Dugan v. Champion Coal & Tow Boat Co.

49 S.W. 958, 105 Ky. 821, 1899 Ky. LEXIS 283
CourtCourt of Appeals of Kentucky
DecidedMarch 2, 1899
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 49 S.W. 958 (Dugan v. Champion Coal & Tow Boat Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Kentucky primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Dugan v. Champion Coal & Tow Boat Co., 49 S.W. 958, 105 Ky. 821, 1899 Ky. LEXIS 283 (Ky. Ct. App. 1899).

Opinion

JUDGE GUFFY

delivered the opinion oe the court.

It appears from this record that, pursuant to an order of the Kenton Circuit Court in the action of V. Shinkle’s- assignee against Shinkle, etc., the Master Commissioner loaned out certain funds. He loaned to the Champion Coal & Towboat Company $6,000, for which it, together with John Cochnower, J. IT. Williams, and A. II. Dugan, as sureties, executed bond payable to Frank P. Helm, Master Commissioner, of date November 8, 1884, and due on the 1st day of the February term of said court, February 2, 1885, with six per cent, from date until paid. It further appears that, at the February term of said court, 1892, the said Master Commissioner was directed to collect the loan bonds outstanding, and to reloan the sums so collected. The Master Commissioner reported to the court that on April 5, 1892, he collected from the Champion Coal & Towboat Company the sum of $8,667, being the amount of their loan bond No. 2,121, with interest to April 5, 1892. This sum of $8,667, the Master Commissioner reloaned to the said Champion Coal & Towboat Company on the same' day, and the said Champion Coal & Towboat Company, by John Cochnower, president, and with John Cochnower, J. H. Williams, and A. H. Dugan as sureties, executed its bond therefor, payable October 5, 1892, No. 3,159.

He collected from the said Champion Coal & Towboat [824]*824Company the sum of $2,791.33, being the other loan bond, No. 2,216, with interest to the 5th of April, 1892. This sum of $2,791.3,3 the Master reloaned to the said Champion Coal & Towboat Company on the same day, and the said company, by John Cochnower, president, with John Cochnower and J. H. Williams, sureties, executed its bond therefor, payable October 5,1892, which is filed herewith, marked “3,160.” The two said loan bonds read as follows:

“Kenton Circuit, Court. Yincent Shinkle’s Assignees, Plaintiffs, v. Vincent Shinkle et al., Defendants. Loan Bond. In consideration of eight thousand six hundred and sixty-seven dollars, which, in pursuance of the order of court made herein at the February term, 1892, Frank P. Helm, Master Commissioner, has this day loaned and delivered to the Champion Coal & Towboat Company, now we, the Champion Coal & Towboat Company, and John Cochnower, James H. Williams, and Austin H. Dugan, securities, do bind ourselves, jointly and severally, to pay unto Frank P. Helm, Master Commissioner of .the Kenton Chancery Court, on the 5th day of October, 1892, (being six months from the date hereof), the sum of eight thousand six hundred and sixty-seven dollars, together with interest thereon at the rate of six per cent, per annum, and payment thereof to be enforceable as the court may direct. Witness our hands this 5th day of April, 1892. Champion Coal & Towboat Co., John Cochnower, President. John Cochnower, J. H. Williams, A. H. Dugan, by A. Shinkle, Attorney in Fact. $8,667.00 and interest, due October 5, 1892.”

.The following is a copy of the power of attorney:

“Know all men by these presents that I, A, H. Dugan, of Louisville, Kentucky, have appointed, and hereby constitute and appoint, Amos Shinkle, of Covington, Kentucky, [825]*825my true and lawful attorney in fact, for me, and in my name, room and stead, to execute and deliver to the Master Commissioner of the Kenton Circuit Court, Kentucky, in the suit pending therein of Y. Shinkle’s Assignees v. V. Shinkle et al., in connection with John Cochnower and J. H. Williams, as co-sureties, a bond to said commissioner in the sum of $6,000, in place of the bond for like amount of date November 8, 1884, executed and delivered to said commissioner in said case by the Champion Coal & Towboat Company, principal, and said Cochnower and Williams and myself as sureties; hereby ratifying and confirming that my said attorney shall lawfully do in the premises. Witness my hand this 30th day of March, 1892. A. H. Dugan. Witnesses: L. H. Noble. Irwin Dugan.'’
“Kenton Chancery Court. Yincent Shinkle’s Assignees, Plaintiffs v. Vincent Shinkle et al.» Defendants. Loan Rond. In consideration of two thousand seven hundred and ninety-one and 33-100 dollars, which, in pursuance of the order of the court made herein at the February term, 1892, Frank P. Helm, Master Commissioner, has this day loaned and delivered to the Champion Coal & Towboat Company, principal, and John Cochnower, and James H. Williams, securities, noto ire, the Champion Coal & Towboat Company, principal, and John Cochnower and James H. Williams, securities, do bind ourselves, jointly and severally, to pay unto Frank P. nelm, Master Commissioner of the Kenton Chancery Court, on the 5th day of October, 1S92 (being six months from date hereof), the sum of two thousand seven hundred and ninety-one and 33-100 dollars, together with interest thereon at the rafe of six per cent, per annum, and payment thereof to be enforceable as the court directs. Witness our hands this 5th day of April, 1892. Champion Coal & Towboat Company, John Cooh[826]*826nower, president. John Cochnower, J. H. Williams. $2,-791,33 and interest, due October o, 1892.”

It will be seen from the foregoing that the bond for $8,-667 purports to be signed by A. Shinkle, attorney in fact for appellant. On April 23, 1894, a judgment or order of distribution was entered by the court aforesaid in regard to the collection and disbursement of outstanding sale and loaned money, the concluding portion of which order reads as follows: “If any of said creditors are indebted by loan, on sale bonds or otherwise, to said assigned estate, the Master will adjust the difference, and collect from or pay to them pro rata the excess, according as it may be.”

On the 23d of November, 1894, the Master Commissioner made a report showing the condition of.the loan bonds, and in that report he refers to the aforesaid bond, purporting to be executed by appellant, the amount of which is set down as $10,010.38, and also refers to the other bond hereinbefore referred to, and reported the last-named bond as amounting to $3,223.98. In the same report it appears that the Champion Coal & Towboat Company was entitled, on account of its claim allowed against said assigned estate, to the sum of $9,988.62, which sum he deducted from $13,234.36, the amount of the twm loan bonds herein-before mentioned, showing a balance still due amounting to $3,245.74 on December 6, 1894. Attorneys J. F. & C. H. Fisk, filed a motion for a lien against the distributable shares of the sundry claimants herein, and also a motion for an order directing the collection in full of the loan bonds to the Champion Coal & Towboat Company; and on the 10th of December, 1894, the following order was entered: “The attorneys, J. F. & C. H. Fisk, are allowed liens for sums sufficient to pay to them reasonable fees for their services as such in behalf of the defendants, the Champion [827]*827Coal & Towboat Company, S. S. Bowman, Jones’ Ex’x, and tbe Marine Railway & Dry Creek Co., against and upon the shares, respectively, of said defendants in the fund herein. The motion for the collection of the loan bonds of the Champion Coal & Towboat Company in full is overruled, and said attorneys except.”

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co. v. McGinnis' Administrator
145 S.W. 1112 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1912)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
49 S.W. 958, 105 Ky. 821, 1899 Ky. LEXIS 283, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/dugan-v-champion-coal-tow-boat-co-kyctapp-1899.