Cheramie v. Cheramie

380 So. 2d 166
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedDecember 27, 1979
Docket12844
StatusPublished
Cited by4 cases

This text of 380 So. 2d 166 (Cheramie v. Cheramie) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Cheramie v. Cheramie, 380 So. 2d 166 (La. Ct. App. 1979).

Opinion

380 So.2d 166 (1979)

Olezime CHERAMIE et al.
v.
Alidore CHERAMIE et al.

No. 12844.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, First Circuit.

December 27, 1979.
Rehearing Denied February 20, 1980.

*167 Carlton J. Cheramie, Golden Meadow, for plaintiffs and appellants Webb Cheramie, Erick Cheramie, Theo J. Cheramie, Mrs. Viola Cheramie Dantin, Mrs. Hazel Cheramie Barrios, Renie J. Cheramie, George Cheramie, Harvey Cheramie, Ansay Cheramie, Asse Cheramie Crosby.

David L. Landry, Thibodaux, for plaintiffs and appellants Annabelle Cheramie Pitre, Thelma Cheramie Messick, Anna Cheramie Camardelle, Marilyn Cheramie DeMatteo, Debra Cheramie Esserman, Stephen J. Cheramie, Jr., Stephanie Cheramie.

Maurice J. Serpas, Galliano, for defendants and appellees Edwin Cheramie, Mrs. Evelia Cheramie, Ludovic Cheramie, Mrs. Rita Cheramie, Mrs. Gail Hebert Cheramie.

Before COVINGTON, LOTTINGER and COLE, JJ.

COLE, Judge.

This is a petitory action in which the principal issue is whether the existence of a usufruct on the disputed tract prevented defendants from acquiring ownership of the land through thirty year acquisitive prescription. Essentially, the suit began as an assertion of ownership by Olezime Cheramie over a tract of land which was claimed and possessed by his brothers, Alidore and Ozeme. Olezime maintains he became owner of the disputed tract by virtue of a 1907 partition executed by him, his brothers and sister.

This suit was filed in 1951 by nine plaintiffs against forty-five defendants. Although the trial was held in 1956 and 1957, no judgment was rendered until 1979 because the judge who presided over the trial left office without rendering a decision. Over the years the number of litigants has been greatly increased through substitutions of parties. Plaintiffs are the heirs and assigns of Olezime. Defendants are basically the heirs and assigns of Alidore and Ozeme. Many of the defendants are holders of mineral interests.

The lower court, sustaining pleas of five year liberative prescription and thirty year acquisitive prescription, held for defendants. Plaintiffs appeal.

The contested property was described in the petition as follows:

A CERTAIN TRACT OF LAND, situated in the Parish of Lafourche, Louisiana, on the left descending bank of Bayou Lafourche, about 55 miles below the Town of Thibodaux, near the Town of Golden Meadow, Louisiana, measuring a front of two hundred ninety-three and 44/100 (293.44 ft.) feet on the left descending bank of said bayou by a depth of forty arpents between parallel lines, comprised within and being the Northernmost one-quarter of Section 23, Township 19 South, Range 22 East, Southeastern Land District of Louisiana, West of the Mississippi River; said tract of land being bounded in the front or on the West by said Bayou Lafourche, above, or on the North by the Northern boundary line of said Section *168 23, in the rear, or on the East, by the Eastern boundary line of said Section 23, and bounded below, or on the South, for a distance of 1000 feet by property of Eugene Cheramie, and for the remainder of its depth by property of Alidore Cheramie; together with all buildings and improvements thereon and all rights, ways, privileges and servitudes thereunto belonging, or in anywise appertaining.

This land is part of a larger tract acquired in 1866 from Martial Celestin Orgeron by Olucien Cheramie, father of Olezime, Alidore, and Ozeme. The act of sale contained the following property description:

A certain tract of land situated in the Parish of Lafourche, on the left descending bank of Bayou Lafourche bounded above by a tract of land belonging to Gratien Thibodaux, and below by a tract of land belonging to Charles Orgeron— with all the buildings and improvements thereon.
Said land has been acquired by the vendor from the State of Louisiana and is described as being Lot [or Section] Number Twenty-three (23) in Township Number Nineteen South of Range Number Twenty-two East, containing one hundred and fifty-eight acres and Seventy-five hundredths of an acre.

Later Olucien acquired a second tract along Bayou Lafourche. This property was located below the first tract in section 22.

In 1869 Olucien Cheramie married Aglae Hebert. From this marriage eight children were born: Olezime, Alidore, Ozeme, Theodore, Joseph Ovide, Julien, Olucien, Jr., and Adolphine. When Olucien died around 1882 he was survived by his widow and eight children.

On July 24, 1907, the Cheramies executed three notarial acts. In the first, Mrs. Aglae Hebert Cheramie sold to her eight children her interest, if any, in the two tracts of land along Bayou Lafourche acquired by her late husband.

The second act was a partition among the eight children of the two tracts. The lower tract, which was located in section 22, was divided into four parcels measuring one arpent front by forty arpents in depth. These four parcels were allotted to Joseph Ovide, Julien, Olucien, Jr., and Adolphine. The upper tract, which was divided into four lots measuring one acre front by forty acres in depth, was described in the act of partition as follows:

A certain tract of land situated in the Parish of Lafourche, State of Louisiana, on the left bank of Bayou Lafourche at about Fifty five miles below the Town of Thibodeaux, measuring Four acres more or less front on Said Bayou Lafourche by Forty Acres in depth, Bounded above by land formerly belonging to Estate of Gratien Thibodeaux and now owned by Francois Deramee and below by other land of Francois Deramee and formerly to Francois Doucet together with the buildings and improvements thereon.

The first upper acre front of this tract was allotted to Olezime and described as "being bounded above by land formerly belonging to Est. Gratien Thibodeaux now owned by Francois Deramee, and below by land allotted to Alidore Cheramie herein." The second acre front went to Alidore, the third to Ozeme, and the fourth to Theodore.

In the third act executed that day, the eight Cheramie children acting as "owners in a divided state" granted to their mother a usufruct for life over their respective tracts that they had been allotted in the partition. Mrs. Cheramie was not a party to this act.

Shortly after the partition each child went into possession of his tract. Theodore testified he, Olezime, Ozeme, and Alidore together measured off their four tracts. No survey was made. The present dispute arises out of the fact that Olezime, who had been allotted the first upper acre front of the upper tract, settled on land that was entirely in section 24, to which Olucien and his heirs had no title. Olezime and the other members of his family thought the land he took possession of was part of the tract Olucien had purchased from Martial Orgeron. Alidore testified the boundary with Thibodaux had been marked during his father's lifetime with a levee and canal *169 built as a joint project by his father and Thibodaux. Olezime possessed up to this canal.

In 1934, Nolan Tomplain, whose ancestor in title was Gratien Thibodaux, brought suit against Olezime asking the court to fix the boundary between their respective tracts of land. Olezime answered admitting the true boundary was the section line between section 23 and 24, but he also asserted he and his father had possessed for over thirty years up to a boundary line marked by a canal and fence. A survey conducted in connection with this suit showed the land Olezime possessed to be in section 24.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Levraea v. Smith
424 So. 2d 277 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1982)
Cheramie v. Cheramie
391 So. 2d 1126 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1980)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
380 So. 2d 166, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/cheramie-v-cheramie-lactapp-1979.