Cooper, Marcus A.

• Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
• Decided: June 2, 2016
• Docket: WR-82,398-03
• Status: Published

Opinion

E§\PARTE\ A A V ‘\\/\'/\Qz_\»;/\.:eoosz¢< l _ YZS”I@#UB

' _ 1¢“.\ a w ¢W _ PPEALS ' i ` Z»_¢)»Mse_-\=§rc&§>d\c\t"'€@(:\§)s\(¢;& A\:'\`\Q/SV\`Y ~ _ _’ \/ .Xm `

<4515;- A*K_A£Pe¢\>,;§,fow¥ r¢g,\k».»x;g\.j~@d\ \0@:4.1\.»;,\ w L\.o\w».~» LQ.»,M¢¢.L % % -YQ `f\°'\wbb\_€. C\€L\X §¢v\__VjA/»<\VW__Q_F,_AF('_QA £Q

AML a.j`;m l\.DX\/v~»s P¢a.,¢.,»e<\ h Aye_@\>AW\'l/`\r°"v’ A.AE.;§>.> YY~,\¢_

`lxv~» L¢q/\'.\_».;,}\‘\~¢j D;,..,~.;Ao~;;___f\\gij¢»‘cc Q,r\ .jl‘_¥g¥g_;/~r_v,\e§/L¥ of LDW¢\LQA\ \»~?@\\¢\bcz,q»»¢» "»`U)_`I-_‘O'F \LD\@<_M¢ Qe_@~\»‘@‘~d '

, lOu/°¢' h__m_ve _‘.Si_/o ` dJ . Vv\. ,@:rhcg+' P'Qe¢l,@g§[§¢:`;a_\)f _.f,

¥"~:0¢3_.3_ Errg/ _L.,\ §L\_@\' A€p;¢_\p,l,§\€'f ¢9;\. 'Y:@'Lr_q\“' d ` y V‘\QA_C_ QL\ é_"ov\.)`l(f`om C¢>w’} \'/_\`°L\_@¥.\w\ via A¢Q\;_Q,O} Ne \cc*' Qfpw¥y\

sté, Ciérk \_L

,_ . _f’d'per'g_e“'l[é\é)v\ _

1 v s1 .§Cé, ` \\"Co~b`\\`§'\j -` Q¢_¢ 01 \§M¢;;».,~u ¢¢J;y__`\»;».;_!>l@;,; App\.\¢@b\¢ so v mem

` who re/ &g.`¢\ .

" , .` r‘;'.wi¢ wm \/\<>vg `b`eey\ `\v\'d:(,\'u\.,» `

l ila ‘~C@\Xd’fv/<)\ Eb_\v c\\»‘§gm;”ir\dr ¥cm_¢__~\_l~ \/9"<\ ”Yf\`\>\ `Cv-f.\- % yw&s_m\:vye'v~c\'y 760-f T_r-‘Q\ §f\ bo,¢§r-`v~\'¥¢~§ 05 5§11('_¥$_§£-_____,_

1 4 Qfg€£r fg.y~.eéy \/\/0$ _Z§Q_\J`Cl£ D§Z»jg;@(nl'@~)j£_'l'\o./$L__€U/

vw ,,;e@£,;~z....~u::\~r@l\wr» =r L

. w m» M`_&L\ M_»,-ui¢l re¢o/A)»`.\;\- J`,s A_¢{,el;°i¢_`y":*f¢§"f`g§¥v\‘:§, b ¢\L_C\cz,|\ §§ w.‘¥k¥mli %l¢\;\¢ w§:\éd .§'Pc@¢£y_:r\%f¢\,

. ~¥`\\'€é `\Iv\_§\»;.,\_\,l\Y`Q,Bl-"AL'»\\'\Q\~;¢>»\ §,a D)‘_¢\~¢J(L,_A\§D'_»"\g_r£, §§ e-F_evj`>é`_;c_-;c_(>\,`i ' LCQB.Q»=§.~L..:MA % c »I__»‘ ~QlvQ[£ @\L¢);L5A,¢9@ »~>*~f%

¢9,;§ *rrp;, ;,¢.\Q%[y,¢,§¢, \./;\ ;_lggl_l§er or\.» LM¢r¢\i\,\/,;yg¢'z\ cc x;\w\,\:~,\\)\»\u\\\\z\f” w @\8.&@1 w /l

' » D`¢§(§n~/;/'y ;¢q md ¥ \c \~ F@\r%)~»o/J §L»_€,L>~A Q,O\§`Z{Q[llal(l_\~`&¢;\/LL$\/h:\'o»v/_,,,_

' ;@§,@\ fm @QM»FM\ LL@\ J;€»DI; 9 ;\c \;~\ L\: be Now ~A¢rva/xv»,w@

\\ Ao% §§

Clr,/l\ `w\‘ §wdgc-.D?(' APNC@\S_-A _ % _§@M,¢JAV; f emm,@¢ :%@%v»1@M @ \. 4 % j__`_._g.\v\»\ v `f`_eqy,e.:¥»‘g`\j_b\y\. _H.BA§_'QQ)¥ [:og'_g/'_,"Q-__.`,o_/_\ % &Atm\,¢ n ¢Q¢.,~.¢¢.I., %x/¢\M;___a_.___: <,»~_;»,;A:,LV_»,), ¥ \;__Cm`q1¥ §lrro»»@ly \00}£ gm _C_qg§idmec_ ..&r@w;i _

f " 'c~‘u\\ Evr¢\(»v§cc_,x §,y;’ Q.&EA_ '§gi;§v\/}Q_\¢¥,\;,n\_ ' l \ wJL\ [l`vr A(,;IS;'¢_`$ Q,: jfq_¢'__~y~_'_ 'Dec'_\£.;io¢. D/`.S`.Zv\/¢,ry_ r"` . Mo/\ A

\

W % . +\% rd + _ Mi) [§h.‘f§f `¢§L_@Jea ¥Cd @§; "F.`Q\ 9 . _ » ` ` _ i -€_ Qu'l€,J$)f'EJ/»“¢cv\cg

~_ 0 // ‘1£ §AL\/ Q;.@Zlu)\ie‘” 515 Z’Jr\.\{@-\`i\.&o .[‘(_v~§£z¢" guam way

`)Ki"e» facie /.‘ -¢»/»`+#\»}\ F<>b¢,; \--w\ _y_r§¢_r;cc+

~f v »» ¢rl@_¢;\»+er% 195 16’

e \¢x»,`k\.‘\b> % LQ¢@,.<,¢¢¢»:tm/¢}”\§-k)ek\y /i>o~\¢_m,\§ , @_V___ » z \L»l»»¢;¢,a, Q»SM;CB_A,Q¢

F:I\d\CQL`C_\Q§}O¢\‘/A¥\' `\'\'\»\`;S CQ\|A€’. ¢S\'\G\»\;\___T!\_c>'¢\.}'\__`[j;___‘|_'__v_' 5 . L ¢ `-¢¢ML\/\/'»`H~; \ %Qé’,?\@ll@ N “ ` V \

_5 5 QCVC./€. S/KQ€ (O.r\\|`,\r\\,\c,`§

_ \:C_dQ_/_o`\. ¢SC.',C

‘_ 4 V<’_v\v\§y\\/_g¢~;¢ \/..',Q.‘_X;w\_: q “\30. `, Pro,).ac..¥¢/` %

1 év-*r\s /\'D ¥*Mv\ O_\/,c_`r 'C¥~C.w£o\.\§.efy V E\/_\‘é_e»\cc. . *_`\L_S>_\;C,,`\J\ '_C w~b¢ l.Ol ‘\` a ;[9_.|,(£8 _F\_o~vv\l-)l V\_`-.£c\_

SEE @ev\r\\‘llvo.r\'.‘& \/_ Q`,‘_tgv\e¢\“\l)'@i\\)\$ "}q l c . - w w 9 t`\f\é"_l\ pres£at&@r dew to him over ` _ \i/ Y~"i\€vt\?dit%f\/ Ev‘.dcr\c@ v\o`m\\, S_U(‘\~|][C\ pl\® l'QI 9 7c K|AHCC §\y\@q|é have f

§\¢\$crl’r`.r\¥ wet c)v\ llc\‘.fc l'\g,r¢y\ 1,0 \<9\@@ note bean used at T/.w.~.\ W¢n\o';.t ' .&Ci~\*\&\ Q@o\ Kv\l£(`,u 5 Disco\'/ery lV `

- o 5 ` C C s) If state withholds or redacts information, state must disclose that a portion of request is being

withheld or redacted _______`_________,

-:- Moti0n to compel requires us to hold hearing to determine whether withholding or redaction is justified

~ tocc'

~:~ This can be dispositive too F °` ` h f “ ~=~_I}’~P.i.€.%l__, sanction is that state cannot use" C \ \ x ~ evidence it failed to disclose g ' l " ' 3 .§). 1 §§ \_£Q § '§g§ De;,;¢¢ "é COV\C \kS¢l)¢\*-YV\§§ O`H)»A\C ll\»c&v\ \'_c\o \ l ) cause acp\\»\-c¢llv\\e$ Skw\d be '\l

`Yrw~\tc/l e..\. 3m \/gy\ ~ mv¢,\~q 4

lnterpreter .=. Art. 23.01 la

l proceed gs&evide e

le W \ w `. o BW~¢‘I Vl()\ut-"`»)v~\pfe.$c£q‘t\>r\`@l U\.`¢Cg¢\¢wc{ `f¢\l\etcc¥!'vq [@.,,,\j¢\

Appel|ate issues

~:- Pre-trial rulings are part of trial recor §2) g f l l

»:» State can appeal ruling that w w __ f

i) Disinisses complaint (art. 44.01(a)(1)) ,`

2) Grants double jeopardy claim (art. 44.01(a)(4)) 50 ' C

3) Grants motion to suppress (art. 44.01 (a!($))

~:~ During appeal, proceedings are stayed (art. 44.01(e)) _

l){)ro§c¢~.lg’£' §l,!jj _L\Q jwv\ Q\/c/ E`lC\/\\p¢>¥w\| E\/¢`¢l¢¢\(e» NAMC\\\;)O\K`\H:€

C wfr 55

Appe|late |ssues ll

~:» A _can a eal an adve e decision after 6 \' 0 ` n

conviction if issue timely raised & preserved \ 0 \ w

~:- ‘Can raise jurisdictional issue on appeal for first - 1

'time 0 f lr[]L/¢j,%%[: Z\§}' {`Ql€\[dv\‘l' ‘l e ¢\+ J _ O` ` ' '~ »

M¢¢§ ;,,§§ Qf §Lgpbe¢|| ` s s \/. ¢Z»‘+c»\ief “\90 M§_ '}C;Qqgw\p¢»>¢¢ti¢» <\»tw+o,

’fw¢\ O\’“' l:\tcu\ », yE\/rde»cc ._Lr\m"`l`l Kv\lF'/C) pm w c/

Other Pre-trial motions

»:- Use of pre-trial is not limited to list in art. 28.01 -:- Rule 702 (admissibi1ity of scientific evidence)

-o» Motion to record proceedings/ court reporter

~:~ Submission of special instructions or requests t for jury charge al k c t a

‘z~ Designation of expert witnesses & materials ‘l~ , _ ~ 9 ~\ 0 upon which they rely

~:~ State’s offer extended could result in guilty/ no § \ ) a vi Q,

contest plea & waiver of trial