Christofferson v. Christofferson

190 P.2d 928, 183 Or. 75, 1948 Ore. LEXIS 154
CourtOregon Supreme Court
DecidedFebruary 4, 1948
StatusPublished
Cited by3 cases

This text of 190 P.2d 928 (Christofferson v. Christofferson) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Oregon Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Christofferson v. Christofferson, 190 P.2d 928, 183 Or. 75, 1948 Ore. LEXIS 154 (Or. 1948).

Opinion

*77 BAILEY, J.

This is an appeal from a decree of the circuit court of Marion county sustaining the validity of the last mil and testament of Lillian R. Christofferson, who died May 30, 1945. The appellants, Lauren, sometimes referred to as Loren, George and Royal Christofferson, and Genevieve Dunning, are the four eldest children of the deceased. Her youngest sons, Gerald Christofferson, individually and as executor of the will, and Burns Christofferson are the respondents.

The will was executed in Salem, Oregon, on the 26th day of March, 1931. The subscribing witnesses thereto were Dr. R. E. Lee Steiner, superintendent of the Oregon State Hospital, and R. H. Bassett, an attorney in Salem. Under the terms of the will one-half of a 20-acre tract of land, located about seven miles northeast of the city of Salem, was devised to Burns and the other half to Gerald. All the rest, residue and remainder of her estate was devised and bequeathed to her six living children, share and share alike.

Contestants, appellants in this court, attack the will on the grounds that (1) it was not duly executed; (2) the testatrix was of unsound mind and did not possess testamentary capacity at the time of its execution; and (3) it was the result of undue influence and coercion by Gerald and Burns Christofferson.

*78 In 1908 the Christofferson family, consisting of Lillian E. Christofferson, her husband Hans Christofferson, and six children, moved from La Grande, Oregon, and located upon the 20-acre tract of land herein-before mentioned. Hans Christofferson, in the fall of 1913, suffered a paralytic stroke which left him partially disabled. In February or March, 1914, he again suffered a stroke which rendered him permanently and totally disabled. Shortly thereafter Mrs. Christofferson, who was then about 46 years of age, became depressed and melancholy and on April 21, 1914, on complaint of her daughter, was committed to the Oregon State Hospital and discharged therefrom on May 18 of that year.

In 1918 one of Mrs. Christofferson’s sons was killed while serving with the armed forces. Her son-in-law died in the same year. These bereavements and the difficulty experienced by her in getting someone to farm the 20-acre tract caused Mrs. Christofferson considerable worry. September 10, 1920, on her own application, she was admitted to the Oregon State Hospital for treatment and discharged on the 19th of that month. The record of the state hospital under date of September 16, 1920, in regard to this commitment contains the following statement: “This woman came under Voluntary Commitment. She was previously an inmate for a short time in 1914. Suffering from mild depression. Her condition then was very similar to her present state of mind. Her husband is paralyzed and she is said to have had much to worry her at home and felt the need of some rest and treatment. She is now much more cheerful and plans to return home next Sunday.” September 19, 1920, she was “discharged as improved.”

She was thereafter voluntarily committed to the *79 state hospital and discharged therefrom on the following dates: Committed May 28, 1926, discharged Jnne 9, 1926; committed Jnne 20, 1926, discharged July 2, 1926. On July 8, 1926, she was involuntarily committed for the second time, and on August 4 of that year paroled to her son, Gerald Christofferson ‘ ‘ as recovered”. She was granted a full discharge on September 1,1929. The last commitment occurred on May 3, 1930, and was voluntary, and she was discharged on May 22 of that year. The last involuntary commitment which occurred on July 8, 1926, was not due to any material change in Mrs. Christofferson’s condition but to facilitate her admission and release or parole from the hospital. Under a voluntary commitment, an applicant could not be detained more than 30 days. Ch. 125, Oregon Laws, 1919, codified as § 127-214, O. C. L. A. In regard to the last commitment the hospital record contains the following:

“May 3, 1930: Sixth commitment. Has been at home with her children since her parole from the institution in August, 1926. Her husband is partially paralyzed and the care of him was too much for her she states. She asked to be returned here so that she could get a rest. Is in very good physical condition, is quiet and orderly and is cooperating well. Diagnosis: 13-B, depressive type.
“May 22,1930: Pull discharge granted this day. Going to Salem, Ore. Condition, recovered.”

Hans Christofferson died on September 24, 1930. He was named as beneficiary in the war risk' insurance policy issued by the government to his deceased son and had been receiving the payments thereon. After his death Mrs. Christofferson sought advice concerning the unpaid balance on the policy and was referred to Mr. Bassett, who was familiar with such matters. This was in October, 1930. In November of that year a *80 petition was filed in the probate court for the administration of the deceased son’s estate, and Gerald Christofferson was appointed administrator of that estate.

During her conferences with Mr. Bassett concerning her deceased son’s estate, Mrs. Christofferson discussed with him the preparation of her last will and testament. Because Mr. Bassett knew of Mrs. Christofferson’s previous commitments to the Oregon State Hospital, he arranged to have Dr. Steiner as one of the subscribing witnesses to her will, which was executed in Dr. Steiner’s office.

On the same day that the testatrix executed the will, she signed and verified a petition for the appointment of a guardian of her estate. In it she alleged that she was owner of the 20-acre tract of land, to which we have referred, of the approximate value of $3500, and of personal property of the approximate value of $4,800. The petition then continues as follows:

“That during the past fifteen years or thereabouts, to and until September, 1930, my deceased husband was an invalid, requiring my constant care and attention; and that because of the work and the many worries falling upon my shoulders in the care of my deceased husband and the rearing of my children, and the managing of the property, particularly the home place, I have, upon several occasions, become sick in mind and body, and during the time of such sickness when run down and in a weakened condition, been treated for a mental sickness at the Oregon State Hospital; the last occasion being as a voluntary patient from May 3, 1930 to May 21,1930, and on said last named date, I was discharged as cured, and that said hospital has no further jurisdiction over my person. That such periods of sickness have only been of temporary duration and at infrequent intervals, but I am ad *81

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Clauder v. Morser
282 P.2d 352 (Oregon Supreme Court, 1955)
Estate of Verd Hill v. Henderson
256 P.2d 735 (Oregon Supreme Court, 1953)
In Re Estate of Beer
222 P.2d 1005 (Oregon Supreme Court, 1950)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
190 P.2d 928, 183 Or. 75, 1948 Ore. LEXIS 154, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/christofferson-v-christofferson-or-1948.