Delaware Trust Co. v. FitzMaurice

31 A.2d 383, 27 Del. Ch. 101, 1943 Del. Ch. LEXIS 42
CourtCourt of Chancery of Delaware
DecidedApril 12, 1943
StatusPublished
Cited by14 cases

This text of 31 A.2d 383 (Delaware Trust Co. v. FitzMaurice) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Chancery of Delaware primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Delaware Trust Co. v. FitzMaurice, 31 A.2d 383, 27 Del. Ch. 101, 1943 Del. Ch. LEXIS 42 (Del. Ct. App. 1943).

Opinion

Harrington, Chancellor:

This is a bill to construe the last will and testament of Ella C. Brady Deakyne, deceased. Her will was, in part, as follows:

“Item 2. I give and bequeath the sum of Five Hundred Dollars to the Catholic Bishop of the City of Wilmington, Delaware, to be distributed by him, in his discretion, within one year after my death, among the priests of his diocese, for the purpose of having masses said for me.”
* *
“Item 7. I give and bequeath my marble top table, my inlaid table and my bedroom suite, formerly belonging to my .mother, to my sister, Sarah Josephine Crumlish.”

In Item 10, the testatrix gave, devised and bequeathed all of the rest, residue and remainder of her estate, real and personal, in trust to pay the income to her husband during his lifetime, and, after his death,

“to pay the sum of Eight Hundred and Thirty-seven Dollars and Eighty-eight Cents, part of the share received by me from the Estate of my father, to my sister, Sarah Josephine Crumlish; and to pay the sum of Eight Hundred and Thirty-seven Dollars and Eighty-eight Cents to the children then living of my sister, Annie M. Bradford, and the issue of any deceased child of hers, such issue of any such deceased child of hers to take among them the share their parent would have received, if living.
“And in further Trust, after the death of my said husband, I direct that my Trustee herein named, or whoever may execute and carry into effect the Trusts, provisions and appointments made in this, my last Will and Testament, shall set aside the principal sum of Ten Thousand Dollars out of said rest, residue and remainder of my estate, for the purposes and upon the Trusts following, to-wit:
“To pay the net income therefrom to Ruth M. Ogle of the City of Wilmington, Delaware, so long as she lives up to and observes and follows the teachings and faith of the Roman Catholic Church, and no longer; and upon her death, or failure to live up to, observe and follow the teachings and faith of that Church, as aforesaid, then and in that [107]*107event the said principal sum of Ten Thousand Dollars, herein created as a Trust Fund, shall fall into, become, and be a part and portion of the said rest, residue and remainder of my estate, as set forth in and to be disposed of as herein provided.
“And in further Trust, to divide and apportion all of the rest, residue and remainder of my estate into three equal parts or shares, and to pay out and dispose of the same in manner following, to-wit:
“One equal third part thereof, I give, devise and bequeath to the children of my sister, Annie M. Bradford, living at the time of my death, and the issue of any deceased child of hers then living, such issue of any deceased child, to take, among them, the share their parent would have taken if then living.
“One other equal third part thereof, I give, devise and bequeath to the grandchildren of my brother, Eugene D. F. Brady, living at the time of my death, and the issue of any deceased grandchildren, such issue of any deceased grandchild to take among them the share their parent would have taken if then living.
“And the income of the remaining one equal third part thereof, I give, devise and bequeath to my sister, Sarah Josephine Crumlish, for and during the term of her life; and immediately upon her death, I give, devise and bequeath the principal of said one equal third part thereof to her children then living at the time of her death, and to the issue of any deceased child of hers, such issue of any such deceased child to take among them the share their parent would have taken if then living.
“Item 11. It is my will, and I so direct, that sums of money or portions of my estate, that are herein and hereby made payable, bequeathed or devised to John Crumlish, child of my said sister, Sarah Josephine Crumlish, shall be paid to said Union National Bank, as Trustee for the said John Crumlish, in trust, to pay the net income therefrom to the said John Crumlish, for and during the term of his natural life; and upon his death, in further Trust, to pay the principal of said Trust Fund, or sum of money so held in trust for the said John Crumlish, to William Crumlish, brother of the said John Crumlish, if living at that time; and in further Trust, if the said William Crumlish be not then living, .then to pay said principal of said fund, so held in trust for the said John Crumlish, equally to and among the next of kin of the said Ella C. Brady Deakyne, in full execution of the said recited trust of and for the said John Crumlish.”

The first codicil to the will of the deceased was dated July 21st, 1936, and was, in part, as follows:

“Item 1. Whereas I gave to Sarah Josephine Crumlish, in Item 7 [108]*108of my last Will, my marble top table, my inlaid table and my bedroom suite, formerly belonging to my mother, now due to the fact that the said Sarah Josephine Crumlish is now dead, I hereby give and bequeath to John Bradley Bradford my marble top table and my inlaid table; and to William Crumlish, I give my bed room suite.
“Item 2. I give and bequeath to Ruth Ogle all of my wearing apparel and bed clothes.
“Item 3. Whereas, in Item 10 of my said Will, I directed my Trustee therein named, upon the death of my husband Thomas Deakyne, to pay the sum of Eight Hundred and thirty Seven and 88/100 Dollars to my sister Sarah Josephine Crumlish; now due to the fact that my said sister is now dead, I hereby give and bequeath the said sum of Eight Hundred and Thirty Seven Dollars and Eighty Eight Cents, to the children of the said Sarah Josephine Crumlish, and to the survivor of them, if either one be dead at the time of my death.”

On January 10th, 1939, the testatrix duly executed a second codicil to her last will and testament, which was as follows:

“The furniture which I left in my will to J. Bradley Bradford and William G. Crumlish is to be sold, and the money I left William G. Crumlish in my will is to be put in trust for him as long as he lives.
“The money which is in the Wilmington Savings Fund under the name of George Thomas Ogle, Son of George and Ruth Ogle is to remain in bank until he is twenty-one and is to be turned over to him at that time, with interest.
“I also wish all my household goods sold at private sale if possible. If it cannot be sold at private sale, then it is to be sold at public sale. Anything not disposed of at such sales Ruth Ogle may have if she so wishes, and then if anything is left it is to be given to the Catholic Guild.”

At the death of the testatrix, the Rt. Rev. Edmond J. FitzMaurice, one of the defendants, was the Catholic Bishop of the Diocese of Wilmington, and still is the Bishop of that diocese.

John Bradley Bradford, a beneficiary under the will, and alleged to be a beneficiary under the codicils thereto, died March 29th, 1938. His surviving children and next of kin are defendants in this action.

[109]*109Sarah Josephine Crumlish died prior to the death of her sister, Ella C. Brady Deakyne, leaving to survive her two children, William G. Crumlish and John S.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Otto v. Gore
45 A.3d 120 (Supreme Court of Delaware, 2012)
In re Estate of Feinberg
Appellate Court of Illinois, 2008
In Re Estate of Laning
339 A.2d 520 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1975)
Farmers Bank of State of Delaware v. Howard
276 A.2d 744 (Court of Chancery of Delaware, 1971)
In Re Madsen's Estate
296 P.2d 518 (Washington Supreme Court, 1956)
Gordon v. Gordon
124 N.E.2d 228 (Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1955)
US Bank of Portland v. Snodgrass
275 P.2d 860 (Oregon Supreme Court, 1954)
Satterfield v. Begley
43 A.2d 246 (Court of Chancery of Delaware, 1945)
Crumlish v. Delaware Trust Co.
38 A.2d 463 (Supreme Court of Delaware, 1944)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
31 A.2d 383, 27 Del. Ch. 101, 1943 Del. Ch. LEXIS 42, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/delaware-trust-co-v-fitzmaurice-delch-1943.