Cleary v. Spa Knitting Co.

222 A.D. 782

• Court: Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York
• Decided: December 15, 1927
• Status: Published

Opinion

Judgment and order as to the appellant Spa Knitting Company, Inc., reversed on the law,-and new trial granted to the appellant, with costs to abide the event, on the ground of prejudicial error of the trial court in refusing to instruct the jury as to the effect of the failure to call the defendant Heffner as a witness. Cochrane, P. J., Hinman and McCann, JJ., concur; Davis and Whitmyer, JJ., dissent on the ground that it appears that the defendant Heffner was an employee of the defendant corporation for a long time prior, and also for several months subsequent, to the accident, and that there was no duty on the part of the trial justice to charge as a matter of law that there was no obligation on the defendant corporation to call the codefendant Heffner and that no inference can be drawn from the failure to call him, or that it was just as much an obligation on the plaintiff to call the eodefendant Heffner as there was upon 'the defendant corporation. (See Schwier v. N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. Co., 90 N. Y. 558, 564; Hicks v. Nassau Electric R. R. Co., 47 App. Div. 479, 481; Treuhaft v. Bender, 193 id. 666.)