Edwards v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

Opinion

234ÿ5664748ÿ9 ÿ 64ÿÿ42ÿÿÿÿ52ÿÿÿ65997ÿ2352ÿ4842ÿ898ÿ2ÿ 484ÿ2352ÿ5ÿ!594ÿ"429294ÿ449!48ÿ358ÿ5 48ÿ#$"ÿ58ÿ9ÿ$44%&4ÿ0'0ÿ234ÿ4956ÿ %524ÿ2ÿ(3%ÿ234ÿ54ÿ(5ÿ979566ÿ5 9748ÿ9 48ÿ5ÿ 697ÿÿ 29264%42ÿ9ÿ"429294)ÿ 5!ÿ 697ÿÿ 29264%42ÿÿÿ*ÿ52ÿ0ÿ ÿ +34ÿ5294ÿ &4,426ÿ42448ÿ92ÿ5ÿ64723ÿ4 ÿÿ46!97ÿ85%574ÿ#ÿ234ÿ 4ÿ ÿ234ÿ42ÿ4!456ÿ252 ÿ444ÿ(44ÿ3468ÿ58ÿ234ÿ4956ÿ%524ÿ4426ÿ9 48ÿ 348697ÿ84 ÿ464297ÿ39ÿ469%95ÿ!94( ÿ475897ÿ234ÿ4ÿÿ85%574ÿs84ÿ9 48ÿ s2&4ÿ.ÿ0'0ÿÿÿ/0ÿs84ÿ9 48ÿ4& 5ÿ.ÿ0'01ÿÿÿ*0ÿs84ÿ9 48ÿ 4& 5ÿ0ÿ0'0ÿÿÿ*1ÿÿ ÿ s ÿ234ÿ59ÿÿ234ÿ4956ÿ%524)ÿ4294%42ÿ239ÿ54ÿ(5ÿ45 9748ÿ2ÿ%4ÿ9ÿ456ÿ 253ÿÿ239ÿ45ÿÿÿ*ÿ"9ÿ2ÿ239ÿ3(4!4ÿ58ÿ66(97ÿ234ÿ4& 5ÿ0'01ÿ252 ÿ 444ÿ234ÿ5294ÿ9648ÿ5ÿ92ÿ252 ÿ42ÿ5225348ÿ3442ÿ5ÿ34894ÿ.ÿ(393ÿ9842994ÿ 5566ÿ85%574ÿ96897ÿ234ÿ2352ÿ234ÿ5294ÿ35!4ÿ57448ÿÿ5ÿ(466ÿ5ÿ234ÿ4ÿ849848ÿ&ÿ234ÿ 64956ÿ%52478ÿ2ÿ59692524ÿ5ÿ956ÿ85%574ÿ8499ÿ992ÿ:252 ÿ42ÿ59:8ÿÿÿ*/ÿ 52ÿ.0ÿ;<<ÿ>?;@ÿ3ÿ3ÿ92ÿ694ÿ54ÿ65ÿÿÿ*/A.0ÿ3ÿBÿ92ÿ5 297ÿÿ52ÿ 49%& 48ÿ444 4ÿÿÿ*/A0ÿ+39ÿ5%4(Cÿ759D4ÿ%4 529ÿ92ÿ2344ÿ 74456ÿ524794Eÿ59ÿ58ÿ 497ÿ52ÿ 49%& 48ÿ444 4ÿ58ÿ2 4ÿ694ÿ54ÿ444 4ÿ 362373ÿ234ÿ5294ÿ898ÿ2ÿ66ÿ5744ÿ8 97ÿ234ÿ 4ÿÿ44897ÿ5ÿ2ÿ4!4ÿ52ÿ444 4ÿ 924%ÿ234ÿ9:ÿ24ÿ2352ÿ234ÿ4%5997ÿ8924ÿ(44ÿ844%48ÿ2ÿ35!4ÿ&44ÿ584,5246ÿ5884 48ÿ ÿ234ÿ&59ÿÿ234ÿ%4ÿ4956ÿ%524)ÿ92ÿ58ÿ%%42ÿ58ÿ4842ÿ234(94ÿ 44!48ÿ234ÿ9732ÿ2ÿ5456ÿ4259ÿ542ÿÿ85%574ÿ9:ÿ52ÿ0Aÿ+3 ÿ562373ÿ234ÿ9:ÿ84ÿ 2ÿ 29224ÿ5ÿ57448Aÿ296529ÿÿ4ÿ92ÿ4!423464 ÿ%4%9569D4ÿ(352ÿ5% 2ÿ 234ÿ5294ÿ479D4ÿ54ÿ2ÿ&4ÿ96848ÿ9ÿ5ÿ85%574ÿ8499ÿ ÿ F5!97ÿ4!94(48ÿ234ÿ%6424ÿ48ÿ58ÿ35!97ÿ3458ÿ%ÿ234ÿ5294ÿ8 97ÿ5ÿ%4ÿ 442ÿ252 ÿ444ÿ#ÿ79!4ÿ 9845&64ÿ(49732ÿ2ÿ234ÿ85%574ÿ5%4(Cÿ42ÿ23ÿ9ÿ234ÿ 9:ÿ5ÿ464297ÿ % ÿ46ÿ5(5848ÿ9ÿ239ÿ%5224ÿ"429294ÿ3566ÿ23444ÿ&4ÿ5(5848ÿ234ÿ 66(97ÿ85%574ÿ%42Eÿ ÿ 3ÿ"59ÿ58ÿ:497ÿ "429294ÿ3566ÿ449!4ÿ234ÿ2522ÿ%549% %ÿÿH0''''''ÿ9ÿ%4 529ÿÿ5256ÿ 59ÿ58ÿ 497ÿ9:ÿ52ÿ00ÿ;<<ÿ>?;@ÿ0ÿI:ÿJÿ''55A.5ÿ+39ÿ9ÿ 9242ÿ(923ÿ234ÿ9ÿ 4956ÿ%524)ÿ!94(ÿKLMLÿs84ÿ9 48ÿs2&4ÿ.ÿ0'0ÿ52ÿ.ÿ56275C97ÿ92ÿ5 2ÿ234ÿ 4!492ÿÿ429294)ÿ9 ÿ58ÿ34ÿ49856ÿ9%59%42ÿ#ÿ&4694!4ÿ2352ÿ234ÿ%549% %ÿ5% 2ÿ Oÿ ÿ #ÿ3468ÿ5ÿ252 ÿ444ÿ9ÿ239ÿ%5224ÿÿ9 4ÿÿ0'01ÿ58ÿ234ÿ5294ÿ%566ÿ659948ÿ52ÿ2352ÿ29%4ÿ2352ÿ234ÿ9:ÿ 4642ÿ234ÿ85%574ÿ%42ÿ2ÿ&4ÿ96848ÿ9ÿ5ÿ8499ÿ ÿ 0ÿ ÿ 234ÿ5678ÿ689ÿ 22478ÿ7ÿ644689ÿ494ÿ7 9ÿ464ÿ0ÿÿ6ÿÿÿ697 9ÿ ÿ5647 ÿ 6ÿ577384ÿ3!9ÿÿ66499ÿ ÿ2!!ÿ634ÿ6"38ÿ234ÿ5678ÿ689ÿ 22478ÿ494ÿ7 9ÿ 464ÿ#ÿ#ÿ6ÿÿÿ4"7899ÿ ÿ5647 ÿ6ÿ577384ÿ3!9ÿÿ66499ÿ ÿ2!!ÿ634ÿ 6"38ÿ234ÿ5678ÿ689ÿ 22478$ÿÿ ÿ %$ÿ'847"4 9ÿ()58 ÿ *77384ÿ +ÿ47"4 " 8ÿ234ÿ6ÿ647ÿ32ÿ)58 ÿ78,449ÿ78,ÿs%.ÿ38 $ÿ8ÿ 6!678ÿ ÿ,!67" ÿÿ6ÿ,387949ÿ ÿ97, 738ÿ689ÿ867ÿ4 3!738ÿ46, 9ÿ9478ÿ  ÿ54734ÿ96"6 ÿ543, 978 $ÿÿ7ÿ 6876!ÿ 7 ÿ3ÿ64 " 8ÿ46, 9ÿÿ ÿ5647 ÿ689ÿ 3ÿ ÿ234" 4ÿ5,76!ÿ"64/ÿ)54 9ÿ7 ÿ4 64978ÿ5647,!64ÿ)58 $ÿÿ 0,,34978!ÿ*77384ÿ7ÿ87!9ÿ3ÿ47"4 " 8ÿ32ÿ56ÿ847"4 9ÿ)58 ÿ78ÿ ÿ 6"38ÿ32ÿ12#$3ÿ,3878ÿ7ÿ ÿ,64ÿ66, 9ÿ 43ÿ6ÿ055897)ÿ0$ÿÿ ÿ 4$ÿ572ÿ464ÿ*!68ÿ 6 ÿ5647 /ÿ54353 9ÿ247,64ÿ,3"586738ÿ7ÿ42!,9ÿ78ÿ 74ÿ8378ÿ!72ÿ,64ÿ5!68ÿ 66, 9ÿ 43ÿ6ÿ055897)ÿÿ 7,ÿ28,738ÿ6ÿ ÿ35467ÿ!72ÿ,64ÿ5!68ÿ689ÿ,344 538978ÿ 56" 8ÿ, 9!ÿ78ÿ7ÿ"64$ÿ6 7ÿ93," 8ÿ798727 ÿ ÿ,6 347 ÿ32ÿ24ÿ,64ÿ689ÿ 5534ÿ 94"789ÿ3ÿÿ46386!ÿ8, 64ÿ6ÿ6ÿ4 !ÿ32ÿ*77384/ÿ,3"586!ÿ7884ÿ78,!978ÿ 5438,9ÿ" 97,6!ÿ,64ÿ69657ÿ975" 8ÿ689ÿ 55!7 ÿ689ÿ6797,64ÿ 47, $ÿ6 ÿ93," 8ÿ 69977386!!ÿ42!,ÿ ÿ7"78ÿ689ÿ4,4ÿ32ÿ54353 9ÿ,3"586738ÿ234ÿ3 ÿ7" ÿ78,!978ÿ 6886!ÿ,3"586738ÿ64ÿ43ÿ46 ÿ3ÿÿ78,3453469ÿ783ÿ ÿ6887ÿ4,4ÿ689ÿ 836738ÿ4 64978ÿ7" ÿ)5,9ÿ3ÿÿ,349ÿ43 ÿ78 468,:; 97,64$ÿÿ 6 ÿ<.=ÿ6 ÿ6ÿ>6?!!ÿ7" ÿ32ÿ,3"586738ÿ7987279ÿ78ÿ ÿ!72ÿ,64ÿ5!68ÿ64ÿ 55349ÿÿ ÿ798,ÿ689ÿ64ÿ7!! 469ÿÿ ÿ,64ÿ6ÿ7ÿ055897)ÿ$ÿ<.=ÿ6ÿ$ÿ6 ÿ5647 ÿ 24 4ÿ454 89ÿ6ÿ ÿ,3"586738ÿ42!,9ÿ 478ÿ78,3453469ÿ3ÿ64 97538ÿ24ÿ ,64ÿ7" ÿ689ÿ ÿ234" 4ÿ5,76!ÿ"64/ÿ54734ÿ 7968,$ÿ8ÿ ÿ<.=ÿ ÿ54353 9ÿ,3"586738ÿ ÿ"69ÿ78ÿ564ÿ43 ÿ24ÿ6887ÿ56" 8ÿ6ÿ7!!ÿ54379ÿ56" 8ÿ234ÿ ÿ!72ÿ,64ÿ 7" ÿ,386789ÿ78ÿ ÿ!72ÿ,64ÿ5!68ÿ055897)ÿÿ7ÿ68ÿ6"38ÿ 227,78ÿ3ÿ54,6 ÿ68ÿ 6887ÿ,3846,ÿ234ÿ6ÿ5453 $ÿ@A$ÿ6ÿ07B$ÿ C678ÿ47 9ÿ ÿ!72ÿ,64ÿ5!68878ÿ"6476!ÿ78ÿ5647,!64ÿ689ÿ ÿ4,349ÿ6ÿ6ÿ 3!ÿÿ 2789ÿ6ÿ ÿ247,64ÿ7" ÿ42!,9ÿ78ÿ055897)ÿÿ64ÿ46386!ÿ 227,78!ÿ 55349ÿÿ  ÿ798,ÿ689ÿ,3878ÿ7ÿ ÿ,3"586738ÿ667!6!ÿ894ÿ ÿD6,,78ÿ0,$ÿÿ ÿ 0ÿ ÿ 2342567834ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ!ÿ"ÿ#$#%ÿÿ&ÿ'ÿ ÿ()ÿ *+,ÿsÿÿ&ÿ./01%10+1"ÿÿÿ&ÿ&ÿ 2ÿ2ÿÿÿÿÿÿ&ÿÿ&ÿ3ÿ4.*"#*15+506  ÿÿ&&ÿ4.#/$$$$+$$6ÿÿÿÿ2ÿ4.#$5/$*+*16 ÿÿ ÿÿÿ,7 ÿÿÿ(ÿÿ'89:,ÿÿ& ÿÿÿ(;ÿ #+,ÿÿ&&ÿÿÿÿÿÿ3ÿÿÿ ÿÿ<ÿ''+=ÿ&ÿÿ!<>ÿ4,2ÿ*6ÿÿÿ ÿÿ& ÿ&ÿÿÿÿÿÿ&ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ,2ÿ#ÿ ÿÿÿ&ÿÿÿ&ÿÿÿÿÿ + :ÿÿÿÿ&ÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÿÿ <ÿ*/46ÿ&ÿÿ? ÿ,+ÿÿ :ÿ7@ÿ&ÿ7ÿÿÿÿÿ3ÿÿÿÿÿA+/ÿ

8Bÿ87ÿ73ÿ3CDECEDFÿÿ GGÿ=ÿ+ÿ7ÿÿ =ÿ+ÿ7ÿÿ 7&ÿ< ÿH ÿ

/ÿ (ÿÿ? ÿ>ÿ**46ÿÿ&ÿ3ÿÿÿ2 ÿÿÿÿ3ÿ&ÿ&ÿÿÿ ÿÿÿ@ÿ +ÿ 0ÿ