DeMoss v. News-Journal Company

408 A.2d 944, 5 Media L. Rep. (BNA) 2144, 1979 Del. LEXIS 480

• Court: Supreme Court of Delaware
• Decided: November 8, 1979
• Status: Published

Opinion

PER CURIAM:

The critical issue in this libel action is whether it is barred by the Statute of Limitations.

The relevant facts are undisputed: the allegedly libelous article was published on July 12, 1973, and plaintiff filed the complaint on May 28,1976, some two years and ten months later.

Plaintiff contends that the three-year statute of limitations in 10 DeLC. § 8106 * should govern the action because libel involves “an injury unaccompanied with force . . .” Defendant argues that the action is barred by 10 DeLC. § 8119 ** because it is a claim for “personal injuries” and thus is within the § 8119 two-year limitations period.

The Superior Court determined that § 8119 controlled and, for that reason, the action was barred by plaintiff’s failure to comply with the time requirements of that statute.

The thoughtful and carefully researched opinion by Judge Wright in McNeill v. Tarumianz, D.Del., 138 F.Supp. 713 (1956), supports the Superior Court’s decision. Judge Wright noted that a libel action involves an injury “ ‘unaccompanied with force or resulting indirectly from the acts of the defendant’ ” (as specified in § 8106), but he went on to determine, after reference to Blackstone’s Commentaries, Kent’s Commentaries, and the decided cases, that a libel action is also included within the § 8119 term “personal injuries.” 138 F.Supp. at 716. He concluded that in such a case the two-year limitations period must control, on the grounds that § 8119 is “specifically set forth as a controlling exception to the general three year limitation period of 10 Delaware Code, Section 8106.” 138 F.Supp. at 715.

We agree with that analysis and conclusion, and we hold that the libel action before us is time barred.

Affirmed.

* 10 Del.C. § 8106 provides in part that

“[n]o action to recover damages for trespass . . . and no action to recover damagés caused by an injury unaccompanied with force or resulting indirectly from the act of the defendant shall be brought after the expiration of 3 years from the accruing of the cause of such action; subject, however, to the provisions of § . . . 8119 . . of this title.”

** 10 Del.C. § 8119 states in substance that: “[n]o action for the recovery of damages upon a claim for alleged personal injuries shall be brought after the expiration of 2 . years from the date upon which it is claimed that such alleged injuries were sustained