Davis, Stephen E.

Court of Appeals of Texas

Davis, Stephen E.

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided December 14, 2015·No. WR-32,505-05·Published

Opinion

. I~. ·{"t8',/'"}{~LOLZC9t.s- W R..- 3Z,.5"o5-0t--l 'Ttl.A ~ Ctx.J~Zr tJo_ Z31-f7l Pt . . CruM CY tr21tttAliLNPIG\LS GP<(~ 23,477-14 \-{01\i_ f'r6._fL_ ~L ~ P~ CL &x 1z..~g CJbo l WL S11ttr1CA! fhJ.sn tJ, 1tZYt& I f57 II - 23o3

f1g-: WIL~3z.,5o5-Dt:-t; c2Y. fi1Yll12'.S7L.-5J?t1c.a.J ~c ~ft~ J. ~OFnedP& n Ll ..J.(y c.y ~ \~ Mo11£:J1J ~ ~ '10 ~I uL Ot2.J fruu ~ M~u ~An 441 PD·J'L N111JMNu.s., I A1 Fo.ertA ~f.}UPC1lP.S 111 thu~ ~ r 0 r2...,i &-1 A1 ~ f-hO PU G.Vtrl ~ i'()12_ J'1tm.t ~AVS. 1,

DlWh'L HauO/htf~~ r ,- t!YLK..! ~AL~,Sr12..., ~~ ¥11'1 f>lfAl..:n::JtL l1J. /~A&!~Ml4\L17 oAlfdl, PLiuc 1 CI"Kr2\ 'AlS..'flLi:J M.w0r\S.. :L ~~hJLLlf PJ ~UQ.SJ qhkl -tlo u 1

~ ~ 1vt.l&1 \.tu t-1Vl 1ltl~ Ho71lo12A BUC' L2oLJ'{lf(" 11Li M vi 6rrJ..-fA-L._I::., St (2., ' v1Lso, H .e. . A ~A, w ouili tlac.J {/L.mt\SLQ ~ (2rutZ..AJ rro r1a;: thti ~r~-SnAMPffi \1\JUone_fL" a::: ~ u..uer'' 1"Hr;; /h~ttg-- &.h ~ Docur1~u~'?

;(YUhJ 1L L{UJ fcHz_ t{ou 12.. !\ss..t s.tAnu::~a:- I A1 ~H LS. f1~tmDL_

.S--rl£l0v!~ ~- ~tthl1s.Sf lcr7cooz...7 -SfR.tAier-n>J' ow uru ,,.-, 1"hc.:s--Ih t 2li:J Pivt &;~ AOSJ.rf~Al • .1~x~~ 11353 RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

DEC 14 2015

Abel Acoa~a, Clerk ~~ i\J 0 - tAl((_- 32: ..505"-OJ.i ·'\ru~ CiDurL-r 1\lo_ 23 '-ill -11- I

11\.l ~ ~r:! s~tz;pvf cnu hJtru s. l

..Lt~-*" JCf7G::£~Lt ~ f2J ~I'L \fs4 CA I M IJtlt\-L tfff1:l14t_S KA'{~ L ~ ~D/~ I

Pou~ Cfuu.ttl~u~, Lf 11--rn~b_t__ s Ctu ~n ILl 1 .-10-1-)S.. ~ esPa,u~ID\1( s s ~~ll..~ Ho-n~,J ~tL Lmchla: /fD Viu£' ~61/lJt1L APPurAnlJ>J ~IL Wt2rl cr Hfhl~ f11i v~ 1A1 y:-~IZJl.f. t} PAu Pi11U ~

./l"c:, /f'Hee NCYL£oll..A-8L.i£' _dus.rf c._{dS t:JP 1"t1~ Cnuttr cF c~N 11\LtlL ttl-v¥~:

L0Yl~ 1\L0W S112:P11. tnJ ~ ls , R~ll. Pfe.D s~ 1!1 ~lit A PAr.) PtmJs. , I J

Pur2.SLJA7t!A' ..fa ~l!..~ IZ .l cP 1U_~ ·m~ Cut£ LF &tif4-tuu~L Prlb- Q.~J/l..fZ: m~;lh A121-. c__ue '-t _oLf .E ~ , -~ 1 1_D7...§ 3 w/ or 11-tB' 1~As.. C.e1~~ cY" C.12-ll'\.f. 11JM.... fi'Wtt£'6u~,. i~d~ As.KS -11A.t~ Hall~ frJJYlT'~ P~.tt t~l o,J fnfL Lf.Dthitr' TO PLL£" t-4-lu 11 C~611lLt4L J41PPU CJo/flmJ 11 fVtL Wt2.t!" oP f1Yl-hl~Mus. tAl ~t\ P~Pteet~ LAu!Jt!:rL 'IILA-L &ua:r H~ {1w'Sli' .f\Jo_ ·cs, L-fl/-tL fl11dY\'L1Qa._ 1 ~ "h~TILbJ o.,p hutl-~lLt-N 1o PA~ Q&.sTS~ Ls i:ht-JtCJ-lEb. ~ {£)(HJ8/I /_ I 1J ~uPfod t{~-F fl 01LJLYL. vJ DUL..h .3HouJ /("J,..(f:C rbLLLJvJ uJ(j-;

I_ H1r~ -i"rL.ttl-'L t.Dutci'S. R~~ P~~U-t L{!S.. HtiUlS..~AL ~ 6\.l ~UIU~ I I. Z.06', f1(LPtU""DA Yl~ f.hJ AloPucm~aJ kJtL WfL-il cF 1~ fiziLpu<;,. I1U rfrt..Lt\1._ CCJud"" A1 0 _ Z3, L/71-A, Auml&' .1/U tiVf t\ 1M ~t1- ~uM il~ SuPPo6 cP- fvt.~ 1Lo7, Jtuc_Lu~uJ &--i£Xrl.t&rr~. L:Jl\J. 1\la\ICD~~ ,Zm!5, ~~CldC.. flu;D t'-l.ts. hr

I CJlll b~&.al.. 1-{, 20~; R~ R til_rtLVLib. S~_s. ~&tlllAL fut6vJL'lL ~ ~!5,: hAl~tJ&S. ()?- ~ 1'1-M.h ~S.IOJJ5 ff- LJLhJ ~ A.iJ:VC11M.81r:iLZ5;2DtS"', ~ 2.3 ~~ ~ fi~DQ_ flUEi::l KLS ~LD~ M.~~uM Wt1Vf ~ c..u:Dl.K CF St::tt~ CDu~. 1

Lbu~u~au.1Li ,"(u~ ~ n~ fi~ .--10 llllt_w~ A~s f1 Y~f2.15:: Cie... "'u uJ- llllit~>{vt~ 'atd 1fi.l ·ifAr£' '/PAC._-;- Yl/\J.~ttJC:J JU~-sst~ -fo A-IYS"u~IC'tl-h~ ~~012}'3:. \1tkU. ~ H ~ &~ C. LJ.~·uV\ <; .. ~ ~LTDIZ...... 1-iVfS. l2f'H~~>ru5.~ ht<;. !f\~16 ~ 11~ MO CTvCLDL ~UM"G" R~~o/ /X( uw .. fJt£~ rft-{~ ~IS. ~UG-vff ~6 ~g- CDM.~ Avz.~ MIJ\lts:nrtu AL ( ~·~I Sc.iuTlW A-R.J-1 lA.i lUI~~;/ f2J t£1?\'L.JT.:)/2__ ffi-<.S -(J.'(tS.,. lr-tOt10fLA8WZ WuLt:Lcs H:aaLi.tSSrcAi -16 ~hrl Kt s.. ~~ MonUJJ Fc:RL Ltz14-\16 --m nLJ:Z: ~611lliAL ftPfLlCi41ioJJ tolL WfL£"1" cf- MJ.hJ~AMUS:.../ 1

UlllWz..Ll./ ti\JCJ" H1tt&rn-s 4SSu~::ZS.. It( ~ ~ ~~1.ouJ1J .rfuvri' /ffAL.f:" fXJL.)(2;l £Y Ci2Af41 , 1J1lL t~PLD\LS ~ .1Vlcb' ~IG-Afi-Yl;,Jcr fm..J~ !(o ~ f2..f:5cu/ld:b. f:Jl{ /(t-(c;- lf21,~ CcJUflf CAJ S@-1~ttl:LDL ~fa ,Zo 15i 1'-\-u,tb !(~A£:;; LDtJ.LDL &uff')ill~~ ~~ "io ~ I!SIJulrr .-{~ ~712£j\/Qlzf"'tLh ~L.)AL /SS.LJ~ lh'-'~ ·~ lf.A.fTlllL A fltU~ttJG-S.. ,1}(/'fill'L.. Cd1JD..z:n 1\.lG- ~ll l21t ~l:D\.IT) A-rL~ IA1\/c:Si1674-'TlaJ HolAllE\ILZ1L t. 1vt~ i1:vflf 0

viv~ ~~~~2-~df:h g~ n.~-r .SuffU£Me1\.lT M~f)ut-1 tAl SJJ)fbif CF MIS. II. 0/ APruct4'ilcnJ 4Al i~~An..tllC w tnA ~uuz- 13. I {d) ll /~tl~ Ahl~ A-&!nOilAL bY.I.D'1ni2AAlA. j,f" n~ o-J Cl2.i6-11lltA:L i\IDVillvt&aLZiLDI5, ·-10 KA-nz:-1 J\lm c;.o/\1; ~~ c...u:tYLlL. or::- ~h C'dutl-T. f~tWJ itLliboJtJG-"" .QcJ ~ ,\ldl R.J&lli~ V1~ ~ \-(~ L..unr-ts.. \A.L tni. /f'vtc£ Cnui/f's. ·n ,u~,JG5.. ~s /hu~ '3~ C:"fli<ll/lL ~~u~uJt::£~L fu""TIIf. a:- ~ AJOL~,zn~,.£oM.8 Z3 ~~ ~TlDL fiC::T.t0..fltJG- (2..1{flu-c.Q.!,S.. SuPPL..g'1.~ OMLW1~UM~ CDuQ_~tL::ruTL!f', /f~STW'llZ: ~ AlCJr f'l~~ -1~ Vt4LID. H~ ~~s..·,--vtg' ·koJD~ Coi.J.ILiCP- CiUv-ttllli~L AfPUJPrLS.. H~ CY2.~ I{ 1'0. ~l-\iwu ep; 1vt~ C6ud TD o,~ k.J~~ <"fl1~ ~~ Prz£)e.~dn\.6- Wtrr1'\· I~ PlA.iAL. h.I\L~ 11\l&s.. oc; fi.\e..~ lh.Lu~ C0n1~US..I Uh..l~ c.r-- LAvJ fhLtD !(o ~ r;gu ILF ~ {Q£...tALAil...h. "fO 'fM-~ C!.t::Ju(};l OF- M~ i \Ai 1L.L fiLm!~ ~~fL 1:;-,WM Hthltl\lf:r HLS. ~N\.3 A-t:(\U~tCA-~ ~~~ 0\.1 ~~u /K~LJ'r2k"ll2:: ~ ~c.o& CDM.fta' tn'\ 11\l A- ~lL f1PhllttiiZR.. fhu.l~ W1U~ts.I1,[Ul \A.L1 n-1 fH~ ~Cft1A1J~ w bu~ Pr<....oc..cz::::s•• I ~ fl~~TEI) 11u .1i·1~ f!.' tm.K'S ·1rrt!C- ~nrnPen &ft./ 4o ~~LJTifL ~~ ..1vte: c..Ll.aLK.'~ ~ ~&J tAh ~

2 :/ftl.LS. \Ait u._ 1-h..LLJtJ ·~ I::Ytl...JOfl.. Stio1J C~ kh\Ab ?~~~ ~ J.U "'D . . oU &SI~utae( ~ We.,,,- u·ri 6-ffrl 0.1\l .. ..{V(L:;Sc( Ulll~ll:il.L~ nJ6- \-i~ CLJfu~, Wt1.L21J Su~A~1 WILLl£MTITI..16 A~IL {o ~ta.L&EF. ~c_u}& [ L:gJ t/;fhlb, prL/1<.1£r1L ~ C:S1J1Trti::J Ai!::Dtfc£:, ~~a... 11~ Pcrr tfvt!l: Cn>uo &1 Alan~ ~ur::::6~uub- l1'S f2ou,J&- Cn11M07lcs~Js.. fot2_SuB.1'1.r.SS..to~L dh~,LIJ .1~ ~ ~07ttb -1v1<1" R~{Dl.Jt~lLTS cr Aa.nc..Ll2:' II~ 07, 1o ~~ A~ kt~t::, fllfLlLDJ~ MO A~ A~,.,~u- H~ Suf~lD\i1"" r-ic:~}~~u M ·1tS ,-(vt~ C!Ju ~- \Aivhsrz..a:~, PtZ.r£M ISIS CD/lJSJ~ . p,~~,s;,.~rtLDJ l2"~ tY-w,s.., Pfl.o s,~, ff21;tc)s, rfKit¥1 n1.1~ Holle:>~ {]oufll EF t2tlU't 11Lir-k_ r+t'f~ DsiU\nrf v-t Ls,. Mon DLL ~ l.u:Jthf ~ 10 n. LJS:: Of'ubLJJ ~~ JA1J'Pl....H~.A n o1J fotL. WrL\t a::: 1'1P\:rv\MMus..J tthu~ I SSut:r' ~12f'::Jf'C1S-' --lc &JM.fEZL. ,(K~ rfA-13~ -fAit.!,~ &urc.;r- /fD P~te..M L1S. Mt,uJ.o-0LJ4L £Junes .. 6X_~ biT~ CJ\1 .;fvtLS. I 0 'f}-( ~At/ aF ~~~IDL1 2o Is-.,

f1 ~Pcr:CTF ULLL{ su e:M I T1'"lili. I

~~~IJ~

S wo,e;J ~~Rfl'T161J ~j s;;:-17£Pv((L)J ~ ~A\1 (S. 2:uJ,Ju- PfusD.ITL-1 1t\l~~ IJU ·1V!~ I

.3n2A tJU- ~ ; o "j L.) ;u rl c_p ~K.

(f)~f-1 ~~\l~ i~ 1'~C 11-Jtil:-J Cnu~ f.iX~'f1& Q'\.[ 1t1tS lCJ-1H ~ CF- ~l:!tuMOOLt.2o~ A~P~TFuL.Df 3u&HtTT~, filKt Bl-r' { · ''[_{LttCZ:: ~101\J IS. f1~l!:' fu£Suth.C(~D tl£9~ Qu~ eF- (ou_ow_[,Af[r' .

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI