Copper Queen Consolidated Mining Co. v. Board of Equalization

65 P. 149, 7 Ariz. 364, 1901 Ariz. LEXIS 61
CourtArizona Supreme Court
DecidedJune 1, 1901
DocketCivil No. 734
StatusPublished
Cited by4 cases

This text of 65 P. 149 (Copper Queen Consolidated Mining Co. v. Board of Equalization) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Arizona Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Copper Queen Consolidated Mining Co. v. Board of Equalization, 65 P. 149, 7 Ariz. 364, 1901 Ariz. LEXIS 61 (Ark. 1901).

Opinion

DOAN, J.

On the twenty-seventh day of July, 1899, the Copper Queen Consolidated Mining Company filed in the district court of the first judicial district in and for the county of Cochise an application for a writ of certiorari to review the action of the board of equalization of Cochise County in the matter of the assessment of the property of the said company, alleged to have been had on the twelfth day of July, 1899. The writ was issued on July 27, 1899, and was worded in part as follows:

“To the Board of Equalization, Cochise County, Arizona: You are hereby commanded to certify fully to the district court of the first judicial district, . . . and annex to this writ a transcript of the record and proceedings of said board, . . . and also a full, true, and correct transcript of the.minutes of the board of equalization in the matter of the. assessment of the property of the Copper Queen Consolidated Mining Company, . . . and also a transcript of any other action or proceeding of said board on or before July 12, 1899, in relation to the assessment of the property of said corporation, that the same may be reviewed by this court; and in the mean time you are required and commanded to desist from further proceedings in the matter to be reviewed in relation to the increased assessment made by you on the twelfth day of July, 1899, to wit: Bisbee, Copper Queen Consolidated Mining and Smelter Company were raised as follows on their assessment. Doctor’s office, ete. (list as contained in return). And until the hearing and determination of said matters and proceed[367]*367ings all further action and proceedings by you in relation thereto are hereby stayed. ...”

The board filed a sworn return to the writ on the twenty-fourth day of November, 1899, of which the following is a partial copy:

“Territory of Arizona, County of Cochise—ss.: Office of the Board of Equalization. I, Frank Hare, clerk of the board of equalization of Cochise county, do hereby certify and return to the writ of certiorari hereto annexed:

“1st. That the list of the property of the Copper Queen Consolidated Mining Company returned by the. county assessor before July 1, 1899, was as follows, to wit:—

‘ ‘ Total valuation of real estate as per schedule A attached:
Value of land ........................................... $ 6,505
Value of improvements ..................................... 42,050
Total value......... $48,555
Description of personal property:
Library ................................................. 300
Pianos and organs.......................................... 100
Merchandise of any and all kinds............................ 54,800
Safe and office furniture.................................... 1,500
Work horses, No. 10 ...................................... 200
Wagons and buggies and other vehicles....................... 475
Harness, saddles, and bridles............................... 100-
Lumber and lagging........................................ 7,880
Hoisting works, pumping and other machinery at mines........ 24,000
Smelting works and appurtenances.......................... 85,000
Mill, mine, and smelter supplies of any and all kinds, including coke and coal............................................ 9,750
Surveyors’ instruments..................................... 50
Assaying outfit............................................ 100
Tools and machinery, including other items and other property not enumerated above, ice machinery....................... 1,500
$234,310
$185,755 Total value of personal property.
48,555 Total value of real estate.......
$234,310

“As sworn to by the agent of the company, Ben Williams.

“2d. That the proceedings of the board of equalization in the said matter were as follows:

“ ‘July 12th, 1899. Board met, pursuant to adjournment [368]*368July 11th, at 9 a. m., all members present, and proceeded with its labors as board of equalization. Clerk instructed to notify all persons whose valuation was raised to appear before the board on July 18th, 19th, and 20th. . . . Copper Queen Consolidated Mining & Smelting Company were raised as follows on their assessment:—

Raise.
Doctor’s office and library building from $7,800 to $9,800......$ 2,000
Hankin’s store, Main street, from $750 to $1,000............ 250
Merchandise, from $54,800 to $84,800............. 30,000
On ten work horses, from $200 to $400....................... 200
On lumber and lagging, from $7,880 to $10,000................ 2,120
On hoisting works, pumping and other machinery, from $24,000 to $39,000.............................................. 15,000
On smelters, from $85,000 to $120,000........................ 35,000
On mine and smelting supplies and coal, etc., from $9,750 to $11,750................................................. 2,000
On improvements consisting of store building, warehouse, hospital building, and doctor’s residence, from- $29,500 to $39,500 10,000
“Added” on cars and ear track in mine....................... 12,000

“ ‘Adjourned to July 18th, at 9 a. m. . . . ’

“On the-12th day of July, by order of the board, I deposited in the Tombstone post-office a notice to the Copper Queen Consolidated Mining Company, in a sealed envelope, and directed to Ben "Williams, the recorded agent of said Copper Queen Consolidated Mining Company, and superintendent, a notice, of which the following is a true copy:

“ ‘Office of the Board of Equalization, Cochise County, Tombstone, Arizona. Ben "Williams, Superintendent, Bisbee: Referring to the inclosed list, you will ascertain the amount the county hoard of equalization proposes to add to your assessment. Should you wish to show cause why said amount should not he added, the board will hear you on July 19th, 1899. Frank Hare, Clerk, by James F. Duncan, Deputy Clerk. [List same as above.] ’

“I further certify that by direction of the board I caused to be published in the Tombstone Prospector, a daily newspaper published in Cochise County, a notice of which the following is a true copy, for a period of eight days:—■

“ ‘Notice.

“ ‘ To property owners the assessed value of whose property was increased by the board of equalization at the July, 1899, [369]*369sitting. Office of the Board of Supervisors, Tombstone, July 22d, 1899. The following is the.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Yuma County v. Arizona Edison Co.
180 P.2d 868 (Arizona Supreme Court, 1947)
City of El Paso v. Howze
248 S.W. 99 (Court of Appeals of Texas, 1923)
Hammer v. Smith
94 P. 1121 (Arizona Supreme Court, 1908)
Montana Ore Purchasing Co. v. Maher
81 P. 13 (Montana Supreme Court, 1905)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
65 P. 149, 7 Ariz. 364, 1901 Ariz. LEXIS 61, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/copper-queen-consolidated-mining-co-v-board-of-equalization-ariz-1901.