Dukes, Mark

Opinion

5_::61504\46 55 5& 5 59 55 ~ 55\ 4§2/@

` RE©EWEI UN » 55 5

…C §4646 @4“(' coumoFcR\M\Nm_APpEALs jj M 7716 0154116“<”®¢49 Nov 0321:13 _i’§i=di:@( 364/464

MM 55 OMKQQ 666166@6116;@166~~ &’“”‘” 9“"”4>// 755>“*5

424 416¢/1_V6f (,UF\ ____O__ 161 …cmc(a»€/(u§ Fcez 1/%_€.1.5 440 1 §§ §4*€ 14411¢1143€61§11€6/[)11<61D111S1M1SSQ BQCCLM.§Q 6 9 9 444 4 346/414 y -;21:§€:;111;1‘:°;::'1":1:‘11"; __ 1 @{§ Eh@ tim qf lm@ging_..___ _\_0 TV\Q 7/£§< § ' 4;_011_ f 40 6661/4 645 9//9661(<

jj;@ 606 / 4 049 C f 1/4’1%614 {€Cg 31 1 __ Ccm€ 0401~ 744me VUM<~€>“ /564\416616¢ 1/1 Cabou@

54 466 am aqm\o@r€@l 6666€ 916614:11§ wa/+ 679 W\m/zoM/MJ 611/164 1650/0 6664_; 1691 661<34 10641410/\ @11\<4 5 41616 mg C66 1441 039 //€46/4/4 1966 _1___6_//0¢61#1?”

~.1_1.._ ___1~__1._._.~.1.111 _»\ z

96414161/1<% `1_5_151__6?6//7/ comic/164 _'1/1_ 136>/6/6/; _§66_< )//. '\6\614> 060/1 50 66049/166( 145/666 4_/;16 6404€ <>9/7/6 <’6 (/__;64101’\4 416 117 dam 09 § 906 ____ /__"2~@ L§

446-41116\0 `1§ 064/141666 061£§¢64664 46 6/1"1/)4_ //61/ cmp/4164 11116606620140(< 06`6641 _ 910 6411611_____ __ 1X664161&1S1§4C1;1_{:15@M4 09 @€;€Qf 66 647>§¢'75:1§_ <;4)66_71 9641416/11

115 774 74>4<1<41111%/<11+11@411444174451

533441114€ 435 5141115)/§ ®§4{44/45 441/1 541§ ' __ , /'1 295 55 TV\C 600/5 56 61§45€05 5@5(5`\516#‘@” 51)444 1111 3_<:11 :3~114141411 41114+ 435 414/ 444 __..

4541'<7_ 15510@56b§f 1 1015 719 444/5 @15€4 750 541 56 42411_111-11“ :5{1\1€ 055,1510/1€/§ …fr5 411/14\ 5€4€5"{1” 41;41 411/145":'»;;1(1510'11#11205 11

U

5){5 51447,Qf 5/\414 5:>1§4:/41: 444/511\71 515/741 j/`hé§ 54142_[1.1-1-1-1 AO;7 Q;é_ HUA/‘,

JLGWKSR 441441’_-5>1§&15'§¢155,/1 7/5§/¢ 4541/ §¢U§MM 1_1Q/1_2511

1 5 m E

11 5651510/1€/ 145144041175//1/15 755/14 751/14/6611/5:4 414514/1 //7 054/4/44175//1 544 //4/€/415\ 1147 445€45 1342 /154 751414_511 117%4175

75/741.;_<:»1`154114;144/1)_4411411417 411111_4:11414°1511/14_747£71”/;411411551<457@ @41145 75/14 4541[4414514`1;4175`) /11 //4/1}1/1507[/4)//) 50 441417§./44§ 1111 57€1./1/4 01441417575 de 54141475/641¢1//7/ 4141©7£<;147/4`)?75¢1/, 55054 \/1

@/Qd<

._. __ ,. W€M‘v“rO/L@” VCMS€O\ C/\ UJ:” \"F ©15\1¢€$@€&€(0 //¢/&HQ

‘ ’ii;j;i?ijj;j;ijji;;j;i;i;i;" 111

?` W€HM@;\ZW~’»ZCWSD@ML@_:1.:<_9/1115§{’71_1§_`:1§:[4£§(:¢§._1.:Z@.[l§f%q.i(_.-,_ 5E§A;-_Q.FK.£(»..(/1,»@}_\.3_¢_&1rv\€¢

' ll,{._4:.`1;Mc@¥:c,.~...{:;@@___/len.c

513 @/ 1 0 5'-:+1¢?1<11£@2, d m

'4'4\€6<~4 656 7`_5 §~4`4€//)1'64444'<7 156 041/1641 666 §7560//64/154€; 75§r _ 446 5<1§46 § 66_§76 776 6§§ /15 6665<><046§6 664 Of :4:4\£6_61561506; 15§ 646156///644§6_ §§41645/6¢ 6467 fica/65 PVON[`_ §75 §§ §§UH@§cd €/6/776/705 75/166/` 666 §/7’#461/ 640€5 605 ///4/§ 1§ 4?§§§§/4 666 W

564461”6150¢’€ 56//01/§€5£§/1¢(§4€/§§4§€75€664€6'4/7 ?/§ 61 4,0.44 175 §§ //%§<,4444//4§1§ /5§60€64 756 7564/0' 364€4 QMd/UC( 9 5444<4 §§ §/ ”4`§117( 66/75/§//§ be_jf§m{€§/ (?4£ 5'/0€€4/75//7 C@c{/?[` 0/4/ ¢€/§ 7506.. 754€ 944 46675 54 656 666/j __ §/w$§@/ §§<4 ;/f6 664ch 56§¢§61 546 3600/§/§444/' 76 C§¢J% 615 (/4»144/44 474/606

2>; 0 16 641/§ 6 _ 6 / j \/ 4446///4;74_ 1546/66 567/144ch ., 6 6 666€?<;////6@/)6/66666

% ' C§/m§ 646 116 467 ll 4 66

,_66664)@/€64/ 6§~/744154/ 75174 §§ 156/4 746 L57’ §4§,6 6

17ij / ¢03§45 /§ 75116§€ 666 /7§\ 6044€§<150/7,_; . Q:ci)W@ 666 6<:660_///_'16 664¢675/ ;4644?,`@ FL@/ U644‘4' 06 v MQ%L{CW(@:;

67/4<0§75¢ 466£._666€§46 [@// 666 496/wm £€466,/6 65 66

4)§§6/636§061§44/ //6§¢, 7500/1 4~4§4615§ 1566 331 35`41§/4 6

94;441<1755 C§'u/ /°v' 644§_44 4§ //606 §515)4,€ 05 476)€6/ 606/1756 666 .

4976447(615 6644§\'§6/%/ 541)1§42~644;441,5444;6[€§4§[ /0/6LJ €¢6/ >/6§§7276 __

614§§1@/7§><4§ 762<>§ 11 _ _ _11111 _

449 444ch 416§[64 607

§ 41 §§ 16 § 414 1171 Wiii;;i‘;i;';;i;;i;j;;i;i;;i;'_i_i;ii §§§6§§/1111 '

QQ@§/€ afl/19 4`440 mM§ 646/ 04414'4@@4 4%§/,»0;/1111_§_{5 §4044/ 961/5€)/464// /661//€04 1446/1764 751.@/4<%111 §1:1 75646 §§106 614/94 15§/6§4/4§ 4§4744§§ 45§6/04/ 1011 ' 444¢4§69/)411§ /1§¢//41/6117141*§1£&$/@€§744 666§§§ Z§/§H§§~

42 §_;/4144 /444$§§44 BQ§C§<§Q §1§_1__1_9§11444946113`1€<1 <§:6_4 041§§ 101_11. _ 994 604 §w§f/\ 67641:_594 746§7’:174:640,1_7[¢<(14§ 66/4464§@4 741/49 9//1\16_1411/_“€1 74`)”§49 466 606/1617

4--~/<\§4&4§0’:4 :4£4 § 7 L\Q /q a

/ §

4 v v\!vv vj v

~W < -3\,*:51`, 1355- § EK; NoTARv PuBL\c '§-. §: STATE oF TExAs

“'€4, .M_C°m- E -2-2 019