Davis, Finnis Ii

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided September 22, 2015·No. WR-83,870-01·Published

Opinion

"§;°$ §§§§§X§‘§Z§§§?§:;§;;°°““§OURTF;§§§§:§&AM mgqu . , ' ' . sEP 2 2 2015 - v\wi§ sm~\g;:_ ‘“> @qu’b\b*\‘®@%@o%*&\@#e% gm <\c>mm\m

~ F'T\r\ <:4 (>,§)Q\\mvi`€ 0\>`3@¢‘€5 to t\\e. SX&\€F;» Ye,\?o<\€€. `\~n oyposs\v\ows to aQQ\R€.u<\*€S @<§Q\`\@r£<`\o‘\ Q¢>‘< wv`\\; § Yvi\>eas cov'p\>§» '\h€, 6\'¢1'¥&, ~P\"r>~§) o§r:z\ &`mc\`mg€a 0<<` caa*<`_»ec>w_\\>s\ms 639 \clm 06 me,\\ bag,-gpp\\mn“\' wo\ counsel o\z?lc\avi’i. `m ve§§>cm_.§e_ aa‘oc;\4 (JI\S\)WD\~“QA by ‘r.\\a€eu>`vc\. “\we_x)\)\)\{mn’\'_\ze)'\evc% \;‘ne Xx\a\ Cc>\>r‘\'_ ch <\ adopt \Je_\‘.‘oo*-v'\m thc §§b?i>§az\%\n}m\g§ 'BQ Qacjmnéx ) O_c)<\(;\us\cm§ 159 \Cm\\mm§e, \1\/ '\~_\\e sXa&c/m‘r\id\ Sae}n ig?mo€ `

"L¥`\/C»\€D\)v\se,\ A?Q`\,C\£L\l ii \9\&’€£\€3"*610\0 \m\lm§beer\ Qomn¢\m\\c\r)\v\ ’\'_\ne. apQ\Xcuv\‘L’<‘emvc\@ 'The_‘ce_¥h@.a\>§\i mmi¢;%e§‘.. E>

G\€&C\\;l:\\ wab; ')1>\-\ L@\%(:\C`L w HQQ 100%\»

\5\0\5 §§\nl>w\ \r)‘-{ (WQ ?\c\&\l`\~‘; ' lmv_;‘\?.n-em\¢\’chem§§\&mn`< (>‘Q:\<¢c_*r_’u> \~_\;.‘txiu\ Co\mSp_\ C\"v`@`\{\a$`\¥ C\.S CL mhb\e,-\\zwose `\"r '\e>un€>u\?§m"m§ ‘@J ’r.\neve_€'.c>‘w\w 'T‘<\ea?§\l cCA\n\~ SX~Q>\F)<\\Y \')c;\'\€.\le$ \'_‘C`\&\ QL>$<\%C\ C\\?\:§A.c\\l’\"< SY eu¥\§&®l<\'\e.\!`mé.\c§<§\)c.

`\<`\cx¥u'vc; ’L‘Mcx\ Cc>uv\%e,\ mm e,\m>_c\ X_c> ‘c_\nc$ucir -\ %UY‘§‘OY Xec§~ \3/ @QQ\~ 4\` mut max oQ \ .~ c;-'?>%' l>\c>¢©€\» \\C\O\\A\l-R\ ~"dw;

-\;he,c.??\\wnt€a\ec\m C\q\m am wx\\\am 3 \°\om& 0\30 a§)€'

`\i¢cm‘v Qc\ec\ e<>m§d\cxm`c 0%¢1\§\§;\`<\~¢\9~0:@3 Un?ro?ess`»ema\ anc\uc;`\; Auv`m up\?\imv\’c~_ )¢xco\ m`\‘<\<\ \~_\'m, 5\0¢\;.~» %

»`m \ng 00\ 520 n 1 0va cwa Ac)» 65 &;10\ as me,\\?.

ac\n lN 1\>&_ 3% Bls“vi\\ ’c‘_‘¥ comm @F TRY\?\A\AT \m’¥\/\ "\`€_X\>c§

E)LW\¥\TE . , . mm c~z%’ o\ov\¥>@\;»\\"\€\ \\\W:R Yi m\!`\£> W=\\V\§ IS_

A\>\>\_U.\\\<.~€§ e>w;um“§ 10 we wm _ . \?mm“e>§ § ¥<>d~_"i ~s\\\w cnm_\um\&§ b% mg 10 wi mmc>m&>\x u>\>\v< §§ c\>\w\z_w\\, \\?? e\\\b il m>me_s aim '¥`\m\\\:‘> §)<>N`\S`SX'_ V\\cs `$\p\%\'\c_un\`!> b\)(}e_c.'\wm ’\.D ma Lom¥@ ‘v`mA‘wBs cz‘v` Qac;\c_&nd CD¥\C\ bs`\ons b€ mm wou\h$\no\b as§ {>\\ m\D_">`. DEY:Q:\;\~\"\ vi?\‘€sw\`-\\A;§._

u&? ou“A'm°c wu“ae.\ \\\x.\e\cm'\$ \Oa\\§§\ic_b

zw>

§rc>om§€§\' v\ <\@<, w\¢\m a <>_K\>L \)cl\\\:X\c:> €'N“\Z\~mcx`\\<\ X}f\\§ C.u$e_z. x\b Q,\I`\Ae_nu.§m‘c GC\\) A`\ 'ia\|\ov wmv¢\\¥‘

¥\G A\>N u‘oc>u\<_\nt>\» w\ce\$| S\\G’L'> m-v,‘(e_ Q`\vc. 9 \\QQ\:LCNP< clan cv\\ 5\\@., 3<\0\..>@§ 3d1th \‘4\@ T`Lc\ \or had cam\\\`\\‘xec\' ‘{e_< A\w} §\\e)< ms?w\& ah >dm_cxw¢sw\e, z Q\%N>\.”SSY @ ¥\\<.~\\u\'<\<;~ add `me>u§ eo\c\\s %L?e< `\ux\cz>‘_\\u&§w{\e \oe'm§\, S\(\e'\;

0\¥.§< c%\>m\\\l (\.0 md feca\\ am er_‘<\\l I\\r>\s mm`l 3\\0>€. we;<_e,@\rc.§. \`<\s.\>~mv\§ mm 9 We.‘\<\c,`idw\\'

~UW‘L_ m Q\ Ci)` B{)P\'\Cm\\_§(`€§€l\j\.

\\>ded\ X\_oa§<. \\{\S`(a`|\¢_\.‘r`£, (xI‘_U>\>v\X. 0

mm <\c)°\;`\'<\c§>r\‘a\§\ e_‘<\\ us`\‘d\ 1}\<, C\l`\A-Qx\c.c_= 'T\m»¥_`\:> t~_\%\§\_\\??o\~’cec\

\Yl ~thu€€.€_b`rc\» @\\BD twme.\ \?‘Cx‘®\": `\‘:~.» 60?1`\¥\%‘(\@,`\5 "Q@_\’\ Q\\ ’\{B E_\/\u¥,

B\Q. CLQP\‘\ mr\`\' ‘_)\no‘i_ V<\o'€€. ¥)nu’\_ MXXM&@ L)A\f\ex\ Ene, evié)ex\€l}©.';‘wk shst Bu\'. amc §\“Q')e.c,\\\e. web \`@_C_D\ICC\ _5@€1§?\\\;0\,5?\,,33>

ma 'Ya‘l\or em\u?s€\\am\i_$‘<\o‘;me<` §»`\\re,>WS

TY\‘). `Yu`/\m‘ Sm’°f. Cz>v\~:>\oufe,\{z§ \o`i 5\.‘3\&_0(`\&!\££,» T)&e, "’

®Y?'\u». Q\r\r\§Xo\)Y\av wm ’u;z?v\mom fox w\e,A \d\s£c $\‘d~ \0\>\\€35 of $u\\ek ‘m>\es max z §Dm\§ even c&>(¢r §ea\-c_\<\`\ng Bq¢c_¢>m§\@) 1\-§:> <\S\‘<\\@ umwa ’cm‘c_u\¥\\ \Y\& Thi \o\'

accounth i\w@. \ne,`\é\e.r\i\'_&@r \`(\<. \\0&\§15 w sod <’=Dw\e‘v.\\mg \x\e\e,¥hr‘c y

Srm.® \mm wanda '\Y\r \c\am$ ‘\`<\\\e§¥\g>a‘ceb X)Ns ma,., P\\§L> m\'\p_x\‘fml \o@

EMMX\QM §Xa’\_cment“\d\¢;\£&\q a(`.\?¥\\`r_cm \»_S\\O\'. L\Ne,\` -' § \\te,~&vme,§

&4; “\§\¢:m L.>\m\e Hr\e,\l mug `\v\. \`{\w \?x>v\ 01 UCQ\* SC€_@\Q\\\ID\‘ ‘\Y\\§‘\~L‘D

`\\'. iam\u§ fha ¢\\)‘(`I w\‘\w\c§ \ demose, *crw<\§€/\ (Y\rv\>\cr<\‘i$ t\i?u\e£ &¥3225

to ’c\r\mh 30 t\\e,‘\\> d§e, €no\.k\ X',~L\\ X§ncr.\\)\“) -A`\‘:‘<‘&%M§¥&\e_m S\M\cmev&>

"'K\\m quXexv\¢v\Xb \§\+rg__<~gj\¥\)\i wm°f_\)ecau&c. X)r\z,wc~l w %n`w\`€w mg diaz w GYY\R mm was 5\\¢<>%‘\\¢~ M‘< mm ~X¢m e‘>\ 05 X\\@s“m,,

mm as Hw, wound mpw\_ 09 '\\§\Qcc\\§ e\\c\ becausam\~§nc,`w man ~ ®Y`O\m\\)w\s t:».?`\r\\`\£)(\ -\5'\<>:/ US€_.J`:.WM §§ch SX€B(QMQ,\(\XS £0 a@@x~cmeh

1;\\&. flw\\cun‘r_ coh\r\`c,\\om Y\\s<> SQLM\B mva cz\f \>RQ¢@\S ve.\\¢e\ on ’€mm §¥u\'em@_n¥_% 'Wm’c. UQY\§CCM\ 5\\0\. m\>\X-\Q\e. \\w\c£, 310 gmm Q\P\\\U'“)(

m¥ex\[.\ 23 ¥B\’\l\\ \)v¥\n "Yn`/ \vv find Q\ov\d,, ®

mm \\arv‘\':> QDY\\\>?,A\»_A mt`\ ’L was §0:>3'\‘“\@, ~‘¢\m`t Sc>\~¢\e. § 15\@,5\“@"€5 Q.`\i§r\o_\' m‘\§‘>ec\ H\e, mo c\\‘r`\~.<‘ Q,\\| m pusseA ‘r_‘nfou§§\n \-.\n& cs§e_(\ m`m&>\..>- `le$ mm \\arf\:z C~‘_cm\e,»u§ wk\\'t¥\e%e.¥hegr~} 09 L,:,\cu\< ‘no&\)w¢&

to ‘\:¥\¢c>’d\<’_r bu\\e§t:. T¥\c§.`\§ c\e.‘? ic.imt”?c&'ermance,\o‘/` mv \\M‘<\'§\‘ocm\)se, _ C\i\d?\`\¢;m\*\_ U>Y\Xu\\f, Jérw{‘c D. l ‘iea\' \0€§0<‘€_ \cr\a\ ma$ e\wcn§e;’v a\%@`oe§c~>m ‘d`\o\ \\<>‘<

\`(\x %n\<\e>/ \ A\$o o?§)\\ LcmX_\mA A amm§m 0\3 \-be_ emma wave a\~_r_\\\v§ W\v \\M\c“\ 5 m\\# s>xr£c¢ Qo\mh csm.\m\\c;\_ mendez @Qg\\~mv\¥ e>v\\\l :‘>\m)’< am e;w\/\<>. \\I\'< &\oxr'\s§cx\)`rk w mem `\X \m`€~ \\Y\e. ‘ms 0sz

C_\`\m`< maf> 5\\§0\`\05 W\M`c_ bC\rwu\"\ B‘<\:;A_`\me.("\r \\61\'€\`5 AQS>XYG`I€¢\ ~\\\e, ‘dm>. »'LWY\\ mm!\ am\'\\>\\“\¥~l 139 bus& swo’cm\o§ @ue.'*<\me,» (\\§D‘.X:r\ ‘©<\n\\m‘\§ c§&\mxa;\ 2b g~\`{\\< \Nm\§ »§m}\*‘<\r\?mo§: w`\v\hc~>\os ama X\\e_§me 69 '“\K.Q\o‘<\ej£a\` mem §§ E'.v\ \ T`(\o§ `\‘c_\.¢o_% %m\ unsup§b€\£§ \o`l ‘\k\e_reco\”és §e,€.§?\?\\\{o\.‘§ \P?_‘LZ 5» \5) \`v<\a h ®:<‘<\e, \.\S\r\c\r>m§ `\‘<\ 3v_$\e,\re.\r\ac,\'e_ mem L'>Q en is § \`\v\c. \:> \§‘u\; mwccz\plkl "l (~"c.°(w‘c u\\ 59 X)r\&m§ ‘Z> &.\.>\uc)m>v\e,mas .'a\o sack ?‘A’(\. `Y\\¢Ymc wiv\Ao\J 1 O~J\ +_\\L me rem door °. \® 635wa wm adam s ?1\\1\<¢1@§ 5\’\_ emma kLS\X\<\ XX\Q_X,\Q<) §m\a‘< dow w\~'(\¢;\z>m§ §>p€.~m` \;’> X\\ex<.u\,\w>‘< zx\?oss/ § X\;\`\W ->énc.,£ c>X§nex 5\<\£>‘<‘) wm M\xe/'i \\X 1065 cian `.\Q_X¢\~i .\L\wo$ c§)\o \\\¢ ’cm \m\\\~@\>-‘c 511`¢<\&¢3“@\5 ¥\M-XB'\"\¢\€§Z \\D\X ie§» i’)o\c \'§c\e,?'o,c.‘< s\:\\ §\w&,$ _ 'L\'\u’c. ¥_\r\e C.‘C‘\me.§€.cf\€. S<’.u\“ c,\n C>\>Q'i<‘..cx Q't>\>w\,d m\\~l @vxe‘o\m\`\e)r Sce®w\w\\\\\m

15»€\)» _ k ®

- 155-mdc deed c\\\_ "c_\<\c ‘0\;\\€_}<5 v ¥c>..(\:`\v§’r_o? Y`{\\'chbl \0\‘ 6\‘\<\

ne>+_ am upg\ “\a~# \o\~ said aqq\\mm 5th at wm w\\\\@ aug \.>e.w_\<\w&<)<_\\e,\s max e>c¢@w\m.¢\ w\»

\§63 mle ind @P\'\wvi €\rv>’c mm 9\\1€"3’€. *c‘;\<).c`c\<‘v md ~€\IU\_\\L miss` marc A\A ‘&xe. 5\¢\§¥§ 35 113? 9 ba\\i§\’\aex$?ev”¥_ mm\§>\me, Q\`c>

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI