COLE v. McDONALD

109 So. 2d 628, 236 Miss. 168, 10 Oil & Gas Rep. 270, 1959 Miss. LEXIS 306
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedMarch 16, 1959
Docket40979
StatusPublished
Cited by22 cases

This text of 109 So. 2d 628 (COLE v. McDONALD) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
COLE v. McDONALD, 109 So. 2d 628, 236 Miss. 168, 10 Oil & Gas Rep. 270, 1959 Miss. LEXIS 306 (Mich. 1959).

Opinion

*170 Holmes, J.

*171 L. B. Cole, as complainant in the court below, filed his original and amended bills of complaint in the Chancery Court of Monroe County against the appellees as defendants in the court below, seeking to have confirmed in him title to certain land therein particularly described situated in Monroe County, Mississippi, and comprising approximately 247.6 acres, less and except an undivided two-thirds interest in and to all oil, gas or other minerals of like, kind and character, which are not a part of the soil, in, on and under said land, and further seeking particularly to have confirmed in him title to all bentonite in, on and under said land, and to cancel all claims of the defendants thereto as clouds upon the asserted title of the complainant. The appellees in their answer did not controvert the complainant’s claim of title to the surface of the land in question, but denied that the complainant was the owner of all bentonite in, on and under said land.

Upon the hearing of the cause, the chancellor rendered a decree confirming in the complainant, L. B. Cole, title to the surface of the land in question and adjudging that the bentonite therein and thereunder was owned in the proportion of one-third by L. B. Cole, the complainant, one-third by James McDonald, Ruth Sykes and Mae Mills, the heirs and devisees of Mrs. Cleo McDonald Young, who was killed in an automobile accident on November 14,1956, and one-third by Mrs. F. A. Bradley, Sr., the sole heir and devisee of F. A. Bradley, Sr., who died on April 5, 1937. From this decree, the complainant, L. B. Cole, prosecuted this appeal. Pending the appeal of this cause to this Court, the complainant, L. B. Cole, died on September 3, 1958, and the cause as to him has been revived in the name of his executor and his heirs and devisees.

The controversy is over the ownership of the bentonite in, on and under the land in question, and arises as follows: For a time prior to February 24, 1927, E. L. *172 Young, F. A. Bradley and L. B. Cole were partners doing business as the E. L. Young Company and the E. L. Young Heading Company. The Partnership was engaged in the sawmill, lumber and timber business and owned real and personal property including the land here in question. On February 24, 1927, E. L. Young died and his widow, Mrs. Cleo McDonald Young, succeeded to the ownership of his interest in said partnership and the assets thereof. On June 30, 1927, the said Mrs. Cleo McDonald Young entered into an agreement with the said F. A. Bradley whereby she conveyed her interest in the assets of the partnership, including the land here involved, to the said F. A. Bradley, subject to certain exceptions and reservations as to oil, gas or other minerals. The agreement contained, among other provisions, the following:

“Party of the first part (Mrs. Cleo McDonald Young) also reserves a one-third (1/3) interest in and to all gas, oil or other minerals that may be found or produced from the lands in Monroe County, Mississippi conveyed to E. L. Young Company by T. A. and L. Jenkins, and the lands in said county conveyed to E. L. Young by Mrs. Gertrude B. Eckford, et al. Each of the parties hereto shall sign and execute such further instruments as the other party shall reasonably require for effectuating this agreement. Party of the first part also reserves a one-third (1/3) interest in the B. H. McFarland, Trustee, oil leases and royalties for which she agrees to credit second party’s (F. A. Bradley) note with $33.33.”

The said agreement contained the following signed by L. B. Cole: “I, L. B. Cole, one of the surviving partners of the firm of E. L. Young Company and E. L. Young Heading Company, hereby agree and consent to the foregoing agreement between Mrs. Cleo McDonald Young and F. A. Bradley.”

*173 Pursuant to said agreement and on the same date, June 30, 1927, Mrs. Cleo McDonald Young executed a deed conveying to F. A. Bradley all of her right, title and interest in the assets of the partnership, including the land in question. This deed contained the following:

“Except that the grantor hereby excepts and reserves unto herself, her heirs and assigns, one-third (1/3) of the oil and gas or other minerals or the proceeds therefrom, which may be found or produced from, under, and on the above described lands, together with the right of ingress and egress for the purpose of developing and extracting said oil and gas and other minerals, and the right to use such part of the surface of said premises as may be necessary or convenient in the development and extraction of said minerals.”

On March 20, 1928, the said L. B. Cole, as the party of the first part, and the said F. A. Bradley, as the party of the sceond part, entered into an agreement in writing whereby the said L. B. Cole conveyed to the said F. A. Bradley his right, title and interest in certain of the assets of the aforesaid partnership, subject to certain reservations and exceptions, and whereby the said F. A. Bradley agreed to convey to the said L. B. Cole, subject to certain reservations and exceptions, all of his interest in certain of the assets and property of the partnership, including the land here in question. Said agreement contained the following provisions:

“Party of the second part (F. A. Bradley) is also to convey to party of the first part (L. B. Cole) all of his interest in the property in Aberdeen, Mississippi, known as the Mrs. Allie M. Watkins property, and also all of his interest in the property in Monroe County, Mississippi, known as the McQuiston and Eckford land, except, said second party is to reserve a one-third (%) interest in and to all oil, gas or other minerals that may be found or produced from said McQuiston and Eckford land. Said *174 party of the first part also reserves a one-third (%) interest in and to all oil, gas or other minerals that may be found or produced on the lands to be conveyed by him to second party, except the land in Aberdeen, Mississippi, known as the French property, and the 10 acres, more or less, in Monroe County, Mississippi known as the O. O. Towery land. Party of the first part also reserves a one-third (%) interest in the B. H. McFarland Trustee oil leases and royalties. Each of the parties hereto shall sign and execute such further instruments as the other party shall reasonably require for effectuating this agree ment. ’ ’

On the same date, March 20, 1928, and pursuant to the aforesaid written agreement, the parties executed deeds, each to the other, for the purpose of effectuating the aforsaid agreement. The said F. A. Bradley executed a deed to L. B. Cole whereby the land in question was conveyed to L. B. Cole. Following the description of the land therein described, the deed contained the following exception and reservation:

“Excepting therefrom one-third (%) of the oil, gas and other minerals, or the proceeds therefrom, which may be found or produced from, under and on the above described lands, which said one-third (%) now belongs to Cleo McDonald Young as shown by deed from her to F. A. Bradley, recorded in Deed Book 95, Page 240, land records of Monroe County, Mississippi, and here referred to.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

John M. Barham, Jr. v. Mississippi Power Company
266 So. 3d 994 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2019)
Estate of Chancellor v. Comm'r
2011 T.C. Memo. 172 (U.S. Tax Court, 2011)
City of Hernando v. North Mississippi Utility Co.
3 So. 3d 775 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2008)
Eaker v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Insurance
216 F. Supp. 2d 606 (S.D. Mississippi, 2001)
In Re Smink
276 B.R. 156 (N.D. Mississippi, 2001)
Miss. Transp. Com'n v. Ronald Adams Cont.
753 So. 2d 1077 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2000)
Rhoden v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.
32 F. Supp. 2d 907 (S.D. Mississippi, 1998)
Yazoo Prop. v. Katz & Besthoff No. 284, Inc.
644 So. 2d 429 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1994)
Vines v. McKenzie Methane Corp.
619 So. 2d 1305 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1993)
McDonald v. Snyder Construction Co.
744 S.W.2d 550 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1988)
W.S. Newell, Inc. v. Randall
373 So. 2d 1068 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1979)
Forbes v. COLUMBIA PULP & PAPER COMPANY, INC.
275 So. 2d 92 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1973)
Dabbs v. International Minerals & Chemical Corp.
339 F. Supp. 654 (N.D. Mississippi, 1972)
Singer v. Tatum
171 So. 2d 134 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1965)
Wanna E. Bumpus v. United States
325 F.2d 264 (Tenth Circuit, 1963)
Cole v. Berry
147 So. 2d 306 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1962)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
109 So. 2d 628, 236 Miss. 168, 10 Oil & Gas Rep. 270, 1959 Miss. LEXIS 306, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/cole-v-mcdonald-miss-1959.