Dethlefson Appeal

254 A.2d 6, 434 Pa. 431, 1969 Pa. LEXIS 473
CourtSupreme Court of Pennsylvania
DecidedMay 28, 1969
DocketAppeal, 336
StatusPublished
Cited by25 cases

This text of 254 A.2d 6 (Dethlefson Appeal) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Pennsylvania primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Dethlefson Appeal, 254 A.2d 6, 434 Pa. 431, 1969 Pa. LEXIS 473 (Pa. 1969).

Opinion

Opinion by

Mr. Justice Cohen,

Appellants, neighboring landowners to the property for which a variance was allowed, did not participate in the proceedings before the Board of Zoning Adjustment of Upper Darby Township or in the appeal to the common pleas court. They, nevertheless, have taken an appeal from the judgment of the lower court reversing the order of the Board. There is mo authority to permit standing to take this appeal and it is therefore quashed.

*433 The Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code of July 31,1968, P. L. (1969) , §1003, grants a right to appeal to the court of common pleas to “any party” before the Board as well as any officer or agency of the municipality. Not having participated as a party before the Board, appellants must intervene under §1006 of the same act to become a party in the court of common pleas proceedings. These particular appellants were relegated thereunder to the rights of intervention under the Rules of Civil Procedure and, not having filed a petition in accordance therewith, nor having otherwise been permitted to intervene, were not before the lower court. Never having been a party before the lower court, appellants can not now obtain appellate review from this Court. Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code, supra, §1012. Alloy Metal Wire Company, Inc., Appeal, 329 Pa. 429, 432, 198 Atl. 448 (1938).

There is but one way to become a party litigant in a court and that is by appearing in the proceedings. Appearing as a witness is not the participation necessary to establish appellants’ right to review.

Appeal quashed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

S. Bethlehem Assoc. v. ZHB of Bethlehem Twp
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 2023
In re General Election 2014
111 A.3d 785 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2015)
In re Consolidated return of Real Estate Tax Sale Held September 10
859 A.2d 15 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2004)
Brendel v. ZONING ENFORCEMENT OFFICER
780 A.2d 750 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2001)
Stanbro v. Zoning Hearing Board
566 A.2d 1285 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1989)
In re Brown
507 A.2d 418 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 1986)
Harveys Lake Borough Taxpayers Ass'n v. Harveys Lake Borough Zoning Hearing Board
455 A.2d 762 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1983)
Gilbert v. Montgomery Township Zoning Hearing Board
427 A.2d 776 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1981)
Bloodworth v. Ellis
267 S.E.2d 96 (Supreme Court of Virginia, 1980)
Controller's Annual Report, Year 1972
390 A.2d 1368 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1978)
Citizens for a Clean Environment v. Zoning Hearing Board
350 A.2d 419 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1976)
Board of County Commissioners v. Maine Central Railroad
343 A.2d 877 (Supreme Judicial Court of Maine, 1975)
Schatz v. Zoning Hearing Board
343 A.2d 90 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1975)
Northampton Residents Ass'n v. Northampton Township Board of Supervisors
322 A.2d 787 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1974)
Blade Mulla, Inc. v. Carlson
298 A.2d 920 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1972)
Frank v. Zoning Hearing Board & Mobile Oil Corp.
296 A.2d 300 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1972)
Scott Appeal
56 Pa. D. & C.2d 92 (Chester County Court of Common Pleas, 1972)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
254 A.2d 6, 434 Pa. 431, 1969 Pa. LEXIS 473, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/dethlefson-appeal-pa-1969.