Crippled Children's Hospital School v. Comatsos

418 S.W.2d 432, 57 Tenn. App. 282, 1966 Tenn. App. LEXIS 207
CourtCourt of Appeals of Tennessee
DecidedApril 22, 1966
StatusPublished

This text of 418 S.W.2d 432 (Crippled Children's Hospital School v. Comatsos) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Tennessee primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Crippled Children's Hospital School v. Comatsos, 418 S.W.2d 432, 57 Tenn. App. 282, 1966 Tenn. App. LEXIS 207 (Tenn. Ct. App. 1966).

Opinions

OABNEY, J.

This is another chapter in the story of the protracted litigation over the estate of John George [285]*285Comatsos. See Crippled Children’s Hospital School and Joseph Bearman et al. v. Nina Comatsos, 48 Tenn.App. 617, 349 S.W.2d 178, and Bearman v. Comatsos, 215 Tenn. 231, 385 S.W.2d 91.

Mr. Comatsos died on September 28, 1958, -while on an extended visit to his native Greece. He was a naturalized citizen of the United States. A resident of Memphis, Tennessee, for many years, he had accumulated property in Greece and Memphis the value of which is roughly estimated at $100,000. ■ -

Mr. Comatsos made regular visits to Greece and in 1947, while visiting in Greece, Mr. Comatsos married the present appellant, Mrs. Nina Comatsos. He was 58 years of age and she was 25 years of age. She has a son by a former marriage. She and Mr. Comatsos had no children. Mr. Comatsos had been a boyhood friend of her mother.

After their marriage in 1947 Mrs. Comatsos came to Memphis, Tennessee, where she lived with. Mr. Comatsos for a short time. She was not satisfied to live in America and returned to Greece to make her home. She is and has and at all times been a non-resident of the United States and a citizen and resident of the country of Greece. At the time of his death Mr. Comatsos was 69' years of age and his widow, Mrs. Comatsos, was 36 years of age.

Before Mr. Comatsos left for his last visit to Greece in September, 1956, he had his will drawn by his attorney and longtime friend, Hon. Joe Bearman, of the Memphis Bar. Under the terms of this will he left one-third of all his property to the appellant, his wife Mrs. Comatsos, and the other two-thirds he devised mostly to charities in Memphis, Tennessee, and in Mytilene, Greece, along with legacies to some friends, relatives and associates [286]*286including- Mr. Bearman, who was to receive $1,000. Reference is made to the opinion of this Court in Crippled Children’s Hospital School and Joseph Bearman et al. v. Nina Comatsos, 48 Tenn.App. 617, supra, for an extended list of the beneficiaries under the Bearman will.

On November 23, 1957, while still in Greece Mr. Com-atsos executed a second will generally referred to as the Greek will and he also executed a written document purporting to revoke the Memphis or Bearman will. Under the Greek will Mrs. Comatsos is the sole beneficiary of all the property of Mr. Comatsos. Our Tennessee Supreme Court, in an opinion by Mr. Chief Justice Burnett of date December 11, 1964, in the case of Bear-man v. Comatsos, 215 Tenn. 231, 385 S.W.2d 91, upheld and affirmed a judgment of the Circuit Court of Shelby County, Tennessee, sustaining the validity of the Memphis or Bearman will and disallowing the probate of the Greek will.

This appeal does not involve the legality of the Memphis will nor Mrs. Comatsos’ rights thereunder. This litigation concerns the legal title to two parcels of commercial real estate located in Memphis, Tennessee, formerly owned by Mr. Comatsos. They are now valued at approximately $65,000. Mrs. Comatsos claims full fee simple title by virtue of two deeds executed by Mr. Com-atsos while in Greece on July 1, 1958, in her favor. The deeds were acknowledged by Mr. Comatsos before the American Consul in Greece on July 22,1958, but were not delivered to the Register of Shelby County, Tennessee, for recording until October 8, 1958, after Mr. Comatsos had died on September 28, 1958.

It will be remembered that the Crippled Children’s Hospital School and Joseph Bearman, legatees and bene-[287]*287fieiaides under the Memphis or Bearman will of Mr. Comatsos,- had first filed suit in the Chancery Court of Shelby County in 1958 shortly after the death of Mr. Comatsos to set aside the two deeds as having been obtained by Mrs. Comatsos under fraud, undue influence and duress.

Chancellor Frazer recused himself because Mrs. Frazer was an officer of the School. Betired Circuit Judge Harry Adams was designated by the Supreme Court to hear the cause. The Chancery Court granted the relief, set aside the deeds and divested title out of Mrs. Comatsos.

This Court reversed because the Memphis or Bearman will had not been finally admitted to probate in Shelby County, Tennessee, and the original complainants, Crippled Children’s Hospital School and Joseph Bearman, as legatees, were not entitled to contest the deeds executed by Mr. Comatsos. The suit was not dismissed but held in abeyance pending the outcome of the proceedings to probate the Memphis or Bearman will. A receiver was appointed to collect the rents from the realty and Mrs. Com-atsos was placed under injunction from encumbering or disposing of the two parcels of land. Shortly after our Tennessee Supreme Court on December 11, 1964, upheld the Memphis or Bearman will the original complainants, Crippled Children’s Hospital School and Joseph Bear-man, Executor et al. on January 15, 1965, filed an amended and supplemental bill in the cause in Chancery Court seeking to have the two deeds under which Mrs. Comatsos claims title to the two parcels of commercial real estate set aside.

On April 30,1965, Chancellor Designate Adams entered an interlocutory order nunc pro tunc for April 22, 1965, [288]*288adjudging the two deeds under which Nina Comatsos claimed title to have been procured from her husband, John George Comatsos, by fraud,' undue influence and coercion. He set aside the deeds, divested title out of the defendant, and vested title in Joseph M. Bearman, Executor of the estate of John George Comatsos.

The decree of April 22, 1965, recited in part as follows:

“This cause came on to be heard on April 22, 1965, upon the motion for a final decree on the pro confesso heretofore taken on the 7th day of April, 1965, upon notice of the motion to the defendant, Nina Comatsos, upon a setting of the case on the Ten-Day Buie Docket, upon the original bill, upon the intervening petition of Joseph M. Bearman, upon the amended and supplemental bill filed by Crippled Childrens Hospital School and Joseph M. Bearman, and upon the entire record, and the Court is of the opinion that upon all of the same there is sufficient (proof) on which to base a ruling for the relief prayed for and, therefore, grants the motion for a final decree on pro confesso.
“Prior to a hearing on all the foregoing, the defendant, Nina Comatsos, in open Court, made an oral motion for a continuance of this matter for a 30-day period in order to enable her to secure counsel, and the Court, being of the opinion that such motion for additional time is not well taken, denied said motion. ’ ’

On May 3, 1965, Mrs. Comatsos, acting by and through her present solicitor, Mr. Thomas Buford, filed a petition to set aside the pro confesso of date April 7, 1965, and the decree of date April 22, 1965, and prayed to be allowed to file an answer. She tendered a sworn answer denying all of the allegations of the original bill.

[289]*289On May 13,1965, the Chancellor entered an order overruling the petition to set aside the pro confesso of date April 7, 1965, and the interlocutory decree of date April 22, 1965.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Maryland Casualty Company v. Gordon
371 S.W.2d 460 (Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 1963)
Hinton v. Robinson
364 S.W.2d 97 (Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 1962)
Bearman v. Camatsos
385 S.W.2d 91 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1964)
Town of Alamo v. FORCUM-JAMES COMPANY
327 S.W.2d 47 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1959)
Reese v. Hake
199 S.W.2d 569 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1947)
Wood v. McFerrin
61 Tenn. 493 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1873)
Bank of Jamaica v. Jefferson
22 S.W. 211 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1893)
Gamble v. Waters
274 S.W.2d 3 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1954)
Columbia Production Credit Ass'n v. Polk
276 S.W.2d 737 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1955)
Harris v. Naff
360 S.W.2d 6 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1962)
Crippled Children's Hospital School v. Camatsos
349 S.W.2d 178 (Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 1960)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
418 S.W.2d 432, 57 Tenn. App. 282, 1966 Tenn. App. LEXIS 207, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/crippled-childrens-hospital-school-v-comatsos-tennctapp-1966.