Clayton v. Meijer Inc

Opinion

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21  &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 1R 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU

,9 )LOH 1DPH DS

%DVHGXSRQWKHIRUHJRLQJWKHMXGJPHQWRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW LV$)),50(' 81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

$17+21< &/$<721 ; 3ODLQWLII$SSHOODQW    1R Y  !  0(,s(5 ,1&25325$7('  'HIHQGDQW$SSHOOHH 1 $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW IRUWKH(DVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI0LFKLJDQDW'HWURLW 1RnsRKQ)HLNHQV'LVWULFWsXGJH 6XEPLWWHG1RYHPEHU 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG)HEUXDU\ %HIRUH0$57,1&KLHI&LUFXLWsXGJH%$7&+(/'(5 &LUFXLWsXGJH6$5*86'LVWULFWsXGJH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &2816(/ 21%5,()sRKQ55XQ\DQ6$&+6:$/'0$1'HWURLW 0LFKLJDQ IRU $SSHOODQW  7KRPDV 0 0LOOHU 6(1,25 /$%25 &2816(/ 0(,s(5 /(*$/ '(3$570(17 *UDQG5DSLGV0LFKLJDQIRU$SSHOOHH

YLRODWLRQ PHUHO\ EHFDXVH LW ZDV WKH HPSOR\HHjV ILUVW YLRODWLRQ RI WKH GRFN 7KH +RQRUDEOH (GPXQG $ 6DUJXV sU 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW sXGJH SROLF\ IRU WKH 6RXWKHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 2KLR VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ

  &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 1R 1R &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ,QWKLVFDVHWKHHPSOR\HUGLVFKDUJHGDQ$IULFDQ$PHULFDQ HPSOR\HHZKRKDGHQJDJHGLQDVHULRXVDFWRIPLVFRQGXFW 23,1,21 ZKLFK UHVXOWHG LQ LQMXU\ WR D FRZRUNHU ZKR ZDV UHQGHUHG BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB WRWDOO\ GLVDEOHG  :KLOH RWKHU ZKLWH HPSOR\HHV PD\ KDYH HQJDJHGLQWKHVDPHDFWVRIQHJOLJHQFHWKHHPSOR\HULVQRW 6$5*86 'LVWULFW sXGJH  $QWKRQ\ &OD\WRQ SODLQWLII SUHFOXGHG IURP FRQVLGHULQJ WKH KDUP UHVXOWLQJ IURP WKH DSSHOODQWDSSHDOVWKHGHFLVLRQRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWJUDQWLQJ FRQGXFW RI LWV HPSOR\HHV  ,Q WKLV FDVH RQO\ &OD\WRQjV VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW WR WKH GHIHQGDQWDSSHOOHH 0HLMHU QHJOLJHQFH FDXVHG VHULRXV LQMXU\ WR D FRZRUNHU  7KLV LV ,QFRUSRUDWHG m0HLMHUl RQ KLV 7LWOH 9,, FODLP RI UDFLDO SUHFLVHO\ mVXFK GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ RU PLWLJDWLQJ FLUFXPVWDQFHl GLVFULPLQDWLRQ)RUWKHUHDVRQVWKDWIROORZWKHGHFLVLRQRI WKDWGLVWLQJXLVKHV&OD\WRQj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†HHWVHT VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWKHUH7KHXQGLVSXWHGIDFWVLQWKLVFDVH 2Q $XJXVW   WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW JUDQWHG 0HLMHUjV GHPRQVWUDWHWKDW&OD\WRQjVLQIUDFWLRQZDVTXDOLWDWLYHO\PRUH PRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW7KHFRXUWIRXQGWKDW&OD\WRQ VHULRXVWKDQWKRVHRIKLVWKUHHFRZRUNHUV7KHHPSOR\HUjV IDLOHGWRHVWDEOLVKDSULPDIDFLHFDVHRIUDFLDOGLVFULPLQDWLRQ PRUH VHYHUH WUHDWPHQW RI PRUH HJUHJLRXV FLUFXPVWDQFHV 7KHMXGJHDSSOLHGWKHIDPLOLDU0F'RQQHOO'RXJODV&RUSY VLPSO\FDQQRWJLYHULVHWRDQLQIHUHQFHZKLFKZRXOGVXSSRUW *UHHQ  86   DQDO\VLV  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW WKHHVWDEOLVKPHQWRIDSULPDIDFLHFDVHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ GHWHUPLQHGWKDWWKHSODLQWLIIKDGHVWDEOLVKHGWKDWKHKDGPHW WKH ILUVW WKUHH SURQJV RI WKH EXUGHQ VKLIWLQJ IUDPHZRUN E\ HVWDEOLVKLQJWKDWKHZDVDPHPEHURIWKHSURWHFWHGFODVVWKDW  ([DPSOHV DERXQG LQ WKH ODZ LQYROYLQJ GLIIHUHQWLDO WUHDWPHQW RI ZKDW KH VXIIHUHG DQ DGYHUVH HPSOR\PHQW DFWLRQ DQG WKDW IRU ZRXOG RWKHUZLVH EH LGHQWLFDO DFWV WKDW UHVXOW LQ GLIIHULQJ OHYHOV RI KDUP WR

SXUSRVHVRIWKHPRWLRQKHZDVTXDOLILHGIRUWKHSRVLWLRQIURP WKLUG SDUWLHV )RU H[DPSOH D IDLOXUH WR XVH D EOLQNHU ZKHQ FKDQJLQJ ODQHV

ZKLFKKHZDVWHUPLQDWHG,GDW7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWIRXQG LV LQ YLUWXDOO\ HYHU\ MXULVGLFWLRQ D PLQRU PLVGHPHDQRU 7KH VDPH FRQGXFW

WKDW&OD\WRQGLGQRWVDWLVI\WKHIRXUWKSURQJRIWKH0F'RQQHOO KRZHYHU PD\ UHVXOW LQ D GHDGO\ FROOLVLRQ MXULVGLFWLRQV ZRXOG WUHDW WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV ,Q WKLV FLUFXPVWDQFH PRVW DV LQYROYLQJ YHKLFXODU 'RXJODVDQDO\VLVLQWKDWKHGLGQRWHVWDEOLVKWKDWKHZDVHLWKHU KRPLFLGH DQ RIIHQVH IRU ZKLFK PXFK JUHDWHU SHQDOWLHV DUH DYDLODEOH

WUHDWHGGLIIHUHQWO\IURPVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGHPSOR\HHVRXWVLGH  WKHSURWHFWHGFODVV,G&OD\WRQDSSHDOHGWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjV &OD\WRQ DOVR FRQWHQGV WKDW KH VKRXOG QRW KDYH EHHQ ILUHG IRU D VLQJOH

JUDQWRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW YLRODWLRQ RI 0HLMHUjV SROLF\ UHTXLULQJ GULYHUV WR PDNH FHUWDLQ WKH GRFN SODWH LV SXOOHG DQG WKH WUDLOHU GRRUV ORFNHG :KLOH WKLV SDUWLFXODU SROLF\ SURYLGHV IRU GLVFKDUJH DIWHU RQO\ D VHFRQG YLRODWLRQ DQRWKHU SROLF\ SURYLGHV IRU GLVFKDUJH XQGHU WKH FRPSDQ\jV VDIHW\ SROLF\ ,W LV FOHDU WKDW WKH IRUPHU SROLF\ GRHV QRW SUHFOXGH GLVFKDUJH IRU D VHULRXV VDIHW\  &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 1R 1R &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 

0F'RQQHOO'RXJODV86DWLQZKLFKWKHSODLQWLII ,, DQ $IULFDQ$PHULFDQ HQJDJHG LQ DQ XQODZIXO WUDIILF REVWUXFWLRQDWWKHHPSOR\HUjVORFDWLRQEXWZDVWUHDWHGPRUH 2Q0D\&OD\WRQGURYHDVHPLWUXFNWR0HLMHUjV VHYHUHO\WKDQZKLWHHPSOR\HHVHQJDJLQJLQWKHVDPHFRQGXFW VWRUHLQ%U\GHQ0LFKLJDQDQGGURSSHGRIIDSDUWLDOO\IXOO $VIXUWKHUH[SODLQHGLQ0F'RQDOGY6DQWD)H7UDQVS&R WUDLOHU:KLOHHQURXWHKHZDVDGYLVHGE\WKHVWRUHPDQDJHU  86   mWKH XOWLPDWH    TXHVWLRQ DV ZH KHZDVWRSLFNXSDQHPSW\WUDLOHUUHDG\WREHWDNHQEDFNWR LQGLFDWHGLQ0F'RQDOG'RXJODV>LVZKHWKHU@DQDOOHJDWLRQ WKH 0HLMHU 'LVWULEXWLRQ &HQWHU IURP ZKLFK &OD\WRQ KDG WKDWµRWKHUHPSOR\HHVLQYROYHGLQDFWVDJDLQVWWKHHPSOR\HU GHSDUWHG RI FRPSDUDEOH VHULRXVQHVV    ZHUH QHYHUWKHOHVV UHWDLQHG jl,GDWQHPSKDVLVLQRULJLQDO $IWHUGURSSLQJRIIWKHILUVWWUDLOHU&OD\WRQEDFNHGXSKLV WUXFNWRDQHPSW\WUDLOHUDQGKLWFKHGLWWRKLVULJ,QVXODWLRQ $VWKLV&RXUWKHOGLQ0LWFKHOOWKHHPSOR\HHVWRZKRPWKH SDGGLQJ VXUURXQGHG WKH GRFN GRRU ZKHUH WKH WUDLOHU ZDV SODLQWLIIVHHNVWRFRPSDUHKLPVHOIPXVWmKDYHHQJDJHGLQWKH SDUNHG&RQVHTXHQWO\IURPKLVWUXFN&OD\WRQFRXOGQRWVHH VDPH FRQGXFW ZLWKRXW VXFK GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ RU PLWLJDWLQJ LQWRWKHORDGLQJGRFNDQGFRXOGQRWVHHWKHUHDUWUDLOHUGRRU FLUFXPVWDQFHV WKDW ZRXOG GLVWLQJXLVK WKHLU FRQGXFW RU WKH ,WLVXQGLVSXWHGWKDW&OD\WRQZDVDZDUHRIWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHV HPSOR\HUVWUHDWPHQWRIWKHPIRULWl)GDW$V DQGNQHZWKDWKHZDVWRPDNHVXUHWKHUHDUWUDLOHUGRRUZDV IXUWKHUH[SODLQHGLQ(UFHJRYLFKWKHSODLQWLIILVUHTXLUHGWR FORVHG DQG WKH GRFN SODWH ZDV UDLVHG EHIRUH PRYLQJ WKH mGHPRQVWUDWHWKDWKHRUVKHLVVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGWRWKHQRQ WUDLOHU SURWHFWHGHPSOR\HHLQDOOUHOHYDQWUHVSHFWVl)GDW HPSKDVLVLQRULJLQDO &OD\WRQ DFNQRZOHGJHG LQ KLV GHSRVLWLRQ WKDW LW ZDV KLV UHVSRQVLELOLW\WRFKHFNWKDWWKHUHDUGRRURIWKHWUDLOHUZDV ,WLV&OD\WRQjVEXUGHQWRHVWDEOLVKWKHHOHPHQWVRIDSULPD FORVHGDQGWKDWWKHGRFNSODWHKDGEHHQUDLVHGEHIRUHKHFRXOG IDFLHFDVH$VZHQRWHGLQ+ROOLQVY$WODQWLF&R,QF VDIHO\GULYHDZD\&OD\WRQDOVRDGPLWVWKDWEHIRUHKHGURYH )GWK&LU WKHULJDZD\IURPWKHGRFNKHGLGQRWJRWRWKHUHDURIWKH WUXFNDQGGHWHUPLQHIRUKLPVHOIWKDWWKHGRRUZDVFORVHGDQG ,Q%XUGLQH86DW6&WWKH WKHGRFNSODWHUDLVHG+HDOVRGLGQRWXVHDWHOHSKRQHRQWKH 6XSUHPH&RXUWREVHUYHGWKDWm>W@KHXOWLPDWHEXUGHQ RXWVLGHRIWKHGRFNGRRUVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHVWDWXVRIWKHWUDLOHU RI SHUVXDGLQJ WKH WULHU RI IDFW WKDW WKH GHIHQGDQW GRRUDQGGRFNSODWH LQWHQWLRQDOO\ GLVFULPLQDWHG DJDLQVW WKH SODLQWLII UHPDLQV DW DOO WLPHV ZLWK WKH SODLQWLIIl DQG WKDW $V&OD\WRQGURYHWKHWUXFNDQGWUDLOHUDZD\IURPWKHGRFN m>W@KHEXUGHQRIHVWDEOLVKLQJDSULPDIDFLHFDVHRI DVHULRXVDFFLGHQWHQVXHG7KHGRRURIWKHWUDLOHUZDVQRW GLVSDUDWHWUHDWPHQWLVQRWRQHURXVl7KHSULPDIDFLH FORVHG)XUWKHUWKHGRFNSODWHZDVVWLOOLQSODFH$\HDU FDVHPHUHO\VHUYHVWRUDLVHDUHEXWWDEOHSUHVXPSWLRQ ROGIHPDOHFRZRUNHUZDVDFWXDOO\VWDQGLQJRQWKHGRFNSODWH RIGLVFULPLQDWLRQE\mHOLPLQDWLQJWKHPRVWFRPPRQ DVWKHYHKLFOHSXOOHGDZD\IURPWKHGRFN$VDUHVXOWWKH QRQGLVFULPLQDWRU\ UHDVRQV IRU WKH >HPSOR\HUjV GRFNSODWHIHOODQGWKHFRZRUNHUIHOOIRXUIHHWWRWKHJURXQG WUHDWPHQW RI WKH SODLQWLII@l LG DW   6 &W  DQG QRW WR VDWLVI\ WKH SODLQWLIIjV XOWLPDWH EXUGHQRISHUVXDVLRQ  ,GDW $ PHWDO GRFN SODWH IRUPV D EULGJH IURP WKH UHFHLYLQJ GRFN WR WKH UHDU RI WKH WUDLOHU DQG LV XVHG WR ORDG PDWHULDOV IURP WKH LQVLGH EXLOGLQJ RQWR WKH WUDLOHU  &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 1R 1R &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 

,QWKHFRXUVHRIWKHIDOOVKHEURNHKHUULJKWNQHHDQGKDVEHHQ RULJLQDO$VIXUWKHUH[SODLQHGLQ(UFHJRYLFKm>W@KHSODLQWLII XQDEOHWRUHWXUQWRZRUNDVDUHVXOWRIKHULQMXULHV QHHGQRWGHPRQVWUDWHDQH[DFWFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKHHPSOR\HH UHFHLYLQJPRUHIDYRUDEOHWUHDWPHQWLQRUGHUIRUWKHWZRWREH )ROORZLQJ&OD\WRQjVGLVFKDUJHKLVIRUPHUVXSHUYLVRUKLUHG FRQVLGHUHGµVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGjUDWKHUWKHSODLQWLIIDQGWKH DQDGGLWLRQDOWHQWUXFNGULYHUVWRSHUIRUPWKHVDPHNLQGRI HPSOR\HHZLWKZKRPWKHSODLQWLIIVHHNVWRFRPSDUHKLPVHOI ZRUNSUHYLRXVO\GRQHE\&OD\WRQ:KLOHWKHUHFRUGEHORZLV RUKHUVHOIPXVWEHVLPLODULQµDOORIWKHUHOHYDQWDVSHFWVjl QRWSUHFLVHDWOHDVWWKUHHDQGSHUKDSVILYHRIWKHQHZKLUHV )GDWHPSKDVLVLQRULJLQDOFLWDWLRQRPLWWHG)LQDOO\ ZHUH $IULFDQ$PHULFDQ  1R VLQJOH QHZ KLUH ILOOHG WKH LQ3HUU\ZHH[SODLQHGWKDWmWKLV&RXUWKDVDVVHUWHGWKDWLQ SRVLWLRQIRUPHUO\SHUIRUPHGE\&OD\WRQ DSSO\LQJ WKH VWDQGDUG >WKDW SODLQWLII PXVW VKRZ WKDW KH LV WUHDWHG GLIIHUHQWO\ WKDQ VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHG HPSOR\HHV IURP &OD\WRQDOVRVXEPLWWHGHYLGHQFHLQVXSSRUWRIKLVFODLPWKDW RXWVLGHWKHFODVV@FRXUWVVKRXOGQRWGHPDQGH[DFWFRUUHODWLRQ RWKHUZKLWHHPSOR\HHVZKRHQJDJHGLQHVVHQWLDOO\WKHVDPH EXWVKRXOGLQVWHDGVHHNUHOHYDQWVLPLODULW\l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jVGLVFKDUJH GURYHWKHWUDLOHUWRDVWDJLQJDUHDZKHUHLWZDVSDUNHGZLWKRXW GLG QRW LQMXUH D FRZRUNHU  $OO IRXU GULYHUV LQFOXGLQJ WKH LQMXU\ WR WKH FRZRUNHU ZKR UHPDLQHG ZLWKRXW $OEDLQj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jV FLUFXPVWDQFHV ZHUH WKH PRVW VLPLODU WR WKH SODLQWLIIV 7KH

HPSOR\HGE\0HLMHUDVDWUXFNGULYHU7KHLQFLGHQWLQYROYLQJ LQFLGHQW LQYROYLQJ $OEDLQ RFFXUUHG ZLWKLQ VL[ PRQWKV RI &OD\WRQjV

)UDOH\RFFXUUHGLQ2FWREHURYHURQH\HDUDIWHU&OD\WRQ LQIUDFWLRQ DQG DW WKH VDPH ORFDWLRQ )XUWKHU $OEDLQ ZDV VXSHUYLVHG E\ WKH

ZDVGLVFKDUJHG)UDOH\DOVRSXOOHGKLVYHKLFOHDZD\ZLWKWKH VDPH LQGLYLGXDO DV ZDV WKH SODLQWLII :LWK UHJDUG WR 3UXLWW DQG )UDOH\ WKH ORFDWLRQV RI WKH LQFLGHQWV ZHUH QRW LGHQWLFDO DOWKRXJK WKH FRQGXFW ZDV GRFN SODWH VWLOO LQ SODFH DQG WKH WUDLOHU GRRUV RSHQ  $ UHPDUNDEO\ VLPLODU RWKHU WKDQ WKH IDFW WKDW QR FRZRUNHU ZDV LQMXUHG  &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 1R 1R &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 

WUHDWHG PRUH IDYRUDEO\ WKDQ WKH SODLQWLIIl  ,G DW  FRQYH\RUV\VWHPZDVVWLOORQWKHWUDLOHUDQGRQHHPSOR\HHZDV HPSKDVLVLQRULJLQDO DFWXDOO\ VWDQGLQJ RQ WKH GRFN SODWH  7KH HPSOR\HH KDG WR MXPS DZD\ IURP WKH GRFN WR HVFDSH LQMXU\  7KH FRQYH\RU 2WKHU7LWOH9,,FDVHVGHFLGHGE\WKLV&RXUWKDYHUHDFKHG V\VWHP DQG SURGXFW ZHUH GDPDJHG DV WKH\ FUDVKHG WR WKH WKH VDPH FRQFOXVLRQ 6HH HJ %UDLWKZDLWH Y 7LPNHQ &R JURXQG  )UDOH\ ZDV GLVFKDUJHG EDVHG XSRQ KLV FRQGXFW )GWK&LU3HUU\Y0F*LQQLV $OWKRXJK)UDOH\jVFRQGXFWGLGQRWUHVXOWLQ LQMXU\WRDFR )GWK&LU+HLQY$OO$P3O\ZRRG&R ZRUNHU)UDOH\KDGEHHQ LQYROYHGLQIRXUDFFLGHQWVZKLFK ,QF)GWK&LU0LWFKHOOY7ROHGR 0HLMHU GHHPHG SUHYHQWDEOH LQ WKH WZR \HDUV SULRU WR KLV +RVS)GWK&LU)XUWKHUWKLV GLVFKDUJH &RXUW KDV DSSOLHG WKH VDPH DQDO\VLV LQ XWLOL]LQJ WKH 0F'RQQHOO'RXJODVIUDPHZRUNZLWKUHJDUGWRWKHHOHPHQWV 7KH FLUFXPVWDQFHV LQYROYLQJ $OEDLQ 3UXLWW DQG )UDOH\ RIWKHSODLQWLIIjVEXUGHQLQHVWDEOLVKLQJDSULPDIDFLHFDVHRI VKDUHDQXPEHURIVLPLODULWLHVLQFOXGLQJWKHIDFWWKDWDOOWKUHH GLVFULPLQDWLRQ ZLWK UHJDUG WR RWKHU DQWLGLVFULPLQDWLRQ ZHUH WUXFN GULYHUV IRU 0HLMHU DQG FRPPLWWHG WKH VDPH VWDWXWHV+RSNLQVY(OHF'DWD6\V&RUS)G FRQGXFWIRUZKLFK&OD\WRQZDVGLVFKDUJHG2IWKHWKUHHRQO\ WK&LUDSSO\LQJWKH0F'RQQHOO'RXJODVWHVWLQD )UDOH\ZDVGLVFKDUJHG+LVSULRUZRUNUHFRUGLQFOXGHGD FDVHXQGHUWKH$PHULFDQVZLWK'LVDELOLWLHV $FW86& QXPEHURISUHYHQWDEOHDFFLGHQWVZKLFKZDVQRWWKHFDVHZLWK †HWVHT(UFHJRYLFKY*RRG\HDU7LUH 5XEEHU&R &OD\WRQ7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWIRXQGWKDWWKHSULPDU\GLIIHUHQFH )GWK&LUDSSO\LQJWKH0F'RQQHOO EHWZHHQWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVLQYROYLQJWKHEDVLVIRU&OD\WRQjV 'RXJODVWHVWWRWKH$JH'LVFULPLQDWLRQDQG(PSOR\PHQW$FW GLVFKDUJH DQG WKH WUHDWPHQW DIIRUGHG $OEDLQ 3UXLWW DQG 86&†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jVJUDQWRIVXPPDU\ WKHSURWHFWHGFODVVLILFDWLRQ7KHUHIRUHLQRUGHUWRHVWDEOLVK MXGJPHQWGHQRYR6HH*ULEFKHFNY5XQ\RQ)G DSULPDIDFLHFDVHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQKHPXVWVKRZWKDWKH WK&LU7KHVWDQGDUGVDSSOLFDEOHWRVXFKUHYLHZ ZDVWUHDWHGGLIIHUHQWO\WKDQVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGHPSOR\HHVIURP DUHZHOOHVWDEOLVKHG RXWVLGHWKHFODVV 6XPPDU\ MXGJPHQW LV DSSURSULDWH ZKHUH QR JHQXLQH $V WKLV &RXUW ILUVW H[SODLQHG LQ 0LWFKHOO m>L@W LV LVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFWH[LVWVVRWKDWWKHPRYDQWLVHQWLWOHG IXQGDPHQWDOWKDWWRPDNHDFRPSDULVRQRIDGLVFULPLQDWLRQ WRMXGJPHQWDVDPDWWHURIODZ)HG5&LY3F7KH SODLQWLIIjVWUHDWPHQWWRWKDWRIQRQPLQRULW\HPSOR\HHVWKH FRXUWGHWHUPLQHVZKHWKHUmWKHUHDUHDQ\JHQXLQHIDFWXDO SODLQWLII PXVW VKRZ WKDW WKH µFRPSDUDEOHVj DUH VLPLODUO\ LVVXHVWKDWSURSHUO\FDQEHUHVROYHGRQO\E\DILQGHURI VLWXDWHG LQ DOO UHVSHFWVl   )G DW  HPSKDVLV LQ IDFWEHFDXVHWKH\PD\UHDVRQDEO\EHUHVROYHGLQIDYRURI  &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 1R 1R &OD\WRQY0HLMHU,QF 

HLWKHUSDUW\l$QGHUVRQY/LEHUW\/REE\,QF86 SODLQWLIIFDQHVWDEOLVKWKHODVWSURQJRIDSULPDIDFLHFDVHE\ 6&W/(GG2I VLPSO\VKRZLQJmWKDWKLVSRVLWLRQUHPDLQHGRSHQIRURUZDV FRXUVHmLQIHUHQFHVWREHGUDZQIURPWKHXQGHUO\LQJIDFWV ILOOHGE\DSHUVRQZKRVHTXDOLILFDWLRQVZHUHVLPLODUWRKLVl PXVWEHYLHZHGLQWKHOLJKWPRVWIDYRUDEOHWRWKHSDUW\ ,GDW7KH&RXUWKHOGWKDWHYLGHQFHUHJDUGLQJGLVSDUDWH RSSRVLQJWKHPRWLRQVl0DWVXVKLWD(OHF,QGXV&RY WUHDWPHQWRIRWKHUVRXWVLGHWKHSURWHFWHGFODVVLILFDWLRQVKRXOG =HQLWK 5DGLR &RUS  86    6&W RQO\EHFRQVLGHUHGLQWKHWKLUGDQGILQDOVWDJHRIWKHDQDO\VLV   /(GG    7KH PRYDQW PHHWV LWV PHDQLQJ DIWHU WKH GHIHQGDQW KDV UHVSRQGHG ZLWK D QRQ LQLWLDOEXUGHQmE\µVKRZLQJjoWKDWLVSRLQWLQJRXWWRWKH GLVFULPLQDWRU\ H[SODQDWLRQ IRU WKH DGYHUVH HPSOR\PHQW GLVWULFW FRXUW oWKDWWKHUHLVDQDEVHQFHRIHYLGHQFHWR DFWLRQ VXSSRUWWKHQRQPRYLQJSDUW\jVFDVHl&HORWH[&RUSY &DWUHWW  86    6&W   &OD\WRQDFNQRZOHGJHVWKDWWKLV&RXUWKDVQRWDGRSWHGWKH /(GG    $W WKDW SRLQW WKH QRQPRYDQW IRUPXODWLRQ VHW IRUWK E\ WKH )LUVW &LUFXLW LQ &RQZDUG mPXVW VHW IRUWK VSHFLILF IDFWV VKRZLQJ WKDW WKHUH LV D ,QVWHDGWKLV&RXUWKDVKHOGWKDWLQRUGHUWRHVWDEOLVKDSULPD JHQXLQHLVVXHIRUWULDOl)HG5&LY3H$QGHUVRQ IDFLHFDVHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQE\WKHGHIHQGDQWmWKHSODLQWLII 86DW6&W PXVW VKRZ  WKDW KH LV D PHPEHU RI D SURWHFWHG JURXS WKDWKHZDVVXEMHFWWRDQDGYHUVHHPSOR\PHQWGHFLVLRQ 'L[RQ Y $QGHUVRQ  )G   Q WK &LU  WKDWKHZDVTXDOLILHGIRUWKHSRVLWLRQDQGWKDWKHZDV SDUDOOHOFLWDWLRQVRPLWWHG UHSODFHGE\DSHUVRQRXWVLGHRIWKHSURWHFWHGFODVV>W@KH IRXUWKHOHPHQWPD\DOVREHVDWLVILHGE\VKRZLQJWKDWVLPLODUO\ ,QFKDOOHQJLQJWKHJUDQWLQJRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW&OD\WRQ VLWXDWHG QRQSURWHFWHG HPSOR\HHV ZHUH WUHDWHG PRUH ILUVW DVVHUWV WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW LQFRUUHFWO\ DSSOLHG WKH IDYRUDEO\l7DOOH\Y%UDYR3LWLQR5HVW/WG)G 0F'RQQHOO'RXJODVWHVW6SHFLILFDOO\&OD\WRQDVVHUWVWKDW WK&LUFLWDWLRQVRPLWWHG WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWHUUHGLQUHTXLULQJKLPWRSURGXFHHYLGHQFH WRVXSSRUWDILQGLQJWKDWSODLQWLIIZDVUHSODFHGE\VRPHRQH 7KLV&RXUWLQ7DOOH\IXUWKHUKHOGmVKRZLQJWKDWVLPLODUO\ RXWVLGHWKHSURWHFWHGFODVV VLWXDWHGQRQSURWHFWHGHPSOR\HHVZHUHWUHDWHGPRUHIDYRUDEO\ WKDQSODLQWLIILVQRWDUHTXLUHPHQWEXWUDWKHUDQDOWHUQDWLYHWR 7RWKHFRQWUDU\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWTXLWHVSHFLILFDOO\VWDWHG VDWLVI\LQJ WKH IRXUWK HOHPHQW RI WKH SULPD IDFLH FDVH o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

GLIIHUHQWO\IURPVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGQRQPLQRULW\HPSOR\HHV KDG UHVSRQGHG ZLWK D OHJLWLPDWH EXVLQHVV MXVWLILFDWLRQ IRU WKH GLVFKDUJH

2SLQLRQDQG2UGHUS 7KH &RXUW DOVR IRXQG WKDW WKH SODLQWLII KDG IDLOHG WR HVWDEOLVK WKDW RWKHU HPSOR\HHV QRW LQ WKH SURWHFWHG FODVVLILFDWLRQ KDG EHHQ WUHDWHG GLIIHUHQWO\

&OD\WRQXUJHVWKLV&RXUWWRDGRSWWKHVWDQGDUGDUWLFXODWHG 7KH )LUVW &LUFXLW DOVR H[SODLQHG DV KDV WKLV &RXUW GHVFULEHG WKH SODLQWLII

E\WKH)LUVW&LUFXLWLQ&RQZDUGY&DPEULGJH6FK&RPP EHDUV WKH EXUGHQ RI HVWDEOLVKLQJ WKDW mRWKHUV VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHG WR KLP LQ DOO UHOHYDQW DVSHFWV ZHUH WUHDWHG GLIIHUHQWO\ E\ WKH HPSOR\HUl &RQZDUG  )G   VW &LU   7KH &RXUW KHOG WKDW D  )G DW