Dinitia Harris, V. Federal Way Public Schools

CourtCourt of Appeals of Washington
DecidedFebruary 28, 2022
Docket81179-7
StatusPublished

This text of Dinitia Harris, V. Federal Way Public Schools (Dinitia Harris, V. Federal Way Public Schools) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Washington primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Dinitia Harris, V. Federal Way Public Schools, (Wash. Ct. App. 2022).

Opinion

NOTICE: SLIP OPINION (not the court’s final written decision)

The opinion that begins on the next page is a slip opinion. Slip opinions are the written opinions that are originally filed by the court. A slip opinion is not necessarily the court’s final written decision. Slip opinions can be changed by subsequent court orders. For example, a court may issue an order making substantive changes to a slip opinion or publishing for precedential purposes a previously “unpublished” opinion. Additionally, nonsubstantive edits (for style, grammar, citation, format, punctuation, etc.) are made before the opinions that have precedential value are published in the official reports of court decisions: the Washington Reports 2d and the Washington Appellate Reports. An opinion in the official reports replaces the slip opinion as the official opinion of the court. The slip opinion that begins on the next page is for a published opinion, and it has since been revised for publication in the printed official reports. The official text of the court’s opinion is found in the advance sheets and the bound volumes of the official reports. Also, an electronic version (intended to mirror the language found in the official reports) of the revised opinion can be found, free of charge, at this website: https://www.lexisnexis.com/clients/wareports. For more information about precedential (published) opinions, nonprecedential (unpublished) opinions, slip opinions, and the official reports, see https://www.courts.wa.gov/opinions and the information that is linked there. For the current opinion, go to https://www.lexisnexis.com/clients/wareports/.

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

DINITIA HARRIS and, RODERICK ) No. 81179-7-I HARRIS, each individually and on ) behalf of the ESTATE OF ALLEN ) HARRIS, and the beneficiaries of ) DIVISION ONE the Estate, ) Respondents, ) ) v. ) ) FEDERAL WAY PUBLIC SCHOOLS, ) a local government entity, ) PUBLISHED OPINION ) Appellant. ) )

MANN, C.J. — Sixteen-year-old Allen Harris fatally suffered a sudden cardiac

arrest during a summer football conditioning workout at Federal Way High School

(FWHS). Allen’s parents Dinitia and Roderick Harris, individually and on behalf of the

estate (Estate), sued the Federal Way Public School District (District). 1 The Estate

alleged, in part, that the District owed an enhanced and solemn duty of reasonable care

to protect its students. The Estate asserted that the District breached that duty by,

among other things, failing to create a medical emergency response plan, failing to

1 We refer to Allen by his first name to avoid confusion. We mean no disrespect. For the current opinion, go to https://www.lexisnexis.com/clients/wareports/.

No. 81179-7-I/2

properly train its coaches, failing to provide prompt and immediate medical attention,

and otherwise failing its obligations to protect student athletes in its charge from

foreseeable harms including those caused by sudden cardiac arrest.

We granted discretionary review to consider the District’s appeal of the trial

court’s decision denying the District’s motion for summary judgment and dismissal of

the Estate’s claims. The District argues that: (1) the trial court erred in not dismissing

the Estate’s negligent-training and negligent-supervision claim when it is undisputed

that vicarious liability applies to the coaches’ conduct, (2) the trial court erred in failing to

apply the RCW 4.24.300(4) gross-negligence standard to the Estate’s vicarious liability

claim, and (3) the District’s coaches exercised at least slight care as a matter of law.

We disagree and hold that the District owed a duty to Allen arising out of the special

relationship between school and student. We also hold that RCW 4.24.300(4) applies

to individual employees and not the District. We affirm.

FACTS

On July 24, 2018, the FWHS football team held an optional official summer

football conditioning workout. 2 Coaches Carl Green, Jared Wren, and Elijah Miller

supervised the workout. Coach Green was in charge of the practice. During football

practices, FWHS normally has an athletic trainer present. During summer conditioning,

including the July 24 workout, FWHS does not have their athletic trainer present.

Approximately 25 players were in attendance. The temperature started in high 70s and

reached the low to mid-80s during the day. The players finished three wind sprints and

2 Our de novo review of a decision on summary judgment construes the facts in a light most

favorable to the nonmoving party—in this case, the Estate. Ranger Ins. Co. v. Pierce County, 164 Wn.2d 545, 552, 192 P.3d 886 (2008).

-2- For the current opinion, go to https://www.lexisnexis.com/clients/wareports/.

No. 81179-7-I/3

were returning to the goal line for the fourth set of sprints. They had been sprinting for

15 to 20 minutes. At approximately 2:39 p.m., and prior to starting the fourth set of

sprints, Allen collapsed and began having what appeared to be seizures. Allen had no

history of seizures and no head trauma when he collapsed.

Coach Green took control of the situation, describing Allen as initially

unresponsive with “eyes back in his head and seizing.” Coach Miller called 911 at

2:39:38 p.m. Miller told the 911 dispatcher that Allen was unconscious and seizing.

Approximately 5 minutes into the 911 call, Coach Miller again told the dispatcher that

Allen was “still not conscious.” No one performed cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)

and no one went to obtain the school’s automated external defibrillator (AED).

According to Coach Green, it would have taken 15 to 20 seconds to retrieve the nearest

AED located in the stadium office. Coach Miller testified that he did not know where the

AEDs were located at the time Allen collapsed. Coach Green believed Allen’s seizure

was heat related and asked another player to pour cold water on his head.

The EMTs arrived at the field at 2:47:15 p.m. and were at Allen’s side at 2:48:30

p.m. The EMT report stated, “16 y/o male, cardiac arrest, witnessed collapse, no med

hx, PT at football practice, no complaints prior to collapse. PT found unconscious and

unresponsive, pulseless.” The EMTs began CPR at 2:49 p.m., and the first AED shock

was administered at 2:52 p.m. The estimated time from collapse to the first CPR was

10 minutes and the time from collapse to the first AED shock was 12 minutes and 22

-3- For the current opinion, go to https://www.lexisnexis.com/clients/wareports/.

No. 81179-7-I/4

seconds. Allen was transported to St. Francis Hospital where he died approximately

two hours later. Sudden cardiac arrest was the only diagnosis to explain Allen’s death. 3

On February 9, 2019, the Estate brought the underlying action for negligence

against the District. The Estate did not name the individual FWHS coaching staff. The

Estate alleged, in part, that the District owed an enhanced and solemn duty of

reasonable care to protect its students. The Estate asserted that the District breached

that duty by, among other things, failing to create a medical emergency response plan,

failing to properly train its coaches, failing to provide prompt and immediate medical

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Carabba v. Anacortes School District No. 103
435 P.2d 936 (Washington Supreme Court, 1967)
Scott v. Blanchet High School
747 P.2d 1124 (Court of Appeals of Washington, 1987)
Wagenblast v. Odessa School District No. 105-157-166J
758 P.2d 968 (Washington Supreme Court, 1988)
Niece v. Elmview Group Home
929 P.2d 420 (Washington Supreme Court, 1997)
Potter v. Washington State Patrol
196 P.3d 691 (Washington Supreme Court, 2008)
Christensen v. Royal School Dist. No. 160
124 P.3d 283 (Washington Supreme Court, 2005)
McNeal v. Allen
621 P.2d 1285 (Washington Supreme Court, 1980)
Robel v. Roundup Corp.
59 P.3d 611 (Washington Supreme Court, 2002)
Ranger Ins. Co. v. Pierce County
192 P.3d 886 (Washington Supreme Court, 2008)
State, Dept. of Ecology v. Campbell & Gwinn
43 P.3d 4 (Washington Supreme Court, 2002)
Donald R. Swank v. Valley Christian School
374 P.3d 245 (Court of Appeals of Washington, 2016)
Johns v. Hake
131 P.2d 933 (Washington Supreme Court, 1942)
Anderson v. Soap Lake Sch. Dist.
423 P.3d 197 (Washington Supreme Court, 2018)
Niece v. Elmview Group Home
131 Wash. 2d 39 (Washington Supreme Court, 1997)
Department of Ecology v. Campbell & Gwinn, L.L.C.
146 Wash. 2d 1 (Washington Supreme Court, 2002)
Robel v. Roundup Corp.
148 Wash. 2d 35 (Washington Supreme Court, 2002)
Christensen v. Royal School District No. 160
156 Wash. 2d 62 (Washington Supreme Court, 2005)
Ranger Insurance v. Pierce County
164 Wash. 2d 545 (Washington Supreme Court, 2008)
Potter v. Washington State Patrol
165 Wash. 2d 67 (Washington Supreme Court, 2008)
N.L. v. Bethel School District
378 P.3d 162 (Washington Supreme Court, 2016)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
Dinitia Harris, V. Federal Way Public Schools, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/dinitia-harris-v-federal-way-public-schools-washctapp-2022.