Chamberlain v. Brewer

5 Ky. Op. 6, 1871 Ky. LEXIS 297

• Court: Court of Appeals of Kentucky
• Decided: October 6, 1871
• Status: Published

Opinion

Opinion by

Judge Hardin :

This case is here for the third time in this court on the appeal of the present appellants. The decision of the first appeal (3 Bush 561) was in effect, that if Watkins and other sureties of the sheriff were induced to believe that the name of D. L. Brewer, affixed to the bond before their own signatures, was his act and deed, and that the same was not his act and did not bind him, then their own attempted execution of the bond was not obligatory on them. A trial of the case in conformity to that decision resulted in a judgment for the defendants, which in an opinion manifesting much hesitation a majority of this court reversed, and remanded the cause with instructions to bring the representative of D. L. Brewer before the court; which was done, and upon another trial on the evidence previously adduced and additional testimony for the defendants, a judgment was again rendered for them.

In view of the fact that the court to which the law and facts were submitted acted in the double capacity of judge and jury, and its judgment is entitled to the weight of the verdict of a jury, which ought not to be disturbed unless palpably against the evidence; and that that is the same decision of the court below, in favor of appellants on the facts, we do not feel at liberty in view of all the evidence to reverse the judgment. Therefore the judgment is'affirmed.

Pryor & Barber, for appellants. Scott, for appellee. Judge Pryor not sitting.