Dufour v. Mayeux

664 So. 2d 577, 1995 WL 640667
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedNovember 2, 1995
Docket95-678
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 664 So. 2d 577 (Dufour v. Mayeux) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Dufour v. Mayeux, 664 So. 2d 577, 1995 WL 640667 (La. Ct. App. 1995).

Opinion

664 So.2d 577 (1995)

Barbara DUFOUR and Barry Dufour, Plaintiffs-Appellants,
v.
Lovell John MAYEUX, Jr., M.D., et al., Defendants-Appellees.

No. 95-678.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

November 2, 1995.
Writ Denied February 2, 1996.

*578 Kent Mercier, for Barbara Dufour & Barry Dufour.

Eugene Joseph Sues, for L.J. Mayeux M.D., et al.

Before DOUCET, C.J., AMY and SULLIVAN, JJ.

*579 SULLIVAN, Judge.

This is a medical malpractice case. Plaintiffs, Barbara and Barry Dufour, filed this suit against defendants, Dr. Lovell John Mayeux, Jr. and Louisiana Medical Mutual Insurance Company, alleging that, through the fault and negligence of Dr. Mayeux, Barbara became wrongfully addicted to the prescription pain drugs Fiorinal and Fiorinal with codeine (Fiorinal # 3). Defendants filed an exception of prescription, asserting that the suit was time barred pursuant to La.R.S. 9:5628 because of plaintiffs' failure to file suit within one (1) year of the date upon which they knew or reasonably should have discovered the alleged malpractice and resulting damage.

The trial court, after conducting a hearing, granted defendants' exception and dismissed plaintiffs' suit with prejudice. In oral reasons assigned, the trial judge concluded that the suit, which was filed on November 4, 1991, had prescribed because it was filed more than one (1) year after October 12, 1990, the date of Dr. Mayeux's last examination of Barbara. He further determined that Barbara was "an intelligent lady" who "knew she had a problem" and that clearly "her addiction to Fiorinal predated October 12 [1990] by a long time."

Plaintiffs appeal the finding that their claim has prescribed and the trial court's evidentiary ruling excluding Barry's testimony concerning the date that another physician told him that Dr. Mayeux had been improperly treating his wife. Our thorough review of the record reveals no error in the trial court's judgment. Accordingly, we affirm.

FACTS

Plaintiffs alleged in their petition that, between 1988 and 1990, the actions of Dr. Mayeux in repeatedly prescribing Fiorinal and Fiorinal # 3 to Barbara without being aware that it was causing her to become addicted to the drug constituted malpractice. Fiorinal and Fiorinal # 3 are considered Schedule III narcotic pain medications. The record indicates that the treatment period in question spanned two (2) years and four (4) months from June 10, 1988 to October 12, 1990.

Dr. Mayeux is a board certified family physician in Marksville, Louisiana. Barbara's first visit to Dr. Mayeux occurred on September 15, 1983. He saw her four (4) more times in 1983 and on five (5) occasions in 1984. On the final doctor/patient interaction of 1984 on June 29, Dr. Mayeux prescribed plain Fiorinal to Barbara for the first time. In 1985, he saw her four (4) times and prescribed plain Fiorinal once for headaches on February 26, 1985. During this early treatment period, Barbara suffered from various maladies including a duodenal ulcer, an ovarian cyst, a fractured toe, anxiety, depression and headaches.

At some point after her last 1985 visit to Dr. Mayeux, the Dufours moved from the Marksville area to Jennings, Louisiana. In 1988, they moved back to Plaucheville, which is near Marksville. Dr. Barry Edwards, a Jennings physician, had previously diagnosed mitral stenosis, commonly known as degenerative neck joint disease. Barbara returned to Dr. Mayeux on June 10, 1988 complaining of headaches. Dr. Mayeux's examination revealed crepitus, a scraping sensation in the neck which causes headaches. He prescribed forty (40) Fiorinal # 3.

On June 27, 1988, Barbara was admitted to Briarwood Hospital for treatment of psychological problems. She remained there on inpatient status until her discharge on July 22, 1988. The records of her stay there are included as an exhibit in this case. She was diagnosed with (1) major depression, recurrent; (2) passive/aggressive traits; and (3) tension and vascular headaches, cervical spine disease. On admission, she gave a medical history of headaches and neck pain. She stated that she took Fiorinal # 3 for this chronic condition and that she was afraid of becoming dependent upon the medication.

Barry informed the Briarwood social worker that Barbara became aware of her Fiorinal abuse "about a year and a half ago," i.e., early 1987. Barry also stated that he became aware of her problem "about a year ago" when he noticed excessive drug bills. According to the Briarwood records, Barry explained to the staff that Barbara would go to numerous doctors "all around" to get new *580 prescriptions and would stop seeing a particular doctor once he discovered Barbara's overuse and refused to refill the prescription. Barry stated that, at one point, he found thirty (30) to thirty-five (35) prescription bottles belonging to Barbara in their home.

At Briarwood, Barbara was treated for her psychological and emotional problems. According to the records, she made marked improvements in her mental state and was released with a good prognosis. However, her substance abuse problem was neither addressed or treated. She was released with the following medication regimen: Prozac 20 mg; Seldane 60 mg; Premarin .625 mg daily; Flexiril 10 mg three times daily; and Lithium 600 mg twice daily.

Upon her release, she saw Dr. Mayeux four (4) more times in 1988 for cervical and lumbar pain. Each time, he prescribed Fiorinal # 3. In 1989, Dr. Mayeux examined Barbara a total of twenty-four (24) times, primarily for tension and migraine headaches and also for lumbar pain. The record indicates that he prescribed Fiorinal # 3 eighteen (18) times, of which twelve (12) times were with no refill and six (6) times were with one (1) refill.

Also in 1989, Barbara underwent a cervical diskectomy and fusion which was performed by Dr. Stephen Goldware, a Lafayette neurosurgeon. This surgery was performed on May 11, 1989. Prior thereto, Dr. Mayeux was not aware that she was to undergo neck surgery. He learned about it on her first visit to him after the surgery. In 1989, she saw Dr. Mayeux ten (10) times before the surgery and fourteen (14) times thereafter.

In 1990, Dr. Mayeux examined, saw or called in a prescription for Barbara on nineteen (19) separate occasions. He prescribed Fiorinal # 3 ten (10) times, eight (8) of which included one (1) refill. Dr. Mayeux prescribed plain Fiorinal six (6) times during 1990. On the date of her final visit, October 12, 1990, Dr. Mayeux prescribed thirty (30) Fiorinal # 3 with no refill for her neck and shoulder pain complaints.

On November 6, 1990, Barbara was admitted to the Rapides Regional Medical Center emergency room for treatment of a drug overdose. She had been found unconscious in an area hotel room by emergency ambulance paramedics. Hospital medical personnel pumped her stomach and stabilized her. The hospital records indicate that, thereafter, she became angry, pulled out her IVS and left against medical advice.

The next day, her husband Barry contacted the Avoyelles Parish Coroner, Dr. F.P. Bordelon, for purposes of having Barbara committed to an inpatient drug abuse treatment facility. Dr. Bordelon signed the commitment papers, and Barbara was admitted to Rapides Regional's Chemical Dependency Services. The certified records of that facility show that, on admission, Barbara acknowledged to her social worker that she had been abusing prescription drugs for thirteen (13) years. She was diagnosed as having significant depression with an unstable personality pattern and low self esteem.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Crescent City Const., Inc. v. Camper
898 So. 2d 408 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2004)
Benoit v. Archer
820 So. 2d 1275 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2002)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
664 So. 2d 577, 1995 WL 640667, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/dufour-v-mayeux-lactapp-1995.