Collins v. Welch

12 N.W. 121, 58 Iowa 72
CourtSupreme Court of Iowa
DecidedApril 19, 1882
StatusPublished
Cited by14 cases

This text of 12 N.W. 121 (Collins v. Welch) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Iowa primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Collins v. Welch, 12 N.W. 121, 58 Iowa 72 (iowa 1882).

Opinions

Adams, C. J.

1. BOARD of supervisors compromise of judgment. There is no pretense that the claim for taxes was not properly put in judgment, and no question is raised bi regal’d to the validity of the judgment, ^ bas now become a claim to be enforced by execnt}oni an(j ju our opinion stands upon the footing of any other judgment. The question, then, arises as to [73]*73whether the board of supervisors has power to compromise a judgment. In our opinion it has. It is provided in section 303 of the Code, subd. 11, that county supervisors are “ to represent their respective counties, and to have the care and management of the property, and business of the county, in all cases where no other provision shall be made.” It was held in Grimes v. Hamilton County, 37 Iowa, 298, that this provision gave the board power to compromise an action if it acted in good faith; and it appears to us that it follows that the board may compromise a judgment if it acts in good faith. It is true that, where a claim has been reduced to judgment, all questions pertaining to the rightfulness of the claim have been adjudicated. But questions may arise subsequent to the rendition of the judgment, and where they are of such a character as to render a compromise expedient, it is manifest that the board ought to have the power to make it. Suppose, for instance, that the financial condition of the judgment debtor is such that the. board is unable to discover any way of collecting any part of the judgment. The board should have the power to accept a part in satisfaction of the whole, if in its judgment the best interests of the county would thereby be promoted. All rules of business conduct by which a prudent person is governed are applicable to a county in the management of its affairs under similar circumstances.

It is true that in the case at bar the plaintiff avers that the judgment debtor was solvent. But that averment is not material. "We cannot go into any such question of fact in this action. The question before us is one of jurisdiction. If the board can make a compromise with an insolvent judgment debtor, it must be allowed to judge for itself in any given case as to whether the debtor is insolvent or not, and-an error made in this respect, however great, would not affect its jurisdiction. In our opinion the demurrer was properly sustained.

Affirmed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Board of Supervisors v. Standard Appliance Co.
87 N.W.2d 459 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1958)
State ex rel. Williams v. City of Pratt
85 P.2d 10 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1938)
Lytle v. Ames
279 N.W. 453 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1938)
Plymouth County v. Koehler
267 N.W. 106 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1936)
Carney v. City of Grinnell
53 F.2d 44 (Eighth Circuit, 1931)
Oakman v. City of Eveleth
203 N.W. 514 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1925)
Horton Township v. Drainage District No. 26
192 Iowa 61 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1921)
First National Bank v. City of Emmetsburg
157 Iowa 555 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1912)
Hagler v. Kelly
103 N.W. 629 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 1905)
Multnomah County v. Title Guarantee Co.
80 P. 409 (Oregon Supreme Court, 1905)
Fox v. Walley
102 N.W. 161 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 1905)
State v. Davis
75 N.W. 897 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1898)
Washburn County v. Thompson
75 N.W. 309 (Wisconsin Supreme Court, 1898)
Hall v. Baker
42 N.W. 104 (Wisconsin Supreme Court, 1889)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
12 N.W. 121, 58 Iowa 72, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/collins-v-welch-iowa-1882.