Edwards v. Edwards

22 Ill. 121
Illinois Supreme Court·Decided April 15, 1859·Published·Cited by 14 cases

Opinion

Breese, J.

The ground assumed by the appellant’s counsel is not tenable. The award of a new trial in the first ejectment suit, wiped out the verdict, and no judgment was or could be rendered on it. It is not a bar to anything. It might well happen that a plaintiff with a perfect title might fail in his suit, by failing to prove possession by defendant at the time of suit brought, and a verdict pass for the defendant. In such case, or in any case, if the verdict be set aside, it could not bar another action.

Setting aside the verdict is, as if it had never been, and cannot be used anywhere, for any purpose. Followed up by a voluntary non-suit, the whole action and all its parts are null.

The judgment is affirmed.

Judgment affirmed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Edwards v. Edwards, 22 Ill. 121 (Ill. 1859).

22 Ill. 121 (Edwards v. Edwards) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Witter v. Bank of Milpitas
269 P. 614 (California Supreme Court, 1928)
Wood v. Gridley
217 Ill. App. 579 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1920)
Ætna Life Insurance v. Hoppin
99 N.E. 375 (Illinois Supreme Court, 1912)
Multnomah County v. Willamette Towing Co.
89 P. 389 (Oregon Supreme Court, 1907)
Meadows v. Osterkamp
103 N.W. 643 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1905)
Connor v. Corson
83 N.W. 588 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1900)
Slauson v. Goodrich Transportation Co.
40 L.R.A. 825 (Wisconsin Supreme Court, 1898)
Evans v. Humphreys
9 App. D.C. 392 (District of Columbia Court of Appeals, 1896)
Hammond v. Carter
44 N.E. 274 (Illinois Supreme Court, 1896)
Louisville, New Albany & Chicago Railway Co. v. Miller
37 N.E. 343 (Indiana Supreme Court, 1894)
State ex rel. Downard v. Templin
23 N.E. 697 (Indiana Supreme Court, 1890)
Phelps v. Winona & St. Peter Railroad
35 N.W. 273 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1887)
Sheldon v. Van Vleck
106 Ill. 45 (Illinois Supreme Court, 1883)
Preachers' Aid Society v. England
106 Ill. 125 (Illinois Supreme Court, 1883)