City of New York v. Dietz

New York Supreme Court

City of New York v. Dietz

66 Misc. 628, 123 N.Y.S. 1072

DecidedMarch 15, 1910

StatusPublished

This text of 66 Misc. 628 (City of New York v. Dietz) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering New York Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

City of New York v. Dietz, 66 Misc. 628, 123 N.Y.S. 1072 (N.Y. Super. Ct. 1910).

Pincite

Opinion

Gebaed, J.

¡Motion for order dismissing the complaint, without costs, and directing the cancellation of the tax. Frederick Dietz, William H. White and Samuel McMillan were trustees of the estate of Bobert E. Dietz, for Anna Dietz. The city of ¡New York commenced suit to collect from them as residents of the borough of the Bronx the personal tax owing from the above named estate. This suit was instituted by the service of a summons and complaint on defendant Dietz. It appears that defendant White is dead, and the corporation counsel agrees that the action against defendant Dietz be dismissed for the reason that he was not a resident of the borough in which .the assessment was made. In the complaint served on Dietz the city prays for judgment for the whole amount of the tax on said estate, and asks this court to hind ¡McMillan, a defendant who had never been served, for the amount claimed to be due in the complaint served on Dietz, and which complaint must- of necessity be dismissed as against Dietz. There are two questions to be decided. First, Does service on one defendant bind all in an action of this nature ? and, second, can one trustee in an action of this nature he hound for the entire amount of the tax due? As to the first question I am of the opinion that section 8, chapter 908 of the Laws of 1896, clearly indicates that the statute contemplates a separate liability, and as to the second question I am of the opinion that each trustee in an action of this nature is liable only for the share of the estate in his hands. People ex rel. Moller v. O’Donnel, 183 N. Y. 9.

Ordered accordingly.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Gebaed, J.

¡Motion for order dismissing the complaint, without costs, and directing the cancellation of the tax. Frederick Dietz, William H. White and Samuel McMillan were trustees of the estate of Bobert E. Dietz, for Anna Dietz. The city of ¡New York commenced suit to collect from them as residents of the borough of the Bronx the personal tax owing from the above named estate. This suit was instituted by the service of a summons and complaint on defendant Dietz. It appears that defendant White is dead, and the corporation counsel agrees that the action against defendant Dietz be dismissed for the reason that he was not a resident of the borough in which .the assessment was made. In the complaint served on Dietz the city prays for judgment for the whole amount of the tax on said estate, and asks this court to hind ¡McMillan, a defendant who had never been served, for the amount claimed to be due in the complaint served on Dietz, and which complaint must- of necessity be dismissed as against Dietz. There are two questions to be decided. First, Does service on one defendant bind all in an action of this nature ? and, second, can one trustee in an action of this nature he hound for the entire amount of the tax due? As to the first question I am of the opinion that section 8, chapter 908 of the Laws of 1896, clearly indicates that the statute contemplates a separate liability, and as to the second question I am of the opinion that each trustee in an action of this nature is liable only for the share of the estate in his hands. People ex rel. Moller v. O’Donnel, 183 N. Y. 9.

Ordered accordingly.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

66 Misc. 628, 123 N.Y.S. 1072, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/city-of-new-york-v-dietz-nysupct-1910.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack