV WRGHPRQVWUDWHWZRWKLQJVERWKRIZKLFKZHUHVDWLVILHGE\ )(/$FODLP'XULQJWKHSURFHHGLQJVEHIRUHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW (KPDQQ)LUVW(KPDQQjVWHVWLPRQ\SURYHGWKDWmWKHWUDLQ (KPDQQUHSHDWHGO\UHTXHVWHGWKDWWKHFRXUWSUHVHQWKLV6$$ FRXSOHUV IDLOHG WR FRXSOH DXWRPDWLFDOO\l  .DYRUNLDQ  FODLP WR WKH MXU\ LQ DGGLWLRQ WR KLV )(/$ FDXVH RI DFWLRQ )GDW6HFRQGKHSURYLGHGSURRIWKDWWKHPLVDOLJQPHQW ZKLFKWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWUHIXVHGWRGR7KHMXU\UHQGHUHGD RIWKHGUDZEDUVWKDWKHZDVZRUNLQJRQWKDWGD\mFDXVHGLQ YHUGLFWDJDLQVW(KPDQQ ZKROHRULQSDUW>KLV@LQMXULHVl,G%XW1RUIRON6RXWKHUQ SUHVHQWHGVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHWRUHEXWLWVOLDELOLW\XQGHUWKH (KPDQQjV FRXQVHO ILOHG DQ DSSHDO LQ $XJXVW RI  6$$  ,W ILUVW HVWDEOLVKHG WKDW (KPDQQ KDG RSHQHG ERWK FKDOOHQJLQJWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGLVPLVVDORIKLV6$$FODLP NQXFNOHVEHIRUHDWWHPSWLQJWRDOLJQWKHRIIFHQWHUGUDZEDUV %HFDXVHWKHWULDORIKLV)(/$FODLPZDVVWLOOSHQGLQJWKLV DQGQRWHG(KPDQQjVFRQFHVVLRQLQKLVGHSRVLWLRQWHVWLPRQ\ FRXUWGLVPLVVHGWKHDSSHDOZLWKRXWSUHMXGLFHIRUODFNRI WKDWKHZDVHYHQWXDOO\VXFFHVVIXOLQFRXSOLQJWKHPLVDOLJQHG DQDSSHDODEOHILQDORUGHU(KPDQQODWHUILOHGDWLPHO\DSSHDO GUDZEDUV  +LV RQO\ HYLGHQFH RI mPDOIXQFWLRQl ZDV WKDW RIKLVFODLPXQGHUWKH6$$RQFHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWHQWHUHGD XQHYHQO\ GLVWULEXWHG OXEULFDWLRQ FDXVHG WKH GUDZEDU LQ ILQDOMXGJPHQWRQKLV)(/$FODLP+HLVQRWFKDOOHQJLQJWKH TXHVWLRQWRVXGGHQO\VWRS MXU\jVYHUGLFWXQGHUWKH)(/$,QVWHDG(KPDQQDUJXHVWKDW KLV6$$FODLPVKRXOGKDYHEHHQVXEPLWWHGWRWKHMXU\+H (KPDQQDUJXHVWKDW0H\HUVY5HDGLQJ&R86 WKXV SUHVHQWV XV ZLWK WKH TXHVWLRQ RI ZKHWKHU WKH VXGGHQ  VHWV D ORZ VWDQGDUG IRU SURYLQJ D GHIHFW XQGHU WKH VWRSSDJH RI WKH FRXSOLQJ PHFKDQLVP GXH WR D ODFN RI 6$$ OXEULFDWLRQ FRQVWLWXWHV D mPDOIXQFWLRQl IRU WKH SXUSRVHV RI VWULFWOLDELOLW\XQGHUWKH6$$ 3URRIRIDQDFWXDOEUHDNRUYLVLEOHGHIHFWLQDFRXSOLQJ DSSOLDQFHLVQRWDSUHUHTXLVLWHWRDILQGLQJWKDWWKHVWDWXWH ,,$1$/<6,6 KDV EHHQ YLRODWHG  :KHUH D MXU\ ILQGV WKDW WKHUH LV D YLRODWLRQLWZLOOEHVXVWDLQHGLIWKHUHLVSURRIWKDWWKH $ 6WDQGDUGRIUHYLHZ PHFKDQLVPIDLOHGWRZRUNHIILFLHQWO\DQGSURSHUO\HYHQ WKRXJK LW ZRUNHG HIILFLHQWO\ ERWK EHIRUH DQG DIWHU WKH :HUHYLHZGHQRYRWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVJUDQWRIVXPPDU\ RFFDVLRQLQTXHVWLRQ7KHWHVWLQIDFWLVWKHSHUIRUPDQFH MXGJPHQW6HHHJ+ROORZD\Y%UXVK)G RI WKH DSSOLDQFH  (IILFLHQW PHDQV DGHTXDWH LQ WK&LU6XPPDU\MXGJPHQWLVSURSHUZKHQWKHUHDUH SHUIRUPDQFH SURGXFLQJ SURSHUO\ D GHVLUHG HIIHFW QRJHQXLQHLVVXHVRIPDWHULDOIDFWLQGLVSXWHDQGWKHPRYLQJ ,QHIILFLHQW PHDQV QRW SURGXFLQJ RU QRW FDSDEOH RI SDUW\LVHQWLWOHGWRMXGJPHQWDVDPDWWHURIODZ)HG5&LY 3F,QGHFLGLQJDPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWWKH  (KPDQQY1RUIRON6RXWKHUQ&RUS 1R 1R (KPDQQY1RUIRON6RXWKHUQ&RUS 

FRXUW PXVW YLHZ WKH HYLGHQFH DQG GUDZ DOO UHDVRQDEOH PLVDOLJQHGGUDZEDUKDVSUHYHQWHGFDUVIURPFRXSOLQJGRHV LQIHUHQFHVLQIDYRURIWKHQRQPRYLQJSDUW\6HH0DWVXVKLWD QRWLQDQGRILWVHOIHVWDEOLVK6$$OLDELOLW\EXWWKDWOLDELOLW\ (OHF,QGXV&RY=HQLWK5DGLR&RUS86 ZLOOEHLPSRVHGLIVRPHVSHFLILFHYLGHQFHRIPDOIXQFWLRQLQJ   7KH MXGJH LV QRW WR mZHLJK WKH HYLGHQFH DQG HTXLSPHQWLVVKRZQWREHWKHGLUHFWFDXVHRIDQHPSOR\HHjV GHWHUPLQHWKHWUXWKRIWKHPDWWHUEXWWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHU LQMXULHVVXVWDLQHGZKLOHPDQXDOO\DOLJQLQJWKHGUDZEDUV WKHUHLVDJHQXLQHLVVXHIRUWULDOl$QGHUVRQY/LEHUW\/REE\ ,QF  86     $ JHQXLQH LVVXH IRU WULDO 7KLVFRXUWIDFHGWKHVDPHLVVXHUDLVHGLQ+LOHVLQWKHFDVH H[LVWVRQO\ZKHQWKHUHLVVXIILFLHQWmHYLGHQFHRQZKLFKWKH RI.DYRUNLDQY&6;7UDQVS,QF)GWK &LU MXU\FRXOGUHDVRQDEO\ILQGIRUWKHSODLQWLIIl,GDW 7KHUDLOURDGHPSOR\HHLQ.DYRUNLDQDOVRVXIIHUHGD EDFNLQMXU\ZKLOHDOLJQLQJGUDZEDUVRQXQFRXSOHGFDUV6HH % 7KH6XSUHPH&RXUWKDVLQWHUSUHWHGWKH6$$WR .DYRUNLDQ  )G DW   ,QWHUSUHWLQJ +LOHV WKH FRXUW UHTXLUHDVKRZLQJWKDWDQLQMXU\UHVXOWHGIURP FRQFOXGHG mWKDW WKH IDLOXUH RI HTXLSPHQW WR SHUIRUP FDQ PDOIXQFWLRQLQJ HTXLSPHQW LQ RUGHU WR VWDWH D FRQVWLWXWHDYLRODWLRQRIWKH>6$$@ZLWKRXWSURRIWKDWWKH FODLPIRUOLDELOLW\XQGHUWKDW$FW HTXLSPHQWLVGHIHFWLYHl,GDW$WLVVXHLQ.DYRUNLDQ ZDVZKHWKHUWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWHUUHGLQLWVDVVLJQPHQWRIWKH (KPDQQ FODLPV WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW PLVLQWHUSUHWHG WKH EXUGHQRISURRILQLWVMXU\LQVWUXFWLRQVRQ.DYRUNLDQjVFODLP 6XSUHPH&RXUWjVRSLQLRQLQ1RUIRON :5\&RY+LOHV ,WVHWIRUWKWKHIROORZLQJIUDPHZRUNWRVWDWHDFODLPDQGSURYH  86   DV ZHOO DV WKLV FRXUWjV GHFLVLRQ LQ OLDELOLW\XQGHUWKH6$$ .DYRUNLDQY&6;7UDQVS,QF)GWK&LU ,Q+LOHVDUDLOURDGZRUNHUVXHGKLVHPSOR\HUXQGHUWKH6$$ >$@WOHDVWLQDFDVHZKHUHFRXSOLQJKDGEHHQDWWHPSWHG IRU EDFN LQMXULHV VXVWDLQHG ZKLOH UHDOLJQLQJ DQ RIIFHQWHU WKH SODLQWLII SURYHV KLV FODLP XQGHU >WKH 6$$@ E\ GUDZEDU  6HH +LOHV  86 DW   8QGHU  86& GHPRQVWUDWLQJWKDWWKHWUDLQFRXSOHUVIDLOHGWRFRXSOH † D  D UDLOURDG LV UHTXLUHG WR XVH FDUV WKDW DUH DXWRPDWLFDOO\RUIDLOHGWRUHPDLQFRXSOHGXQWLOSXUSRVHO\ HTXLSSHGZLWKmFRXSOHUVFRXSOLQJDXWRPDWLFDOO\E\LPSDFW UHOHDVHGDQGWKDWWKLVIDLOXUHFDXVHGLQZKROHRULQ DQG FDSDEOH RI EHLQJ XQFRXSOHG ZLWKRXW WKH QHFHVVLW\ RI SDUWWKHSODLQWLIIjVLQMXU\$GHIHQGDQWPD\UHEXWWKH LQGLYLGXDOVJRLQJEHWZHHQWKHHQGVRIWKHYHKLFOHVl SODLQWLIIjVFDVHE\SURYLQJERWKWKDWWKHHTXLSPHQW ZDV QRW SURSHUO\ VHW HJ WKDW WKH GUDZEDUV ZHUH QRW +LOHVDUJXHGWKDWWKLVSURYLVLRQVKRXOGEHUHDGWRLPSRVH SURSHUO\ DOLJQHG RU WKDW RQH RI WKH NQXFNOHV ZDV QRW OLDELOLW\ RQ WKH UDLOURDG ZKHQHYHU DQ HPSOR\HH LV LQMXUHG RSHQDQGWKDWDGHIHFWLQWKHHTXLSPHQWGLGQRWFDXVH ZKLOHJRLQJEHWZHHQWKHHQGVRIUDLOFDUVWRPDQXDOO\DOLJQ WKHHTXLSPHQWWREHLPSURSHUO\VHWLHWKHHTXLSPHQW RIIFHQWHUGUDZEDUV7KH&RXUWGLVDJUHHG&RJQL]DQWWKDW EHFDPH LPSURSHUO\ VHW GXULQJ WKH RUGLQDU\ FRXUVH RI +LOHVjVUHDGLQJZRXOGFUHDWHOLDELOLW\DQ\WLPHDGUDZEDUZDV UDLOURDGRSHUDWLRQV RIIFHQWHUDQGUHTXLUHGPDQXDODOLJQLQJWKH&RXUWKHOGWKDW mD PLVDOLJQHG GUDZEDU VLPSO\ LV QRW D YLRODWLRQ RI >WKH ,G FLWDWLRQ DQG LQWHUQDO TXRWDWLRQ PDUNV RPLWWHG  7KH 6$$@l86DW7KH&RXUWKRZHYHUVXUYH\HGLWV SODLQWLII LQ .DYRUNLDQ LQMXUHG KLV EDFN ZKLOH SXVKLQJ D FDVHODZLQWHUSUHWLQJWKH6$$DQGFRQFOXGHGWKDWmIDLOXUHWR GUDZEDUGXULQJDFRXSOLQJDWWHPSW6HHLGDW'HVSLWH SHUIRUPFDVHVPDGHFOHDUWKDWWKHUDLOURDGZLOOEHOLDEOHIRU WKH MXU\ LQVWUXFWLRQ WKDW LPSURSHUO\ SODFHG WKH EXUGHQ RQ LQMXULHVFDXVHGE\PDOIXQFWLRQLQJHTXLSPHQWHYHQZKHQFDUV .DYRUNLDQWRVKRZWKDWmWKHHTXLSPHQWZDVSURSHUO\VHWlWKH DUHHTXLSSHGZLWKDXWRPDWLFFRXSOHUVl,GDWHPSKDVLV MXU\UHWXUQHGDYHUGLFWLQKLVIDYRU,GDW7KHQHFHVVDU\ DGGHG  ,Q VXP WKH &RXUW KHOG WKDW WKH VLPSOH IDFW WKDW D LPSOLFDWLRQLVWKDWWKHMXU\IRXQGWKDW.DYRUNLDQjVLQMXU\ZDV