Crank, Alex, Ii

Texas Supreme Court·Decided November 3, 2015·No. PD-0203-15·Published

Opinion

-?©3 -IS

s^ptrz- ^{<?&smr <£AAX-K NOV 03 205

ORIGINAL *******

NOV 03 2015

r Abel Acosta, Cierk

fc£tf£Ytf&*f<5- APA?2-LA*n)S ASTpZAkSAS, CUT-6f -7^*1^/ P£7T?T?Ofi/

f%£7l5£ M>7ZZ7^y ^^'*A= T&^r <?&G/jeLTlJi &V£J*/&- <*rf *?

A/-So &ACLoS£T> A££ <LoPtt?> oF; Atevz /^otz&/A J

UMOV&l ^ tnjev&J <st>PBT$ (c/s ?-7-/ir) ; AMP, AneW1** Ovr-or-T^jfcr. l>r«, R*\T. j VOX** ^^ ****"*» *** A^r "uktABu; To Fo(L<*JM&K , TH£ ^>IS /*"** of cooer -T*>ez> Pot ffrvxpe. Ats At>^uat^ Airpejs^. p^trASS R.ouT£ -Ttte<S£ AAQTirorfS To THe ?Rj>S&cxATOfK *

"7fM*/£- ¥&J fttL YoUR. ASS*ST7W<^ 3*f Tft£*£ MATTERS,

Zll—J- • ??73L /=^. ?&>?G' Or*-)

In Ttt€ dougT &F ciA&KWAL APPe**-* *? T^**s Ak. Pt>-0£LQ3-/5 _ ^JJt^JL^S^A/j^M. _ ^JJ^&^^sezuZAL^AV*^.

T7&r $rm& aATZ&Fs "TZitt&^r ga 7&X4S

AWo-rz&AA AS* fretf&tX&AAg-

-~~ &>/ne^ Ate&A,« ^^^'faLj.^fei^^ ^A&>re- S?Y*jeZ> A&*» .AAsTMAeXEfr 4AV&4T A/V& A?&&°£ziTtev^-y

<2)*?0&~o<i-Q&iaq~<L& &z2>£p£zp *sf *£-£<?-/! f *re>&-Q<!~Qoi&l-cn _rtr_sirgr> ^/ ^/i-fl 9 c) ^OS^O*}^ <D&f0'?~C£ ZE/s/C&Z&exT /H4/wg»47g- j*a

„, eY **3> ~p3.fr W2» Fjxey _w HH^-i^ \ •W i-iiiiiii-biih-jii—i^i-imb ii iwiummini.nii, iii'iiih—i hip ii iiin mi-i i. ...T••.. 1 1 ii •„ i.».iJ..ii,.,——•,.,•„• . .. •„•• .— .. ... , 1^.„. _,-nm,|U

J^LMp&turt Pp-ezcZ'/s- Repo^a oat fo-tV-/6rf ^^mmg^&jaM Ab~oa-o?••/$ A5z-gt> £/A_AA>^=£r/^

A<AAe2^/?Mr A/as <&&*# 7?&: dipy/tr- A/&*>f? or tw& ^efpezTZiv: A^*?73t7fe* OAAPfitrLt^TZ? SjPt/A&eZ-; 3W <r/fi*r^ bAA~ VOL 4-7/-*/ fr%ff GAAAfreVy Aa/Z> APA^A+a^^d^us^ «7& /=&-* AAjtS hb>/}«j>6£ ATrrsyi^Ar at- A PA\Qp£fiL P&rzrrxvA/ Az>& '7>^d&£-73zw#eV #&Aft?W{ 1>ag /Q~*&~l<r^ ^^cveg/ By tfertrsxitfe- Mrs t5~*~PAG& 0 i/_ng,tfcgxy oat (c-iq~\5f two-Vg: 7>AYs fferpoizgri-fric T>>>.k, WAS GMe+J "frOS, -3V4.gr> A^TZba/ S/A?ujs TMgr d&cs/zr**

/,

Af&r h>-&*0?~{<

_fe3#.„:Z^„J^^^^ -2to&33S^jr^33^^^

Tfre: "nrm.e *p? T>£P^^>awt^ £M&usr&vcy 9 // g*__- Abe AAA

AhH> Sxr&AATFxiLMJT 3L£X>I> Z-oSS aaO> BfZAsm/ 2>M4<S--7? TtfAT

yg 7&*TzrpYc ; ^-tms^; 71&rS /&*/***£££: &UAL7- Has B&ert -/TteA&cx&V-Y >^_&z^y>M^c_r /wc <7Xjx*t. apcfj*rS4r*. /5 Y A/3rS 3r*7Sr AMr0£#S;

(k) t ^^^H 7>e5ffttfC APAjS^UAA/T^ lbJZPAXV*r73&A/ OA? <&An??*rrv*73iMSjn- fiz&#r*S amp AteaA£L£z*era? A? A OAaran> 3r#7&5 ^TzrmcV -7Wse0v&#g&7' -7^0r^ £*A7X3aAr .Sg^^gfZ, TZitt ^Att> <£s>ir£*i^oA _zrs /"u>/>gg AualY £~Xf£A&*/<£X> JTa/ APP4&u**rAs &TAMC& P&r< T&sc, &&sf aatj> jts a sz^^7?W7sm^ ^£Afr£*i\/&MT*/& tZzriLtx/A+s-rwGe _ AcPperz^Arfr P/zAV^ Tfcrs £av&r-

AAP&Mi+ASr PAAIA3 T7AZ5 tauter ACC&Tr SAz~I> 37XLUCM. Penr*1>irset &ev, (p>-.oio3^/5; A ^ As Mars Sas^P W 7%Sg^^g-e^^APA. Aal*^,j &/££ *7&f. Amp 7*k, &< APA, P/&*-,/'•&"* -2*r.Axs* ^Assmc &AArz&L&S7-

^£g?fr_ £e&/u£*x- AtoJAZ^J Ah*z&At& *T& Pk£&-£W7~A

fA&AxCATXDfi/ AtS£> AATSdeATPOCT T^ A43r5£: A /e&WS€>A/A}£l*e 7&O0T 7&9M 7Z& 61 U&5-TZVA/ AurAV P&0A* "7&*r tn/Ay A*V> -pePfrZVirt, VettMPAiST *A Ar P*Z& Tlbxat , Al09££±S XAAA2>€XkUA7e:

z.*

„* .Az#&*A*Ar ^???^g? r^aj-tgza^:^ £3&***/£rt&{.t fVi-Uf ao&l> pTterrtf / AA& J£^^ /fafiAFSTY -A3^_AAQ^J&£^3>£Z*!£y * ,

^§I^^J3^^..JmAiUXm^v ,...-.

.A&S&g&A^mAZL.

J7p,ct^r #> fi/^rfsSL 3f"7-2. AZMr3&>**, AhtVATSKY C/a^t ,^?^^^7v^.2^fc^, *77l£&U-

A?A&rrttrzA~ri£ csfc .^ng t/3*_r

A A^A^ <3&vyfyjFy, A££^&:akZ^~£gJg%^^

3nf$A5, ~3*> ,H&£B«%. £gg3-ae&..:Otor^^ ^g££JA,t #F XfWA JkSA>T^AL^A^-J^^mS3B^A^, ,AA£jg2^Aa!&l£, PeTPAAWAAf 0tsr-&F-TZM£\ Pe^rrxoA/ A*? ~Z2tx<laijc7*z>asaAY

._^_.__»-" aovAjr 0A? &zx*wml AA>A><e>rz-*y Ate,£*x fel3c$ .AaffiEafyZfr/i Kllr7S.4--J5EugL-Z2lm. aaggi^-^e^z^--LJ5^agC

AVoz&Ss &xvw =*A TV/gr T&c, Pr A?A. Pjz*<l. / T& ££ __ fvt-Wfte$><£& AT MT& '?>&eA&Tzz>Al& .,., ,, ,•.. ,.

^_^_aL_£_J_fe_^_C Z2><c^Tr ^aa*2C£jglL

^^m/£^7SM^^IJc^Z^Z.2>^/^

2^

UN3VORH ^-f™^, ^ ^e

pefiTvfiX THi tone*"

^^2-2 ^y of _Z£J. --

ftHHO Vol**** —-

*z<gnAi ^•AAt 3

7735"/

f,

'z T40 jLVi-S- *W4. : %£^*r>** ">v£i?t.

' ^ *XW&^X #ZY„*A^ ^ * "••'-•- . , _frt ?.?P<Mfi/v <tA*V &*/..*>$ ^*-i 7^.^' '-S^X-H ** *AW^S

sf-fg.

_ -A* <Af.fi"**? VIA* 3*? yi* M-AJV: ?*•{*** w *r&A- ^& y *x jj £.' V^ *>

---at- -a- ?.jy 'y~A. t* \?J :X ^ -j*.^ li>il<|fl'l|'i||>|l['li||i|»l|ili|i|<'lptH|tiliiiH!l|||i|-]it:{itll' Ki-/ ?$r*vj 0fr-80-T4040-££4ZJf Z40SS8T5E44 IDS t i ... ,*f> . in a

S-^/i A*^ 'M "3- T.A d^VMilO- OX 3 1SVNH \Afort~, aassaaaav sv aiavysAnao ion .*i„ £.W^&A

-t'-'^> '' '4,8 4, 3 JX IN jn e )/?••& &-&aa 1 _j ' r* ? r a ^ fy Zw* £JL •£& A>&£$ A* 9- £.A 3 V V AffCLO^^ S^xAf ^ %i J^^ \/ 3$, o&g <>£>?.£-

M jj r j\- -?4V A »"t/A"» '* J. '>?-»5 «"<a_ >?^ *W /* *#<£ 3> */ J» "» ^ a? "-i- ^i4/ -jr-i-

A

'•&#

s? t -.

. S- T*f€ •&******* *<>* P?tIA/& T#£ **P&Wj G*f1-Ot-Ts**€

f# AfttlLJ** t2*ApAV*f A>*}L,

t//-* 7^.j.**/. cot/*7 erf r*i* ^°~ ti*.y *rf ^<-*

e g.A2Sn?&Ai As*S* ts<* - 7y/-*«

,TTZ*f* Mf»"7'o A*<*' *<« ^^r"^

if A&fit***'' #i.cci«*P t4*~***»t£ SW ^ ***•"* fA -A

?,

P$a, ..<,-._ i, „„,,,.

13* 7s'f't /V-V 'f 3 A£-£Z/f& UA&At A^ %A*&t*J *£&&£> AA&SA" Ao*Z TH£. ptt&V**5'*'1* t ST*-****™* AA* , AS ?#t.ie<#s :

/ \ t ijttK *s ?,** ** *A* +•& &V A&tt-#T-~

7^ ***** * wm : ?-.**' sv, ****** »>" >*,*'<*"»*** An£&£** A*m*<$ / f **•**p " A *• "•' J "• S¥ a. ^UV^S US***, A«r> LrxS-rm, *A< £ r* >£ 3o*AH ** *n *'

ft) T//_>-5 ^/*5<F £V^.5 ttfZ&JfAAtV AS<iJ&s*VP T'^ ''"^

AfVJ> t j<si .'\/5 J* e 7* & <~< - •*•**.

as*. y<i-<&•-bote** ~f*

-j ., ^ < TMV **f Wil,?**** Wt* €.- %e

Mj s a rrt t1 aAd ls 8a ^^ , r^> Mj£.-7AMo 7*2 Al Cover tfice**** /S fj) AA?<<i««T J* A&o»- A**?«*, >*-

KA) ,^cS „,-,«* PASCAL XJSASliyrV.

Iff***,**,****"""- ;*• 7^- A^^rt^>/^ *AtU#* to** * %^3S<S ^^S-^^^ ^fe A.->A**LA*n/

^w5f Tts. ^^/^" ,^^'^ ^1J/^^ Af*V<rM&X4 At*** &>**•*«** JOSS.

jRi Sf£ ci f yt. t- V Sue ^> ? - e~x>t

APfi £ *AiAf ?/A<f "*? ? ~*>/y4 1< SzpTmsgn n, -2-© rff Aft £ •% ttfrf/f/^^ iS,

~Pat-€~&

3$j£ / „**<~5!>& 5*w? // - fipi.ita*SPY ONJ T

7?3Si

f*

/&._

u,.^lo..*J-i».J-,«...^ii .H—mum ff»i n.J"a »W"•-•—>•• • —•• i W«>m*ii''y* • •'. • ••"—»'••• -• •'•• —

A1tfn 3 r?tA T£ Of S*- AVatE —r — -i

_r //«-**•• *?v e ^ ^ y -r'**r * t#v€ amp e^^^cr

A«*TTt>*f Pa* £*1 *N$™#i or Tua**. t^ rait, rr , COT -Of »T3^ T P€l 3 '. T»M /«V* ^3 SCA eTZttfA** A& ¥J ^'VsA f,(AS &££*' ?#S?r> VJA %)**>- fi*A3L Tc 1HG #f PJC<f 0?

*~ v • ** A*, -rax fiJfV P. #* 3-ox. i3. H&S . €AP3 7

,Ti. «r, 3-, *4i n 'i C £3 _»&•5 1f S ? '

5~r

Ho. „ _.• X N -T~A?<£

• A*&VA1 »A fA-J *"*«"*L APAf-Ai^

/ttf*,* -"^of-A^JS , &AA4 44. AST*/** ?-7 »-**-"*'<*

T>/# •SmTA of ~/<f *A "^

(ii) £op-re 3 ^,< P.TJ75W*VS ^C3>^vs/A^ ^r-tf^V7

To 7**€' H3*>*uAAZ*-e Coo?* of €£3»*-jt**L AA^t'A c1> .

(3*1*. £<£• *A* l>At Alex <?&A<tfPf *j AApet.&At'*/'**' *y >?*&£*, z* T/t4r A3&VA- "$>'"'•*/**" p Al*& tfvA«&£ *e& A^tuSe A--S& Ast&S 7//> 3 P$a$& ft*** ?J--»^*- -X * •' ~ _ , -vT-a»rf/ (t&fOPItS +•<&• f£7S-m>"e« -> 'rc'^ '

^ *,_* //« _v*«~«" ^ ^ , ^er, ,,^^ *.

, - //».i# *-. Thin**J >_. "'£ 'wU'

/ -. .../v > «. •*tsA&J 6*»lT ****** "?* To"** f. A APt * £AAS 7 A"'t '' -" 'J'"*'*** - .

»"i .- - ^ <. A**&*f /-..^ •A/>S fc/i&CWt^ a*-»7a/*V. AS&*^

fj'^ ,,...,,„,», •iAffA2rA?*A'*3'4>*f?A'1*fe t***^ U7 <• **<• 4** st At. ?J5l7fr./V«5S Tc ^ AK6?o CoAY

,^t^ 0/C /t^/^TT ^*<Tfe--Pi/At, AU££ 9,3 (*)>

7,

A& •_ _ ~__„^ -. .,„

Y- AftP'tiAtff ^imse^S TTASAT AS/4" **VAT^ JM 7W& 2AAtoKW

jj, W a«<,«t &>******* -r„*A<A*«***r* r#~"«* $U<H .-, -s Apt* Aft&Z >i ^^^fi ^ '

#W^S pvfi*u#e*T T# let.**-- •'

\H.Hk'£fr0ZG, f>At**JS£ S AoAfsn>r&e'f>4 a*??***-***7/ f&r?7*-GAA*r# /^W5TS T#*7 rAf>S tetA*>«vt<4£€ touAr Aee**>r ^tte o*j&T#At. <*?y*m*V Pe.®AA^, eur.^-TjMi ftirrj** f9iz tuzePi'r&MtAAY *tV?c»tj ***?# apa?*'** St*"**e ?* *#* Stat* frx-st'*?4**& A*<™<*«* Y, *"***•'><** *'* "'^ "to*****'**-

&t SP*. Clr #* tV 5"o«3 A* J * 7 6"fc

AASC**• AAA"t AtJA~f ? 7jT&/tS£ A .• 44 f_ M ><*• «' '*? •' **AA^ JE

3S7_i /i-./i-« - 55 =- Scuj *v *-tw».j / _• \A2A*C» $71ifyJ, "7 AX<* ?/77 3'5 /

***/• 073: AJf si TA £>r $A A SA'x *r €

X f4At~.*V AA<-*7fY ?M< * 7****' "•<*& f&*P**r ***** ** T"* #&*V* *-"» P»*>€ &>•*-*>/& PAOSC P£-mcAf&*'S A"*-(u4«/ 7 0

if* T>fiA-b/A, &OT -Of • "flA'^£ Pils 77W fa,?, !>J5eAA7jAfJA*~y Pi VJCtA/

OP 1V-4Z Sr-ATT: fa*S*c*J73M& A;7i>AAt&Y, A.*.<>qk /A¥®£, AAAJ^J

Ai..€.k AaajV&s s~

?.

A/o f*P-OSLO'S- JS

Xti TH£ CtCOfCi OF C&3A\?tJAi. APPEALS of T^XvtS /4 US t -r a/f T grx A-%

/'-•

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Crank, Alex, Ii, (Tex. 2015).

Crank, Alex, Ii (Crank, Alex, Ii) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.