Duquesne Light Co. v. Longue Vue Club

63 A.3d 270, 2013 Pa. Super. 8, 2013 Pa. Super. LEXIS 16
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
DecidedJanuary 15, 2013
StatusPublished
Cited by21 cases

This text of 63 A.3d 270 (Duquesne Light Co. v. Longue Vue Club) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Superior Court of Pennsylvania primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Duquesne Light Co. v. Longue Vue Club, 63 A.3d 270, 2013 Pa. Super. 8, 2013 Pa. Super. LEXIS 16 (Pa. Ct. App. 2013).

Opinions

OPINION BY

STRASSBURGER, J.:

Longue Vue Club (Longue Vue), Appellant, appeals from the June 13, 2012, order granting a preliminary injunction1 on behalf of Appellee Duquesne Light Company (Duquesne Light). We affirm.

The trial court has ably summarized the relevant factual and procedural history of this case.

On September 20, 1920, by a deed issued from Mutual Life Insurance Company of New York, Longue Vue took title of a piece of real property (hereinafter “Parcel 1”) in Penn Township, which is now known as Penn Hills Township. The deed was recorded in the office of the Allegheny County Recorder of Deeds at Deed Book Volume 2105, page 161. On December 2, 1949, by a deed issued from Fidelity Trust Company, et al., Executors, Longue Vue took title to an adjacent piece of real property (hereinafter “Parcel 2”) in Penn Hills Township. The deed was recorded in the office of Allegheny County Recorder of Deeds at Deed Book Volume 3075, page 383. These pieces of land (hereinafter collectively “Longue Vue property”) are now home to the Longue Vue Club, [a] historic club offering a golf course, a clubhouse, outdoor space, and various other amenities and leisure activities. The Club enjoys prized views of the Allegheny River from its clubhouse (the “Pink Terrace”), golf course, and shooting range.
On September 19, 1949, Longue Vue granted Duquesne Light an easement over and across Parcel 1 via an Indenture recorded in the office of the Allegheny County Recorder of Deeds at Deed Book Volume 3055, Page 622. In relevant part, the Easement Agreement with regards to Parcel 1 provides:
... a perpetual easement and right of way fifty (50) feet in width, with the additional right to erect and maintain the necessary anchors and appurtenances in connection therewith outside the limits of said right of way, upon, over, under and across that certain tract of land situate in the Township of Penn, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, which the Mutual Life Insurance Company of New York by its deed dated September 20,1920, and of record in the Recorder’s Office of Allegheny County, Pa., in Deed Book Vol. 2105, page 161, granted and conveyed unto Longuevue [sic ], party of the first part hereto;
for a transmission system for the conveyance, distribution and use of electric current, consisting of wires, cables and crossarms, supported on poles, H-frames, steel towers or columns, and anchors, guys and other fixtures and apparatus which [Duquesne Light], its successors or assigns, may deem necessary or proper for use in connection with said transmission system, with the right, privilege and authority to erect, construct, use operate, maintain, repair, renew and finally remove the same, and to enter upon said tract of land at any time for said purposes, together with the further right to trim [273]*273or remove any trees, shrubbery or obstructions which at any time [Du-quesne Light], its successor or assigns, may deem necessary to prevent interference or threatened interference with the construction, maintenance, repair, renewal, use or operation of said transmission system, and with the further additional right to install and maintain electric conductors underneath the surface of the ground in the vicinity of said poles, “H” frames, steel towers or columns, for the purpose of providing grounding protection for said electric transmission system, if now or at some future time [Duquesne Light], its successors or assigns, desire so to do. The said Duquesne Light Company, its successors and assigns, shall have the right at any time to replace one kind of construction with another, and the erection of one kind of support shall not preclude the erection of another.
[[Image here]]
On October 24, 1949, prior to the deeding of Parcel 2 to Longue Vue, Fidelity Trust Company granted Du-quesne Light an easement over and across Parcel 2 via an Indenture recorded in the office of the Allegheny County Recorder of Deeds at Deed Book Volume 3072, Page 64. In relevant part, the Easement Agreement with [regard] to Parcel 2 provides:
... a perpetual easement and right of way fifty (50) feet in width upon, over, and across that certain tract of land situate in Penn Township, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, which Isabel Wallace et al. by their deed dated June 17, 1926, and of record in the Recorder’s Office of Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, in Deed Book Vol. 2277, page 566, granted and conveyed unto Edmund W. Mudge; for a transmission system for the conveyance, distribution and use of electric current, consisting of cables and wires and other fixtures and apparatus which the said Grantee may deem necessary or proper for use in connection with said transmission system, with the right, privilege and authority to erect, construct, use, operate, maintain, repair, renew and finally remove the same, and to enter upon said tract of land at any time for said purposes, together with the further right to trim or remove any trees, shrubs or obstructions which at any time the said Grantee may deem necessary to prevent interference or threatened interference with the construction, maintenance, repair, renewal, use or operation of said transmission system. The said easement and right of way across the land hereinbefore described shall extend across the westerly end of said land from land now or formerly of Longvue Club to land now or formerly of Catherine M. Battaglia. The center line thereof shall be located substantially as shown by the red line on print of Duquesne Light Company drawing No.LL-3832, attached hereto and made a part hereof. No supporting structures shall be erected on said land.
The easements over and across Parcel 1 and Parcel 2 (hereinafter “the Easements”), have been used, since 1949, as a location for a part of a 69kV [kilovolt] electrical transmission line.
In 2009, realizing that an upgrade to the line was necessary to meet electricity demand in the region, as well as to make sure that the electricity being provided was reliable, Duquesne Light began seeking the necessary Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (hereinafter [274]*274“PUC”) approvals in order to upgrade the 69kV line to a 345kV line. During the PUC approval process, numerous notices were sent to Longue Vue, inviting the club, as the holder of affected property, to participate in the process, attend a hearing, and voice any concerns it might have. Longue Vue did not participate in the PUC approval process, which was completed when the upgrade was approved by PUC on February 10, 2011.
Duquesne Light determined that it would be necessary to construct temporary access roads to reach the Easements and complete the upgrade project. Duquesne Light also determined that it would need to perform core boring and drilling tests in the Easements prior to beginning the upgrade, and informed Longue Vue of the commencement of its preliminary work in December of 2010. However, when Duquesne Light’s contractors began constructing a temporary access road on December 9, 2010, the contractors were asked to leave by Longue Vue employees. On December 27, 2010, Longue Vue notified Duquesne Light that Longue Vue believed that Duquesne Light did not have the right to access any portion of the Longue Vue property outside of that expressly granted by the Easement Agreements.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Wallace, R. v. Keldon Holdings
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2025
Stone, R. v. Lystn, LLC
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2025
In Re: Trust Agreement of James Castelli
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2024
In Re: Trust Agreement of Castelli, J.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2022
Cersosimo, R. v. Keystone Group of Companies
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2022
Trust of Nell G. Jack
2022 Pa. Super. 158 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2022)
Cole, K. v. Zwergel, J.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2022
PFB Members' Service Corp. v. Eckenroad, T.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2020
Wells Fargo v. Edgewood Partners
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2019
Therapy Source, Inc. v. Lidstone, C.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2019
Healthcare Ventures v. Premier Pharmacy
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2018
Sellard, J. v. Showers, G.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2018
White, R. v. White, R.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2018
Zokaites Contracting v. Bell-Pug
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2017
Meyer-Chatfield Corp v. Bank Financial Services
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2016
Bair v. Charney
48 Pa. D. & C.5th 65 (Lycoming County Court of Common Pleas, 2015)
Comprehensive Women's Health Services v. Grube, T.
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2014
SLT Holdings v. Mitch-Well Energy
Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2014
Czarkowski v. Jennings
34 Pa. D. & C.5th 303 (Lackawanna County Court of Common Pleas, 2013)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
63 A.3d 270, 2013 Pa. Super. 8, 2013 Pa. Super. LEXIS 16, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/duquesne-light-co-v-longue-vue-club-pasuperct-2013.