Daniels, Raymond

• Court: Texas Supreme Court
• Decided: November 3, 2015
• Docket: WR-48,289-08
• Status: Published

Opinion

."W.C.\.N fl § mcu?>~ L\L\DMXC . ' 0 w C' \’M'

-CD\.L\P\\c o§ CQ(»W;\Q/A mm\> QW‘W\'D@B\N:£\$~§Q. » n Ugd' 3 8@’0§

1 ¢`\N>§"\QBS be- YDLC§L'.> §OLC\\,L QD\.N`)\'KO C’..C>\O.S`\&~c€`-

ND\D C_DW\&& Q \D\N\ \:Xo/\Br\o `\"P\_¢,l@ s\©@\\(`;a\\

\\5 \\¢\.\Q.(`A,\d 0 €’, ama \M>\r ex loA \.\.)v\a.\h S\\¢>\.§ §\~e, Y\\lx\\o\.) \_~:§Uuw Q'Ltuse‘, al _ _1 l

l \. ¥\QQ\ CL\»>< R was `3(\¢\\>\5( A“\!\ %\\OX"\D 55 D¥ ¥'(lc§\j) L O.\.o>` Cb\$;§>.% cwa csx \_;:w ‘P

C;:\\Q, Ke\o~\'\“ §\,\&¢\Luu,\ \\.';R,\f \»c§( C_O\L\`X D¥ R~E>)AQ C_D\).\dd¢\)§`(`?/\u‘.> \ g \‘:->\o \d ‘\'\¢\P, \§¢0\13¢0\\.\,9 §`;“j W\l S

N\?X\%‘L S\K\\O\U.Q. \’;`> web D'.cCu.vcc\e mo `)cO R¢\r~€ Q,O\.>.E\ D§ CK \ \M mm\ “w€u\$

¥\. .\_\~§E¥¥ E.c;r\\\& C)£>S »S`-€a.\oc,e D§( CD\MO">E/\; TQ\\CL\ C_D\.uo§e.\ \\G£)\r C»B.u§r \~§:n§ \N\a\&€

\Amo 3 z> Cc>umse\ %§\§'£;x\:\:§ Q¢D\Q Q€\QS \\mes~\ @3,`\0¢0 cuo& CLP¢ ewe_§c>\§t_€(v§.\ S@,e_ §\( &\$~\€ \\:u\>\\km cpSD S\D §§ ':6&§ S`s§") T£\c. Q\_\W\. M\>»K\°\°sz\. ' E@EWED §N

» @oum' oFcRnM\NALAPPEALS F ' Nov 03 2915

l 9 g ’ Az@@w\@@§@a,©e@ve<

%. l15\\\\) ‘€-_C.A\§vi\§¢> mixe.c_i&s§@m \r> \\z§\,¥u\\:§

"\\;\»E&_,\`\ \e. \,S we_`\\\/\,\ev a §v¢_ _§¢, \;)u\R - €QDSOWNKQ. c§.e,g,i€s€o\s d ¥,\L Qa\P-\e. Qc§cj 5~ 13']»' S;.\o.:saaH;%~»W)~ »\e»%.c~v?,l,¢.»;%…‘ ' oo§.).

C,.v C§>\\\JS€:\$ ¥u\s\ \_,;\,_\3 E', `SS'D _"’d\\()u> Cl \e&§\`\'\ W\“CC\'C S\,\\~>Qo€,\bt\ @¥Oc,es.s o \3 w`.<\,\\>ee$ `§\,\molQe>sa$

w\m usa; R\vo_ B\r\\)e@; o¥ Mxe_ \\\P\/\lc,\e ma \¥\\e_

m3 0? Nv>\). `\,\ ’AO\\ `\5 a\)©\a\‘m@ 0? (e`“‘

\:w»d\ Cmv\‘i)u\$b\sf:j §\mr,e&$ v B., bc§$\`\t.mjs< bci I`\\:es R\\<'Ar \\e 5305€ § \&M‘€Jg

OY QM§\¢.\.§:_ 0 k\.\\?, ammxe man »m¢¢,\;w.. S\€\°m\\)t€ \j\i>, hrs Dq\~e§ C<.C.\'c>\\@v_ \s\QO\’)\ .

G\DA §mo\~>.c\s\;\ \g\ QC> \Z , 365 §\(\\`»\/):3¥§ ”\A\ 0`\:>5\ Q> \, `md R$P\\cou\_s 'N\E.w\o\$cw&um 0¥ L&Q ' O\€Se.\k.'\€§ W\\\\§¢\ \:\`~S VQS>\- ` @Du\?{wl‘¢oo \,0&»`\7 » \&»D ¥'»\L\\..\n`\\> \>3¢_€ € W\o\‘.\ec§~ "\\cb V\Me,,\\omuabl€

hc\§‘&\ AQ'DS‘\)"\ \ C;’.\*€I\(< §§ CD\.\("\~ O¥C¢`»w\-» '\M`~~@\\ \Q,Ww\§ C>cA. &"4*‘\ QO\S. '

%.. RQQ\\R.\L\\\ “¢“`%ui>.s \\Q, Q\EQXH§ ¥09\ él!wow‘¥\o \l?\\,\\ ;\\{. :LW>*\\ %:,SX¢~W,& CM\ m ex \-\\mes>\\oy\oa % Co\\ec{:c\ va§¥mo\& §Q¥§§-

v\/\m dow CO\\JC,~@_\H\)`\@ w ' ‘\ €~, 10, l Q)\vo§ (;\\~u\§ow_s \)00\:3\-¥:0 §§ S\€c\/» P. D.

C>¥ §.o,~e\rs \)0\4\0 w\od~e \\#\\P,`\ ~P ¢\ 310 5 j SeL\\rQ.\/\ ®Y Q‘L\\ @\\bmt,mo §Sf:auc,\,¢ ioop .

_91€_50\0¢ Se,e %_d('\\‘»l>l¥=s {\“ &"C/'

QO\ 1

W"

1 1111\11@.11 111 515 1111 111 @1>\ 1111et 1133

\)0\1§§€10 §0 §§1~€_ 110¢1¢§1‘€,13§ 010 11€5"\', 13 \

015 %\\1\1\13\31 § CL\€>O 151€£11*13`\€& 1~/\0§'\1‘€, ®‘9.10` 111)¢11 Qo§`\c‘ QGU\\\'L‘)§\OD \DQ` T Rv§ 11DY1 Q\\~e& 1131`1`11101`1,'1/1‘€. %15§111,`\ Q.\~e\f\'§ 1\'\€>\)&1\/\\11~111 111“\€1(_`)1"1 aka olch §,w\ §1> 111>111§ 01 1111 111 111\ 1\1>1>~11111 6,\112\1

1\\€\ 1\1>,®§§1°1 010 ®c:§c)\o~eQ §Ol‘“®o\§.-

aug/acl /_1.`0_%\ j\l\ 15 D¥¥~€\\]$€ Q?_Q(NX \`)D(`\`\Y\“?O 1311 \3£;$1§ ‘€Q

SF~e,\ 91 Q&\~\o§ 15 L\)\B@m¢ §\11¢;1`,§1`\ Nb§ Q>€zw 1~,\1 1\91>\1@110§\ 011;>1§ §§1¢1,`\7 LO~ 1

113\110 15 b§§\\c>e& § \W`\§\‘e§‘*` 05 63

§\)1€5\`1 10 S& L,\A &Qp\veaw§;j 0-,£\1 10§01>3 0110&§>;01€:\/\01\1>1)\10_011>\3 C,OM`§"¢, 1061 101-1615 f o.o§\¥c>mo 01 140 1101\ 1\11>1 \101) gwo

1 l\ is CC>\MO§`>€_\ :SO_,\M€§ \1 Toc,m 'u>u$) 10&11>1°.0`1'111@,

§'091 \\')D§ § 1`§\110 (`)~91€, \1`11:1\ 111&111123 1§\©§1&§0 5\1\(§>[\&011€311~¢1`§\1`1:_&1\1\`\0§11>11>1'¢:(k \_X 1155 §§ 1: QD\%\R-, C§\L~€_ §l>\l§§§~& \l\`\®\u§1\;§":$:`1"'(1 3 k§§>\\;cho\:> L\»;" B`“‘ C>“\ '\"\ "‘ va\@\>t§\

weo§ 1_1\5\ \m§~e& §\11€ \1\31§{6\ §§oc\£$ Cmos§ 11 10101

gm k&@\\cm§( vi 1145 §\L\L\\ QGR `1\!1011>\\115 §§\LCD\N&\~

BRQD\~.§¢£(BL G_ wm $`?§ub£ §§ \§1 1`\ k 0\1€¢»)`1 DQ Y~,`$&~QO\' \\13 9\\;§@_ Cu115] 0110;>01,11$

\\'1@€& `o.S\>L 1\11>_ 1010`*‘~ Cow‘§ 11 “S:\)\}Qs\,\ 1110 1 1159 §\110` 311 31 111 QO\\~€,C: \1&1§ e‘ 009/1111 QOO` 1131~11_1£55 %uc)AOQ»sus

¢' 4 \\C‘C\\m\e,a}r D‘r\' ;c‘.c:\§ ` LL. RW\§M.J\' NO)\A€:> \\~\usr a C,¢`\W`\.\>Q\A~e¥e.¢xc~¢\

\$> \mX cc\\ou> games 'Arz>' a\\I\A\xes¢¥ich\&>o

\)\e§ml`\s N\O\§.£ §§\3 C\\?_'S\oc\~e§ clva §§ ‘{§M€Sx¢`\o DYY§Q»&QB \ E;\\oé\ \\;\u§r Ar\\€, c>\\»\\»> §ch \L~e_@w§ \DQM{@ \,j

0§§\¢,€¢5 be R,\\e, 930-emc R\\c& wu:>, CX\)CX`\\¢,\\A\L §§ R¢\¢€_ `D\A\’A\(\,»L‘, `\B gy\/\;\mxf’ B\ \D\i\.:.(`_,\/\ \_'3 D¥%UO§€_ Q€,§>D("\c w¢`$\'-\~CU

§\::SDY¥~`\L+Q §e_\\»(>t_ §A\Mo§ LG\m>

m%¥\.\é\\¥\¢\ en w (L N\c\\(~a N\\Q §§ \RS;.\ : wm qb D

C,o\} c;\uf<)lc>w§ 0\\- LQLD

l. Si\)b \\§o~'@ T€.\QLLS Qb\`\c,e §§e§>w‘\l\med( N\cm\m\\ `\ 5 a\dv:~\o\ \0\>@ Rr\¢\\m. \A§€§c~ \_a»o §on ma Se\\\)§r,e~s.. Q\u\e°‘\ [D 5<\¢&€_5

§ ~\-\\e.l?>\\'\`r`\c»e& \.0\/® \f\)\u\§ §§ \\z\/x€ £u!ves+ `N\\)§A¥ Y»\\\~€; a QWD 99 \R QP_\OG\Y 5 \\/\»e£>v;, `

Q\»x\~?_%~ Cw e/ gov Q'~f D \Jg~T-€.\Lu§ \_.0 CcL\ - Q~c>\}?_\& \va\en)`\c QOA'€,S€¢.\L`\§@OS\ 3 Se¢, \L\_z.o<>\'\,<>0§.\ \w\@\<;“,¢j \‘»\M>. Q \:X€> G~\Q& Q\<>_gu.\a§iow.a Q¢or W\\x\§c;\ §>\A Q©\io.exug)cm C\NeCov‘/l~

Q\Qd¢`\,o\s DY Q'e\s*\-c{\vo \>CDL€A»\ML\ S\\€-,Ds.;

é>c) \'\ \ £\\.5`0 C)§¥ `»Q:Q\S 3 \}`\©\u\.`\ 05 \\/\A‘€SC QLL.\€.§ y'\; ;`0\¢€\;§\

' \\\\Q, \_cLu:»S b 9 R\me SL¢¢\L §§ `T~e)£c¢$ ,

@mgdl \_Q¥\U&§m c ©K€.w}se_s Cc>m€<§é&ec\\ RQQ\§¢,QQ\ §\SGL\/\f> §§ C\q~& Ct>w\\c 0? C,£\\\!v\`\\oo\\ MOQ.OL\§ %QQ Q€/\;f& §bf\'\ §§ `\\\ .@\'CLMY-\ue|.wm\)\ "‘<'c Q&_c€ Ar\‘\£ D\§ \®\\\ Uu\ \\\0§$)\;§§\¢“6©`\ D$\ D.\?Ar;& wm ‘:;@\M\\ ©:SM;& QM» §MAI¢ U§L\\%A S\<\:\&)qu PbQ CL %\): fu\€cw \/\`%Cm`\\\>';§ \'U `©W)A.\)\C:€. `\1\’\~& ()’Q$\A DQ¥`\@£Q. ©~T\Y;Mf,;;:¢l>§@ ~¥0 \\Q\\P_\§ `£\\}Q\§Cm§»§ B`\\' \*\, \.B~\N\e Vv\e\)\ Q§C\\\\§ §§ &\)\~C ©\”L\,c.‘e$§'

C‘mo§z 11 ¥u\b&uwue¢\)\@\\\j §O\;JQ\YJ`\QL\,

\_»\\\JS\QOQ\\\ 0 € C\u vul'{,a>») `IQ_Q£>£§R%N?¢~>AD¢>~Z.@.\~V Q. S~\a`Lt_ \\¢\\o\`\ `\"¢\

Q~L¢\--c/,vm...»'\_; _qO_ T m Q_o\z ~z ec_x: A~c> C\\_~¢ \z as L. ¢;L(`_» wa le ::..-\~.-¢.1:‘4»

m>§>, * *

f

‘;,) §§ C>¢_Sc 10 - 10 \§>