Dougherty v. Campbell

1 Blackf. 39, 1819 Ind. LEXIS 6

• Court: Indiana Supreme Court
• Decided: July 10, 1819
• Status: Published

Opinion

Scott, J.

There are five legitimate methods by which matters of fact may be spread on the record. By consent of parties, by special verdict, by over, by bill of exceptions, and by demurrer to evidence

(1). One party cannot avail himself of the first method without the consent of his adversary; nor of the second without the concurrence of a jury; the three latter are at his election, and he has always a right to use them, when in his opinion they may operate to his advantage. It is the business and the duty'of the Court, in all cases before them, to know what is offered in evidence, and if a bill of exceptions, of a demurrer to evidence, is tendered, in which the facts are not correctly stated, it is the duty of the Court to correct the statement. But whether it be a demurrer to evidence, or a bill of exceptions, nothing can justify or excuse any Court or judge, in refusing to either party the benefit of a correct statement of facts. The Court erred, then, in not permitting the defendant to demur to the evidence.

Per Curiam.

The judgment is reversed, and the verdict set aside, with costs. Cause remanded to the Circuit Court, with directions to award a venire facias de novo.

Cole v. Driskell, in this Court, ante, p. 16.