Eastman v. Thayer

60 N.H. 575

• Court: Supreme Court of New Hampshire
• Decided: June 5, 1881
• Status: Published

Opinion

Blodgett, J.

No difficulty attends this case. The defendant,, by an instrument under seal, leased to the trustee a boarding-house- and its furniture, and covenanted to do certain things which he-wholly failed to do, whereby the trustee sustained damage, the amount of which has not been agreed upon by the parties, or determined by the arbitrator named in the lease, or in any other way.. That such damage is a proper matter for recoupment in an action to recover the rent is well settled (Tay. L. & T., s. 374, WoodLand &. T., s. 465, 1 Sedg. Dam. (7th ed.) 394, note a, 2 ib. 292); and that its ascertainment requires the exercise of judgment, discretion, and opinion, and not mere calculation or computation, is. a self-evident proposition. Consequently the defendant’s claim against the trustee must be regarded as one for unliquidated damages, and hence it cannot be reached by the trustee process. Mc-Kean v. Turner, 45 N. H. 203, 204; Gove v. Varrell, 58 N. H. 78;. Bucklin v. Powell, ante 119.

Trustee discharged-

Stanley, J., did not sit: the others concurred.